10 Comic Book Characters Who REPLACED Heroes (And Failed)

10. Spider-Woman Replaced By Mattie

Martha Franklin, or Mattie, is the third and most troubled of those who have worn the mantle of Spider-Woman. She was first introduced to us in The Amazing Spider-Man #5, in preparation for her own series.

Despite her young age, inability to settle on a costume, and general inexperience, Mattie seemed to be doing a decent job. Unfortunately, her series only lasted 18 issues, and things quickly went downhill.

In Alias we find out why her stint as Spider-Woman was short-lived. The young teen can't catch a break (and by can't catch a break, I mean things get down right horrific). Mattie was excited to be asked out on a date by a dreamy older guy who seemed nice – until he slipped her a roofie.

She's kept drugged up and in costume by King-pin wannabe and self-professed rapist Denny. He's making a hell of a profit off her, by cutting out chunks of her body to sell as a new street drug. Turns out, her flesh gives a temporary superpower inducing high. Who knew.

After being rescued by the original Spider-Woman and Jessica Jones, Mattie retires. She does eventually re-don her costume in Loners, but it's all about seeking out revenge, and not about representing the legacy of Spider-Woman.