WWE vs Arrow - 7 Reasons Why Stardust & Stephen Amell Is A Great Idea

Could this be the beginning of Cody's return?

By Chris Smith /

The Stardust character has been divisive, to put it mildly. Having the talented and under appreciated Cody Rhodes running around dressed as a Goldust Lite has not been the career maker fans wanted for him. Spouting nonsensical riddles and making cartoonish noises, the character has been, at best, a fun midcard distraction. 

Advertisement

Several weeks ago it seemed that WWE had something meaningful lined up for him when Stardust crossed paths with actor Stephen Amell of Arrow. The two had a brief exchange on television, and since then they have been involved in a war of words on Twitter. This has been building towards a match between the two at this year's SummerSlam on August 23rd.

Last month however, the wrestling world was struck with the tragic passing of Rhodes' father Virgil "Dusty Rhodes" Runnels. Amongst grief and condolences for the Rhodes family, fans speculated that Virgil's death would be the catalyst for Cody to finally drop the Stardust gimmick and return to his former self. However last Monday on Raw, Rhodes returned as Stardust, with only a brief - almost obligatory - mention of his father on commentary. It seems WWE are sticking with the Amell feud.

Many fans have been critical of this decision, mostly out of fatigue for the Stardust character and apathy towards Amell. But it's easy to understand the appeal of the match. 

Here's why you should not only support their decision, but look forward to seeing Amell step into a WWE ring.

7. Stephen Amell Can Hold His Own Physically

One argument against celebrities (especially actors) getting in the ring is that they are not trained wrestlers and therefore it's insulting to portray them as equals to men and women who have spent years training to a professional standard. That's a fair argument, but that doesn't mean that an actor cannot be trained. Especially an actor with as much physical training under his belt as Stephen Amell.

Advertisement

A real specimen, Amell is highly skilled at Parkour or Free Running (WWE fans may remember that John Morrison brought a lot of that to his in ring style), and performs many of his own stunts on Arrow. 

Though he will still require training to work a professional wrestling match, you should be confident Amell will take to it extremely well. And besides, he's not going in completely blind.

6. He's A Huge Wrestling Fan

Another criticism of celebrities getting in the ring is that they are only there to promote their own show/movie/album/book/etc and that they have no interest in or respect for professional wrestling. For Stephen Amell, that isn't the case at all.

Advertisement

Amell's love of wrestling dates back to his childhood and eclipses his love of comics - somewhat surprising considering the role he's best known for playing. He even tweeted last year that he wanted to host Raw, promising that he'd even be willing to wrestle if WWE let him. In fact forget being a fan, Amell is almost a bonafide Mark for the business!

Fans can always spot the difference between a celebrity who uses WWE as a means to an end, and a celebrity who genuinely wants to be there. Amell is the latter and he will make every effort to show the fans that he loves wrestling just as much as they do.

5. A Star On The Rise

Stephen Amell is fast becoming a recognizable name.

Advertisement

In addition to his starring role on Arrow as the titular hero Olver Queen, Amell has landed the role of fan favorite Casey Jones in the upcoming Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles sequel. This is a big step for his career as many fans will be tuning in to see how he fares on the big screen, in such a prominent role. WWE fans will also have a reason to check out the movie as it stars current Mr Money in the Bank Sheamus as Rocksteady.

Back to Amell, his popularity has increased with Arrow's success thanks to the current overall dominance of the superhero genre. In addition to three seasons with a fourth on the way, Arrow has spawned two spin off shows - The Flash and the upcoming Legends of Tomorrow. Superheroes are owning the movies right now and they're steadily taking over television. WWE is right to strike while the iron is hot and right now Amell is on fire.

4. Wrestlers And Superheroes Will Always Be Linked

Not everyone who loves superheroes watches wrestling. Just like not every wrestling fan reads comic books. But the number of fans who cross over into both mediums runs well into the thousands.

Advertisement

Both genres feature the same core elements. The struggle between good and evil? Larger than life figures that rise to the occasion and overcome the odds? Masked men who hide their identities and become symbols? Epic fights between heroes and villains? It's all there on the screen! And the page!

It's also been suggested that Stardust seems to think that Stephen Amell really is the Green Arrow, not just an actor. If the story continues in this direction we could potentially see Amell enter the ring in his Arrow costume. Does that not sound amazing?

WWE fans aren't likely to be won over by stars from Entourage or Jersey Shore. But the fact that Stephen Amell portrays a masked vigilante on Arrow, should be enough for some fans to give him a second look and say "Tell me more." Similarly fans of the TV show who might tune into WWE for the first time to see Amell wrestle, would likely respond more to a theatrical character like Stardust, than a more typical wrestler like The Miz or Bad News Barrett.

3. Dusty Would Want The Show To Go On

That might sound cliche but the fact is Dusty Rhodes loved the business and devoted his life to it. Belonging to an old school generation, Rhodes respected the nature of the beast and understood the sacrifices wrestlers have to make for the good of the show.

Advertisement

That's not to sound callous or disrespectful. His loss is still felt by all within the wresting world and fans are understandably disappointed that Cody is still maintaining this bizarre gimmick that requires him to dismiss his name and history. Nonetheless, Dusty wouldn't want anyone - least of all his son - to stop the act on his account.

Cody also shares his father's passion for the business and earlier this week he responded to fans who criticized his continued use of the Stardust gimmick: “Troubled seeing some people think I’d allow or be comfortable w/the worst thing that’s ever happened to me be exploited on TV for a return.”

WWE planted the seeds for this story before Dusty's passing and thus far have shown no signs of pulling the plug. Nor would the Rhodes family want them to.

2. Cody As Himself Is Actually Pretty Boring

This won't be a popular opinion but here it is: Cody Rhodes is pretty bland. Talented, charismatic, likeable, handsome (y'know - for the ladies!) but without a gimmick the man is just another wrestler. Who is Cody Rhodes? What are his motivations? What separates him from every other mid-carder in WWE?

Advertisement

Over the years we've seen him as one third of Randy Orton's Legacy, a dashing narcissist, and a tragic masked villain. The Legacy was never a trio, it was Randy Orton and minions. The Dashing gimmick was notable only for the digital mirror on the Tron. The Dr Doom inspired masked man had potential, but suffered in the details - if he didn't want us to see his face, then why wear a clear mask? At one point his career was so directionless he grew a mustache. That was his gimmick. And the mustache got more cheers than he did!

Fact is though, all of those gimmicks are the most memorable parts of Codys career, because on his own, he's just rather dull. Yes, his Brotherhood tag team with Goldust was fantastic, but that was born out of a red hot angle with the Shield and their father Dusty Rhodes. As the months went by and new tag teams emerged, WWE just couldn't keep their momentum going. 

Now Goldust is out with an injury and Cody is on his own. While Stardust doesn't scream main eventer, it allows Rhodes to show a different side of his personality that love it or hate it, makes him stand out from the rest of the roster. The Stardust/Amell feud is the most notable thing Cody has done since the Brotherhood split up.

And for those who disagree, well there's good news too ...

1. This Could Lead To Cody's Return

Stardust believes Stephen Amell is the Arrow. He's talked about knowing his secret and wanting to see heroes fall. No doubt if the feud continues he will accuse Amell of hiding behind a mask and pretending to be someone he's not. Well wouldn't that be a perfect opportunity for Amell to point out the obvious?

Advertisement

Perhaps this feud will end with Amell pointing out the fact that Cody has been hiding behind the mask (or paint, whatever) and denying who he truly is. As the "Cody" chants get louder every week, it would be a perfect way for Amell to endear himself to the WWE audience by agreeing with them and demanding that Cody return to being who he really is.

If nothing else, WWE really won't have any reason to keep the Stardust character around after their match, so Cody Rhodes will surely return to form after SummerSlam. But why not make it part of the story and give this angle a layer of depth that would elevate it from being just another celebrity match and give the fans something to really invest in? All the pieces are there! You might even say the stars have aligned!

Advertisement