10 Comic Books Where Evil Won
Both Marvel and DC have ended their comics on some particularly dour notes.
It would be a huge mistake to think of comics as being predictable, but at least when in respect to the superhero genre, it's a given that most readers will go into a comic expecting good to triumph over evil.
Sure, there'll be trials and tribulations that may leave a mark (this is the modern age of comics after all), but the thought of having a hero lose and it be the ending isn't something I'd wager too many readers contemplate when in the thrall of a given story, despite plenty of comics having done just that over the last 30-40 years.
Yes, in the case of Marvel and DC the status quo will eventually resume, but the heroes and supporting characters of those respective universes still often have to reckon with some truly awful consequences committed by a villain or some other evil force.
Things can be even bleaker away from the confines of the Big Two and superhero books in general as well, with noir tales from Frank Miller and Image Comics collaborators Ed Brubaker and Sean Phillips conforming to a genre tradition in ending on devastating and all too often tragic notes.
These endings vary in terms of their own effectiveness and staying power, but one thing's for sure: they all have a spectacular ability to bum you out.
10. Memetic
From Batman writer James Tynion IV and artists Erik Donovan and Adam Guzowski comes Memetic, a Boom! Studios comic replete with all the apocalyptic horror you could ever hope for.
The comic itself focuses on a number of characters but in particular a queer college student called Aaron, who's colourblind and has a hearing impairment.
Aaron's disability is what makes him immune to a new meme taking the world by storm called the Good Times Sloth, which, when viewed, makes those who see it experience intense sensations of joy. However, it soon transpires that anyone who views the meme begins to bleed from their eyes and scream uncontrollably, losing all control and becoming violent against all those who aren't also screaming their lungs out.
The world descends into chaos, and while trying to find a cure for those who witnessed the meme Aaron's boyfriend Ryan reveals that he himself had seen it, which leads him to take his own life by jumping off a balcony. Things only get worse from there, with the Screamers evolving to transmit the meme's virus without any visuals necessary, which leads to the comic's other protagonists - Marcus, Peter and Meredith - all becoming infected, while all the other Screamers merge to form giant human-meat-towers with nothing but their faces intact.
Yep...
Our heroes eventually find the creator of the meme, but any hope for a cure disappears once he kills himself, with all his other computers destroyed. Meredith decides to take her own life at this point, while Marcus transforms into a Screamer, and Aaron willingly assimilates himself into the human tower nightmare because he feels left out.
Memetic's ridiculously bleak conclusion is capped off by an alien vessel descending onto the planet, which serves as the cherry on top of the proverbial depression cake it serves up from start to end.
9. Ruins
In terms of "must-read" Marvel comics, Kurt Busiek and Alex Ross' Marvels is absolutely up there with the best of the best.
The series, which released over the course of four months in 1994, chronicled the development of the Marvel universe through the eyes of Daily Bugle reporter Phil Sheldon, who personally witnesses the world transition from the Golden Age of the 1930s and forties to the Marvel Age of the 1960s. It's a fairly seminal work - one defined by its beauty and the story's deep reverence for the superhero genre.
But then there's Ruins, which is everything Marvels isn't.
Released a year after Marvels and with an entirely different creative team, Ruins essentially explored a version of the Marvel universe where everything that could go wrong did go wrong.
Instead of transforming into an angry rage monster, Bruce Banner's run-in with the gamma bomb test turned him into a hulking mass of grotesque tumours. The United States is also run by an oppressive dictatorship and the Avengers are a rebel group based in California who suffer significant deaths as the result of a Quinjet crash.
It's just all a bit grim, really. Literally everything goes wrong and not even Galactus is spared. Oh, and Nick Fury's a cannibal - just in case you thought it couldn't get any weirder.
8. Joker
Brian Azzarello and Lee Bermejo's Joker released in the midst of The Dark Knight and that's pretty apparent once you read it.
Bermejo's Clown Prince seemingly takes a number of cues design-wise from Heath Ledger's depiction, while Azzarello's script casts the character in a less comedic light. This version of Joker is brutal, uncaring and exists in a version of Gotham that is bleaker than bleak, and that naturally translates into the comic's finale, which ends with small-time crook and reader surrogate Johnny Frost taking a tumble into the Gotham river after being scarred by his chaotic associate.
Joker may still be a Batman comic at the end of the day, but the Caped Crusader doesn't stand in the way of his arch-nemesis' rampage until the final act, where he's able to manipulate the clown into having one of his trademark outbursts.
Sadly, said outburst is what leads Frost to his doom, capping off a thoroughly miserable and exploitative journey that involved Joker flaying a man for looking at Harley Quinn too long, and also raping Frost's ex-wife.
Truly, we live in a soci-edgy.
7. The Fade Out
Ed Brubaker and Sean Phillips are absolutely terrific together. The duo have forged a compelling partnership over at Image Comics since the early 2010s, with a heavy focus on film noir. (Brubaker also made a return to the espionage genre with Image in 2013 with Velvet, having done so to great acclaim initially during his highly influential run on Captain America alongside artist Steve Epting in the mid-aughts.)
Now, if there's anything consistent with the film noir genre it's that most stories within it tend to end on a bit of a bummer. They're atmospheric, moody, morally complex and almost always seductive, but the running theme tends to be that the protagonist rarely comes out on top by journey's end.
Case in point, The Fade Out - one of Brubaker and Phillips' most superb collaborations yet situated in Hollywood during the second Red Scare of the 1940s and fifties.
The Fade Out tells the story of Charlie and Gil, the former a successful screenwriter left with writer's block after returning from the Second World War, and the latter an equally skilled victim of the Hollywood blacklist due to his own politics.
The series dives deep into the seedy underbelly of the Hollywood studios during the era, with Charlie unearthing a horrifying cover-up after he wakes up next to a dead star after a particularly heavy party. I dare not spoil the particulars of the ending - because the comic really must be read - but it's as devastating as it is brilliant.
6. Torso
Torso tells the story of The Untouchables sequel that never was, focusing on Eliot Ness after his legendary takedown of Chicago gangster Al Capone as he tries to unearth the mystery of the Cleveland Torso Killer, a real-life serial killer who was said to have personally targeted Ness once he became the city's Safety Director in the 1930s.
A collaboration between Marvel-turned-DC writer Brian Michael Bendis and Marc Andreyko, Torso is a moody, atmospheric read that lays bear the true horror of the Torso Killings, telling the story from the perspective of Ness and two other detectives, Peter Myrlo and Sam Simon.
Bendis himself researched the case extensively while developing the comic, which in real life went unsolved despite Ness believing the culprit to be a doctor called Francis E. Sweeney, a veteran of The Great War who was also a surgeon. The story goes that Ness was unable to apprehend Sweeney due to him being related to an influential Cleveland politician, Martin L. Sweeney, but Torso dares to fill in the blanks a little more gruesomely.
After resorting to burning down a Hooverville Ness believed the murderer was selecting his victims from, detectives Myrlo and Simon make a breakthrough in the case, but things go horribly, horribly wrong.
As with The Fade Out, it's better that you read this one without getting spoiled. Just be prepared for a gut-wrenching conclusion.
5. Batman: A Death In The Family
Batman: A Death in the Family is one of the most iconic comics in the Caped Crusader's history, but not because it was good.
The tale is weirdly plotted and features a frankly embarrassing plot as the Joker becomes an ambassador for Iran at the United Nations (and you thought Riggs and Murtaugh had it bad in Lethal Weapon 2), and derives significance mostly because it marks the sole occasion where readers voted to kill off a comic book character.
Death in the Family is steeped in controversy both on and off the page, but it also cannot be denied that it marks an occasion where evil came out on top. Readers voted by a narrow margin to kill Jason Todd, the second Robin (although allegations of vote tampering abound), and it represents to this day Batman's greatest failure.
Sure Jason himself may have returned, but there's no getting away from the fact that the Clown Prince brutally beat and then exploded a child to death in a comic, and that it was what the readers wanted. That's just straight up cold no matter how you cut it.
4. JLA: Earth 2
If there's one thing Grant Morrison just LOVES it's classic throwbacks to old Silver Age staples. It's present throughout their run on Batman, and they sprinkled in similar nods towards the sci-fi laden DC era in their Justice League works from the late nineties and early aughts.
JLA: Earth 2 is one such occasion where Morrison's Silver Age hijinks are on full display, as the Justice League of Earth Prime take on their evil counterparts from the antimatter universe, a reality that naturally gravitates towards evil outcomes rather than good ones.
Morrison's comic, which features art from Frank Quitely, ends in a stalemate between the two Leagues, but there's no getting away from just how evil the antimatter universe is. Earth 2 has Ultraman rather than Superman, Owlman instead of Batman, Superwoman as the evil Wonder Woman and then Johnny Quick and Power Ring as the stand-ins for Flash and Green Lantern, and they are all bad to the bone.
In the antimatter universe, literally every hero who emerges is doomed to fail, whereas in the main DC reality, they're usually meant to prevail. Apply that to the entire history of the old Earth 2 (which also directly implies Benedict Arnold successfully betrayed George Washington to the British), and you're left with countless lifetimes of evil endings.
3. The Hard Goodbye
Sin City is a classic Frank Miller tale that plants its roots firmly in the noir genre, and anyone familiar with the series will know it has a habit of ending things on dour notes.
Nowhere is this best embodied than in the comic's debut arc, The Hard Goodbye, which would later be adapted to the big screen along with many of Miller's other Sin City works in 2005, with Mickey Rourke playing the comic's protagonist Marv.
The Hard Goodbye sees Marv - a veteran-cum-hitman - stand accused of the murder of a sex worker he'd been frequenting, called Goldie. Marv sets out to clear his name, and eventually discovers that Goldie was the victim of a Sin City serial killer called Kevin (played by Elijah Wood in the film).
Marv gets his revenge in brutal fashion, dismembering Kevin and feeding him to his dogs, but it's all for nought. Kevin was well connected to Sin City's influential Roark family, who have the cops in their pocket. Marv is tried and eventually convicted of all of Kevin's murders, and is summarily executed in the electric chair.
2. Watchmen
There's not much else that could be said about Watchmen that hasn't been said already, but it is important to clarify one thing in particular before diving into discussion surrounding its ending.
No, Rorschach is not the hero of Watchmen. He's a superhero satire and a psychotic Randian paragon, and he's also far from the martyr some readers have wrongly painted him as in discussions surrounding the comic. So, let's get stuck into it.
Watchmen concludes just as the United States and the Soviet Union teeter on the edge of nuclear conflict. Nite-Owl and Rorschach discover that Ozymandias has devised a secret plan to bring about world peace that will in itself result in the deaths of thousands: dropping a fake alien squid in the middle of New York in order to get the world powers to work together against a fake alien threat.
Ozymandias' actions are evil, no matter how well intentioned, but the heroes stand to lose more from immediately exposing his conspiracy than they do if they just go along, as it could reopen the prospect of open nuclear conflict, and so they all, bar Rorschach, agree to keep it secret. The only alternative in that moment, which Rorschach doesn't realise, would lead to countless more deaths.
That said, no matter his beliefs or intentions, Ozymandias still commits an unquestionably evil act. Evidence presented in the text suggests that his recourse wasn't necessary either, and if we are to take Doomsday Clock and HBO's Watchmen as true sequels, Ozymandias' scheme gets exposed anyway, making him both a mass murderer and the world's dumbest smart person.
1. Spider-Man: One More Day
It's difficult to think of a more controversial comic book than Spider-Man: One More Day. The series upended decades worth of Peter Parker's history in an attempt to make him seem more hip and relatable with The Youth, and it's a decision Marvel are still reckoning with almost 15 years later.
The comic takes place in the aftermath of Civil War where Peter very stupidly revealed his identity to the world to help convince those sceptical of Iron Man's pro-registration movement. He switches sides in the course of the conflict, becomes a fugitive, and then his old adversaries start targeting his family (because of course they do), which leads to Aunt May getting mortally wounded.
Peter does what any irradiated young adult would do in the Marvel universe and decides to strike a deal with Mephisto to bring his elderly aunt back to life. Mephisto conveniently throws in the addition of a mind-wipe so that people will also forget Peter's identity reveal, but at the cost of his marriage with Mary Jane, plus the children they would've eventually had.
One More Day exemplifies everything that's wrong with the superhero genre, but specifically Marvel and DC's obsession with the status quo. It also remains the bedrock on which all subsequent Spidey runs have been laid on, and if that isn't the naffest thing ever, what is?