10 Comics You Loved As A Teen (But Should Never Return To)
Can we get a 'yikes!' in here?
Although there's a good chance there are folks who only just encountered comics when they were adults, for most fans, it's likelier they first embarked into the medium when they were young. There are comics geared towards a wide variety of age ranges, but most tended to make the big leap when they were teenagers - and that can mean there's a great deal of nostalgia attached to the comics that got them into the medium in the first place.
Unfortunately, some of those comics just don't hold up all that well when you revisit them through a more experienced lens. In a lot of cases, what could've been a nice trip down memory lane instead turns into something pretty awkward fairly quickly, as the flaws of those old, beloved storylines of yore suddenly become just that little bit more noticeable.
Of course, there's nothing to stop readers from loving those books for being their gateway into comics, and it's likelier still that plenty have their admirers today. It's just that, the further you get away from certain comics, it's easier to notice what they got wrong - in some instances because the creator of said book has gone on the record to state just how much they don't like it.
Factor in dated industry practices, a classic ol' dollop of superhero sexism and threadbare storylines being rescued by legendary art, and it's plain to see that some of those old, beloved comics just don't cut the mustard anymore - no matter how much it pains us to admit it.
10. The Killing Joke
Every now and then an entry comes along where you can literally hear guns cocking in the distance, but stay put, chill out, and let me explain why one of the most important Batman tales of all time isn't... actually... all that good.
On a purely technical level, The Killing Joke is masterful. Brian Bolland turns in the work of his career here, and whether you prefer the original colours or the ones from the Deluxe Edition, The Killing Joke is still a plainly stunning comic to look at it. It's also a book filled to the brim with iconic moments, while its discussion surrounding the duality of Joker and Batman is peerless in many regards. So why has the magic suddenly worn off in the three decades since it first hit the shelves?
Well, for all that The Killing Joke succeeds as a Batman/Joker story, it's its legacy that's more difficult to reckon with. In typical fashion, Moore himself has gone on the record to lament his Batman comic, describing it as a "regrettable misstep" in a Q&A session a few years back, while others have equally taken issue with the book's treatment of Barbara Gordon, who the Joker seriously maims in a bid to turn the Dark Knight's staunchest ally, Commissioner Gordon, insane.
These critiques are only worsened by the fact that comics legend Len Wein reportedly told Moore to "cripple the bitch" when he first informed him of his plans for Batgirl, with The Killing Joke now often decried by fans for typifying the "women in refrigerators" trope (although this story would take a nicer turn when Babs became one of the few disabled heroes in the superhero genre as Oracle).
Lastly - although it's not exactly the book's fault - it's fair to say that TKJ has inspired a near unending wave of material that seeks to explore the Joker's origin, even though the comic definitively states that not even the Clown Prince himself is aware of his beginnings. Every year a comic, film or some kind of adaptation seeks to explain the inexplainable, and they all go some way in lessening the legend of DC's most iconic supervillain.
9. Witchblade
There's a lot of love for Witchblade out there amongst readers, and the character has even been recast as a sort of feminist icon too. Alongside characters like Red Sonja and Vampirella, who've all undergone similar transformations over the last two decades, to grapple with Witchblade's legacy isn't as clear cut as you may think.
Still, for all that Witchblade commands a loyal fandom and continues to see success even twenty years following its original debut... it's still a weird comic. Too weird, if anything. It so transparently conforms to the worst excesses of the nineties and just looks comically out of place in 2019, where nuanced depictions of women in the medium tend to be less exploitative.
Look, there's nothing wrong with a sexy comic. But there is a point where 'sexy' gets so exaggerated that it becomes almost comical. Witchblade sadly falls into that category in hindsight, even if there's still plenty to appreciate about it.
8. Deadpool... Like, A Lot Of Deadpool
Deadpool's a great character, but like the best of things, he's best enjoyed in small amounts, and when his worst excesses can be inhibited. Sadly, for a good while now, poor Wade Wilson has effectively been Flanderised by multiple, successive series and spin-offs; he's rarely ever compelling and, when he is, it tends to be a genuine surprise.
The problem with Deadpool is that the character is inherently interesting. There's something to enjoy about a fourth-wall-breaking anti-hero who, more often than not, ends up being the reluctant protagonist sent in to save the day. He's a Deathstroke parody and a fine outlet for satire in the right hands, but in the wrong hands, Wilson's stories quickly devolve into a convoluted hodgepodge of self-referential meta-humour, monotonous violence and outdated gimmicks, and it's made all the worse by the fact that - at the height of the character's popularity - he was showing up in pretty much everything Marvel published.
If that wasn't all though, the cherry on chop is that the character effectively has the 'bazinga!' of the superhero genre in 'chimichanga!', which he utters all the time as if the word itself is inherently funny. It isn't! And every time it comes back it feels as though the writer responsible is sat mashing 'XD lol' into their script in some outdated attempt at getting a laugh out of the reader. It's 2019! Get a different joke.
The worst thing about this is that Wade Wilson is tremendous when handled correctly. So why is he just an immature edgelord in most of his books?
7. The Old Star Wars Expanded Universe
Star Wars means a great deal to a lot of people, and while Marvel and DC have their die hard fans, the galaxy far, far away isn't exactly found wanting in that department either. This is still the case even if you narrow the focus down to Star Wars' hardcore, who consume every ounce of Expanded Universe literature they can as soon as it becomes available.
Anyone following the franchise over the last decade will likely be aware that there are in fact two Star Wars continuities though. There's the new canon, introduced post-2012 that encompasses all the films, books, comics and animated shows released since Disney took control of Lucasfilm, and the old one, dubbed 'Legends' for the sake of delineating the material.
Even today, fans love the Legends canon, and it's not as if you have to look far to understand why. Expanded Universe stories had fleshed out Star Wars' canon in a whole new way, and publisher Dark Horse were largely responsible. Comics like Knights of the Old Republic and The Battle of Jabiim both drew plaudits and there were dozens more that were truly original. Most, although it pains us to admit, simply weren't up to scratch though.
Whether it was rehashing ideas like Luke Skywalker falling to the Dark Side or introducing simply ridiculous threats like the Yuuzhan Vong, the old canon was too convoluted for its own good.
6. Joker
Brian Azzarello and Lee Bermejo started their recurring creative partnership at DC with 2005's Luthor, a comic devoted to the Man of Steel's greatest adversary. The duo followed this up with Joker, an Elseworlds-style look into the inner-workings of the Clown Prince designed to launch alongside the premiere of Christopher Nolan's The Dark Knight. Bermejo's version of Joker even boasted the same appearance as Heath Ledger's clown, to the point where some mistook the comic as a movie tie-in.
And that's one of the first problems with Joker. Despite having nothing to do with Nolan's film, and having seemingly been green-lit only days after Luthor's publication, it's just impossible to look at without thinking of The Dark Knight. The book's title was even originally meant to be Joker: Dark Knight, which DC of course changed when they realised comparisons to Nolan's film were becoming increasingly inevitable.
Outside of The Dark Knight comparisons though, Joker's grimdark approach to the Clown Prince seems almost tedious in retrospect. Factor in the book's bizarre interpretation of Harley Quinn, and it seems almost as though it was intended to shock first, and offer a compelling look into the inner-most workings of the Batman villain second.
5. Batman: Hush
It's not exactly difficult to see why Batman fans LOVE Hush. Its story was written by Long Halloween and Dark Victory scribe Jeph Loeb, while superstar artist Jim Lee handled pencils. It looks phenomenal (even if I personally don't default to Lee's style), but when you look past the art, it becomes clear the story just can't match it.
Loeb will never not be a comics legend, but Hush typifies his biggest shortcomings as a writer. The actual mystery isn't all that well crafted - certainly not, when compared to classics like TLH and DV - and it almost feels like a compilation of moments designed to please Bat-fans rather than the mystery-thriller it's touted to be. Batman fights Superman, there's an obligatory 'will they, won't they' romance with Catwoman, and the comic's positively littered with supporting characters for no other reason than to lend a sense of scale to the proceedings.
Hush also has an abundance of Bat-villains at play, but they almost feel tacked-on. Of course they're integral to Hush's revenge, but their appearances feel just 'ok' at best and contrived at worst, which is a huge problem, given they overshadow the book's mystery at every turn.
And that's the main issue with the comic. It has all the trappings of an epic Batman story, but it's so overstuffed with heroes and villains that it forgets to seed a compelling plot. As a series of vignettes it's technically stunning, but as a story? It just doesn't come together.
4. Maximum Carnage
The nineties were a... confusing time for comics. Everything was extreme, edgy or some variation on either word, and while the X-Men were still Marvel's most profitable super-team, its most popular solo hero was still everyone's favourite friendly neighbourhood Spider-Man.
Spider-Man's popularity had approached astronomical levels while Todd McFarlane handled art duties, and this just so happened to coincide with the rise of Venom as a key force in Spidey's comics. The two forged a fearsome rivalry, but then Marvel decided Eddie Brock could be better utilised as an anti-hero rather than as a straight up villain.
Enter Carnage, a Symbiote offspring that attached itself to notorious serial killer Cletus Kasady while he and Brock shared a cell. Carnage embarks on his own wave of terror, and so it falls to Spidey and Venom to track him down, and put a stop to him before more innocents are hurt.
And that's basically it. Maximum Carnage features a cool team-up between Spider-Man and Venom that would get any fan excited, but in reality it embodies some of the most dated tropes of that particular decade.
3. Ultimate X-Men
The X-Men movies were occasionally brilliant, but no one was under any illusions as to what they thought of the comics. An active dig from Cyclops about 'yellow spandex' in the first film made that clear and more, but Marvel still saw an opportunity for their comics to hopefully benefit from Fox's movies. Grant Morrison and Frank Quitely's New X-Men comic gave the team black suits, but so too did Ultimate X-Men, a reimagining of Stan Lee and Jack Kirby's creations designed to modernise the group in line with how The Ultimates did with the Avengers a year earlier.
The Ultimate Universe was an exciting prospect at the beginning of the 2000s, but its success was limited in retrospect. The legacy of Brian Bendis' Ultimate Spider-Man goes without saying, while Mark Millar and Bryan Hitch's Ultimates would later form the visual template for the Marvel Cinematic Universe in later years. Both those comics were brilliant, but later efforts weren't so fortunate - particularly Ultimate X-Men.
Although Millar had succeeded in reimagining the Avengers in a post-9/11 era, his approach towards the X-Men was less compelling. Adorned in black suits, this new team didn't have an issue with killing, and the 'modernisation' really amounts to little more other than the fact they're more lethal and more cynical than their mainstream counterparts.
The end result is something really quite ugly, but back when it was cool to hate on colourful costumes and superheroes using non-lethal methods, Ultimate X-Men found a following when it probably shouldn't have.
2. The Clone Saga
This might come as a shock, given folks who read the Clone Saga as it released probably hated it with an unending passion for the constant back and forth over whether or not Peter Parker was a clone, or just how many clones there were, or whether it was the Jackal behind the whole thing or Norman Osborn, but here's the thing - everyone who was young back when the comic released absolutely adored the Scarlet Spider, for little reason other than he had a denim hoodie overlaid on a blank red costume.
Frankly, it all sounds ridiculous, but literally everyone adores Ben Reilly for the simple fact he looked really cool as the Scarlet Spider. Even the name 'Scarlet Spider' sounds impossibly cool, and while it's easy to look back at Ben today and recoil in horror at the context that brought him into our lives, it's still the case even today that the Scarlet Spider boasts major appeal amongst fans who grew up with the Clone Saga in their periphery.
And that's the thing! Ben Reilly is cool. His suit as the main Spider-Man designed by Mark Bagley? Super cool. The older costume? Also cool, and it's with that in mind that the character's continued survival starts to make sense, even when the Clone Saga itself is probably the messiest superhero comic ever published.
Still, even if you consider yourself a Reilly aficionado, it really isn't worth going through the dozens upon dozens of issues from the Clone Saga to complete his story. The memory is much better than the actual thing - trust me.
1. Civil War
And thus we come to the messiest entry on this entire list: Civil War - a comic so influential, and yet so, so lacklustre.
Like plenty of comics, Mark Millar and Steven McNiven's story is stunning to look at, and the series' iconography is wonderfully composed. Everyone remembers those "Whose side are YOU on?" adverts that were plastered across comic book stores in the build up to the event, and fans found themselves torn at the prospect of their favourite heroes coming to blows against each other. Nothing like it had really happened before - not on this scale.
Depending on where you fall on the 'heroes fighting heroes' issue you either think Civil War has a brilliant concept or one best left confined to tedious internet debates about who could kick whose butt the hardest. If it's the latter, then the comic obviously isn't going to appeal to you. If it's the former, then it's worth noting that, while the idea behind Civil War is compelling on a base level, the execution is lacking in several areas.
Millar's superhero story is a clear critique of post-9/11 politics in the US, and more specifically the Patriot Act. That in itself is fine of course, but when you consider the whole premise behind the series was to pit Marvel's heroes and readers against each other in a civil conflict, the fact the choice between who was right or wrong was so obvious kind of ruins the whole thing immediately.
Because, from start to finish, Iron Man in Civil War is an appalling reactionary with few redeeming features. Captain America is the clear hero of the story, and while Millar does try to extrapolate some nuance from their conflict in its climax - where Cap realises he's gone too far - it's clear the anti-registration forces are the good guys in this scenario.
The film fares much better in this regard, providing a compelling emotional and political reason for why Cap and Iron Man turn against each other. The comic does neither, and leaves certain heroes unrecognisable in service of its plot.