WWE: 4 Reasons Why The Shield Should Stay As A Threesome

By Vectron44 /

The Shield are one of the best things the WWE has going for it at the moment. After their debut at Survivor Series in the Triple Threat WWE Championship Match- interfering to help CM Punk retain the title against Ryback and John Cena, the Shield has dealt out its own brutal form of justice to many of the top faces in the WWE- including Chris Jericho, Sheamus, Ryback, John Cena, Daniel Bryan, Kofi Kingston, Kane and even the Undertaker. There is no doubt that the trio of Dean Ambrose, Seth Rollins and Roman Reigns has a great deal going for it. So you can't blame some people for being tempted to trying to spice up the mix even more by attempting to even more people to the Shield's banner in order to try and generate even more excitement for what is essentially one of the best story arcs the WWE has at the moment. However, there have been many tales of stables going wrong in the past because someone took what was in essence a simple idea and then adding too much to it- leaving it a complex mess that left out much that was cool about it in the first place. So here's 5 reasons to keep the Shield's group a trio.

4. They Compliment Each Other Perfectly

Some have said that the addition of a fourth member of the Shield would allow them to cover their bases better in areas that the three current members may be a little wanting. However, this argument does not really hold up when one sees the immense range of talents these three wrestlers have. After all not just anyone gets to face the Undertaker unless the Deadman thinks they are good and ready. The Shield has three performers that are not only great for each other but in their own ways unique- both in the ring and on the microphone. First off there is Dean Ambrose whose unique off-kilter promos which seem to have a little of Heath Ledger's Joker about them gives the Shield a disturbing feel in a similar way that Mick Foley did in his first few promos as Mankind. Ambrose also is great in the ring, with his frenetic brawling/submission style and his ability to sell- particularly submission moves ( nobody has made the Walls of Jericho look more painful in a long time ). Secondly there is Seth Rollins who has the look and technique to eventually be a CM Punk style face- full of countercultural rage to offset the wholesome John Cena type with great high flying and high impact moves. Finally there is Roman Reigns whose spears and powerbombs say far more than many words could. He screams and spits and acts like the true enforcer of the group and will only become better with time. So put simply, why would you want to add anything to this group? They seem to have filled all the gaps that each performer has really well- which is one of the reasons they are so hot at the moment in the WWE.

3. Their Youth Is Their Strength

Some would counter that a better way to add a fourth member would therefore be to add a veteran to the group. After all, what could possibly help this young group more than a old hand giving them some more legitimacy in their future endeavours moving towards mid card and maybe top card titles? And there is no doubt that it would make great television if the fourth member of the Shield was revealed not to be a younger hand but an older star who was mentoring the group from behind the scenes and now had decided to reveal himself to the WWE Universe. The trouble with this idea is the fact that the Shield have become great partly due to the fact that they are outsiders. They don't wear normal wrestling attire, they don't cut normal promos, they don't even come through the normal entrance to get to the ring before a match. One can't help but feel if an older hand was added to the mix then they would no longer be the upstarts everyone thought they were. Furthermore, they'd just be a group following the orders of someone else and much of the focus would turn from the Shield themselves to the older superstar. Some may say they could add an elder member the way Nexus added John Cena- by force but even that would turn the focus away from the Shield and to the oppressed babyface- as it did for the Nexus storyline with Cena seeming to dominate much of the proceedings after that.

2. They Need To Look Powerful, Not Invincible

The Shield has been named by JBL as possibly the greatest three-man tag team in WWE history because of their ability to work brilliantly as a team. Their victories so far have allowed them to be seen as resourceful, strong and talented. Their ambushes on superstars during promos and after matches show that they are prepared to bulldoze anyone on their way to the top. Put any more wrestlers in the Shield therefore seems a bit superfluous at the moment- they are currently an unbeaten tag team ( if one doesn't count the Cena DQ on the last Raw) that has taken on and beaten some of the biggest names in the industry. To add another name would actually be worse than do nothing- it would actually make the Shield seem too powerful- thus making much of their matches boring. One could see this problem with the nWo in WCW as they began recruiting more and more guys to the fold and thus stagnating much of the angles because the nWo seemed to be too big to fail. Furthermore, when a heel stable does become too big to fail, it often does no favours to the babyfaces who contribute to its downfall. Take the Nexus for instance, whose reign of terror managed to brutalise many of the top superstars in the business but in turn was halted by ( mostly alone ) John Cena. The fact that Cena succeeded where so many superstars had failed in breaking up the Nexus did nothing for his credibility simply because many fans believed it was just another example of Cena winning whatever the odds. And speaking of the nWo, that leads me to my next point.

1. Big Stables Are Often Boring Stables

The nWo was an amazingly cool concept in its inception that rocketed WCW to new heights when it first came on the scene in mid-1996. Arrogant, cocky and brash, the trio of Kevin Nash, Scott Hall and Hulk Hogan began tearing up WCW and causing mayhem wherever they went. However as the group grew out from the three founding members it soon became clear that what once was the golden goose for WCW had now become incredibly unwieldy and even dull to both the other wrestlers as well as the WCW universe as a whole. The anti-establishment group had recruited so many wrestlers that by 1998 they practically were the establishment and it wasn't long before the stable and the story collapsed under its own weight. The best stables in wrestling history have revolved around three, four people or five people at most- the Four Horsemen, D-Generation X, Evolution and now the Shield have that in common. This is because the stable can then still focus on the individuals with in the storyline and give everyone a role. Individuals in the nWo would soon become generic simply because there was little for them to do. So that's my views. Please feel free to add your own!