10 Best 'What If?' Marvel Stories You Must Read

With Disney+ making an animated 'What If?' series, what are the best stories from the comic?

By Jonathan H. Kantor /

Marvel Comics' popular What If...? series of books has been optioned as a television series for Disney+, leaving many fans wondering what stories might make their way to the small screen. The series will be an animated anthology, which will take much of its content directly from the comics.

Advertisement

That being said, there is a lot of content to choose from, and many of the stories written in What If...? over the years have gone on to influence the Marvel multiverse, which suggests the show could adapt pretty much anything and everything into the new series.

Whatever Marvel and Disney decide to do, the older comics have been cast back into the light leaving many to look back on the amazing series. Fans unfamiliar with them are wondering what they were all about, while those who read the books are considering which stories might be adapted for the new show.

This list compiles the 10 best What If...? stories ever written, and though the TV show won't be arriving until a while from now, it's never a bad time to talk about Marvel's best What If? tales.

10. What If... Venom Had Possessed The Punisher?

What If...? Vol. 2 #44, (1992)

Advertisement

Venom was a hugely popular character back in the early nineties, so Marvel played around with who/what he was early on with some What If...? storylines. In what many consider to be one of the best, Venom doesn't possess Eddie Brock, but rather finds Frank Castle instead.

It all went down when Castle ended up at the church where Peter Parker rid himself of the Venom Symbiote instead of Brock. It bonded with him, but he thought it was just some advanced SHIELD technology and not an alien symbiote intent on taking over his body and mind.

With the new "tech," Castle became an even deadlier Punisher. He killed the Kingpin and Tombstone but began a struggle with the symbiote for dominance of his body. It started controlling him at night while he slept, which brought him to the attention of Spider-Man, Daredevil, and Moon Knight who confronted him.

Castle's struggle with the symbiote ultimately ended in his favor when he threatened to kill himself if he didn't regain control. From that point, he was the master of the Venom symbiote (and a more powerful Punisher to boot). The heroes left him alone at the end of the story thinking he could be a powerful ally sometime in the future.

9. What If... Captain America Were Not Revived Until Today?

What If...? Vol.1 #44 (1983)

Advertisement

In the regular continuity of the Marvel Universe, Captain America was found by Namor, the Sub-Mariner as he was fleeing from the Avengers. He was a block of ice being worshiped by Inuits, so Namor picked him up and chucked him into the water where he thawed.

He then went on to join the team, gave it new life, and become the hero of the modern Marvel Universe. But, what if that didn't happen? What would happen to the Avengers, and what would occur if Cap wasn't unfrozen until today (Not talking about the MCU here)?

That question was explored by having Namor flee from the Avengers, but not find and thaw Cap as he did in Avengers #4. Because he wasn't around, the team wasn't rebuilt around his leadership. The Avengers disbanded, and the world moved on without them until a duplicate of Cap and Bucky are found and unfrozen, but they go on to create a situation that leads to race wars and martial law in the United States.

When Cap was finally unfrozen, he finds a world much different than the one he left. The bad Captain America is building a monarchy in the remnants of the U.S. (to fight communism), and it's up to the real Cap to take him out, which he does at the end of the story leading to a hopeful future.

8. What If... Wolverine Had Killed The Hulk?

What If...? Vol.1 #31 (1982)

Advertisement

Wolverine was first introduced in Incredible Hulk #180-181 where he was pitted against the Green Goliath in the forests of Canada. Wolverine proved capable of penetrating the Hulk's skin and survived a beating, but in the original books, the Wendigo interrupted their battle and Wolverine was put to sleep alongside the Hulk.

But what if that didn't happen and Wolverine actually killed the Hulk? The Hulk's death would have severe repercussions across the Marvel Universe, but in this story, Wolverine has to face murder charges after he fatally wounds the Hulk.

Facing the law, he falls into the hands of Magneto who recruits him into the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants. After taking up with the villainous organization, Wolverine is given his first assignment: infiltrate the X-Men, which he does fairly easily.

While with the team, he proved his abilities in the Danger Room against some Sentinels, but when it came time to betray them, he pulled a double-cross against the Master of Magnetism himself. The fight ends in a draw as both Mutants kill one another, and it all came to pass because Wolverine was able to kill the Hulk the first time they met.

7. What If... The FF Had Not Gained Their Superpowers?

What If...? Vol. 1 #36 (1982)

Advertisement

The Fantastic Four got their powers thanks to Reed Richards' refusal to follow the rules. In the debut issue of the famous family, Reed and the gang hopped onto their rocket prior to the installation of its proper shielding and wound up getting bathed in cosmic rays.

What would have happened had Reed followed the rules and waited? That question was answered when Reed did precisely that! The group waited, they launched their rocket, which soared into the sky with complete success. The test helps to establish the American Space industry, and the group is labeled heroes... but they didn't get any superpowers.

Just as it played out in the original issue, Mole Man attacks with an army of his molemen. Even though the U.S. Army was tasked to investigate, Reed, Sue, Johnny, and Ben all head into the tunnel beneath their compound to take on the subterranean menace.

Without any superpowers at all, they managed to win the day! With their victory against the menace of the Mole Man behind them, they go on to become pulp adventurers who don't need any superpowers to fight against the forces of evil!

6. What If... Someone Else Besides Spider-Man Had Been Bitten By The Radioactive Spider?

What If...? Vol. 1 #7 (1978)

Advertisement

Pretty much everyone knows that Peter Parker was bitten by a radioactive spider while on a school field trip, but what would happen if somebody else got bitten instead? This has been explored throughout the Marvel Universe, but long before the debut of Silk, the concept was tackled in a multi-part story in the pages of What If...?

In the first alternate story, Flash Thompson is bitten by the spider, but Peter sees it happen and runs some tests. Flash then goes on to become a superhero while Peter becomes his biggest fan. He ends up getting killed while fighting the Vulture when he is dropped from very high up. Without the web fluid Peter developed, Flash was left without any means of slowing his fall.

In the next story, Betty Brant is bitten by the spider while Peter watches. She goes on to become a superhero while Peter helps her by designing a costume and web shooters. When a criminal she failed to stop killed Ben Parker, she punched him to death in a rage. Unable to face her murderous abilities, she abandoned the life of a superhero.

In the final story, John Jameson was bitten by the spider. When his father, J. Jonah Jameson finds out, he immediately promotes his son's new powers in the paper while encouraging him to become a superhero. Like Flash, he didn't have web shooters, which proved fatal when he dropped to Earth from a failed space capsule, which crushed him.

5. What If... The Avengers Fought The Kree-Skrull War Without Rick Jones?

What If...? Vol. 1 #20 (1980)

Advertisement

The Kree-Skrull War was one of the biggest conflicts in Marvel history. It was literally intergalactic, and the Avengers got mixed up in the middle of it. Back when it happened in the regular continuity, the only thing that brought it to an end quickly was Rick Jones.

He managed to tap into the Destiny Force to summon forth a horde of Golden Age heroes to fight the gathered aliens making him something of a deus ex machina, which means he was vital to the whole plot. That begs the question, what if he wasn't around for that final battle?

In the story, Ronan kills Jones soon after capturing him, which enabled the conflict to continue. Professor X used all of his psychic powers to rally the combined forces of Earth against the Skrull armada while Princess Anelle began a rebellion against her father on the Skrull homeworld. At the same time, the Supreme Intelligence used Jones' remains to become a completely new being able to break free and destroy Ronan.

With Ronan gone, a peace was found between the various combatants. Anelle took over her father's role as the leader of the Skrull while the Supremor (The Supreme Intelligence's new identity) handed over command of the Kree to Mar-Vell and all was right in the cosmos... except for Rick Jones... that guy was dead.

4. What If... Beast & The Thing Continued To Mutate?

What If...? Vol. 1 #37 (1983)

Advertisement

The concept of continual mutation has been ongoing in the Marvel Universe for some time, but back in 1983, it was a relatively new idea fleshed out in the pages of What If...? This story takes elements from Amazing Adventures #11 and examines them in a new, different light.

What if Hank McCoy's mutation formula was a bit more potent than it was previously? The result isn't a lovable furry genius who hangs from the chandelier, but rather, a beast whose mind is as savage as he looked. When Professor X sensed Hank's trouble, he sent Cyclops, Angel, and Marvel Girl in to help.

They found him in Central Park where he immediately attacked them. Using what little intellect he had remaining, he found a way to surrender, but the X-Men were unable to help him. As a result, they were forced to relocate Beast to the Savage Land where he could roam free, unable to hurt anyone.

The Thing's story diverged from Marvel Two-In-One #82, which has the Thing continue to mutate from Virus X. He changed into a monstrous radioactive monster. Just when a cure is ready for him, his body erupted in radioactive energy releasing all of the stored cosmic rays his body had built up over the years. He was cured of both being the Thing and Virus X, but what's more, Alicia regained her sight. He left the Fantastic Four to be with Alicia while Giant-Man replaced him on the team.

3. What If... The Avengers Defeated Everybody?

What If...? Vol. 1 #29 (1981)

Advertisement

The Avengers are Earth's mightiest heroes, but what would happen if they all decided to turn on every other hero in the Marvel Universe? In a world that is similar to the one presented in Avengers Annual #2, the Scarlet Centurion managed to trick the Avengers into doing just that.

Unlike the original story, a future group of Avengers from another reality didn't arrive in time to stop the Centurion's plan. This left the Avengers to do exactly what the Centurion wanted, but it didn't go fully according to plan thanks to the Incredible Hulk.

The Hulk reached a point where he turned on the rest of the team, but when that happened, they banded together and defeated him leading to his being added to the Centurion's collection. When the dust settled, the remaining Avengers decided to retire, but it was at that point that the Scarlet Centurion decided to take over the world.

With the new threat on the horizon, Thor, Iron Man, the Wasp, and Giant-Man banded together once more to take him on. They managed to finally defeat him, but when the fight finally came to an end, they all decided to remain retired.

2. What If... The Hulk Had The Brain Of Bruce Banner?

What If...? Vol. 1 #2 (1977)

Advertisement

The Incredible Hulk has gone through a number of changes over the years, but for the most part, he has been a mindless rage monster often referred to as "savage." In the early days of the character, there was no concept of merging the psyches of the Hulk and Bruce Banner... until, of course, What If...? came along.

In this story, the question of what would happen if the Hulk's mind had merged with that of Bruce Banner was answered. This occurred long before it actually happened in the comics, so forget what you know about Professor Hulk for the moment.

Instead of being transformed into a mindless monster, Banner's intellect was completely intact when he transformed into the Hulk. He never became an enemy of General Ross, but it wasn't until Galactus came to Earth that the real need for an intelligent Hulk came into play.

Instead of going for the Ultimate Nullifier as they did in the Fantastic Four books, Reed Richards, Professor X, and Banner-Hulk combined themselves via an upgraded Cerebro they called the Psychotron. The three merged into a new being called "X-Man" whose combined might succeeded in deterring the World Devourer from destroying the Earth. When the job was done, the men returned to normal, but without their superpowers while the Thing transformed into a more monstrous version of himself more akin to the original Hulk.

1. What If... Spider-Man Had Never Become A Crimefighter?

What If...? Vol. 1 #19 (1980)

Advertisement

As any reader of Spider-Man comics knows, Peter Parker became a crimefighter after he allowed a criminal to escape his clutches only to find he had killed his beloved Uncle Ben. Remembering his uncle's words, "With great power comes great responsibility," Peter took to webslinging, and became a superhero.

What would have happened had he not let that criminal go by? Stopping his meant keeping Ben alive, which meant he might not go on to become a superhero after all. In this story, Parker took out the robber to make himself look good with the cops, and it worked.

He then went on to guest-host the Tonight Show, and signed a movie deal with Marlon Brando and Gene Hackman. After this, he became a superhero marketing agent with services provided to the Fantastic Four and Daredevil, but his actions came into conflict with J. Jonah Jameson, who was ultimately fired from the Daily Bugle.

Later, Parker was meeting with the writers about his next film when he was dropped through the floor. He was then faced with fighting a plethora of supervillains but had the assistance of Daredevil, and the pair managed to beat them all. When the mastermind was finally unmasked, it turned out to be none other than J. Jonah Jameson himself! He blamed Parker for ruining his life, and after thinking about it, he realized he was right. By not acting responsibly (as his uncle had taught him), he had caused the ruin of another man's life.

Advertisement