10 Best Batman Villain Triumphs

By Gavin Eddings /

Batman can do no wrong. He is often cited as the best comic book character by everyone including movie lovers, comic newbies, and long-time comic fans like myself. Whether you discovered Batman through the fantastic animated series of the early 90€™s or became acquainted with the Caped Crusader through his more recent film outings, the fact remains that Batman is awesome. When you start getting into anything Batman, you know you are in for some Bat-action, Bat-drama, and Batman coming out on top. Batman can be thwarted, though. After all, he is just a rich guy with gadgets. He doesn€™t have a healing factor or super-senses, he€™s just a human. And as we all know, humans can sometimes be defeated. It€™s not always fun to admit that our favorite nocturnal defender of the night has been beaten before, but we have to face facts. Batman gets beat up sometimes. This list is dedicated to those times and the villains who got a little retribution against ol€™ Bats. And don€™t worry, this isn€™t going to be 10 things the Joker did to Batman. Oh no, other villains have been known the best The Dark Knight as well. Without further ado, here are the 10 Best Batman Villain Triumphs. Oh, and before I start, spoilers will be taking place, including one that is very recent...

10. The Joker Shoots Barbara Gordon In The Spine

Advertisement
Let€™s start in some familiar territory and where most would assume I would begin: The Joker shooting Barbara Gordon. During the 80€™s (to some extent, today) Alan Moore could do no wrong. He had already penned Watchmen, V For Vendetta, and finished up a successful run on Swamp Thing. Then, in 1988, he had an idea for a Batman one-shot that would eventually become The Killing Joke. The whole purpose of the one-shot was to shed some light on the mysterious origins of who The Joker was before he became The Joker. Also, the core concept was that anyone could become just as crazy as The Joker just as long as they have €œone bad day.€ The Joker tries to turn Commissioner Gordon as mad as him by shooting his daughter (the then Batgirl, Barbara) in the spine, paralyzing her. This would be an event that would stay canon until The New 52 (in which they universe acknowledges The Killing Joke, but instead of making her paralysis permanent, she eventually recovers from it). This is a triumph because it showed that The Joker was willing to do anything in order to get a point across, even if it meant shooting a girl point-blank. And Batman would be powerless to do anything.

9. The Riddler Was Behind Hush

One of the more recent Batman stories that has gone on to be considered classic was the 2002-2003 storyline Hush, written by Jeph Loeb and drawn by the always fantastic Jim Lee. This story saw Batman fighting everyone from new villain Hush, to old villains like The Joker, Riddler, Clayface, and even a Poison Ivy-controlled Superman. The whole premise of the storyline was that there was bandage-faced, trench-coat wearing murderer named Hush loose in Gotham who wanted to destroy Batman. In typical Batman fashion, there are never enough cooks in the kitchen so the entire Rogues Gallery gets involved. In one of the key moments, The Joker appears to kill Dr. Thomas Elliot, a childhood friend of Bruce Wayne. But wait, this isn€™t another Joker triumph is it? Nope, turns out, Dr. Thomas Elliot faked his death (Clayface took his appearance) and actually was Hush. His entire motivation was that Bruce Wayne€™s father had helped save Elliot€™s parents, who had been in a car accident set up by a young Thomas. Thomas Elliot wanted his parent€™s dead so he could have his inheritance. Essentially, he was jealous that Bruce Wayne had gotten the life that he wanted. But wait, how did Thomas Elliot figure out that Batman was Bruce Wayne? Leave that to The Riddler, who was behind the entire plot. He had figured out who Batman really was and contacted Elliot. Lazarus Pits and other complicated things occurred, but The Riddler, who wasn€™t seen as much of a threat, not only figured out who Batman was, but put in motion a plan that almost destroyed everything. This story also marked the first return appearance of the long deceased Jason Todd. While Batman assumed Clayface had taken his form, Todd€™s grave remained empty, leaving only The Riddler to know his whereabouts. This is a triumph because Batman never suspected The Riddler was the one behind-the-scenes making everything happen. Anytime a villain is able to outsmart The World€™s Greatest Detective that can only go in the €œWin€ column.

8. The Joker Kills Robin #2

Speaking of Jason Todd, how€™d he die in the first place? Firstly, it€™s your fault (maybe, depending on whether or not you were alive in the 80€™s and dialed a 1-900 number determining Todd€™s fate), but it is also the fault of the Joker. Jason Todd was not a popular character and people never really took to him as Robin. Clearly, something had to be done so DC decided to hold the aforementioned phone poll and let the readers determine the fate of Jason Todd. We now know how that turned out, causing one of the most defining events in Batman€™s history: Jason Todd died. And at the hands of The Joker no less. The Joker kidnapped Jason Todd, beat him (nearly) to death with a crowbar and then locked him inside a warehouse with a bomb. By the time Batman was able to reach Jason, it was too late: The bomb had already gone off. The iconic image of Batman holding a bloody Jason Todd has become one of the most recognizable covers of all time. This storyline took place shortly after The Killing Joke, so The Joker was amassing quite the body count during the late 80€™s. This event is a triumph because The Joker actually killed someone close to Batman and would leave him mentally scarred for the next decade and a half. Because of Jason€™s death, Batman would become reluctant to take on any new partners for fear of getting them killed. Immediately following Jason€™s death, The Joker almost got the ultimate triumph over Batman: he enraged Batman so much that Batman seriously considered breaking his own rules and ending The Joker once and for all.

7. Kevin Smith Makes Batman Pee Himself

I need to preface this by saying that this triumph might be a stretch but I€™m going to try to make it work. When I refer to Kevin Smith, I am referring to renowned filmmakers and writer Kevin Smith, known for his Jay and Silent Bob movies. Kevin Smith has also been known to dabble in (often delayed) comic writing as well. In 2010, Kevin Smith penned the first part of a 12-issue mini-series called Batman: The Widening Gyre. It€™s a pretty terrible story yet Smith thinks it is genius because he was super high on drugs when he wrote it. And I€™m not exaggerating. He€™s proud of this weed-produced turd he has written. Some of the more notable writing includes Silver St. Cloud referring to Batman as €œDee-Dee€ because he gave her double digit orgasms the first time they had sex. Someone wrote that. On paper. For people to read. Not only is it ridiculous, but blatantly offensive to anyone who has ever enjoyed Batman. If only it ended there. Oh no, that villainous Smith had to take it one step further and not only make a terrible story, but also drag down Batman: Year One with him. In Smith€™s €œstory,€ Batman recants using explosives as a diversionary tactic for the first time. The blast was so terrifying, Batman peed himself when it went off. Thanks to Kevin Smith, it is now canon that Batman pees himself. Why not just give him I.B.B.S. (Irritable Batman Bowel Syndrome) as well? Why is this a triumph? Sometimes the writer can be just as big of a villain as any big bad in the story. Many writers would write €œBatman peed himself€ on a white board, realize what they wrote, chuckle, and erase it. Kevin Smith MADE IT ACTUALLY HAPPEN! And Kevin Smith is the one villain Batman can never take down.

6. Darkseid Kills Batman

Well, it certainly doesn€™t get more triumphant than killing Batman, does it? That€™s what happened in Final Crisis and the Batman R.I.P storyline. Well, sort of. This is one of the muddier triumphs on the list but it none-the-less affected the DC Universe for an amount of time. Batman, while fighting Darkseid, gets hit with the Omega Sanction, which is a killing blow. Superman is then seen holding the charred body of Batman and comic fans everywhere were left with a tear in their eye. Of all the villains to do in the Dark Knight, it wasn€™t even someone in his own Rogues Gallery to do it. Of course, we later find out that Superman was holding one of the many clones of Batman and not the real deal, but Batman is still missing. Turns out, he was thrown back in time by the Omega Sanction and not actually killed. Still, Batman was out of commission for some time that lead to Nightwing taking up the mantle of the Bat. As convoluted and confusing as this sounds, it still goes down as a triumph because comic fans believed Bruce Wayne to be dead. This also sent a message to any other villains that even Batman could be killed (or at least thrown through time for a bit).

5. Bane Breaks Batman€™s Back

I was only about 6 years old when this storyline took place but I remember the buzz surrounding it as my dad is a huge comic enthusiast. The thought that Batman could be broken was a foreign concept to my young mind. This story took place around the same time that Superman was killed by Doomsday so the whole world was watching what DC would do next. And they did not disappoint. The created a new villain in Bane, who would eventually be the one to break Batman. People tend to think that this happened fairly quickly or that Batman fought Bane one-on-one and lost. The actual story started well before the actual fight. Bane systematically took out Batman by exhausting him physically, mentally, and emotionally. Bane broke out all of the prisoners contained at Arkham Asylum. Batman was forced to fight criminals non-stop. Bane broke out not only criminals like The Joker and Riddler, but lesser villains like Killer Moth and Firefly. After a marathon of fighting the entire fleet of villains alone, Bane breaks an exhausted Batman€™s back by slamming him onto his knee. This is a triumph not just because of the physical harm done, but the mental damage done. Sure, Batman had been beaten before but he was literally broken. He had to also call in to question his decision to work alone and his entire way of taking down criminals. Bane also showed Batman does have a limit and that he should not underestimate his opponents. Luckily, with this past Summer€™s Dark Knight Rises film, Bane was finally given proper film treatment and displayed as the criminal genius he is.

4. Hugo Strange Learns Batman€™s Secret Identity

Hugo Strange is one of the more underrated villains Batman faces on a regular basis, even though he pre-dates the appearance of The Joker. Hugo Strange is still a dangerous foe and one that should be taken very, very seriously. Back in the 1970€™s, Hugo Strange was involved in a story called Strange Apparitions. Strange opened a hospital for the very wealthy and then held them hostage. Bruce Wayne becomes one of his patients following a fight with a new villain and Strange discovers that Bruce Wayne is Batman. In an instant, the one thing that Batman protected above everything else was immediately compromised. What does Strange do with this information? Like any good villain, he auctions off Batman€™s identity to the highest bidder but not before causing a little chaos in Wayne€™s life. The potential buyers included The Joker, The Penguin and mob boss Rupert Thorne. Instead of playing nice and paying like the rest, Thorne kidnaps Strange and beats him to death while trying to get the secret out of him. Thorne is then haunted by a ghost of Hugo Strange, but never learns the secret. This is a triumph because with a little detective work, Hugo Strange was able to figure out that Bruce Wayne was Batman. This leaves Batman vulnerable to attacks not just as Batman, but also as Bruce Wayne. He also runs the risk of Hugo Strange telling the world that he is Batman and completely destroying his entire operation. While not the biggest name in the hall of Batman villains, Hugo Strange is certainly formidable.

3. Alfred Gets Killed By A Rock

Last month, the whole world was watching as Scott Snyder€™s Death of the Family story arc wrapped up. One of the biggest questions Bat fans had was whether or not Snyder had done the unthinkable and killed Alfred. That didn€™t happen and instead we are left with mixed feelings about the storyline. If you need some Alfred death to quench your thirst for Alfred death, you are in luck. Alfred was actually killed back in the 1960€™s by Batman€™s most formidable foe: a giant boulder. Alfred is taken captive by the Tri-State gang and is going to be executed. Batman and Robin go to bust him out, but they think he€™s already dead. Alfred, who has gotten himself out, thinks that Batman and Robin have also been killed, so whacky shenanigans ensue. Alfred takes it upon himself to commandeer a motorcycle and Sons of Anarchy his way out of there. During his escape though, a giant boulder becomes dislodged and crushes him, while Batman (realizing Alfred wasn€™t dead after all) screams €œOH NO! NO!€, which is the 1960€™s version of the F-word. Many of the may be wondering why this death isn€™t a bigger deal or why you may not have heard of it. Like a few other entries on the list, the story loses focus and eventually turns into a mess that was dragged out for 3 years. A new villain shows up with the name The Outsider who torments Batman for a few months. Eventually, The Outsider is revealed to be a revived Alfred who has come back with revenge on his mind. They never really specify what the revenge is for, so I€™m going to assume he was fed up with doing Bruce Wayne€™s laundry. Batman eventually punches The Outsider into turning back into Alfred. Alfred regains his place as Batman€™s butler and all is well with the world. This is a triumph because it showed Batman that it might not always be super villains who are responsible for the fate of his friends and family. Sometimes, it can be a falling boulder with a blood-lust.

2. Talia Al Ghul Has a Child With Batman

When I first heard the idea of Batman having a child, I groaned. How could this possibly work? Sure, Batman had been around children before (and even helped raise a few), but the idea that Batman could have a biological child still seemed like it wouldn€™t work. Luckily, the genius of Grant Morrison was at play and gave Batman a new dimension to his character. Enter Damian Wayne: the son of Batman and Talia Al Ghul, the daughter of dangerous foe Ra€™s Al Ghul. Raised by Talia and the League of Assassins, Damian is highly-trained and dangerous. During Batman€™s first encounter with Damian, he realizes just how twisted his views on life really are. After taking Damian back to the Batcave, Damian escapes, goes on patrol, and ends up cutting the head off of a local criminal. Tim Drake, the Robin at the time, explains that that is not the way that they do things. Damian takes note of this, and then promptly beats the crap out of Tim. Damian then steals Jason Todd€™s Robin outfit and takes his place at his father€™s side as the new Robin, which has had a tremendous affect on the Bat-family. This is a huge triumph for Talia Al Ghul and Ra€™s Al Ghul, respectively. Not only does Damian tie all of them together by blood, it also offers Talia and Ra€™s leverage in any situation. There is also always the risk of Damian being a secret agent for The League of Assassins and killing Batman when he least expects it. Batman is also left not only worrying about another Robin and the harm that may come to him, but the fate of his own son as well. It appears that Damian may be the latest victim of the Robin curse, as the latest issue of Batman: Incorporated sees Damian getting killed. If Damian is in fact dead, the triumph of Talia over Batman has only just begun.

1. Joe Chill Kills Bruce Wayne€™s Parents

This is what started it all. If not for Joe Chill killing Bruce Wayne€™s parents, there would be no Batman. On their way home from a night on the town, Joe Chill mugs Thomas and Martha Wayne. The mugging escalates and he ends up killing them. Bruce is left in Crime Alley, with his dead parents laying at his feet. As far as superhero origin stories go, there is none more tragic than that of Batman. After their death, Bruce Wayne vowed to avenge his parents' death and prevent anyone else from ever having to endure what he went through. This is a triumph because it is the single-most important event in Batman€™s mythology. No matter how many criminals Batman puts away, no matter how many robberies he stops, the fact remains that his parents are dead. He can€™t bring them back. His parents' death is the one thing that he can never let go of. Every time he visits Crime-Alley, Joe Chill gets another triumph because he is the one that forced Bruce Wayne to become Batman. He took away Wayne€™s opportunity at a normal life. Without Joe Chill, Batman would have never had his back broken by Bane, put Jason Todd or Barbara Gordon in harm€™s way, hell, without Joe Chill, The Joker wouldn€™t even exist. In the end, it wasn€™t a super villain or multi-dimensional being that got the best of Batman, it was a simple mugger named Joe Chill. Not only did he destroy the life of Bruce Wayne, but he also destroyed every life living in Gotham. Anything I missed? Any notable triumphs that I should have acknowledged? Let me know in the Bat-comments!