10 Biggest DC Comics Controversies
More character deaths, reboots and refigurings than you can shake a Bucky at.
DC has become the punching bag of the comic book world as of late, and not without good reason. The company has a long history - whether in pursuit of publicity or from complete stupidity - of making incredibly controversial decisions. There have been storylines that got fanboys' chins wagging in all the wrong ways, editorial decisions that live on in infamy, and more character deaths, reboots and refigurings than you can shake a Bucky at.
Not more than you can rank and order into an entertaining list, however. Delving into the company's murky history, both on and off the page, has brought up ten of the most controversial decisions that Detective Comics Comics (that is their actual name) have made during their over eighty years in the business. It so easily could have been 20. Or 30. Or 40...
10. Batwoman Can't Get Married
One of the most boneheaded editorial decrees Dan DiDio has passed down (so far) was his recent decision that Batwoman, one of DC's first openly gay characters - good! - couldn't get married to Maggie Sawyer, her long-time girlfriend - less good! When this editorial meddling came out, there was a lot of speculation on why DC was so intent on blocking the storyline. Naturally, people's first instinct was that DC was...maybe kinda homophobic? It turned out their reasoning was actually even more stupid than that.
Batwoman's marriage wasn't denied on grounds of her sexuality, no; it's because no DC superhero is allowed to be married. Apparently, heroes shouldn't have happy personal lives, because that would somehow make for a less dramatic story, because there are never any tensions or emotional stakes in marriage. The editors also said they wanted to keep the focus on the superheroics, rather than nuptials, but by that logic, no DC character should have any sort of relationships at all.
Regardless of the strange reasoning behind it, celebrated Batwoman co-writers J.H. Williams III and W. Haden Blackman immediately left the book because of the scandal. A lot of that going around these days...
9. Firing/Rehiring Everyone
Particularly egregious though their case is, J.H. Williams III and W. Haden Blackman aren't the only members of DC's creative staff who've been shafted over the past few years. In fact, since 2009 there are nearly forty examples of writers, artists and the like being fired from books, leaving due to behind-the-scenes issues, or having their series cancelled without warning. It started with writer Nick Spencer being fired before his first issue of Supergirl came out (he was credited as "co-writer" with James Peaty, who took over), and went downhill from there.
Now, shuffling of creative teams is no new thing, especially in a freelance industry like comic books. But the sheer number of them amongst DC in recent times has been staggering, and the circumstances even more so. Iconic writer/artist George Perez left due to editorial interference, iZombie scribe Chris Robertson departed due to the company being "unethical", Gail Simone was fired and then re-hired on Batwoman when fans kicked off, and Superman Family Adventures creators Art Baltazar and Franco found out their book was cancelled when they saw in solicits that said issue 12 was the finale.
Spencer would later describe the way DC treats freelancers as "abhorrent", and that's hard to argue with.
8. Starfire's Reboot
Before the New 52 hard reset of the DC Universe, Starfire was one of its strongest female characters: a long-time member of the Teen Titans, she escaped a stiflingly patriarchal home planet, became a hero on Earth, and had a pretty cool power set too. She grew even more in popularity, especially amongst younger female fans, in the Teen Titans cartoons. In the New 52, Starfire is...different.
Very different. Where once there was a character that was nuanced, complex and three-dimensional (something pretty rare for female characters in comics, or fiction as a whole) there are now boobs. And a butt. And she hits on everyone. And that's kind of all she is. No distinct personality, no interesting characteristics, just a woman to be ogled.
Fans and critics have aimed similar complaints about the Catwoman reboot, that somehow managed to sexualise a woman in a skin-tight PVC suit even more than before, but the Starfire thing is especially controversial considering all those aforementioned female pre-teen fans of the TV incarnation coming a cropper when they pick up a comic book.
7. Hiring Orson Scott Card
Oh yeah, there was another reason people were suspicious of DC's motivations for banning a high-profile gay marriage from happening in their comics: because they had recently hired a high-profile writer who actively campaigns to ban gay marriage in real life.
Noted homophobe Orson Scott Card is otherwise known for his classic sci-fi novel Ender's Game, which is probably what he was hired for, rather than for his bigotry. But it was the bigotry that captured the public's imagination. Card was tapped to write a story for the anthology series Adventures of Superman, which in the end never got published.
Fans and comic shops alike threatened to boycott the series (a similar fate befell the recent film adaptation of Ender's Game) due to Card's outspoken political views and, whilst DC first took the position of "we believe in freedom of expression, his views aren't our views etc", artist Chris Sprouse leaving the project over all the bad publicity seemed the final nail in the coffin.
6.The Death And Return Of Superman
Looking further back at DC Comics controversies, publicity is often the driving force behind it. I don't think anyone could argue that the Death (And Inevitable Return) Of Superman storyline was written because it was a good story because...well, it isn't that.
It's just a massively overpowered villain pummeling Superman to - spoilers! - death, a few months of people being sad about it, and then the big blue Boy Scout improbably rising from the grave, because there weren't enough Jesus parallels between the characters before. It worked, though! The series was hugely controversial because, well, DC were killing off their flagship character, an icon of modern American pop culture. But that meant it was also widely reported in news outlets that usually wouldn't touch comics unless it was a ten foot barge pole with "BIFF! POW! COMICS AREN'T JUST FOR KIDS!" taped to the end of it.
Funnily enough, all the people who were upset at Supes being killed off were even more upset when he came back less than a year later, as it confirmed their suspicions that the whole thing was just a publicity stunt.
5. The Death (And Resurrection) Of Jason Todd
You know you've got an unpopular character on your hands when fans are literally ringing up and begging you to kill him off. That was ultimately what sealed the fate of the second Robin, Jason Todd, filling in for Dick Grayson while he was off galavanting with the Teen Titans as Nightwing.
Jason was written as a the opposite of Dick: he ignored most of Batman's orders, was generally a whiny brat, and was responsible for the deaths of several villains. So, following an outpouring of correspondence from readers who hated, hated, hated this Robin, DC decided the best way to decide what happened to Jason was to take it to an X-Factor-style phone-in vote.
It actually ended up being pretty close, but regardless, A Death In The Family ended with Robin II being bludgeoned to death with a crowbar by The Joker. Frank Miller - no stranger to controversy himself - called it the ugliest and most cynical thing he'd seen in comics. This was 1988, though, so there was still plenty of time for DC to do worse. Like bringing Jason Todd back in recent years as The Red Hood. But that's a story for another day...
4. Identity Crisis
Speaking of worse, remember Identity Crisis? No doubt you've probably tried to suppress the memories of the 2004 limited series, so sorry for bringing them back to light.
It's important that we remember comics' mistakes though, or else they're bound to repeat them. And we really don't need another series where every superhero in the DCU is a manipulative, back-stabbing jerk, a goofy Silver Age villain is turned into a rapist, and The Atom's estranged wife turns out to be an insane murderer. BIFF! POW! COMICS AREN'T JUST FOR KIDS!
Identity Crisis was controversial on so many levels. The use of rape of a plot device has, unfortunately, become even more prevalent after the series. As has retroactively inserting dark, "gritty" dramatic twists into comic books and assuming that makes them mature, even when they're handled in the most immature way. Fans hate Identity Crisis for the way it tainted pretty much every major player in the DC Universe...and it sold in its millions.
3. The Harley Quinn Art Contest
Breaking into comics is a tricky business, so DC came up with - surprisingly at this point, I know - a good idea to give people a leg up. Last year they held a contest for budding pencillers to have a crack at drawing a portion of Harley Quinn #0; the winner would have their work published in a major comic book! So where's the controversy? Well, it comes down to what exactly people were being asked to draw. Basically, the sequence consisted of The Joker's girlfriend trying to kill herself in various ways. Which, y'know, isn't in the best taste. Even less so when you announce the contest to draw said scene the week before National Suicide Prevention Week. Here's what DC were asking for specifically;
The controversy sparked widespread protests and news reports, which meant that were eventually forced to apologise. Well, they apologised if people were offended, but not for being offensive. DC are never very good at taking responsibility for things.
2. Bill Finger - Unknown Batman Creator
Or for admitting what people are responsible for, for that matter. Take a look at any piece of Batman media, be it a comic, one of the Arkham games, even the Christopher Nolan films: in every single case, the Dark Knight is credited as being the sole creation of artist Bob Kane. In reality, nothing could be further from the truth.
And DC knows it. In fact, the amount of the classic elements of Batman's character Kane created is pretty miniscule, as Bat artist Ty Templeton chronicled in a hilarious comic. It was writer Bill Finger who came up with all of the character's early stories, who created The Joker and Robin, who invented the Bat Cave, the Batmobile...everything. The reason Kane gets all the credit? He basically strong-armed DC into it - screwing over Superman creators Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster in the process - and the contract still stands.
So Kane didn't create DC, and everybody knows it, but DC are still locked into claiming he did. The story has seen a resurgence in recent years as fans and Finger's family alike battle to get him the credit he deserved. In the end Finger died penniless and practically unknown, whilst Kane died the creator of Batman.
1. The New 52
DC doesn't exactly shy away from reboots. In fact, since the classic eighties maxi-series Crisis on Infinite Earths, the company has had a continuity-tidying crossover event every few years to try and make sense of its decades of backstory and characters.
I'm not sure what the straw that broke the camel's back was, but in 2011 the most recent crossover, Flashpoint, ended in a complete reset of the DC Universe. To mixed success, to put it mildly. Along with being blighted by editorial meddling and behind-the-scenes troubles, the New 52 has been controversial amongst fans for the changes made to characters, the staggering amount of the 52 series launched that have since been cancelled, the lack of quality of a lot of the writing and art, delays, and a total failure to complete their mission statement of making the DCU more accessible to new readers.
I defy you to find a mention of the New 52 - by someone other than DC's editors - which is accompanied by anything positive.