10 Comic Characters Who Totally Changed After Appearing On Screen

After the movies were smash hits, these comics needed to adapt or die!

By Jimmy Kavanagh /

It is easy to forget sometimes that not everyone has an encyclopedic knowledge of comic book heroes and villains. Despite many beloved characters existing for decades, starring in hundreds of stories and developing committed fan bases, there are even more people who go through their entire lives without ever hearing of them. This is simply because, as hard as it is to believe, not everyone in this world is obsessed with comics.

Advertisement

However, if box office records are to be believed, it would seem that everyone in this world is obsessed with comic book movies. If you have a character that you think everyone alive deserves to see, all you have to do is stick them in a superhero movie, and wait for everyone alive to roll up to the cinema. If that doesn't work, giving them their own TV show should be just as effective.

But what happens when the filmmakers change a character for the screen? This is all well and good until film fans come looking for their new fictional friend in the comics, and find a totally different person. We'd love to say that comic creators stick to their artistic vision and remain true to their original character, but that's just not how business works, baby. Here are ten comic characters who completely changed once their on-screen versions became more popular.

10. Yondu

A founding member of the Guardians of the Galaxy, the original Yondu Udonta first appeared in Marvel Superheroes #18 in 1969. This blue-skinned, large mohawked alien was the last surviving member of the Zatoan tribe in the far-off 31st Century. As a character, he fit into the "noble savage" archetype, a spiritual being who was eager to serve and help his fellow Guardians.

Advertisement

Marvel Studios decided to take this character in quite a different direction. Rather than a faithful servant who was all about teamwork, James Gunn wrote Yondu as a father figure for Star Lord, and a fairly lousy one at that. This rough-and-ready space cowboy version of Yondu was played with grizzled menace by Michael Rooker, star of Henry: Portrait of a Serial Killer. He was such a hit that he was given an even bigger role in the sequel, being promoted from comic relief to the ultimate hero of the story.

The next time we met Yondu in the comics, he was a completely different person from his first appearance. And we do literally mean a completely different person - because the original Yondu lives in the 31st Century, the Guardians of the Galaxy comic could easily introduce a brand new character who lives in the present day. It's just an amazing coincidence that he also happens to be named Yondu Udonta, and that he looks and acts exactly like he does in the movies.

9. Batman

It's almost impossible to imagine now, but in the 1960s there was a point when it looked like it was all over for Batman. Sales of the series had been dwindling, and DC were dangerously close to cancelling the caped crusader's comic. This was well before Batman had seventeen films, fifteen TV shows, and forty-one video games under his belt, with the Batman franchise consisting of nothing but the comics and an old theatrical serial from the 1940s. If the comics had been discontinued, it could have been the end of Batman in pop culture altogether!

Advertisement

It was this 1940s serial that ended up being the ticket to Batman's salvation. After it was re-discovered as a campy cult hit in the sixties, a new TV show based on Batman and his sidekick was commissioned. This show only had one goal: take the accidental campiness of the original serial, and turn it up to eleven. And, like the animated text that would appear on screen whenever Batman punched anyone, it was a SMASH!

DC knew that if they wanted to keep making comics, they would have to re-design Batman to appeal to fans of the show. It was out with spooky, Gothic detective stories, and in with psychedelic silliness.

This, in turn, led to another re-design of the character. As soon as the show fell out of popularity, the comics doubled down on re-establishing Batman as a dark, conflicted hero, desperate to reclaim the character's dignity. Even Bruce Wayne has to change with the times!

8. Batgirl

Barbara Gordon's alter-ego Batgirl has become one of the most celebrated members of the Bat Family, and a fan favourite superhero for many. But what few people realise is that before Batgirl, there was Bat-Girl!

Advertisement

The original Bat-Girl was the superhero persona of Betty Kane, a much more comedic take on the character. There honestly wasn't much to Bat-Girl, except for the fact that she was a Girl who dressed like a Bat. A Bat-Girl. She was created to be little more than a love interest for Robin, introduced for the sole purpose of convincing the censors that there was no romantic relationship between Batman and his sidekick. After a few appearances, she was dismissed by the editors as being "too silly", and was more or less retconned out of existence.

It was the sixties TV show that introduced the much more interesting Barbara "Batgirl" Gordon. As the daughter of one of Batman's closest allies, Commissioner Jim Gordon, she added a dynamic new layer to the series. Not only was she an ass-kicking vigilante, her inclusion added an exciting family drama aspect: she could never allow her father to discover that he was working alongside his own daughter. When the comic writers realised the storytelling opportunities this created, they knew they had to bring her into the comics canon immediately.

7. Alfred Pennyworth

Alfred Pennyworth, Bruce Wayne's loyal butler, is one of the most iconic characters in comics history. He is so integral to the story and image of the Dark Knight that he is one of the only other characters to appear in every single Batman movie (with the exception of Suicide Squad, but is anyone really counting that one?). He has such an iconic look and recognisable mannerisms, it's hard to believe that he started out as a very, very different character.

Advertisement

Alfred was originally nothing more than some light comic relief. Although he was still Batman's butler, he also moonlighted as a bumbling, overweight amateur detective who would solve cases completely by accident. This got old quite fast, and Alfred was in desperate need of rejuvenation. However, unlike Batman and Batgirl, it was not the sixties TV show that prompted his redesign - it was the 1943 serial.

The thin, moustachioed William Austin played Alfred in the serial, and although the portrayal couldn't have been less similar to the comics, it made so much more sense as a character. Those working on the comics realised this, and concocted a plan to transform him: Alfred would take a break from working at Wayne Manor, and visit a health resort. When he returned, he had lost weight, grown a moustache, and become considerably less bumbling. This look has remained unchanged ever since.

6. Daredevil

If you were to break down the most important aspects of Daredevil, it would probably go something like this: he's DARING, and he dresses like a DEVIL. The fact that he's also Matt Murdock, a blind lawyer with super senses who's been trained in the art of ninja fighting, should really be secondary to these two things.

Advertisement

And yet, on-screen adaptations of the character tend to shy away from this, especially the Devil part. Daredevil's first live action appearance was not his fantastic Netflix show or his considerably less fantastic Ben Affleck film: it was The Trial of the Incredible Hulk, a fantastically cheesy TV movie from 1989. This outfit completely disregarded the devilish look of the original, instead focusing on the 'blind' and 'ninja' aspects of the character. And, despite it being a bit of a cop-out and not at all comic accurate... It actually looked pretty cool.

Frank Miller and John Romita Jr. certainly thought so, and featured this black costume prominently in The Man Without Fear, the definitive version of Daredevil's origin story. This comic went on to inspire Netflix's Daredevil show, which clearly prefers this more realistic outfit and uses every opportunity to get Matt Murdock back into it.

5. Spider-Man

Spider-Man is a superhero who has remained remarkably unchanged since he was first introduced. Some might even say TOO unchanged: despite Peter Parker debuting as a sixteen year old in 1962, somehow in the 2020s he is only in his mid-twenties and studying in college. Talk about ageing gracefully!

Advertisement

One thing that has occasionally changed over the years is his set of superpowers. The original character really only had two things going for him: he was really strong and really sticky. His web shooters were a mechanism he invented himself, using the remarkable intellect he possessed even before he had been bitten by a radioactive spider.

That was until the 2002 Spider-Man film came along, and replaced the web-shooters with organic webbing, another by-product of the spider bite. After the movie was a huge hit, the comics decided to introduce this organic webbing to cater towards their new fans. How would they achieve this? Why, through bizarre, unsettling body horror of course!

Readers were treated to watching Peter Parker transform into a giant spider, lay a massive egg, and then give birth to a new version of himself that could shoot webs. Because comics!

4. Nick Fury

There are a few steps to this transformation. Nick Fury is one of Marvel's longest running characters, debuting alongside his Howling Commandos in 1963. In all that time, he had a pretty consistent look: a square-jawed army man who usually wore an eyepatch.

Advertisement

When Marvel introduced its Ultimate Universe, a series of comics about alternate versions of fan-favourite characters, the alternate Fury was designed to look exactly like Samuel L. Jackson. When Jackson became aware of this, he said that he was absolutely fine with his image being stolen, as long as he could play the character if they ever made a movie about him. Eleven movies later, and Jackson's performance has become the most iconic version of Fury yet, and many casual fans' first introduction to the character.

Riding the wave of Sam Jackson buzz, Marvel Comics decided to introduce Marcus Johnson into their main universe. Johnson also happened to look a whole lot like Sam Jackson, and was revealed to actually be the original Nick Fury's long-lost son. After he had his eye cut out by a Soviet-based terrorist organisation, Johnson got an eyepatch of his own, changed his name to Nick Fury Jr, and essentially replaced his father in the comics.

3. Loki

Loki was always your classic cackling villain. With his ridiculous costume and huge horned helmet, he was one of the Avengers' sillier foes, whose only goal was to make mischief and look ludicrous doing it.

Advertisement

However, Tom Hiddleston's portrayal of Loki offered something very different. The actor's natural charisma and pitch perfect over-acting gave us a hugely entertaining villain, one that an audience could love to hate while never forgetting just how threatening he was. It's a real testament to Hiddleston's performance that the audience could boo him in Avengers Assemble, but still shed a tear when he seemingly died in Avengers: Infinity War.

The comics could not ignore that one of their second-tier villains had become one of the MCU's biggest stars, so they knew that a bit of a reboot was in order. They re-designed him, not only to look more like Hiddleston, but to have a cooler, more 21st-Century personality. Loki went from Trickster God to Hipster God, in one of the few cases where a modern update of a classic character actually worked.

2. Mister Freeze

Mr. Freeze began life as 'Mr. Zero', an inept joke of a Batman villain whose origin was nothing more complex than accidentally spilling chemicals on himself. A forgettable villain of the week, his gimmick was that he loved low temperatures and had a gun that could freeze things. Ironically, he just wasn't very cool.

Advertisement

That all changed with Batman: The Animated Series. The show gave him a new look and a new name, rebranding Mr. Zero as the admittedly equally silly-sounding Mr. Freeze. However, it was his new tragic backstory that turned him into the unforgettable conflicted villain he is today. In perhaps the most extreme version of the 'women in refrigerators' trope, it is revealed that everything Freeze does is motivated by his desire to save his wife Nora, who remains cryogenically frozen until he can develop a cure for her incurable disease.

Alongside this Shakespearean tragedy of a backstory came Shakespearean language, with the writers having Freeze spout such beautiful prose as:

"Think of it Batman. To never again walk on a summer's day with a hot wind in your face, and a warm hand to hold... I'm beyond emotions. They've been frozen dead in me."

Freeze's debut episode of the cartoon won an Emmy for Outstanding Writing in an Animated Program, and this far superior version of the villain was immediately adopted by the comics.

1. Superman

It's hard to picture a world before Superman. As the first ever superhero, he is such a huge part of the cultural zeitgeist that it feels like he always existed. Imagine the excitement of the children of 1938, when he first debuted, fully formed, flying out of the pages of Action Comics #1...

Advertisement

Oh, except he wouldn't have been flying.

Believe it or not, the original comic book Superman did not have the power to fly. He was just really good at jumping, being able to "leap 1/8 of a mile" and "hurdle a 20 story building". It was the 1941 cartoon that introduced the power of flight and, frankly, it was done out of pure laziness.

The animators of the Superman series were sick of the amount of drawings it took to make the hero look like he was bouncing around from building to building, so they requested to introduce a new superpower. Giving him the ability to simply outstretch his arm and soar up, up, and away greatly reduced the animators' workload, and inadvertently created one of Superman's most iconic traits and a staple of all superpowers.

Advertisement