10 Best Superman & Lex Luthor Stories Ever Written

The best of enemies, to the bitter end...

By Neil Gray /

Every hero needs a villain. An arch nemesis to butt head with on a regular basis and, on occasion, to throw through a building or two but it can be a hard thing to get right. Get it wrong and you end up with someone like the Rainbow Raider who's only real power is to be able to see in bright colors but if you nail it, then you can set in motion a rivalry that lasts for decades.

Advertisement

This is what Superman and Lex Luthor have had for nearly eighty years now as these two have gone head to head time and time again. Lex is driven by an unreasonable hatred for Kal, seeing him as nothing more than an unwanted alien who is trying to take over his planet. This means that he is always planning and plotting to destroy the Man of Steel with varying degrees of success.

But which stories from their illustrious past are the ones that you should check out? And which of these truly deserves the title of the greatest story ever written? Read on to find out.

10. Injustice: Gods Among Us

Now admittedly, this isn't a straight forward Superman and Lex Luthor tale as there is far more going on here than the story of two men but the dynamic is such an interesting one, what with their roles being reversed, that it would be remiss not to include it on this list.

Advertisement

After Superman goes power crazy, due to the Joker turning Metropolis into a million tiny radioactive pieces, it falls to Batman to put a stop Kal-El's reign of terror. Along the way, he is helped out by heroes from Earth prime as well as forming an alliance with Harley Quinn but the strangest member of his rebellion is Lex Luthor.

The reason that it's such an odd arrangement is that Lex and Clark are childhood friends and Lex has done nothing over the years to betray Superman's trust. When he is found alive in one of his bunkers after the explosion, Kal is genuinely happy to see him and when Lex agrees to help the Justice League rule over humans with an iron fist it seems as if these two will fight side by side to the end.

So, it comes as quite a shock when he betrays him, especially as it costs him his life.

9. Lex Luthor: Man Of Steel

This 2005 mini-series from Brian Azzarello and Lee Bermejo gives us a different look at the man known as Luthor. For a start the whole story is told from Lex's point of view, giving the reader a closer understanding and a deeper examination of what really makes the man tick. Something that hadn't really happened in comics before.

Advertisement

This version of Lex is a lot different from the one that fans have become accustomed to. He is more benevolent, even going as far as to turn his Science Spire into a non-profit organization, and it seems that it's the so-called heroes that are the ones that shouldn't be trusted.

Throughout the book, it seems that Lex only wants what is best for the human race and when he unveils a brand new superhero, known as Hope, it looks like he very well might just get it. But, as is always the case, there is more going on than first meets the eye.

It turns out that Hope is an Android that Lex has created with the specific purpose of bringing Superman down and during their final battle, Lex detonates Hope, making it appear as if Kal is responsible for her death.

This leads to a final confrontation between the two is powerful enough to have Lex questioning his own humanity.

8. Superman/Batman: Public Enemies

Like 'Injustice' before it, Superman/Batman Public Enemies isn't a straight forward story of Lex and Clark as it has everyone's favorite billionaire who dresses like a giant bat involved but it still deserves its place on this list as it shows what happens when someone that is as hell-bent on destroying another, as Lex is with Superman, gets the ultimate power of the Presidential office.

Advertisement

Lex is the big kahuna, the top dog, the...er...head cheese after he runs for President and wins. His first edict is to declare the World's Finest as Public Enemies #1 and the way he justifies his actions is to blame Superman for a giant asteroid of kryptonite that is heading towards the Earth and if this isn't enough to sway opinion against him, he has Metallo murdered and pins the crime on Kal.

Obviously, the two heroes aren't going to take this laying down and they set out to prove that it's actually Luthor that the planet should be afraid of and not them.

This is something they eventually achieve, even though they have to go through Lex's own group of Superheroes to do so, and with the truth out Lex's is carted away to face trial for his crimes.

7. The Secret Revealed

Everyone knows that Lex's hatred for Superman is as strong as a million red suns but just what lengths is he willing to go to to get what he wants? Well, according to this 1987 issue, by John Byrne and Terry Austin, it isn't beyond him to use a little torture to find out what he needs to know.

Advertisement

Determined to find out just who lurks behind the familiar red and blue suit, Lex makes it his mission to expose Superman and he does this by having some of his goons pay a visit to the Kent's farm. It's here that, after they have drugged and captured both John and Martha, they bump into Lana Lang and do the same to her.

When Lex lays eyes on her he immediately recognizes her as someone who is close to Kal and proceeds to torture the hell out of her as he tries, in vain, to get her to cough up a name. When this doesn't happen he lets her escape, knowing that the first person she will run to is the Big Blue Boy Scout.

Even now, just over thirty years later, this is a great comic and the sight of an obviously tortured Lana is still as shocking as it was back then.

6. How Much Can One Man Hate?

The 'Superman Adventures' comic book is one of the most underrated in the entire DC library. Based on the superb 'Superman: Animated Series', it is, arguably, the best version of the Man of Steel throughout the 90s and it also gives the reader some of the greatest stories told in that time period. And none more so than Mark Millar's 'How Much Can One Man Hate?"

Advertisement

After he foils yet another attempt on his life, Superman heads to Lex Corp and asks Luthor a simple question: "What have I ever done to make you hate me this much?". Lex reply is simple: "If you have to ask, you'll never know."

What follows is a look into the reasons behind Lex's blind hatred towards Kal and it seems that it all comes down to jealousy. Everything that he has he's had to work for whereas Clark is seen as a hero just because he saves cats from trees and, up to a point, you can kind of understand what he's getting at.

When another of Lex's creations is sent out to destroy Superman and is eventually defeated, Kal confronts him again and says that he's wasted his genius when he could've been making the world a better place.

5. Krisis Of The Krimson Kryptonite

Even though 'Krisis of the Krimson Kryptonite' is kicked off by Mister Mxyzptlk, he is only the catalyst behind the whole thing as the majority of the story is, once again, taken up by Lex's continuing quest to destroy Superman.

Advertisement

When Mxyzptlk creates red kryptonite he offers it to Luthor who is more than happy to take it off his hands. Armed with this new weapon he immediately starts to make Kal's life a living hell by stripping him of his powers.

It's when he is transporting a criminal to jail that the new kryptonite first takes effect. This means he loses his power and falls into the harbor and from here things just get worse for him. He is beaten up by Lex and then thrown out of his office and he has to keep his weakness under wraps as he knows that if the criminal element of Metropolis ever found out about it, they would run wild.

He manages to achieve this with the help of Starman but it isn't until he visits Luthor in the guise of Clark Kent does he finally get the truth about where the red kryptonite comes from.

4. The Showdown Between Luthor And Superman

It may be a surprise to see this story on this list, let alone so far up it, but it is a testament to the work of Edmond Hamilton, Curt Swan and George Klein that it should be considered essential reading for anyone with even a passing interest in the relationship between Lex and Superman.

Advertisement

It is the first time that Luthor is depicted in the way that has since become so familiar. He is conniving and untrustworthy and is willing to do whatever it takes to finally vanquish his foe. He challenges Supes to a mano-a-mano fight on an alien planet that is orbited by a red sun and it isn't long before Superman takes him up on his offer.

With his powers drained it doesn't take Lex long to get the upper hand and because Kal has spent his life holding back so he doesn't kill anyone, he is on the serious end of an ass whupping. In fact, it is only one lucky haymaker that lays Luthor out cold that stops this from being a complete massacre.

Even though Superman is victorious in the end, Lex escapes too fight another day.

3. The Death Of Superman

This isn't 'The Death of Superman' that everyone is so familiar with. This one is from 1961 and is an imaginary tale where Lex finally does what he has always wanted to and kills the Man of Steel. But it isn't just because he manages to pull off the impossible that makes this story so great, it's the way he goes about achieving this.

Advertisement

Jerry Siegel, Curt Swan, and Sheldon Moldoff's story show's just what lengths Lex is willing to go to, to destroy his nemesis as he cures cancer just so he can get close enough to Superman to kill him.

Having access to the prison laboratories is all he needs to do this and this, in turn, turns him into a national hero as well as getting Supes to trust him. In fact, he has so much faith in Luthor that when he is attacked by mobsters it's the Big Blue Boy Scout who rushes to his aid. But, as always, everything is not as it seems and when he rushes to his aid again it turns out that it's a trap.

With all his friends watching, Superman is injected with a fatal dose of kryptonite and dies, giving Lex everything he's always dreamed of. Oh, and and a trip to the Phantom Zone, cause you ain't getting away with that s**t.

2. Red Son

There is a lot going on in this comic but the underlying story is still the one that these two have fought over and over. It's just that this time around, Lex Luthor is actually fighting for the good fight.

Advertisement

Instead of landing in Smallville it's Russia that becomes the adopted home for Superman and, after his existence is revealed, a new arms race is started except this time it's one for powers instead of nuclear weapons.

He is immediately seen as a threat to the safety of the United States and this brings Lex into the loop as he is recruited by C.I.A agent, Jimmy Olsen, to devise a way to kill the Red Son. Even though his attempts fail, he finds himself in the position to run for President and win. This gives him the opportunity to really throw all of the resources of the US behind him as he continually tries to find a way to destroy Superman.

Red Son is a fantastic story that asks the greatest 'What If?' question of all time and its answer is quite simple. That it really would take a super genius to defeat a Superman.

1. All-Star Superman

There is no doubt that Grant Morrison and Frank Quietly's 'All-Star Superman' is the greatest Superman story ever told and, because of this, it's also the greatest Superman and Lex Luthor story ever written.

Advertisement

When Lex sabotages the PROJECT team as they are exploring the sun it's up to Superman to save them. He does this but at quite a cost as it was Luthor's plan all along to have the Man of Steel exposed to massive amounts of solar radiation, as this unstabilizes his molecular structure and, even though it grants him brand new powers, begins to kill him.

Knowing that his time is short he puts all of his efforts into making sure the planet is safe after he is gone and in doing so comes face to face with Lex in one last battle between the two. His final victory sees him shoot Luthor with a gravity gun and this drains him of his powers, letting Lex finally sees the world as Superman sees it, bringing to a close one of the greatest rivalries in comic book lore.

At least, for a while.

Advertisement