10 Comics Heroes Who Broke Their Mentor's Rules

Superhero rules are made to be broken.

By Zoë Miskelly /

The one especially difficult thing about being a sidekick is that you now have to follow the moral code and rules of your mentor, whether you like it or not. Even if you hugely disagree with part of their mantras, you have to bite the bullet, pull up your superhero boots, and deal with the fact that this is your life now.

Advertisement

Although this isn't always the case. There are plenty of times that folk have completely disregarded the advice and orders of their mentors - to varying results. Sometimes, breaking the rules is exactly what teaches these loveable miscreants why they should have been following them in the first place. Sometimes, however, it makes them horrendous monstrous supervillains - so you can never quite be sure what's going to happen.

Hell, even some superheroes have opted against following what their mentors have taught them - either because it prevented them from carrying out some good deed, because it no longer matched their own personal morals, or just because they couldn't be bothered.

Ranging from understandable to downright psychopathic, here are the times heroes and their wards broke the chains of their mentor's rules - for better, and also undeniably for worse.

10. Speedy

Having spent his life until his teens stealing from food courts and off-licenses, getting to be a superhero alongside the rest of the Teen Titans was more than a bit of shock to the young Roy Harper.

Advertisement

Used to enjoying life where and when he could, Green Arrow's apprentice took to party life straight away, and embraced it so much that it began to genuinely effect his prowess as a superhero.

Enraged by this, Oliver Queen kicked Roy out, the stress of which would convince Harper to become a drug addict. While Queen was horrified to learn what had become of his sidekick, it would be sometime before the two would actually reconcile - and even when they did, Roy would refuse to become his sidekick again, venturing out for himself instead under the identities of Arsenal and later Red Arrow.

Oliver wasn't exactly the most supportive mentor, however, as it was actually a pep talk from Killer Croc that helped Harper get his life back on track. When a giant evil crocodile is doing a better job at being a guardian than you, you might need to have a think about your life.

9. Kid Marvelman

Kid Marvelman - or Kid Miracleman, depending on if you pick the series up after their names legally had to be altered - is a prime example of how teaching a sidekick a specific set of rules can go very, very wrong.

Advertisement

Much like Shazam, Kid Marvelman is able to transform into an adult superhero whenever he says his hero name. After an attempt is made on his life, the Kid opts out of transforming back into his human self, meaning the young Johnny Bates doesn't age.

Unsurprisingly, this isn't great for his mental state, which becomes increasingly unstable, leading him further and further from the lessons that Marvelman taught him, and further into being a bloodthirsty monster and businessman.

When the Kid gets bad enough that Marvelman is forced to fight him, he reveals one final, awful twist; anytime the hero is about to throw the final punch, Kid Marvelman transforms back into the innocent Johnny Bates, who is significantly less punchable.

After Kid Miracleman manages this trick twice, his former mentor realises that there's only one way to stop all of this, forcing him to snap the neck of the innocent and very traumatised young Bates.

8. Amadeus Cho

When Amadeus Cho took Bruce Banner's gamma radiation - and took on the responsibility of being the Hulk from the scientist - he did so under one strict proviso; he needed to remain calm.

Advertisement

Initially, this didn't seem a wild concept. After all, it's been made very clear over the years that Banner's childhood abuse and residual trauma resulted in both the Hulk being more uncontrollable, and in the jolly green giant coming out more, as Banner still has some underlying anger issues.

As a happy-go-lucky genius, it didn't seem too crazy for him to be able to control his new gamma-based form. However, as Cho is only human, he inevitably gives in to his anger many times, scaring both those around him, and Amadeus himself.

Worse yet, this doesn't end up stopping Banner from becoming the Hulk on the long term, so the end result is just more crazy green bad boys running around - although one now has an admittedly sweet haircut.

7. Damian Wayne

The situation between Damian Wayne and his dad is basically that of a particularly unhinged daytime sitcom. Batman's son was raised by assassins, meaning he has an almost instinctive bloodthirst - as well as a huge problem with his own identity, as he simultaneously thinks of himself as the best, and unworthy of being related to the Dark Knight.

Advertisement

As such, the pair struggled with their relationship for a long time after Bruce took his boy in. These struggles seemed to be almost coming to an end - and then Damian killed a supervillain who was trying to kill his dear old dad.

Weirdly, this is actually the catalyst the two needed in order to talk everything out. Damian is still a bundle of murderous rage, but he's a bundle of murderous rage that knows his dad will always love him, and just wants the best for him - and that's more than enough to pacify him for the meantime.

6. Superboy

With Superboy-Prime having grown up for most of his life in a world where Clark Kent and his superhero alter ego were fictional, it makes sense that, perhaps initially, he didn't hold the same level of respect for the Man of Steel that many of his other protégés may have had.

Advertisement

But, when Superman trains his unusual doppelgänger, the two do appear to bond - which makes it all the more sad that Prime absolutely loses it and becomes the major villain in Infinite Crisis.

While Superman and his Amazon Prime counterpart didn't have a profound bond, Prime did grow up learning the spaceman's rules and moral code from comics, meaning he knew he was breaking every single one when he did defect to the side of evil.

5. Invincible

When your dad is a superhero who is training you, you'd imagine that your life - and moral code - is more or less helpfully set out for you before you even have to think about your superhero name.

Advertisement

For Mark, however, his life and heroic career become infinitely more complicated because of his dear old dad. Because Omni-Man turns out to have ulterior motives for protecting Earth - namely, the motive that his alien race wants to take it over, and so he's been playing mother hen with it until they can show up.

When he reveals this to Mark, the young hero forgoes everything his dad has taught him as the pair get in a fight.

While there is no way Mark can win, Nolan can't find it in himself to kill his own boy, leading to the pair eventually reconciling.

4. Black Widow

Breaking your mentor's rules can, in some circumstances, actually be a really good thing for your superhero career.

Advertisement

This is exactly the case for Black Widow, who not only had to go against everything her assassin trainers in the Red Room taught her, but also break the mind control they had on her in order to become the ass-kicking superhero and secret agent we know today.

Crucially, it's also been good for Natasha's personal character development, as we've seen her greatly transform from the unfeeling villain she was when she first appeared on the inked page. Though she's not exactly a peppy figure nowadays, she is a person who can make her own decisions - and someone capable of restraining her urge to kill for at least three seconds longer than she used to be able to.

3. Cyclops

One part mentor, one part dad-or-grandad, Professor X is an especially unusual authoritative figure. Because he's likely to deal with dating problems and awkward mutant pimples just as much as he is legitimate threats, since most of his wards are teens who he's more or less adopted.

Advertisement

And Xavier doesn't seem to expect all that much, aside from wanting his students to be empathetic, rational and kind in their dealings with others.

Thus, when Cyclops goes mad with the power of the Phoenix Force and explodes the Professor, you can imagine his mentor would be more than a little miffed, if he wasn't currently busy with being dead. As a man who is usually one of the most logical X-Men, Charles thought he could rationalise with his golden boy, meeting him in a dramatic final confrontation where the Professor emphasis how much he loves his laser-powered boy.

In return, he's blasted with the power of a million suns. Kids are so ungrateful these days.

2. Jason Todd

When it comes to rules, Batman is the hero with the most concrete selection. Or rather, the most concrete one, as his 'no-kill' rule is perhaps one of the most well known things about him.

Advertisement

And so, when it's revealed that Jason Todd - Batman's former Robin, who was killed by the Joker and then made significantly less dead - has turned a new, pro-murder leaf, the Dark Knight is naturally devastated.

Todd breaking this rule under the new mantle of the Red Hood does make totally sense though. Given he literally died to a supervillain, it's only natural that when he's brought back, he's more than a little bitter about the fact that his murderer has essentially gotten off scot-free.

Though indiscriminately slaying anyone who looks vaguely shady isn't exactly a baller plan, you also can't totally fault Jason for changing his MO a little after the whole 'beaten to death by a crowbar' thing.

1. Hal Jordan

As the emerald-clad space police, the Green Lanterns have an awful lot of rules to follow. They have to follow and obey the Guardians - little blue councilmen who are pacifists to a fault - and also serve as a sort of de facto mentor to each member of the Lantern Corps.

Advertisement

Because of these rules often being incredibly limiting, many Lanterns find themselves either building elaborate loopholes, or outright breaking their code for the greater good. For example, one of the Corps' greatest heroes, Hal Jordan, is found doing things that go against his oaths just as often as he's found complying with them.

Even when he's not outright ignoring the orders of the Guardians, Hal often places protecting Earth as as priority over other planets due to his lingering attachment towards our little blue world - which is understandable, but also totally against Green Lantern code.

He's also gotten in a fair amount of brawls with his teammates, but given he has often had to work with Guy Gardner - a man so annoying Batman once punched him out - you can hardly blame him.

Advertisement