10 Comic Book Cover Gimmicks That Cheapened Great Characters

How to sell as many comic books as possible: put a giant green naked lady on the cover.

By Robert Cook /

Being an artist is a lot like being a stripper. No matter how lofty your goals, you have to catch someone's attention before they stuff a dollar in your panties, and the comic book equivalent to a thong is a tantalizing cover. But just as a provocative outfit might obscure a more transcendent beauty, often cool-but-cheap covers make a hero look a tiny bit sad. It's hardly a new issue, with it being traced back as far as the 1950s, when covers became a lot more involved. Keep in mind that the first appearance of Superman was just him lifting a car - and that's it. During the '50s, however, artists started incorporating eye€“catching features such as wacky plots, sensationalist slogans, and gimmicks that would later give rise to the embossed covers and scratch-and-sniff (seriously) monstrosities that have followed since. Later, 60s and 70s comic publishers €“ especially Marvel €“ started packing their covers with previews for two and sometimes even three different stories, when before there was no such indication, and not to mention lots of random hero fights. The 80's drifted away from overly busy covers in favour of dynamic images and tie-ins to major storylines of the era, such as DC's Crisis On Infinite Earths and Marvel's Secret Wars. And then the 90s there was boobs - lots and lots of boobs. Oh, and guns; lots of guns. It's safe to say covers have

Honourable Mention

Chew Goes Scratch & Sniff
Usually, the idea of a variant interactive cover that features a scratch and sniff feature would be completely deplorable, but just about the only comic that could pull it off without leaving a bad taste in the mouth (somewhat ironically) is the excellent Chew, which has done more for gastronomic crime than McDonalds. The cover, which was announced to be unveiled at Comic Con 2011, was herladed by the creative team of John Layman and Rob Guillory, with the former simply teasing: "Has there ever been a scratch 'n' sniff comic book cover? Or is the CHEW SDCC '11 variant gonna be the first?"

10. T+A Shots

One of the things that has caused a rift between breast-men and butt-men is that the two are often visually exclusive, but trust modern art to bridge the disparity. Intrepid comic book artists have taken the task of completely removing super-heroines' spines, allowing them to contort their bodies in such a way that both headlights and bumper are in full view, and thus was born the compromise of the ages. This is oddly common trope has been going on for years now. The progenitors are often thought to be artists like Tarot's Jim Balentz and Youngblood's Rob Liefeld, both of whom seem to have never taken a single course in anatomy. Example: Black Widow Being named after an animal that murders post-coitus, Black Widow is apt to be hyper-sexualized., but the contortion seem above is a bit much even for her, and she looks like a broken Barbie doll. I don't know if the artist has ever seen someone jump, but they normally don't attempt to twist their torso in mid-air, while leaving their legs perfectly sitll. The common reasoning for this is that "she's inhumanly acrobatic, therefore inhumanly flexible," which is why on this cover, Hawkeye's back and junk are simultaneously in full view as he's jumping. Except that they aren't.

9. Guest Characters

Did you ever gone to a high school party where you didn't know anyone? Probably not, but you WOULD go if you heard that hot guy on the basketball team with the tribal tattoo, devil-may-care attitude and the dirt-bike was there. Comic books creators know that that's the best way to sell some of their wares as well, invoking the same feeling using cover cameos. If a character is new or unpopular, it makes sense to have a popular character appear on the cover to boost sales, but often the cameos are nothing more than a quick "hi-goodbye" from the hero. I read a Spider-Man comic once where Thor flew by Spider-Man and he got caught in his air funnel. For one panel. Of course, the paragon saint of this trope is none other than... Example: Wolverine Wolverine used to only be associated with the X-Men, but then he started becoming Marvel's brooding equivalent to Batman, making his popularity skyrocket. And once the character started gaining a fan-base, everybody tried to get the Canadian Carpet into any comic they could, whether it made sense or not. See above: Anita Blake is a vampire hunter, Wolverine is a mutant superhero. Why would they meet? He is not a vampire, and she wouldn't register on his "to fight" list. And the funny thing is that they don 't even meet. If you look closely (and it has to be REALLY closely,) you can see that the cover clearly states that Wolverine NEVER appears. So the hook for this issue is an outright lie.

8. "Cool" Poses

People just standing around normally is pretty boring, which is why most covers show characters fighting or threatening scenarios. But some artists skip the actual justification for a dynamic cover and go right for the "cool" points. With these, we get gems such as unnecessary flexing, overly sexual poses, and badass arm folding. These covers are the comic book equivalent of snapchats of 15 year old girls making duck-faces in the bathroom mirror. Example: Princess Leia This has got to be one of the most poorly conceived covers of all time. First off, this is Hoth, an ice planet, which is so cold that people get stuffed into animal carcasses just to stay alive. Yet, Leia has her hood wide open like she's enjoying a brisk spring breeze, not to mention the fact that she appears to be wearing a lycra onesie. Secondly, Yoda looks like he's in the midst of walking - i.e. not posing - judging by his cane and direct expression, which means Leia has inexplicably stopped on the middle of Hoth, an ice planet, to pose like a Playboy bunny while walking. And thirdly, the pose doesn't even make sense in context. Is she falling down? Why are her arms so far apart? Why does she have a gun out? Why is she looking at the reader?

7. Swimsuit Issues

Swimsuit issues are the most unabashed form of fan-service in comics. This distasteful trope began mostly in the 80's, especially in team comics. Some comics would settle for just having characters at the beach in the context of a plot, but then some didn't even have the pretense of story and just had a bunch of characters lounging around in swimsuits. And this wasn't just the slightly tarty heroines, even sacred characters like Storm from the X-Men put on breasty holster at one point. Even the ladies might get to see a few man-cakes as well (looking at you, Howard The Duck ). Example: Grimm Fairy Tales Grimm Fairy Tales is a series of "mature" fairy tale adaptations, which would probably have the Grimms spinning in their graves (if they weren't pretty dark themselves anyway.) And by mature, obviously I mean there's lots of mostly uncovered boobs, in every issue. So you can imagine that when they do a swimsuit issue, they go hard. So hard that they often forget the women are supposed to be fairy tale characters and now Penthouse pets, to the extent that some of the titillators make no attempt to make it clear which beloved fairy tale character they are objectifying, as above. Unless we've all just forgotten about the classic fable of Little Pink Flossin' Boobs .

6. Superheroes Fighting Each Other

You know how superheroes are supposed to help people? Well screw that, let's just have them fight each other instead, in as many different variations as possible, because there's nothing fans love better than a cover dust-up between iconic characters. As previously mentioned, this was a particularly popular trope during the 60s and 70s, when the idea of a shared universe began to be focused on at Marvel and DC, so crossovers became more common. There's no better fable on living together in harmony than your childhood heroes beating each other's faces because of a funny look. Unlike superhero/supervillain battles, hero match-ups leave room for suspense. Could Superman lick Thor? Would Thor like the licking? Would this be an unexpected and uncomfortable tangent for the audience? Example: The Avengers/X-Men Now, there's nothing wrong with this cover technically, but the sheer obviousness of the fight's direction is just sad. Fun fact: Gambit used to be my favorite superhero - he was like a Wolverine who could get tail in real life - so you can imagine how depressing it was knowing he was going to get the gumbo beaten out of him by Captain America. It's obvious. No, American would write a comic where the living symbol of the nation loses to an effete french-speaker. The writers don't even pretend as if he had a chance: at one point in this issue, Gambit literally blows up Cap's armor, which Cap casually gets up from and then knocks out Gambit in one punch. Thanks a lot Marvel, you have officially ruined my childhood.

5. Celebrity Guest Stars

Many people's favourite moment in Harold And Kumar Go To White Castle is the cameo by Neil Patrick Harris cameo. But imagine how successful that would have been when he appeared if he had no voice and could only speak through written notes - oh, and he didn't actually act like himself. And in all honesty, he was actually just a guy who looks a lot like NPH, but wasn't really him. That doesn't sound great, does it? What we would then have is the essence of a comic book celebrity cameo: an awkward gimmick that confuses the aesthetic remove. Probably the first big celebrity cameo in comics was when Muhammad Ali "fought" Superman, and nowadays, the most well known would be the countless Barack Obama appearances. No matter who it is, it's always stupid to me - unless a celebrity writes and draws himself into a comic, the "cameo" is probably going to lack any of the spirit that makes film cameos so much fun. Example: Punisher Ignoring the fact that I know from personal experience how much this comic sucks, this cover is just embarrassing. I don't remember if or why Eminem is supposed to be that squinty but it really bothers me here. In addition, given the urban quality of the guest star, the artist clearly tried to inject some "hoodness" into Punisher. Hence Frank Castle's "gangsta style" pistol holding (complete with a curiously limp wrist) - really doing his Marine training proud, there. Even the look on his face seems to be saying "Why is God making me do this?" Why indeed.

4. Superheroes Being Jerks

In real life, normal people love to point out when celebs are douchebags - after all, it makes us all feel that little bit better about ourselves, and makes their sleeping on solid gold mattresses a little easier to swallow. If superheroes really existed, I would assume we would extend them the same courtesy. As such, a cover showing a hero as a bit of a d*ck is bound to make readers inquisitive, and have other, more overtly sadistic fans rubbing their hands with glee. Why would Captain America steal a baby? Why would Batman punch an old lady? These are questions that need answering. Example: Superman The trend of having covers depicting Superman as a jerk was a particularly popular trope during the 50s and 60s. The idea of course was that Superman was such a paragon of morals that readers would be shocked to see him act like a jerk, but it ceased to have any effect after 379 instances of jerkiness, though no-one seems to have told the writers and cover makers. This cover is just one of many examples; you could write an essay on how ridiculous it is. So let's get through this: Jimmy is a reporter at a newspaper, so I don't think he's young enough to be adopted even as a joke. In addition, that robe is awesome considering that in-universe Superman memorabilia is probably uncommon and custom made. And lastly, why the hell would Jimmy keep hanging out with this jerk?

Advertisement

3. Superheroes Quitting

Just like being jerks, heroes quitting is an immediately compelling situation because it's fundamentally against character. So once again, savvy artists used this gimmick a lot in the 50s and 60s to make readers do a double take at their issue - "Superman has quite being Super? What the deuce!" they'd say, before throwing money at the cover. Generally it was the most hot-headed member of the group like Wolverine or the Human Torch, and of course, just like with Superman being a jerk, this kind of diminishes the heroism of superheroes since it implies it doesn't take much for them to quit. One would assume they'd be more legit. Too legit, even. Example:HawkeyeThe Avenger with the most instances of hitting and quitting is Clint Barton aka Hawkeye - he literally has other superhero identities like Goliath and Ronin just so he can quit as much as possible. Now, I like Hawkeye - he's a pretty fun character, but with that being said; nobody on the Avengers should care about Hawkeye leaving. The dude shoots arrows, and offers little else. In addition, why did he break his most-likely-very-expensive bow? That isn't a requisite to leaving a team: do cops disassemble their pistols when they leave the force? Do basketball players deflate all their balls once they retire? Dumb decisions like that is why they don't need him anyway.

2. Superheroes Hooking Up

Like the Ross and Rachel of comic books, superheroes porking each other has been an American - or at least nerdy Americans' - obsession for years. We all want to know what the sight of Batman/Batgirl looks like, or Superman/Wonder Woman... or even Professor X/Magneto. The most popular is probably the pairing of Superman and Wonder Woman because people like all-Americanism, even when it's an alien and a foreigner being all American and getting it on to make special super-American babies. I honestly never got it myself. Whatever the reason, having two heroes smooch each other is often a quick way to make a reader squee like a Belieber. This is probably because most audiences find it intolerable to look at two people of the opposite sex - or same sex, in some instances - merely be acquainted with each other without visiting the bone zone. As with anything else in comics, these hook ups rarely last, if they even happen in the first place. Example: Cyclops and x-23 For some background, X-23 is an teenage female clone of Wolverine who was evil but now is kinda good. Comics, lol. This means that Cyclops is kind of making out with the actual Wolverine, which has been on the tip of most X-Men's pens for a long while, without ever seeing actual expression. It doesn't help that from the angle of his body, it looks like she's straight up attacking Cyke with that kiss, which would explain why her claws are popped out. Unless that how Wolverine and his clones get a boner? Are we even sure this is a female?

1. Manga Style

As many have realized over the last two decades, Japanese animation is greatly eclipsing its Western counterpart. And by Western I mean only us really. The same thing is slowly becoming true with comic books as well, which has caused major comic companies to take notice of what works for them. They've started incorporating more mature subject matter; they've started introducing a less rigid aesthetic, and they've started using more understated pencilling and inking. Actually, they've done absolutely none of these things because I just made it all up. What some companies - we'll call them Marvel - have done is simply create a tragically shallow branch of comics that take on "Manga influences" such as big eyes, big boots, and big artistic failures. I can't wait till they learn about tentacle rape. Example: X-Men Let's go down the list of problems here. Wolverine has lightsaber claws, an omega tattoo on his face, and the extremely well protected shoulders. Storm has luminescent paneling, a cape that Spawn would find overblown, and afro puffs. Cyclops has a penis mask that connects to a burka and a lite brite X symbol. Jean Grey has thigh-high robot boots and a slutty Jetson's schoolgirl outfit. Rogue is lucky enough to only have dumb green hair. And , I don't know the girl in the front but I hope she has a good reason for only having one sleeve on her arm. And only one full boot. Oh and the X-Men symbol is now crossed swords because that's clearly more Asian. On the bright side though, there are no tentacles. Which comic book cover gimmicks do you think have cheapened great characters and properties? Share your picks in the comments thread below.