10 Amazing Comic Book Redesigns That Didn't Last

Think Aquaman wasn't cool before the film? Think again.

By Ewan Paterson /

DC Comics

Redesigns are part and parcel of the superhero genre. If there's a hero, you can be certain that, at some stage, they're going to start to look a little outdated, and that's when comic book artists get to have their fun.

Advertisement

Either born out of frustration with a tired design or simply inspiration to try something different, comic book redesigns are as divisive as they are exciting, and sometimes (not all of the time), they can work tremendously.

For some characters, changes can be as big as scrapping an old costume from the ground up, whereas with others, the design is so timeless to begin with only minor alterations are called for. Either approach can yield a major impact, and though superhero comics have a habit of reverting to the status quo, some designs manage to leave a lasting impact.

Advertisement

Sadly, that cyclical return to the norm means that some of the best redesigns come and go in a flash. One day you're enjoying a Batsuit with a brilliant purple trim - the next, he's back to the usual black and grey. It's the case with dozens of characters, but here are those redesigns readers have ended up missing the most...

10. Spider-Woman's Jacket

Marvel Comics

The original Spider-Woman outfit is a bit of a relic, which is why it's something of a surprise to see it mounting a comeback in the pages of Marvel Strikeforce, a comic set to release later in 2019.

Advertisement

There's nothing inherently bad about the costume, but it does sort of conform to the old skin-tight mantra of designs gone by. It's why it was so interesting to see Jessica get a new look in 2014. courtesy of artists Kris Anka and Javier Rogriguez.

Marvel Comics

No longer donning the jumpsuit of yore, Drew now had a practical outfit that was functional, fashionable, and looked like the kind of outfit a super-spy/superhero would actually wear.

Advertisement

Drew sadly featured only sporadically in the years following the introduction of this outfit, and there's currently no word on why it was dropped. Here's hoping it mounts a comeback somewhere down the line.

9. Batman Incorporated

DC Comics

One of the biggest question that'll always divide Bat-fans straight down the middle (apart from how long the ears should be - it's short, btw), is what colour the character looks best in. We've seen variations of black, grey and blue, and it's all punctuated by the symbol on his chest.

Advertisement

For the past two decades, the plain old black symbol has been the standard uniform of the Dark Knight, while the years before saw him adopt a yellow crescent to fall behind the bat. It marked a comeback in Batman Inc., in a suit designed by David Finch, and it proceeded to last a grand total of a year before falling to the wayside in the New 52.

The Inc. suit is the best of both worlds, marrying the darker coloured Batsuits of the modern age with the classic vibrancy of the character's older comics. It was the perfect union, possessed symbolic value in terms of Batman's mission coming out of the shadows, and just looked the part in general.

Advertisement

If only it was around for longer...

8. Batgirl Of Burnside

DC Comics

Oracle fans may have found themselves disappointed when DC decided to make Barbara Gordon Batgirl again (thus depriving readers of a valuable disabled icon), but the move wasn't completely bad; it did, of course, give us the Batgirl of Burnside, a series that showcased Barbara going back to university in the trendy Gotham suburb of the same name.

Advertisement

A new change in surroundings necessitated a change in look, and the task fell to Babs Tarr. Tarr became the first woman to draw Batgirl long-term, joining fellow creatives Brenden Fletcher and Cameron Stewart to revamp the character four years into DC's controversial New 52 experiment. The resulting change was exemplified by Tarr's redesign, which imbued Batgirl with a hefty dose of purple while departing from the darker tones that had until then typified Gordon's experience in DC's new mythos.

The combo of purple and yellow is fairly synonymous with the character, but the best thing about Gordon's new look was that it was so stylish.

Advertisement

Instead of it being a traditional superhero costume, her jacket was almost like a biker's, giving the suit a more DIY, assembled-at-home kind of look.

7. The Many Stylings Of Cowan's Question

DC Comics/Denys Cowan

Ask DC fans what the Question's most typical outfit is, and they're likely to point out the fedora-wearing, trenchoat-clad figure that he's commonly depicted as. However, while that look is fairly iconic, it was dated three decades ago - hence why it's still a little weird to see Vic Sage still wearing a uniform no one would be caught dead in these days.

Advertisement

There's something to be said about formal crimefighting attire, but one of the coolest things about the Question series from the eighties was that Vic switched up his look on the fly. His costume is, in essence, just the pseudoderm mask that hides his facial features and dyes his hair a different colour; he should be able to throw on all sorts of clothes to go with it.

And for a while, the Question did. Shirts, jumpers, tank-tops, bomber jackets and trucker hats were all in Vic's wardrobe during the eighties, and it's high-time they made a comeback.

Advertisement

Well, maybe not in a vintage kind of way. The point is the Question used to be on the pulse of fashion. It's high-time DC restored him as their most stylish figure.

6. Ben Reilly's Spider-Man

Marvel Comics/Mark Bagley

It takes a lot to top Steve Ditko's original Spider-Man costume, but several artists have come close. We've seen a striking Spider-Man in Insomniac's game from 2018, a 'superior' design when Dock Ock took over Peter Parker's body, and a neo-noir design from 2099. But out of all the recent designs that were phased out too quickly, Ben Reilly's Spider-Man costume has to be the coolest.

Advertisement

Introduced during the Clone Saga when Marvel planned to retire Peter Parker and replace him with what was then thought to be the real version - and not a clone - Ben's Spider-Man suit is arresting for all the right reasons. The black spider spans across his chest and falls over his shoulders, while the external web-cartridges lend a more competent feel to the outfit overall.

Naturally, when Marvel got cold feet and reinstated Peter as the OG Spidey, the Ben Reilly character was retired and with it the suit designed by Mark Bagley.

Advertisement

Bagley has hit home runs every time he's been given the chance to put his own spin on Spidey's costume, most recently in Spider-Man: Life Story, but Reilly's is still the best.

5. DC Rebirth Batman

DC Comics

Batman's been through about three redesigns over the last decade (four, if you count Dick Grayson Batman), and none ever seem to stick. The first was the aforementioned Inc. suit, the second the one seen during the New 52, and the third - the subject of this entry - Greg Capullo's from DC Rebirth.

Advertisement

This suit is the culmination of all of Batman's different looks over the years, and it deserved to stick around for longer. The purple trip on the cape works as a glorious throwback to the gloves the Dark Knight sported when he first appeared, while the golden border around the black bat-symbol serves as the perfect blend between the OG symbol and the yellow crescent utilised in the years following.

Rebirth's look has, for now however, been replaced by the classic black trunks-black symbol combo. It's fine, and there's a Doomsday Clock costume update still to come, but the Dark Knight hadn't looked this good in years when Capullo got the chance to leave his own stamp on him three years ago.

Advertisement

4. Harpoon-Handed Aquaman

DC Comics

It's fair to say that most non-comics readers didn't care about Aquaman until last year's film released with Jason Mamoa in the title role, but to say that the character wasn't 'cool' beforehand would be to erase one of the best redesigns in DC history - the one seen during Peter David's Aquaman comic from the nineties.

Advertisement

King Arthur Curry lost his hand and proceeded to do what any upstanding underwater king would do in that situation, and replaced it with harpoon. Curry would retain his prosthetic for a good decade after, eventually wielding it on the small screen with the Justice League on the DC Animated Universe cartoon. The Atlantean would ditch his trademark gold and green outfit for that outing, and - when combined with the hook - it was something to behold.

Warner Bros.

The ensuing years would see DC once again adopt silver age Aquaman as the standard, but with Mamoa's likeness now influencing aspects of the character in the comics, one can only hope the harpoon makes a comeback.

Advertisement

3. Deathstroke Defiance

DC Comics

The Ikon suit sported by Deathstroke throughout DC Rebirth is by far the character's best look, but it's not the only one he rocks. When operating as the leader of a team of superheroes known as Defiance, Deathstroke dons a black and white Ikon costume complete with a cape. Nothing beats the black and orange, but if anything were to come close - or deserved to stick around for longer - it would be his outfit for Defiance.

Advertisement

Deathstroke is one of the most surprising comics to have emerged from DC Rebirth, blending high-stakes military fiction with superhero shenanigans to great effect, and it's arguably on Defiance where Christopher Priest and Carlo Pagulayan got the best out of it.

Slade trains a new team, comprised of his own family and other figures he's encountered over the course of the series, and all wear a black and white uniform to prove their newfound role.

Advertisement

It takes a bit of getting used to, but once it settled in, the Defiance costume was perfect.

2. Black Bat

DC Comics

Cassandra Cain is better known to readers as the second Batgirl, with the character having operated under the mantle all the way up until 2009, where she was then replaced by former Spoiler and Robin, Stephanie Brown. Luckily, this switch also necessitated a change in outfit, and it was a great one.

Advertisement

Although there's no denying that Cass looked the part in her original Batgirl outfit, her costume as Black Bat was even better. The cape was tattered and worn, providing a different kind of intimidation factor compared to the clean-cut trim of most other Bat-family outfits. The black and gold theme was still there, but the material of the cape elevated it to a whole other level.

Then there was the mask. Rather than it being the typical domino masks DC's heroes all tend to swear by, Cass adopted one that made it look as though she had bat-ears too, sort of like a nice blend between the Dark Knight's old cowl, and what his sidekicks all tend to wear.

Advertisement

Cass goes by Orphan these days, but it'd be great to see her return to the mantle - and outfit - that fans couldn't get enough of.

1. Pre-New 52 Red Robin

DC Comics

The New 52 featured some hokey redesigns, but perhaps the most unfortunate belonged to Tim Drake. The character had rebranded himself as Red Robin in 2009, at which point Damian Wayne became the regular Robin. The mantle stuck, but the Kingdom Come-inspired costume didn't, with Drake instead opting for a mechanical cape and design that proved that 'more' doesn't always mean 'better'.

Advertisement

Possibly one of the most underrated comics of the Batman Reborn era, Chris Yost, Fabian Nicieza and Marcus To's Red Robin saw Tim Drake try and find the answers behind Batman's death in Final Crisis. To do this, To outfitted Drake in a new outfit, one inspired by Dick Grayson's costume from 1996's seminal Elseworlds tale, Kingdom Come.

The flat cowl may not have been for everyone, but the mix of bandoliers with the red and black gave Tim another iconic look in his already modest wardrobe of account outfits. Drake's been a bit of a trend-setter in that sense, owning the two best Robin outfits in the green-sleeved version seen in the nineties, and the all-red one seen during the mid noughties.

Advertisement

Out of all, though, Red Robin was probably the best. It's just a shame DC didn't stick with it for their future reboots.