10 Controversial Batman Comics DC Wants You To Forget
Not the comics we deserve, but the comics we need.
In the realm of DC comics, Batman is the rich grandad of the lot - created only four years after DC started printing superheroes proper. The main comic has been running for longer than most of us have been alive, let alone comic fans, meaning there is an ungodly supply of Bat-themed joy for any willing soul to make their way through.
However, this longevity does also have some downsides. When Batman was first introduced, it was into a world that was drastically different to modern times, in terms of what would be considered kind of a dick move - calling disabled people evil, for example.
More than that, the fact that Batman has existed for such a long time means people have to use weird and wild characters and plots to attempt to create something new - or at least not do the same comic that was done twenty odd years ago. They always have interesting results, but also more often than not leave you wondering how the whole thing came to be in the first place.
Be it through a strange character, plot, or premise, these are a series of comics that you will never forget - even if you really, really want to.
10. Evil Santa Klaus
Ed Brubaker's time working on Batman created some of the most interesting Batman comics of the past two decades. The writer did what most comic writers appear scared to do, creating new characters and villains whilst still making good use of old favourites.
However, all silver linings must have clouds, and with these excellent comics came some wild and wonderful moments. The weirdest of these would have to be in Batman #598, which contains an evil Santa Klaus that Batman hunts down on Christmas.
A great premise for a children's book - less so for a legit Batman comic.
That said, a children's adaption would have to remove the two of the weirder things about Klaus - namely, his mind-reading abilities and penchant for murder. Seeing a cracked-out Santa Klaus systematically murder those he deems naughty is not exactly what you'd expect from a Christmas comic, it also makes for a surprisingly gripping read.
While a hate-filled, murderous Santa Klaus is a beautiful addition to the Batman villain roster, with the recent popularity of Calendar Man it's unlikely we'll ever see the jolly psychopath again.
9. Batman: Manbat
Kirk Langstrom - also know as Manbat - is maybe the single most underused Batman villain to still be considered part of the character's rogues' gallery. That's why it's a shame that the Manbat standalone comic is an Elseworld tale, because it essentially means some of the most interesting stuff we know about Langstrom isn't canon.
However, this isn't a total tragedy, as a canon Batman: Manbat would practically ruin the character, if not also Batman himself. It's not totally unrealistic to consider that the plot may have been the result of the writing staff having some sort of join nightmare and writing it all down, as the entire thing has a strange, surreal quality to it. Everything seems slightly off - Batman has dodgy dealings with government agents and wears a cowboy hat, the main villain is crickets, there's a humanoid bat watching MTV - it's almost indescribably weird.
If you want to see two humanoid bat people have a drawn-out sex scene - while their son watches, no less - this comic is your ticket to weird fantasy town. For any sane humans, it's maybe worth repressing any and all memories of it.
8. The Milkman Crime Syndicate
Batman #16 is a first in many ways; the first time Alfred is in a Batman comic, one of the first appearances of the Joker and the first (and maybe only) time milkmen have been used in an evil scheme.
The beautiful part of this is that there is the strong suggestion in the comic that milkmen are generally saints, which is either made up for the sake of the comic, or the most obscure fact known to man. The fact that this makes Batman's milkman initially above suspicion is hilarious though, as it's strange to think the one role the detective would never question is that of a loyal deliverer of milk.
Ironically, it's also one of the most educational Batman comics to date - on specifically dairies, and the things within them - although it seems unlikely that you could pasteurise a body to get rid of it, as unexpectedly badass as that sounds.
Although it's 99% likely the entire thing was written specifically to make dairy puns, the fun mystery of the comic is sure to have contributed to the initial popularity of the Batman comics - so it's not all bad.
7. The Duc D'Orterre
The Duc D'Orterre is an obscure Batman villain, who appeared in one comic - Detective Comics #34 - for the sole purpose of making wild s**t go down. This is the only logical explanation for a man who - in a single comic - attempts murder with a deadly spinning wheel, has made a garden of flowers with human faces, and has burnt a man's entire face off.
There are villains who, despite several comic appearances, have not done as many insane things as the Duc D'orterre manages in the span of thirteen pages.
The brevity may also add to what makes the comic so crazy, as it seems to go from normal to death traps in no time flat. The plant women are never explicitly saved, either, so they're either in perpetual suffering or being saved for the single craziest Poison Ivy comic the human brain can comprehend.
Honestly, there's no way the Duc's first appearance could ever be topped - and that's why it seems unlikely DC would want you to remember what could be their wildest villain to date.
6. Death In The Family
Death in the Family holds a unique spot in the realms of controversial comics, in that any and every purposefully controversial comic is almost definitely based on it.
Jason Todd's death shocked readers universally - and vaguely ironically, since they did vote via phone call for him to die. This was in an era where heroes tended to die for real, and so the concept of a little boy being genuinely murdered was completely shocking - especially for those who suddenly felt a little guilty for phoning in.
It didn't help matters that his death sequence - a series of panels showing only the Joker's smiling face as he beat him to death with a crowbar - is as brutal as it is genuinely terrifying.
Even now, with Jason's resurrection, Death in the Family still has a solid impact on his character that is unlikely to ever be changed. Jason will permanently be the black sheep of the Batclan due to his ordeal as a child, meaning even in DC's retcon of Jason's death, the impact of the comic is still felt.
5. Flashpoint
While most people hope to forget at least parts of Flashpoint, the decision to have Bruce's father, Thomas Wayne, star as Batman is a controversial one at best.
Thomas has donned the cape in many comic series prior - hell, he even continues to into the New 52 - but the Flashpoint version of this is perhaps the darkest one that has ever seen the light of day, with a misanthrope Thomas operating with less of a moral code than we're used to seeing from the Dark Knight.
What truly makes this controversial is that it was actually pretty good - both in plot and in revitalising overused characters. The tragedy of Flashpoint Batman is that if the writers had had the freedom to make Thomas any figure other than Batman, there is a chance that the series could have survived to this day.
As it is, the comic instead remains a grim reminder that sometimes promising comics will be cut short by uncontrollable outside factors - a unfortunate but very real danger working with such famous franchises.
4. Joker Time
Joker Time is possibly the weirdest comic to feature the clown ever - and given he was once emperor of the entire universe, that's saying something.
Joker Time appears to be made to criticise the media, although it does this mostly through the Joker's own dialogue, which seems like a questionable choice given the Joker is less than trustworthy. Stranger yet, the comic attempts to depict its events realistically, somehow implying that a TV show would kidnap a homicidal maniac for an interview, and then be surprised when he acts a little unusually.
It's interesting, sure, but that doesn't always equal a well executed comic. The strange thing is, the Joker origin stories in the comic are incredibly well done - which has to make you wonder why the rest of the story isn't of equal quality. If there was more of a plot it could easily be forgiven, but the whole thing is basically just a Joker monologue, which gets tiring after 100 or so pages.
In all fairness, Joker Time is made out of an interesting and genuinely fresh premise - it's just a shame that it's carried out in such a ham-fisted manner.
3. The Killing Joke
In terms of standalone comics, The Killing Joke is pretty much the most famous Batman comic around. Love it or hate it, the story is incredibly well known, and has played a large part in establishing the tone of the franchise as it is today.
In spite of all this, The Killing Joke is probably also one of the most controversial comic books in existence, banned from countless libraries to this day for the graphic scenes contained within it. Although the comic is well-crafted, it's also heavily criticised, as it falls into a trap that comics succumb to to this day - that of mutilating its' female cast to give the hero some sort of justifiable emotional reaction.
The writer - comic icon Alan Moore - has openly expressed regret on the treatment of Barbara Gordon, stating "they should've reined me in, but they didn't," in an interview with the now defunct Wizard Magazine.
The Killing Joke is a cornerstone of the Batman series - and rightfully so - but it's worth keeping in mind that even the most famous and well-made of comics still have their questionable elements.
2. Stan Lee's Batman
In November 2001, the moons and stars aligned, and us mere mortals were graced with a collaboration between DC and Marvel that let us see what Batman could have been like were he initially created by Stan Lee himself. Although very different from the classic Dark Knight backstory, Lee created a shockingly engaging and well-rounded Batman - which could be the first reason DC would prefer you didn't think about it so often.
While it would be sacrilege to change Bruce Wayne's story at such a late date, the re-imagining does raise some important points about the man behind the mask. Wayne Williams - while clearly not a perfect character from the name alone - does seem to have more of a life outside of the mask than his canon counterpart. While comics have made it apparent that Bruce is often the mask Batman hides behind, it would perhaps be a pleasant change to see him function as a little more than that.
Also, the main villain's name is Handz Horgum, which is the only real flaw in the comic - because anyone named that is pretty hard to hate.
1. The 'Ugliest Man'
For a now seventy-year-old series, the older comics of Batman still mostly hold up surprisingly well. After all, many of the characters we know and love today were born in this era, and so it makes sense that their origins were good - otherwise, they wouldn't have made it so far.
There are some villains, however, whose disappearance from the DC roster is both a blessing and a curse. The prime example of this exists in Batman #3, affectionately referred to in-comic as 'The Ugliest Man in The World'.
His tragic villain backstory, you ask? Well, he's ugly, so he... wants to do crime. That's how that worked back then, apparently.
Although the end of the comic does have the dynamic duo sympathize with the guy, there is the uncomfortable implication that ugly people have some sort of genuine instinct to do terrible things. (It's maybe not DC's magnum opus.)
There is also the unfortunate mention that the Ugly Man's henchmen were given congenital iodine deficiency syndrome - an actual, real medical condition, that maybe shouldn't be made out to make you evil, given that it's essentially calling people with a disability bad guys.