Clichés. They're everywhere in pop culture, it's unavoidable. They're something that comes up over and over again. So often that they become predictable and laughable for how often they appear. While some are beloved and necessary for certain types of culture, there are some that have become more than a little irritating over time.
Advertisement
Comic books have their fair share of clichés. Luckily for fans, a lot of clichés in comics have died over time. Villains are no longer shouting "I'll get you next time!" or have obviously evil birth names. Let's face it, guys with names like Victor Von Doom and Sinestro really had no alternate carrier paths other than being evil.
They were never going to be motivational speakers or baristas. Love interests are no longer solely damsels in distress and dialogue is as corny as it once was. So if some angnnoy clichés have died over time, what are the ones that are left? What is plaguing the comic book industry that makes things predictable and obvious?
Advertisement
Let's see what ideas have been overused in comic books today...
10. Orphans
DC Comics
All heroes need an origin story. And since reading that one day, out of the blue someone decides to become a hero for no apparent reason does not make for very compelling reading. Almost every hero has to have some trigger or tragedy to make them decide to step up and be more than an ordinary citizen. Or they just get some random blast to radiation, either way.
Advertisement
The origin story that has been absolutely beaten to death is the orphan story. Batman? Dead parents. Superman? Dead parents, dead planet, AND a dead foster dad. Spider-Man? Dead parents, and a dead uncle. And being a cliche, this of course isn't just limited to classic comics. Newer heroes continue to get the orphan treatment. Even in recent years well-established characters have become orphans.
In the early 2000's Wolverine was shown to be an orphan. Sure he killed his father and then his mother committed suicide, which is slightly darker than most orphan stories, but it still counts.
Advertisement
It's hard to take the orphan story seriously anymore when it's been done so many times before.
9. True Love
Marvel Comics
Ah Romance. The most prominent type of storytelling throughout all art forms is the love story. And what does romance mean in comics? Not a damn thing. There are two constants in comic book romance: 1. It will end. 2. Almost every combination of characters have been a couple a some point in time.
Advertisement
In recent years the idea of a one-night-stand or a short fling has entered into main stream comics, the relationships are still treated as serious business. Comic book romances just can't be taken seriously, but they are treated like life and death by the writers. The idea of coupling has become such a joke that the most extreme combinations have been put together. Rogue and Magneto? Yeah, nobody took that seriously. Iceman and Mystique? That was just...weird. And how many true loves has Wolverine had? Too many to keep track.
Even the most classic and long term of relationships eventually end. Peter Parker and Mary-Jane ended a few years ago. Lois Lane and Clark Kent are no longer together since DC launched "The New 52". The argument could be made that all of the different pairings that get made over the years provide the opportunity to tell different stories with different characters, but I disagree. Comic book characters are modern myths, a heightened version of humanity that we should strive to share more in common. Except that nobody has a stable relationship. It's kind of a poor message.
Advertisement
Love stories will continue to happen, this is inevitable. Just don't pretend like it's something worth investing any kind of attachment.
8. Character Retcon
There's an unwritten rule in comics. The characters don't age, or they do it very slowly. This keeps the characters fresh and relevant to the readers as comics continue to come out.
Advertisement
Except sometimes companies decide that they need more than an iPad to keep their characters fresh. Every so often, DC rewrites their entire universe; and it's met with mixed results.
The general feeling is that DC wants to make their characters history a little more digestible without endless trips to Wikipedia. It also gives them an opportunity to tell varying origin stories and bring characters back to a place where they can grow and evolve.
Advertisement
I understand it, I personally don't like it, but it at least makes sense. Then there's Marvel. Marvel takes the method of having all of their characters history count (mostly) and is made up of one long epic story.
This creates a problem. Sometimes characters get boring, or they've really just evolved as far as they can. So Marvel just up and changes an entire character's history. 'Cause they can.
Advertisement
Spider-Man is probably the one that fans reacted to with the most negativity. Marvel took one of their spotlight characters and just decided to change everything. Peter Parker has to make a deal with the devil to give up his love (no, really) for Mary-Jane, that totally changed his history. Marvel said that they wanted to make Spider-Man more relatable again and make his character struggle. I'd buy that excuse if it just didn't come down to Peter having more awkward dates. It's a little late now, but you know what's a relatable problem Marvel? Divorce. At least it's more relatable than going to hell in order to give up your "love". Character retcon is generally lazy writing and happens far too often for readers to ever get invested in the characters. Why take a story seriously if what they're reading might not ultimately carry any weight.
7. Copycat Character
Good characters are a hard thing to come by. They can only have so many origin stories, powers, motivation, and personalities. But the same kind of character keeps coming up, the copycat. What happens when a character is successful and creative teams want to do something new? The take something popular and make it slightly different, while still keeping it recognizable. The problem with these characters is that they are almost never as interesting the original, and they just keep coming. The most entertaining copycat comes with the gender switch. While some characters have survived over time, these are usually not characters that are interesting or last for any length of time. Was there anybody really clamoring for a female Deadpool? Or a She-Hulk? Or a Red She-Hulk? Having a few of these characters would be fine, but an astounding number of them have been made over the years. Then there's the twin, the clone, the alternate dimension, the unknown child, the mirror villain, the list goes on. The same characters have been copied so many times, it's impossible to keep track of all of them.
6. Writing For Trades
When comics first started, stories began and ended single issues. The story started with a conflict, it was resolved, and the next issue began fresh. As comics matured and evolved, the idea of writing stories that lasted more than one issue came into play. This was revolutionary and completely changed how comics were written. It gave writers and artists the opportunity to tell a story for as long as they needed without the restriction of a single issue. Then came the Trade Paperback. Comics coming from major publishers now are written exclusively to be collected in a TPB. Most story arcs last a typical five to six issues, maybe with a filler comic thrown in there to flesh the collection out. Like so many comic book clichés, it takes away from the overall story. Readers know how long it will take for a resolution and essentially the beats of introducing a problem, trying to overcome it, and usually succeeding. Look at "Days of Future Past", an acclaimed classic story. How long did this epic take to complete? Two issues. It wasn't bloated, or unnecessarily expanded for the sake of filling a TPB, the story was only told for as long as needed. Comic collections are really a fantastic thing. It's an easy way to sit down with an entire story without having to pull out individual issues and makes some nearly unattainable comics accessible to a wider audience. It's also a nice way for companies to make some extra money. However, forcing stories to fit a certain format is not helped the quality of stories. Sadly, this is a cliché that's probably here to stay.
5. Movies Influencing Comics
This is probably the newest cliché that exists in comics today, but one that has already been overdone and is incredibly predictable. "X-men" in 2000 was a huge turning point for comics. Even though comic book movies had been released in the past, this is really what kicked off comic book movies as their own genre. Marvel then decided to change up their X-men roster at the time to reflect the characters in the film. The idea is simple, the X-men were introduced to a wider audience with the film and Marvel wanted to bring in new readers. Fine. It's glaringly obvious when this happens, but it's understandable. The trick is to know when to not overdo it. There's a tendency to relaunch comics with a new issue #1. Iron Man did it in 2008 and Spider-Man is going to be doing it this April. Another example is having the antagonist of a film to suddenly become the villain for an arc in the comics around the time of the movies release. These again, are understandable. But then it starts to get silly. My favorite recent example is War Machine. The comic book War Machine became Iron Patriot, just like in "Iron Man 3". What? It doesn't make any sense within the canon of the comics. Would anybody find Norman Osborn's old armor patriotic? Probably not. Dialogue from movies can be really overused too. Following the success of "The Avengers", Black Widow kept on bringing up how she has "red in her ledger". That line was used in multiple comics over a very short period of time. The line loses its power if everyone keeps using it. And it's just lazy writing. They deserve 12% credit for originality.
4. Cross Story Comics
Comic book characters share a rich in diverse universe. For comic book fans, one of the best things is seeing your favorite characters from different books interact with each other. Except is has gone way too far. Marvel and DC now seem define their comics and all stories by "events". Something big that happens that will forever change their respective universes (it usually doesn't change things all that much). Cross comic stories have in the past, been handled well in some instances. But the big trend that has been going on, especially in the last ten years, is that events are all companies put their energies into. One major event happens after another, which diminishes the impact of how epic the story should feel. Events should feel like a big deal. Now they're just overdone and blown way out of proportion. Aside from big cross comic stories never stopping for more than a few months at a time, they also cross over too far. Events cross over into more than just their own miniseries, but into almost every comic a company may own. In order to keep track of everything, readers would need to buy a ridiculous number of comics to get the full impact of the event. This has likely attributed to an increase in comic book piracy just so readers can try and keep track of what is happening in these "major" events. Cross comic stories shouldn't die entirely, just be put on life support. Marvel and DC need to cut back in scale and frequency if events going to be something to look forward to.
3. Boobs
There is a very true cliché. Sex sells. This translates into comics into one (or two) obvious ways. Boobs. Here's the thing, sex appeal in any form of pop culture is never going to go away. That's fine, I'm not arguing against it. All I'm saying is make it less obvious. When this topic is usually brought up, proportions are typically the main point. I don't really care about that either. Comics are a heightened version of reality. The same basic goes for the male characters too when it comes to muscle, it's a heightened sexual visual. Where the cliché comes in and takes sex appeal to just a silly place is the poses and the costumes. Most male hero costumes seemed to be designed with some purpose in mind. That might be for armor, a symbol, or some metaphor. Female costumes are designed to usually show off as much boob as a possible. How is this helpful for fighting crime or super villains? Does the plan begin and end with "distract them with cleavage"? The other big one is the poses. Imagine how exhausting it would be in real life to always be striking the sexiest pose possible at any given second? Especially in highly stressful situations, as I imagine fighting off alien hordes probably would be. Look at the poster for "The Avengers". Black Widow is the only one who thought sticking her butt out was a good pose to be ready for a fight. I think the Hulk in the same pose would have at least been a lot more entertaining. Sex appeal? Fine. Giant boobs? Fine. Where this cliché needs to change is how the sex appeal is presented. Maybe some minor level of subtlety?
2. Kid Sidekicks
Originally, the sole target audience for comics was young children. What they read was adult heroes swinging in and stopping some kind of villain or crime. Well gosh, if the young reader could find a supporting character that they could identify with or even pretend to be, that would only boost comic sales! This has been done with varying success over the years. The sidekick seems to work best when they are there to bring out some humanity in gruffer characters like Batman with the many different Robin's, or Wolverine with characters like Shadowcat, Jubilee, Armor, and so on. Where this gets old is by having endless C-list heroes who are nothing more than younger versions of older heroes. And so often the names are unoriginal. How to you make a young Aquaman? Take the word "man" and make it something younger. Aqua Lad. Genius! How about the Flash? Not a lot of wordplay can be done there....just call him Kid Flash and be done with it. The worst ones are when the sidekick shares the same name as main hero. After his resurrection, Green Arrow's sidekick was...Green Arrow. And Hawkeye currently has a young sidekick called...Hawkeye. Not even trying there. New characters are necessary to continue any form of storytelling, especially one as long lasting as comics. How about instead of creating young versions of popular characters so they can have teen angst, why don't we just get some new original characters?
1. Resurrection
This should come as no surprise to anyone for being at the top of the list. Death in comic books carries no weight whatsoever. Why? Because nobody stays dead! Back when Superman "died", it was a huge deal. It made international news. There were lines forming outside of comic book stores. The world was shocked. How could DC kill of the original super hero? Bringing him back a few months after sales had been boosted with some weak coma story was the answer to that. There's no question, death issues sell, and so do resurrection ones. When a character dies, it's just starts a countdown until they come back. What diminishes the story even more than it being a cliché, is that it's always announced. Death and resurrections are typically announced months in advance. It's sad when a death or resurrection announcement in more surprising than the actual story itself. It doesn't matter how final death may seem either, the resurrection is going to happen. Colossus is a fun one. After he died, he was cremated. His ashes were spread in Russia. It was almost like Marvel was trying to prove that they were capable of killing off a popular character. Nope. Turns out, those weren't really his ashes! Death in comics is as far from final as it could possibly. When every major death feels like a means to boost sales, it's time to up the stakes and make character deaths actually mean something. Resurrection is by far the biggest comic book cliché that needs to die.