10 Biggest Comic Book Twists You Never Saw Coming
Every now and then, there are those comic book twists that knock readers right out of their chairs.
There are certain things that we’ve come to expect as comic book readers. The hero may struggle and suffer but will ultimately come out on top. The bottom line is justice will prevail and the good guys go home in the end. And the bad guys may make some advances and may win a few of the battles, but they will ultimately lose. These are tropes that make up the backbone of the comics medium.
Truly clever creators know how to turn those tropes on their heads and keep the readers guessing. They’ll bring back a character who couldn’t possibly come back, kill off someone who should never be killed, or make a background character into the most important figure in the world - just to keep the readers on their toes.
And the readers are along for the ride. They are willing participants. They accept what they have been told before, rely on the accepted trope, and never see the twist until it is right in front of them. Like the large hill on a roller coaster, the reader feels their heart drop as they turn the page or worse, are forced to wait a month until they can learn what happens next.
Here, are ten such examples of classic twists that even the most seasoned comic book fan didn't see coming.
10. The Truth About The Swamp Thing
There are few origins as tragic as the origin of the Swamp Thing. And as he goes on through his existence, he finds that what he thinks he knows about himself is wrong. He is not a man transformed. He isn’t a man at all. The creature that believed itself to be Alec Holland is quite literally a force of nature.
When scientist Alec was caught in a lab explosion and drenched in his Bio-Restorative Formula that would solve any nation’s food problem, he leaped into the swamp. The formula reacted with the vegetation in the swamp and Holland believed it transformed him into a hulking plant monster. He sought ways to get his human body back and was often opposed by Anton Arcane. After being captured by General Sunderland and experimented on by Jason Woodrue, it was discovered that Swamp Thing wasn’t Alec Holland at all. He was a plant creature with the consciousness and meteorites of Holland.
London magician John Constantine told Swamp Thing that he was the latest in the line of plant elementals and took him to the Parliament of Trees, where all the retired planet elementals reside. Constantine explained that Swamp Thing was an avatar of the Green, the elemental force that connects all plant life in the world and how to travel it around the world and beyond.
9. Sharon Carter Killed Captain America
The superhero Civil War was raging until Captain America saw everyday people step up to defend Iron Man, and Steve realized that he had made the wrong decision and surrendered. Rogers was taken into S.H.I.E.L.D. custody and, on the courthouse steps, the Sentinel of Liberty was killed. But the killing blow didn’t come from a sniper. It came from someone he loved.
Sharon Carter was the niece of heroic WWII freedom fighter Margaret “Peggy” Carter who had fought alongside Captain America many times during the war. The elderly aunt would regale her impressionable young niece with stories of her exploits, and this was at least partially the reason for Sharon to join S.H.I.E.L.D. as Agent 13 and go on to have a distinguished career of her own. She worked alongside the revived Steve Rogers and the two began a relationship.
Agent 13 fell under the hypnotic control of Dr. Faustus, while he was posing as a S.H.I.E.L.D. psychiatrist, and the Red Skull, Faustus’ superior. They planted a post-hypnotic suggestion in Sharon to find and kill Captain America. On that day, it appeared to everyone present that the villain Crossbones had killed Steve with a sniper rifle. But as Sharon kneeled over Cap, she shot him with a second gun. This gun didn’t actually kill him but displaced him in time. With Sharon and the Avengers' help, he eventually returned.
8. Barbara Gordon Shot!
It was a quiet night at the home of father and daughter James and Barbara Gordon until a knock on the door changed everything. The Joker shot Barbara through the spine and shattered her career as Batgirl, and the twist is that the Clown Prince of Crime wasn’t even there for her. She was just a means to an end.
When the Joker arrived at the Gordon house that evening, his intention was to kidnap Commissioner Gordon and attempt to drive him insane. Shooting Barbara, stripping her naked, and taking pictures of her was simply one piece of the plan to push Jim Gordon over the edge. Barbara was merely a convenient cog in the Clown’s plan. He had no clue that he had robbed the Bat Family of a key member.
Thankfully, Barbara’s indomitable will and intelligence allowed her to rise above her hardship and become an even stronger force for justice as the Oracle. As the information broker to the superhero and intelligence community, like Amanda Waller’s early Suicide Squad, and as the woman in the chair for the Birds of Prey, Barbara became much feared by the criminal community because her digital presence was everywhere and there was little she couldn’t find out with just a few keystrokes.
7. Krakoa Means Life
The establishment of the island nation of Krakoa brought about many changes in the lives of the mutants of the Marvel Universe, but there is one secret that they keep from the rest of the world that changed the landscape in a nearly unbelievable way. The Mutants have conquered death itself.
When they were putting things in motion for the creation of a nation for mutants, Moira MacTaggert and Charles Xavier believed the right combination of mutants could resurrect the dead. To facilitate this, Xavier and Magneto charged mutant geneticist Mr. Sinister to archive the genetic material of every mutant on the planet. Xavier had mutant inventor Forge create a Cerebro-style unit to house the consciousness of every mutant.
Once Krakoa was established, the Five were chosen. Egg creates an egg for the new body to form. Then they are ejected with DNA from Sinister’s archive and made viable by the reality-altering powers of Proteus. Elixir gives the eggs life and Tempus uses her time-altering powers to mature the mutant to adulthood. Hope Summers makes sure all things work in unison. A telepath then returns the consciousness of the person to the body and that mutant is born anew. The Five follows strict Resurrection Protocols and the resurrections are something the X-Men do not share with their fellow superheroes or anyone else.
6. The Truth About Hush
Tommy Elliot was born a child of wealth and privilege and was friends with young Bruce Wayne, often beating him in strategy games. But unlike the loving Wayne home, Elliot’s father was an abusive alcoholic and his mother was more worried about holding on to the wealth. As a young man, Elliot tried to kill his parents by cutting their brake line. His father died but his mother was saved by Dr. Thomas Wayne, sparking Elliot’s resentment of the elder Wayne.
Having eventually smothered his over-possessive mother with a pillow, Tommy went to medical school and encountered Edward Nashton when working as a neurosurgeon. The Riddler attempted to sell the knowledge of the Lazarus Pits to the young doctor, while Elliot wanted Nygma’s help getting revenge on his old friend, Bruce Wayne. Riddler revealed to Elliot that Batman and Bruce Wayne were one and the same, and Elliot adopted the identity of Hush to put his plan in motion to tear the Dark Knight down.
Elliot employed, threatened, or tricked many of Batman’s rogues gallery into helping him with his plan to destroy Batman’s life through relentless attacks on him and his allies and friends. At one point, he even removed Catwoman’s heart and kept it frozen using technology from Mr. Freeze. Elliot’s worst act against Batman was to have plastic surgery to look just like Bruce Wayne.
5. The Skrulls Among Us
The Skrulls were once an annoying but ultimately silly race of aliens. The Fantastic Four made a team of them transform themselves into cows, after all. But when they used their shape-shifting skills to begin a covert invasion of the 616 Earth, it quickly became hard to know who to trust during the Secret Invasion.
One of the consequences of the superhero Civil War and the desolation of the Avengers was that their ally Ronin was left in Japan without any backup against the Hand. Ronin was captured and discovered to be the deaf hero Echo. Word got back to Wolverine and he convinced his team of New Avengers to travel to Japan to save her. During the fight, Echo killed Elektra, who turned into a Skrull when she died. This immediately made the New Avengers distrust each other.
Spider-Woman, who had already been replaced, suggested that only Iron Man had the equipment to determine what Elektra truly was. Luke Cage angrily claimed that if anyone was a Skrull, it had to be Stark, based on his actions. She fought the team and took the corpse to Stark. The shocked Iron Man contacted his fellow members of the clandestine Illuminati, discovering that Black Bolt was also a Skrull that Namor killed. They left realizing that they could not truly trust one another.
4. Jason Todd Lives
It’s not that rare for characters to return from the dead in comics these days. It is rare that such a hated character returns to become someone that is beloved by many fans. Jason Todd, the second Robin, was an obnoxious punk. He was reckless, didn’t follow Batman’s orders, and was a brutal fighter who went too far. Still, his death at the hands of the Joker devastated Bruce and drove him into his own bout of brutal retribution on the criminal world.
Jason was resurrected six months after his death by Talia al Ghul using a Lazarus Pit. Talia took Jason to the All Caste to be trained in letting go of his anger, but in true Todd fashion, he believed that he knew best and rejected this tenant of their teachings. He later joined the League of Assassins where he trained with both the Bronze Tiger and Lady Shiva, but he left the group when he realized that they only cared for profit and not justice.
Traveling to Gotham, Jason took up the mantle of the Red Hood, a former alias of the man who became the Joker. He tried to take revenge on both Batman and the Joker but all those plans failed. He soon left and began to fight for justice on an international scale before rejoining the larger Bat-Family.
3. It Was Moira All Along
Dr. Moira MacTaggert has been many things to the X-Men over the years. A skilled geneticist, second only to Charles Xavier and Hank McCoy, wife to Sean Cassidy, the X-Man Banshee, and surrogate mother to New Mutant Rahne Sinclair, Wolfbane. She has healed their wounds, given them a place to rest, and been an ally and friend. But recently it has been revealed that Moira is the most important mutant in existence.
Moira had the power of reincarnation and retention of all the knowledge from her previous lives. In her third life, she discovered a cure for the mutant gene but was killed by Mystique and Destiny. In her fourth and fifth lives, she embraced Charles Xavier, in her eighth she joined Magneto, and, in her ninth, Apocalypse but died each time. In each of her lives, she learned one secret: the Mutants always failed.
In her tenth and current life, she had been able to unite Xavier, Magneto, and Apocalypse with all the other mutants on the planet and create a nation for mutants named Krakoa, where all mutants are safe, and most, but not all, old arguments have been forgotten. Moira has been kept hidden and no one with precognition powers was allowed to be resurrected lest they discover her secret. This failed when Destiny was resurrected and she was forced to flee.
2. “35 Minutes Ago...”
It is 1985 in an alternate reality and Richard Nixon is in his fifth term as the American President as the world inches closer to nuclear annihilation. And in New York City, a Comedian is murdered. Uncompromising vigilante Rorschach believed it was an attack on “masks” because the Comedian was the secret identity of government-sanctioned hero Robert Blake. It turned out to be something much more sinister.
Adrian Veidt, formerly the hero Ozymandias, billionaire industrialist, and supposed smartest man in the world had come up with a plan that would unite the warring United States and Russia in a common goal and save the lives of billions, by causing the death of millions. Veidt planned to fake an alien invasion that would kill half the population of New York City to unite America and Russia against the threat. Ozymandias took several steps to ensure his plan's success, including Blake’s murder.
Rorschach and Nite-Owl put together clues to discover Veidt’s plan, Manhattan and Silk Spectre return from Mars and all converge on Karnak, Ozymandias’ Antarctica retreat to stop him. While explaining his plan, Veidt says he is not some ridiculous movie villain who monologues his plan and gave the hero time to defeat him. Ozymandias informed them that he set the plan in motion 35 minutes ago.
1. Death Of Gwen Stacy
Amazing Spider-Man #121 may have been the most shocking comic twist ever thrown at readers of the time. While waiting for Peter Parker in his apartment, his girlfriend Gwen Stacy was surprised by the sudden intrusion of the Green Goblin. Gwen fought in vain but the Goblin knocked her out with gas from one of his pumpkins and left it in the mess for Spider-Man to find.
The Green Goblin took Gwen to the top of the Brooklyn Bridge and, despite being very ill, Spider-Man tracked them there. The pair fought and the Goblin revealed Spider-Man’s identity as Peter Parker. Gwen was shocked as she blamed him for the death of her police captain father and now discovered that the Wall-crawler was actually the man she loved.
The Goblin threw Gwen off of the bridge and Spidey shot a web that grabbed her leg, but her neck snapped from the sudden stop and she died. Peter swore vengeance on the Goblin and beat him near to death but stopped short of killing him. Norman impaled himself with his Glider when Web-head leaped out of the way.
The “Snap!” sound effect was tiny but it was deafening to readers of the time. It was shocking to see the hero fail to save the woman he loved. This one moment stuck with many readers to this day.