10 Comic Book Deaths That Haven't Been Undone
Comic book characters never stay dead, right? Wrong!
As the old comic book fan phrase used to go, nobody stays dead in comics except Bucky, Jason Todd and Uncle Ben. But then, in 2005, the former two names on that short list younger aides to Captain America and Batman, respectively both made big comebacks. This served as further proof that death is never an end in comic book fiction.
At times, it seems like the writers in charge of Marvel and DC will resurrect whoever the hell they like via any wacky means they can dream up if they can fill a few bankable issues with a decent story as a result. Incredibly rarely, this isnt the case. Once in every seven blue moons, a character will die and stay dead in a comic book. Now its time to salute these fallen comic book characters; the select few who havent found a way back from their demise yet.
10. Goliath (Bill Foster)
In Mark Millars Civil War comics set to provide the framework for Marvel Studios next big tent-pole, Captain America: Civil War there needed to be some real stakes to convince readers that the conflict between established superheroes was truly dangerous. To achieve this, Millar decided to kill off Bill Foster (AKA the ginormous superhero Goliath/ Black Goliath).
A rogue clone of Thor named Ragnarok that was created by Tony Stark and pals as a replacement for the God Of Thunder struck Goliath down during a massive super-powered battle. (If youre unfamiliar, the heroes were essentially fighting over the Superhuman Registration Act, which sought to give the government control over heroes.) Get ready for the shortest comeback in history, Thor Goliath yelled at the clone upon its arrival, before Ragnarok responded with a snarky I dont think so and sent a bolt of lightning straight through Goliath's chest, killing him. This deadly event led to changes of heart and allegiance within the conflict.
A funeral was held, and Bills nephew Tom Foster later took up the mantle of Black Goliath. Importantly, Bill stayed dead, hammering home the fact that the superhero Civil War was no-nonsense clash of heroes and ideologies, where lives were actually at stake for a change.
9. Jor-El And Lara Lor-Van
Some characters are invented with the expressed purpose of dying and supplying an origin story for more important characters. Supermans parents - Jor-El and Lara Lor-Van fit firmly into this category. Jor-El was the scientist who predicted the demise of Krypton, and Lara Lor-Van was his wife. Together, they sent their infant son away so he would survive the destruction of his home world.
Notably, theyve never risen from the dead and Superman has never found a way to save them. Theyve cropped up in wobbly timeline stories and multiple flashbacks over the years, but nothing more than that. The fact that these two must fall for the iconic hero Superman to rise is too large a part of the Man of Steels mythology for the writer's to ever truly bring them back. That'd be nothing but a disservice to the big blue boy scout.
8. Ant-Man (Eric O'Grady)
S.H.I.E.L.D. agent Eric OGrady stole the Ant-Man armour from his friends dead body and went on to use the suit of Marvels premiere diminutive superhero for his own gain, repeatedly. He was one of the least likeable superheroes ever (and actually a practising villain for a time), and even used his shrinking powers to stalk women.
From time to time he did help save the world, though, and Eric did eventually get a chance to make amends for his crimes when Steve Rogers overlooked his years of criminality and invited him to join the Secret Avengers. It was as a member of this team that Eric eventually met his end. He was beaten to death by a group of androids that worked for a supervillain team called The Descendants. He had one final moment of redemption at the last; as he fought off the robots long enough for a young child to escape.
Although the Avengers thought Eric had survived for a time (The Descendants sent back a robotic decoy in his place), Erics death was never in question for the audience. The fact that he died at the end of his redemptive arc is rather fitting for the character, too, so its probably for the best that he hasn't been revived.
7. Howard And Maria Stark
Here are some more parents that had to die to fit into the origin story of a more important character. Howard Stark, father to Iron Man himself, was killed in a traffic collision along with his wife (and Tonys mother) Maria.
Although its been suggested that their demise wasn't accidental, the comics have never delved too deeply into the details of Tonys parents death. The writers seem to prefer leaving it open to interpretation, which adds a nice air of mystery to Tonys backstory. Regardless, the death of his parents is a core part of Tony Starks story. Their passing makes him a billionaire orphan whos forced to take up leadership of Stark Industries much earlier than he would've done otherwise.
This forges him into the anarchic genius industrialist that we've grown to know and love. Again, different versions of Tonys parents have made appearances in alternate timeline stories and other such meanderings from the main Marvel plot, but they've never truly returned to life.
6. The Ancient One (Yao)
The Ancient One soon to be gender-swapped and played by Tilda Swinton in the MCU was Earths Sorcerer Supreme before Doctor Strange took up the mantle. She taught both Stephen Strange and his nemesis Baron Moro in the ways of the mystic arts. Years later, The Ancient One died.
This transpired because an extra-dimensional demon called Shuma-Gorath had kidnapped The Ancient One and wanted to force him into serving as a gateway and allow it passage to Earth. Knowing the terror this would cause, The Ancient One ordered Doctor Strange to kill him and thwart Shuma-Goraths plan. The death of the mentor figure is an archetype of storytelling, so this shouldnt come as too much of a surprise.
If anything, its more shocking that it took Marvel a period of several years to get around to killing The Ancient One once Stranges training was complete. Like Obi-Wan Kenobi in Star Wars, The Ancient One has popped up a couple of times since undergoing mortal death. Hes never technically returned from the grave, but he has made spirit-style cameos. I dont think that discounts him from a place on this list, thoug
5. Ben Reilly
Ben Reilly is one of many clones of Peter Parker that comic book fans have had to wrap their heads around over the years. Some time after the second Clone Saga, Peter gave up being Spider-Man and focused on his personal life, leaving Reilly to take up the mantle (although Reilly had previously preferred the name Scarlet Spider).
This didn't end well. The original Green Goblin returned and made short work of Reilly (who was at a disadvantage due a gas that had removed his Spider-Sense). Peter was drawn back in to the fight, but Reilly still ended up dead from Goblin glider impalement. Peter scattered Reillys ashes and resumed the responsibilities of Spider-Man. Ben Reilly never made a return, although fans and writers alike have expressed an interest in somehow seeing him reincarnated over the years.
Reilly's legacy is still felt in the comics, though. Notably, in recent years Peters previously-evil clone Kaine has been repurposed as a new version of Scarlet Spider.
4. Captain Marvel (Mar-Vell)
For four years, Marvel have managed to keep Mar-Vell deceased, which is pretty impressive by modern standards. Prior to this, though, there was time when he would have comfortably topped this list... When this cosmic hero - the original Captain Marvel, no less - first died of cancer back in 1982, the decision stuck for a very long time.
With only a couple of ghostly cameos in the interim years, he didn't return properly until the huge crossover Chaos War brought him back in 2010. And even then, it was only a very brief cheating of death. Later, in 2012, Mar-Vell had one final chance to cling on to life when a crystal was used to keep his cancer at bay. However, after realising that this powerful crystal was endangering the lives of his fellow Kree, Mar-Vell heroically sacrificed his last lease of life to save the others. From there, it doesn't look like he'll ever return.
Which is, arguably, a good thing. It seems important for comics to show that real-life diseases like cancer cant be beaten by snazzy sci-fi ideas (even if it did work for Deadpool, to an extent). With that in mind, it's probably far wiser to keep Mar-Vell dead rather than bring him back again. Carol Danvers is doing a great job with his mantle, anyway.
3. Thomas And Martha Wayne
Thomas and Martha Wayne are intrinsic to Batmans story. If they hadnt been gunned down in Crime Alley by the mugger Joe Chill, Bruce Wayne probably wouldn't have become a vigilante at all. Its understandable, then, that their deaths havent ever been undone within the main DC Comics continuity. One notable what if? story about Bruces parents emerged in 2011 with the publication of the Flashpoint comics.
Therein, it was posited by writer Geoff Johns that - in an alternate universe where Bruce got killed in lieu of his parent - perhaps Thomas would become Batman and Martha the Joker. But thats never happened in the main DC universe. The closest weve come to a resurrection for Thomas and Martha was when Ras al Ghul threatened to use one of his reincarnating Lazarus Pits on Bruces parents, bringing them back as decomposed zombies. Naturally, Bruce managed to stop him.
Let's hope nothing like that ever happens, because bringing Bruce's parents back would be pure sacrilege.
2. Gwen Stacy
Gwen Stacy Peter Parkers first true love died in the comics in 1973. It was a hugely shocking moment for fans and a large part of Peters personal development. When the Green Goblin threw Gwen of a bridge, Peter tried to catch her leg with his web. In doing so, he gave her whiplash and accidentally killed her. This accident haunted him for years.
As this event was so tragic to Peter, its important that the comics don't go back on it. And so far, they never have. The writers have given us Gwens secret children, clones of Gwen, and even an alt-universe Gwen who became Spider-Woman, but never a reincarnated Gwen from the main timeline. If they ever do bring her back for real, the fan backlash would be intense.
A better way to use Gwen going forward is to continue showing the impact that her death still has on Peters life. Its referenced quite a lot, and whenever Peter meets an alt-Gwen he tends to be hugely protective of them. Which is understandable. Nods like this from the writers are far preferable than a resurrected Gwen, I'm sure we can all agree.
1. Uncle Ben
And finally, there could only ever be one winner right? Where Bucky and Jason Todd have flaked, Uncle Ben has stood firm. Peter Parkers adoptive father is the cornerstone of Spidey's heroic development. As the man that taught him about power and responsibility, no one played a bigger part in turning Peter into Spider-Man.
Uncle Bens death shot by a criminal that Peter could have stopped - is tragic, and it forced the young Spidey to buck up his ideas. He couldn't just use his powers for money anymore; he had to do something good with them. And he did, never forgetting what Ben taught him (not even when Doc Ock stole his body for a year). As with all the significant comic book characters that die, there have been plenty of echoes and references back to Uncle Ben over years. Just recently, an alternate version of Ben showed up. He was a cowardly Spider-Man from another universe that needed reminding of the responsibility that came with his power.
Once Peter got five minutes to talk to Ben's ghost. It was touching, and it didn't overstay its welcome. This is about as much as fans could handle. Rare nuggets of alt-Ben action could be interesting, but nobody wants to see the original version of the character come back in any major way. After all, if this list proves anything its that some characters can be far more effective in death than in survival.
Do you think comic book characters should stay dead? Or would you like some of these guys to come back? Let us know in the comments