10 Comics Changed Due To Fan Backlash
Can you believe the Clone Saga was almost good?
To quote Mallrats' Brodie Bruce, "You f**kers think just because a guy reads comics he can't start some sh*t?"
Few fandoms are as passionate and territorial as comic book fans. For better or for worse, comics fans - including us here at WhatCulture - will painfully plead their case on heavy hitting matters such as why Superman forever needs to have red underpants over his tights, and why Gambit is far cooler than Wolverine.
The point being, comics fandom is one that is never afraid to speak its mind.
As a result of this strong-willed mentality, comics fans have often caught the attention of those in the industry with both their praise and their displeasure. And on that displeasure front, while some comics creators are happy to ignore any negativity that comes their way, other times we've seen a fan backlash be so strong that action has had to be taken to go back on certain decisions.
Here, then, are ten examples of when the backlash of comic book fans forced some of the biggest comic book companies in the industry to rethink their output and make major changes.
10. Explaining Batgirl's Villainous Side
Remember when brutal mute Cassandra Cain was one of the most intriguing and interesting characters in comics?
That seems like forever ago, and, in reality, we are talking about the Cass of 15-20 years ago. For a spell, Cain's Batgirl was one of the very best characters in the comic book industry, particularly when it came to the unique relationship she had with Tim Drake.
These days, Cain feels like a bit of an afterthought, usually seen as one of the oft-changing roster of The Outsiders. When it comes to where things went wrong for the character, one glaring example of fans lambasting DC's decision making process was when the call was made to turn Cassandra Cain into a full-blown villain.
Granted, Cass had previously been seen to take a darker slant over the years, but the One Year Later landscape of DC Comics positioned her as the head of the League of Assassins and eradicated the nuanced semblances of 'good' that had been established in the character since her debut.
Instead, Cassandra was now a maniacal murderous sort who was intent on turning fellow heroes to the dark side - all with zero logical explanation.
Fans hated it, and the push back saw DC having to worm their way out of this experiment by falling back on the lazy excuse of daddy issues. Said daddy issues saw Cass swayed by the words of Deathstroke, who used his position to manipulate Cain through a mind-controlling drug.
9. Invisible Woman's Powers
For the most part in comics, a fan backlash usually occurs after a change has taken place. In the example of Sue Storm, though, the backlash came because of how much that character needed to change.
When the Fantastic Four were first created by Stan Lee and Jack Kirby, Sue's Invisible Woman act saw her with the ability to render herself invisible at will. But after the first few adventures of Marvel's First Family, readers felt that Sue was a useless afterthought in most of these missions.
This was at the time when the likes of Lee and Kirby were keen to address fan letters in the actual comic books themselves. Seeing the outcry of negativity towards the Invisible Woman, this matter was originally addressed by the FF retorting that Sue was the inspiration behind the group, and how she supported the other three members of the team in the Fantastic Four's battles.
That response from Lee and Kirby was a lame one that didn't wash with readers, and so change was on the way for Sue Storm.
That change famously came in Fantastic Four #22, when Sue's powers were expanded on to allow her to manipulate invisible force fields and also be able to make others invisible. Skip forward a few years, and the Invisible Woman was soon one of the most powerful heroes in all of Marvel Comics.
Were it not for that early fan backlash though, who knows how things would've played out for the Invisible Woman.
8. The Saga Of... The Clone Saga
Just the mere mention of the words "The Clone Saga" will send shivers up the spine of comic book readers of a certain vintage.
From 1994 to 1996, The Clone Saga caused headache after headache as Marvel Comics tried to breathe new life into their Spider-Man property. Bringing Peter Parker clone Ben Reilly fully into the fold, the main crux of so much of The Clone Saga revolved around whether Ben was a clone of Peter, or whether Peter was a clone of Ben. Added to that, there were also several other Spider-clones involved, with tinkering aplenty from the nefarious Jackal.
Shockingly, there was a moment in time where writer Terry Cavanagh was moving forward to establish that Peter Parker was indeed the real clone. Yes, Ben Reilly, aka the Scarlet Spider, had always been the real Peter.
Fans rejected that notion, with it effectively pissing away all that they'd come to know and love about the Spider-Man who'd debuted in Amazing Fantasy #15 back in 1962. Due to this fan backlash, the decision was made to change things up... so that both Peter and Ben were somehow clones.
By the time all was said and done, there would be the revelation that Norman Osborn had orchestrated this whole farce - and that, yes, Ben Reilly was a clone, and yes, Peter Parker was the real, err, Peter Parker.
7. DC Comics Passes On Second Coming
Fan backlash? Technically not. But Second Coming received such a ferocious backlash from non-fans, it resulted in the book losing its spot at DC Comics.
Mark Russell and Richard Pace's Second Coming was first published last year by AHOY Comics, but original plans called for Second Coming to go out under DC Comics' Vertigo imprint.
For those not familiar with Second Coming, the title centres on God sending Jesus to the present-day Earth. Unhappy at how his son handled things the first time around, God is looking for Jesus to make amends by using the superhero Sun-Man as inspiration on how to get things done.
Even though the book was designed to be a slice of social commentary on Christianity, DC Comics ran into a brickwall of backlash before they could even get a single issue of Second Coming published.
Upon getting word of Second Coming, certain Christian groups set up an online petition which garnered well over 200,000 signatures decrying for this title to be cancelled.
By all accounts, DC did want to push forward with publishing Second Coming, but they wanted Warren and Race to make certain changes to the tale. As such, the duo instead decided to ask for the rights to the title to be returned to them - a move which DC agreed to - so that they could publish Second Coming elsewhere in the way that they had intended the story to be presented.
6. Jason Todd's Future Gets Put To A Public Vote
The history of Jason Todd is a muddied one, for sure.
Having taken on the mantle of Robin after Dick Grayson had outgrown the role, the huge Crisis on Infinite Earths event saw changes made to the characterisation of Jason. After the powers-that-be - including editor Denny O'Neil - feared Todd was presented as Dick-lite, post-Crisis gave the opportunity to made Jason his own man, to spruce up his character, and to give him more of an edge.
By that time, though, the damage had already been done, with readers having made up their mind that Jason Todd absolutely sucked, and that he was a shell of the Robin that Dick Grayson was. That reader resentment and backlash culminated, of course, in 1988's A Death in the Family.
With many deeming Jason an impostor in the Robin role, the backlash was so ferocious that DC started to have cold feet about Todd's place alongside Batman. So much so, the comic book powerhouse made the unique, bold call to have fans decide whether to kill off Jason. By putting Robin's fate in the hands of the fans, that was the definitive way to see just how bad the backlash to Todd was.
After a crowbar-heavy meeting with The Joker left Jason incapacitated and in a building laced with explosives, readers were given the option to vote via telephone on whether Jason lived or died. In a tight affair, 50.3% of 10,614 total votes called for Jason Todd to perish.
Even more interesting, fans instantly warmed to Jason upon his eventual return 17 years later in 2005's Under the Hood arc - and he's still revered as one of DC's coolest characters to this day.
5. More Women In Creative Positions At DC Comics
Not a single comic book title or comic book arc, but fan backlash in 2011 saw the comic book industry look at ways to change its very make-up.
For decades, the comic book industry was one accused of sexism both in terms of how it presented its characters and in who was involved on the creative side of the industry. And rightly so, for the industry is one that was for so long dominated by men in positions of power, and likewise there was the creepy way that so many female characters were sexualised in their appearance or in what their roles were.
Thankfully, fan backlash to this sexism became so hot in 2011 that DC Comics had to publicly come out to address these issues and promise to push forward with change. Back then, Jim Lee and Dan DiDio released a statement admitting that they'd "heard from fans about a need for more women writers, artists and characters" and that they would be taking these concerns seriously and addressing them as a matter of urgency.
Name such as Gail Simone and Kelly Sue DeConnick have led the charge in this regard, although there is still a long way to go. In 2011, stats showed that around 10% of all comics creators were female. More recently, that figure is now closer to 20%.
While fan backlash caused the heavy-hitting publishing houses to actively seek for more creative input from women, there is still so much more than can be done.
4. Saving Deadpool... Twice
See Deadpool in that header image? Imagine that pooch is really the comic book fanbase running to his rescue to make their affection known. Not once, mind, but twice.
Even though these days the Merc with a Mouth has become a pop culture phenomenon, that wasn't always the case. If anything, Wade Wilson was a C-list (at best!) character who was sometimes a villain, sometimes an anti-hero, and sometimes had a mild sprinkling of humour thrown in for good measure.
Having debuted in 1991 as an X-Men villain, it took until 1997 for Wade to get his own comic book title.
That Deadpool Vol. 1 run saw writer Joe Kelly and artist Ed McGuinness do wonders with Chiyonosake and give the character so many of the traits fans now know and love about Deadpool. The thing is, Marvel Comics wasn't all that fussed on Wade Wilson and cancelled that title after just 25 issues.
An outraged response from readers saw Marvel backed into bringing that Deadpool title back, although the book would again be cancelled with Deadpool #33. Undeterred, those same fans went to bat for Wade - with Marvel having to once again un-cancel the book.
In total, that first solo Deadpool title would end up running for 69 issues before coming to an end in 2002. It would then take a further six years for Wilson to be given his own solo book again, and nowadays it seems completely unfeasible for Deadpool to be without his own title.
3. Bruce Wayne's Early Return As Batman
When it comes to passionate, vocal fan bases, few are quite as intense as those who love nothing more than taking a trip to the streets and rooftops of Gotham City.
Back during the Knightfall story of 1993, Bane was introduced to comics in a major way. That major way, of course, would see this masked powerhouse debut by showing both his smarts and his strength - releasing Arkham Asylum's most infamous names as a way to tire out Batman, before stepping forward himself to break the Bat's back.
The reason for this, was that a new Batman was to be introduced.
As seen, that new Batman was Jean-Paul Valley, aka Azrael. A brutal, clinical figure, the intention of those at DC Comics was to showcase how different Gotham would be with a vicious Batman overseeing proceedings.
From writer Chuck Dixon, so negative was the reaction to Azrael, the decision was made to rush Bruce Wayne back into the cape 'n' cowl way sooner than first planned.
After having his back broken by Bane, Bruce was to be out of commission for a substantial period of time. Instead, he would return to battle and defeat Azrael just a matter of months later, before then handing the Batman mantle to Dick Grayson while Wayne himself worked on completing his full rehabilitation.
In his short spell as Batman, Jean-Paul Valley managed to piss off Tim Drake, piss of Dick Grayson, and hugely piss off readers who had zero interest in seeing his garish Batsuit and murderous ways.
2. Keeping Mayday Alive
May Parker - affectionately known as Mayday - is a character who was originally intended for a one-off appearance as part of Marvel's What If...? line. Created by Tom DeFalco and Ron Frenz, May is the teenage daughter of Peter Parker and Mary Jane Watson - and yes, she has superpowers that mirror her old man's.
Rarely have comic book readers played such a pivotal role in a characters's existence than in the case of Spider-Girl. Firstly, so well received was May's What If...? appearance, Marvel Comics were pushed to give Spider-Girl her own title. That would be titled simply 'Spider-Girl', and May Parker's existence would eventually lead to an entire alternative world of books being launched under the MC2 banner.
Across the years, Marvel made several announcements of impending cancellation for the Spider-Girl book - and each and every time, the passionate push back from fans saw said cancellation scrapped. Even when Spider-Girl did get cancelled after 100 issues, the book was soon relaunched as The Amazing Spider-Girl.
When The Amazing Spider-Girl was brought to a close after 30 issues, May Parker's adventures continued on in The Amazing Spider-Man Family, and May has since been a semi-regular part of reader's habits thanks to titles such as Spectacular Spider-Girl, Web of Spider-Man, and Spider-Geddon.
So directly responsible were readers for keeping Mayday alive, those involved with the character have regularly championed the fan base.
For example, writer Tom DeFalco thanked the fans for not giving up on the the character's solo title "even when Marvel cancelled it and and told me there was no hope of ever bringing it back," before proclaiming "Spider-Girl lives because of her fans!"
1. Credit Where Credit's Due
While a Neal Adams-fronted campaign saw Superman creators Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster acknowledged by Warner Bros. as the brains behind the Man of Steel ahead of 1978's Superman: The Movie - a move that granted Siegel and Shuster financial rewards for their creation - it took until 2015 for Bill Finger to get the credit he deserved.
Alongside Bob Kane, Bill Finger created, amongst others, Batman.
If you were a casual fan of the Bat, you likely wouldn't have been aware of Finger's involvement in the origins of the Caped Crusader, and that's largely down to how DC Comics - then operating as National Comics - made a deal with Bob Kane to solely credit Kane as Batman's creator.
For the more hardcore fans, they had spent decades berating the handling of Bill Finger's role in the creation of the World's Greatest Detective, with Finger and his family having missed out on the credit and financial gains that come along with having such a major role in creating a bone fide pop culture legend.
Even though DC began to recognise Finger's role by the turn of the century, it took until 2015 for the fan backlash to finally cause the company to properly credit Bill Finger in any and all Batman projects. And even now, that credit usually reads "Batman created by Bob Kane with Bill Finger" - despite many claiming that Finger was the one most responsible for crafting and shaping the Dark Knight we see today.