10 Comic Book Betrayals We All Should Have Seen Coming

Looking at the betrayals that surprised nobody.

By James Egan /

Comic books are loaded with moments designed to shock readers. In nearly every issue, a secret identity is revealed, a hero suffers a tragedy, or an iconic character dies.

Advertisement

However, one of the most mind-blowing occurrences, not just in comics but in all storytelling, is a betrayal. We have all experienced that moment where we allow ourselves to care about a seemingly noble person, only to realise they are the villain. Comic fans were left speechless when Reed Richards became the murderous Maker. We couldn't believe it when Iron Man turned against Captain America. It blew our minds to learn the Justice League had Batman's memory wiped.

Even though backstabbings like this are meant to catch readers off-guard, that's not always the case. In fact, some betrayals are foreshadowed so unsubtly, it's insulting to think you couldn't figure it out. Was anyone surprised when the Avengers turned on the Hulk? Wasn't it obvious who the villain was in Watchmen? Was anybody astonished when Harry Osborn turned evil for the FOURTH time!?

Here are the ten betrayals in comics we all deduced way before the big reveal.

10. The Illuminati Blast Hulk Into Space - Incredible Hulk #91-92 (2006)

Years ago, Iron Man, Professor X, Black Bolt, Namor the Submariner, Reed Richards, Professor X, and Doctor Strange formed The Illuminati - a group brought together to discuss matters considered too dangerous for the public to know. Because The Illuminati make difficult or immoral decisions for the greater good, their discussions were kept secret for a long time, even from each member's teams and families.

Advertisement

When society grew tired of the Incredible Hulk's relentless rampages, The Illuminati took it upon themselves to get rid of him. After the Jade Giant was lured onto a space station, it sealed shut and blasted across the galaxy. As the spaceship began its journey, its computer played a recording of The Illuminati which informed the Hulk that their decision to banish him from Earth was harsh but justified.

Even though the green-skinned superhero was furious, you can't blame his teammates. After devastating cities and destroying entire worlds over the years, it was only a matter of time before the Hulk's rage resulted in the death of innocents. Considering Hulk shifted the tectonic plates when he returned to Earth one year later, nearly imploding the planet, The Illuminati's decision was perfectly reasonable.

9. Cyclops Kills Professor X - Avengers Vs X-Men #12 (2012)

At some point in a major comic book event, an important character usually dies. Flash perished in Crisis On Infinite Earths. Captain America was shot dead in Civil War. Hawkeye died during House of M... twice. Even though these deaths are meant to come out of nowhere, some readers catch on quickly.

Advertisement

In Avengers vs X-Men, The Phoenix Force split its power between five mutants - Colossus, Namor, Magik, Emma Frost, and Cyclops. Despite the fact the Phoenix has obliterated entire galaxies, the quintet tried to use the deity's power to benefit the world. But as the Phoenix seeped into Cyclops's mind, he turned on his fellow superheroes. When Professor Charles Xavier tried to stop him, Cyke killed him.

But since Scott Summers is renowned for repressing his emotions, readers knew he was going to commit some atrocity once he bonded with the Phoenix. Also, his "betrayal" to Professor X was a long-time coming. Even though Scott was once the most devoted X-Man, he grew to hate the professor after learning his mentor had lied to his students and mind-wiped them multiple times. As a result, this confrontation wasn't shocking - it was inevitable.

8. Harry Osborn Keeps Turning Evil - Amazing Spider-Man #136 (1974)

When Norman Osborn seemingly died during the 1970s, it appeared to be the end of Green Goblin. But Spider-Man's nemesis was so popular, there was no way he wouldn't return in some way. Sure enough, several people have taken the mantle of Green Goblin, most notably Norman's son, Harry Osborn.

Advertisement

Only one year after Norman supposed croaked, Harry followed in his father's footsteps by becoming the new Goblin. When Harry developed amnesia, he forget about his villainous persona, seemingly ending his tenure as the Green Goblin.

However, Harry returned to supervillainy in many story arcs including Inferno, Best of Enemies, and American Son. In recent comics, Spidey faced off with a seemingly new foe called The Kindred who was ultimately revealed to be Harry.

Because Harry is Peter Parker's best friend, it's meant to be startling to see him try and kill Spider-Man. But because Harry's has been infected with the same Goblin formula that drove his old man crazy, it's only a matter of time before he embraces his wicked side again. Anytime something fishy happens with Oscorp and Norman is out of commission, you can bet Harry is the one pulling the strings.

7. Batman's Secret Files On His Teammates - JLA #43-46 (2000)

During the Tower of Babel storyline, Ra's Al Ghul took down the entire Justice League by exploiting their weaknesses. After he froze Plastic Man, crippled Superman with Red Kryptonite, and made Green Lantern go blind, the remaining Leaguers couldn't understand how Ra's was able to defeat them so easily.

Advertisement

Eventually, the JLA learned the deranged alchemist had accessed Batman's dossier and used his data to figure out the simplest way to take down each superhero. The League were horrified, realising that Batman had analysed and compiled each member's strengths and weaknesses without their consent. Although Batman stated his data was crucial in case any of the superheroes turned evil, the Justice League felt like the Dark Knight betrayed their trust and so, encouraged him to leave the team.

However, Batman's actions aren't that surprising since... he's Batman. Despite having no superpowers, the Caped Crusader usually comes out on top because he has a plan for every contingency. Because the League have been brainwashed on multiple occasions, having a system to immobilise them sounds logical. Considering Superman was mind-controlled shortly after and nearly killed innocent people, it would be unreasonable for Batman NOT to learn how to incapacitate his teammates.

6. Doctor Strange Mindwipes Captain America - New Avengers #3 (2013)

Because Marvel's Illuminati have to work in a very grey area, Iron Man never asked Captain America to join, knowing his uncompromisable morals would conflict with the group's decision-making. Sure enough, Steve Rogers flew into a rage when he learned about Tony Stark's covert think-tank, believing his teammates had betrayed him. But after learning about imminent dangers which put the whole universe at risk, Cap reluctantly agreed to ally with The Illuminati.

Advertisement

But when Tony learned their universe was going to clash with another, he urged the group to destroy the opposing reality to survive. Unsurprisingly, the star-spangled superhero rejected this idea, saying they should find another way. Because of his defiance, Tony acknowledged it was a mistake to have invited his comrade into the team. Immediately after Cap made his intentions clear, Tony ordered Doctor Strange to erase his memory, leaving him with no recollection of his time with the cabal.

However, we all knew this was going to happen the instant Cap learned of The Illuminati's existence. Considering the group chooses who lives or who dies, Cap's unwavering principles was always going to pose a problem.

5. Ozymandias Is The Mask-Killer - Watchmen #10-11 (1987)

Alan Moore's Watchmen takes place in a world that was filled with superheroes until vigilantism was criminalised. When an ex-vigilante called The Comedian is found murdered, his former ally, Rorschach, believes someone is picking off costumed heroes.

Advertisement

When Rorschach shares his Mask-Killer theory with his team, the Crimebusters, they assume he's being paranoid. But when their old teammate, Adrian Veidt AKA Ozymandias, is nearly assassinated, the Crimebusters realise Rorschach is onto something.

However, we learn in the climax that the Mask Killer is none other than Ozymandias himself. He explains to his friends that he staged his assassination attempt so no one would suspect he was the one who murdered The Comedian.

However, it was obvious Adrian was the killer since... there was literally nobody else it could've been! Considering every hero was helping Rorschach, save for Adrian, he was the only suspect. Because Ozy emphasises that he can catch a bullet with his bare hands, it wasn't farfetched to consider he faked an assassination to throw his friends off.

Watchmen may be hailed as one of, if not, the greatest graphic novel ever, but the whodunnit subplot is disappointingly predictable.

4. Captain America Joins Hydra - Captain America: Steve Rogers #1-2 (2016)

The reveal that Captain America was secretly a Hydra agent caused the biggest stir in Marvel Comics in years. The idea that the most moral superhero would not only join, but lead the world's biggest terrorist organization, shook many readers to their core.

Advertisement

However, there were some fans who weren't surprised in the least. But they didn't think this twist was obvious because it was foreshadowed. Some readers suspected Marvel would try something like this for one simple reason - comic sales are in massive decline. Even though the MCU is dominating cinema, comics haven't been selling for years. Out of desperation, publishers have recently tried the usual gimmicks such as mini-series, crossovers, first-issue relaunches, and relaunching entire universes.

And what better way is there to get comic fans talking than by using the classic "good guy turns bad" angle? Even though the Secret Empire storyline was reviled by almost everyone, a lot of people bought the comic to see what the fuss was all about. However, this is a problem since the comics' success will give publishers more incentive to churn out stories centred around shock value rather than character and plot.

3. Xorn Is Magneto - New X-Men #146 (2003)

While in China, the X-Men freed a psychic mutant called Xorn from prison. When Xorn's powers manifested, his brain turned into a tiny star, which can create a destructive black hole if he removes his helmet. When Cyclops asked Xorn to join the X-Men, the mysterious mutant happily accepted. Because of his zen-like philosophy and calm demeanour, Professor X's students instantly made their new teammate feel welcome.

Advertisement

But several years later, Xorn was revealed to be none other than Magneto. Like a wolf in sheep's clothing, the Master of Magnetism tricked the X-Men into inviting him into their home so he could destroy them from within.

However, the X-Men (and the readers) should've seen this twist coming simply because of the timing. Before this point, Magneto was believed to have died in Genosha after the island was destroyed by a Sentinel.

And when did the X-Men discover Xorn? One month after Magneto mysteriously disappeared. Considering the professor couldn't read Xorn's face and the fact that this "new" mutant could move metal objects with his mind also should've set off a hundred red flags.

2. Jason Todd Betrays Batman Over And Over

Jason Todd started his superhero career as Batman's second Robin. But because of his temper, it wasn't long before he butted his heads with his mentor. Even though Bats lives by a No-Kill Rule, Jason refused to see eye-to-eye and thus, reinvented himself as a murderous antihero called Red Hood. Even though Todd only killed rapists and serial killers, his actions violated Batman's principles, causing the pair to become sworn enemies.

Advertisement

But over the years, the Dark Knight convinced Jason that he could do more good by rejoining The Bat Family. But after Bruce Wayne seemingly died, Todd declared himself as the new Batman and started using lethal force against criminals.

Luckily, Batman's sidekicks encouraged Jason to stop... until he shot the Penguin point-blank in the face. But then Jason became a force of good again... until he blew the Joker's brains out. (Don't worry. He got better.) Even though each of these incidents were meant to be shocking, they weren't out of character. Since Jason Todd has always been a loose cannon, it's not a question if he will kill again but when.

1. Every Joker Team-Up Ever

The idea that Batman would ever ally with Joker sounds inconceivable. However, we all know Bats would do anything to save the day, even buddying up with the deranged jester.

Advertisement

In The Batman and the Bold #191, the pair teamed up for the first time after the Clown Prince of Crime was framed for Penguin's murder. Although this should've been a one-time thing, readers loved watching sworn enemies working together. As a result, DC Comics had Batman partnering up with Joker again and again. Over the years, the two of them have been forced to ally against Ra's Al Ghul, Advance Man, and The Batman Who Laughs. When they were poisoned by the same virus in Batman: Europa, they travelled the globe for a cure.

Because most of these team-ups involve Batman saving Joker's life, you'd think they could find some way to bury the hatchet. Of course, this is Joker we're talking about so that's never going to happen. Every time they pair up, you can practically see the mad clown looking for the opportunity to stab the Dark Knight in the back. So, when Joker makes his move and turns on Batman, no one is the slightest bit surprised.

Advertisement