10 Criminally Underrated Batman Comics

Come with us while we unearth some hidden Batman gems!

By Michael Gordon /

With 2014 being The Dark Knight's 75th birthday, now seems as good a time as any to cast our eyes back through the DC Comics archive to unearth some of the best Batman stories ever told. Whenever people talk about great Batman stories, the following titles inevitably come up: Year One; The Dark Knight Returns; The Long Halloween; The Killing Joke; Hush. This list is not about these comics. They've (rightfully) been worshipped enough, adored by all and sundry as the classics they are. Instead, this list is about the stories that we believe are almost as good, but have been lost in the shuffle somewhat. Given that The Caped Crusader has been in continual publication for these 75 years, there is a truly enormous amount of material to sift through. Batman appears in so many different comics every single month that it is difficult enough to produce a Top Ten list for a single year, never mind one covering his whole history. Therefore, the forthcoming list is not an exhaustive one. These are simply ten stories that we feel deserve a bit more recognition, for someone to celebrate them. You know, give them a bit of love. They deserve it. These are the stories that mightn't be the most well-known but are more than worth tracking down and reading. These are 10 of the most underrated Batman comics ever.

10. Gotham County Line (2005)

In a previous article, we highlighted how Batman is a character that can function in stories of many different genre's, rather than limiting a writer to superhero tales. Gotham County Line, published by DC in late 2005/early 2006 as a three-issue Prestige Format miniseries, is unashamedly a horror story, and a very good one at that. Written by Steve Niles, of 30 Days Of Night fame, and featuring macabre, grotesque artwork from Scott Hampton (Batman: Night Cries), Gotham County Line features Batman investigating a series of ritualistic murders in the Gotham suburbs. What initially seems to be a gritty, harrowing serial killer story quickly escalates as Batman finds himself drawn into a terrifying, supernatural realm. Gotham County Line is a twisted, scary treat, with Niles really bringing his own voice to the material. The story gleefully becomes more and more overtly supernatural as it goes on, and by the end we have Batman fighting hordes of the undead and talking to the corpses of his parents. It also benefits from appearances by Deadman and The Phantom Stranger, two beloved characters more known for appearing in the mystical corner of the DC Universe. Serial killers? Zombies? Batman trapped in a phantom world between the living and the dead? Some fans may be reluctant to embrace a Batman story with such elements, but Gotham County Line rewards readers that go with it. Niles knows his way around a horror comic, but also clearly has an affinity for Batman, as his depiction of how the grounded Bruce Wayne would deal with such events feels spot-on.

9. Heart Of Hush (2008)

Thomas Elliott, or Hush as he is more commonly known, has experienced a chequered history as a Batman villain. Initially appearing as the mastermind behind Jeph Loeb and Jim Lee's excellent, mega-selling and aptly titled 'Hush' storyline in 2003, it seemed DC writers were unsure how to use the character in the years afterward. He appeared again in 2004 in the pages of the (now-defunct) Gotham Knights series, in the 'Payback' arc, written by A.J. Lieberman. This story went down like a lead balloon amongst fans, as it failed to really give much insight into the character at all, and instead the story is mostly remembered for the awesome Lee Bermejo painted covers. It took until 2008 for a writer to really grasp what made Hush so interesting, and Heart Of Hush was a breath of fresh air for readers who saw the untapped potential in the character. Written by Paul Dini, one of the brilliant minds behind many of Batman: The Animated Series' best episodes, the story delves deeply into Hush's backstory, bringing his motivations into clearer focus. We already knew that Hush was Bruce Wayne's childhood friend Tommy Elliott, from a fellow rich Gotham family, who hated Bruce because of his father Dr. Thomas Wayne, who saved the life of Tommy's mother after he had schemed to have his parent's killed. Dini then smartly expanded on the idea of Hush as a perverted mirror image of Bruce (he even performs plastic surgery on himself to look like Bruce, in order to steal his identity). More is revealed about his relationship with his enfeebled yet domineering mother and his resentment of how Bruce inherited his family's wealth and became free of the 'burden' of his parents. This psychological complexity is riveting, and coupled with Hush's cruel and calculating plans (he cuts out Catwoman's heart at one point in the story, keeping her on a life-support system supplied by Mr Freeze), contributes to a great, underrated Batman yarn. Well played, Mr Dini.

8. The Cult (1988)

The Cult is a pitch dark, brutal entry in the history of the Bat that has been largely forgotten due to several controversial elements of the story. Published in 1988 as a four-issue Prestige Format miniseries, similar to the format established by The Dark Knight returns two years earlier, The Cult puts readers off-balance from the beginning of the very first issue. We find out that Batman has been captured by self-proclaimed 'Messiah' Deacon Blackfire and his army of 'Underdwellers' (brainwashed homeless citizens of Gotham) and is in the process of being drugged, beaten and brainwashed into submission to the cult. It's an off-kilter and upsetting way to begin the story, which must have been the exact intention of writer Jim Starlin and artist Bernie Wrightson. Fans are used to seeing Batman as an infallible, unbeatable hero who always finds his way out of any situation, but much of this story features him in various states of crippling fear and disorientation, doped up to the eyeballs and experiencing distressing visions. Whenever Batman finds his way back to health and defeats Blackfire, the reader feels vindicated. This is a victory that feels earned, precisely because of the unexpectedly dire circumstances our hero is in at the beginning. The story was the source of much controversy due to Batman's use of guns, and there is no doubt that certain portions of the tale are uncomfortable to read as they just don't fit with our interpretation of the Bat. The image of Batman holding a machine gun (even if that gun fires tranquilizers instead of bullets) is a strange and off-putting one, as is the horrifying scene were a drugged Batman seemingly shoots and kills an innocent Gothamite. Even though it's easy to see what Starlin was aiming for, these elements probably should have been changed by DC editorial. Christopher Nolan was obviously heavily inspired by The Cult when making The Dark Knight Rises. The idea of a villain commanding a subterranean army of followers, successfully cutting Gotham off from the rest of the world and ruling with fear and mass killings, was used to great effect with Bane in the movie. Several panels even appeared to be lifted verbatim for the film, including the image of soldiers that had been sent in to help liberate the city being hung from a Gotham bridge in full view of the media.

7. Year Two (1987)

Year Two is another Batman story that might be more fondly remembered if it didn't so heavily feature our hero being forced to contemplate the use of guns. Batman and firearms are simply two things that just don't mix for most fans. Batman hates guns and would never use one. It's one of the most defining aspects of the character and generally stories move into troubling territory whenever they tackle this issue. However, Year Two presents a chilling narrative and builds a truly compelling rationale behind Batman taking up the way of the gun. In Year Two, Batman comes up against Gotham's first vigilante, The Reaper, who uses much more lethal methods in his war on crime (namely, a huge grim reaper style scythe and an arsenal of guns). Batman is summarily beaten by The Reaper and left close to death, and it is at this point that the young and relatively inexperienced Bruce believes he may have to play The Reaper at his own game. He retrieves the gun used to kill his parents and even teams up with members of the Gotham underworld, specifically Joe Chill (!) in order to kill The Reaper. Of course, in the end Batman decides not to kill either The Reaper or Chill, the man who killed Thomas and Martha Wayne, but even the notion that he came so far before pulling away is anathema to most fans. It appears that in the late 1980's, DC was experimenting and pushing Batman's boundaries more than ever before. Year One and The Dark Knight Returns pushed just far enough, as they were brutal but true to the character. The Cult and Year Two perhaps went over the line, and that is why they aren't heralded as much. But they are still interesting and important curiosities and to us, deserve to be read and discussed. An intriguing side-note is that The Reaper inspired the creation of The Phantasm in the acclaimed animated movie 'Mask Of The Phantasm', so it's clear that maybe writer Mike W. Barr was on to something special with that character and it just needed to be refined.

6. Born To Kill (2011)

Born To Kill, the story that launched the Batman and Robin title in DC's New 52 continuity in 2011, is a superb exploration of the relationship between Bruce Wayne and his son Damian, the ten year old badass raised to be a trained killer by the League of Assassins. Damian is a brilliant character, a boy raised by evil but with good in his heart, who ends up in an entirely different emotional place from where he started. Born To Kill details the teething problems that were experienced whenever he was in the midst of his early days as Robin. In previous stories that took place in pre-New 52 continuity, Damian had operated with Dick Grayson as Batman, because Bruce Wayne was thought to be dead at this point. This meant that Damian held an idealised view of his father in his head. Born To Kill deals with the difficulties Damian then has when trying to work with his father, a completely different personality to Dick, with whom Damian had forged such a strong partnership. The story features a new villain named Nobody, who is murdering criminals in Gotham and tries to convert Damian to this dark side, telling the boy that he was always meant to be a killer and not a hero. He is revealed to be Morgan Ducard, the son of Henri Ducard, a man who had trained Bruce Wayne in the past. Morgan resents Bruce for stealing his father's attention away and seeks to gain his revenge by subverting the ideals that Bruce had been trying to instil in Damian. Born To Kill, written by Peter Tomasi and drawn by Patrick Gleason, suffered upon release simply because it was published at the same time as Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo were defining Batman for the modern age with their Court Of Owls opus. We reckon it deserves to be more widely acknowledged in the pantheon of Batman's greatest hits.

5. The Man Who Laughs (2005)

Ed Brubaker is a writer known these days for his long runs on Marvel's Captain America (where he introduced the resurrected Bucky Barnes as the Winter Soldier) and Daredevil, as well as his creator owned material such as Criminal, Fatale and Incognito. However, in the early to mid-2000's he was a DC guy, working on a number of Batman related titles, including the flagship Batman comic and defining runs on Catwoman and Gotham Central. The Man Who Laughs is Brubaker and artist Doug Mahnke's retelling of the very first Joker story, a modernised version of Batman #1 from 1940. It serves as a neat companion piece to both The Killing Joke, Alan Moore and Brian Bolland's masterpiece from 1988, and also as a semi-sequel to Frank Miller's Year One. Brubaker and Mahnke present a horrific vision of The Joker, a homicidal clown who is somehow able to broadcast the names of his victims ahead of time, and even predict their exact times of death. The story presents Joker as a truly intellectual villain with an aptitude for chemistry that he uses to deadly effect. He delights in his game of challenging Batman and the GCPD with knowledge of his crimes and watching as they strive to stop him somehow. Brubaker knows that Joker is a top villain not because he can match Batman in a fight, but because they can engage in a battle of wits. Mahnke's artwork is astounding, lending the story of a sense of petrifying authenticity. We reckon his depiction of the Joker is one of the very best and he brings a frightening zeal to his pages of the disfigured victims of Joker's gas attacks.

4. Dead Reckoning (2003)

Speaking of Ed Brubaker, here he is again with a story that appeared in Detective Comics #777 - 782 in 2003. Dead Reckoning is a great little mystery, starring a number of the Rogues Gallery who are brought together by a mysterious new villain masterminding events from the shadows. Sound familiar? If you think this sounds at all similar to the plot structure of Hush, then you would indeed be correct. Ironically, Dead Reckoning was being published in Detective Comics at the very same time as Hush in the pages of the main Batman title. Unfortunately, this meant that the story was somewhat lost as everyone was swept up in the hoopla surrounding Hush, but we think it's time to heap some praise on it. A small time crook turns up dead wearing the costume of the little-known villain Killer Moth. The only clue left at the scene is a double-sided coin bearing scratches similar to the one used by everyone's favourite scarred former District Attorney, Two-Face. As the story develops, it becomes apparent that someone is targeting a selection of Batman's villains, including the Penguin, Riddler, Joker, Scarecrow, Mad Hatter and Killer Moth and Two-Face is central to this killer's motivations. The killer is revealed to be Paul Sloane, an actor with disturbing ties to the villains, who had impersonated Two-Face at one point. He is now known as the Charlatan, a master of disguise. It's sad that this story has mostly been forgotten, as it is a great read, with an intricate plot and fitting artwork from Tommy Castillo. Oddly, comparatively little of Brubaker's Batman material from this period has been re-printed in trade paperback format, including none of his Detective Comics run. It's well worth tracking down the single issues, however, or downloading the digital copies. We still hold out hope that Brubaker will revisit the character of the Charlatan at some point as well.

3. Death And The Maidens (2003)

Greg Rucka is a writer, similar to Ed Brubaker, who contributed vastly to the Batman universe in the early 2000's as scribe of Detective Comics. Together, they were responsible for brilliant stories like Officer Down and Bruce Wayne: Murderer? Rucka also gave the world some superb Ra's al Ghul tales, including Evolution (which is available as a trade paperback) and Death and the Maidens, which was billed as the LAST Ra's story. Of course, given that this is comics, and nobody ever stays dead except for Uncle Ben, Ra's made his return a few years later. But that doesn't lessen the impact of this story, which is at least one of the best Ra's stories, if not the last. Death and the Maidens is a nine-issue miniseries with artwork by comic book legend Klaus Janson (The Dark Knight Returns, Daredevil), and deals with a dying Ra's al Ghul who makes Batman a tantalising offer in exchange for the location of a life-preserving Lazarus Pit - the ability for Batman to speak with his dead parents! The series is intriguing because it reminds the reader that while Ra's is virtually immortal and has lived for centuries, it is only because of the Pits and in this story he is very much in danger of dying for the first time in hundreds of years. The idea of Batman being able to talk to the spirits of his parents is a writer's dream as well. Would they be proud of Bruce for dedicating his life to a war on crime? Or would they be sad that their son has held on to their deaths so much that he has never led a normal life? The story is also notable for introducing us to Nyssa Raatko, Ra's' second daughter and half-sister of Talia. One of the great benefits of any Ra's story is that it can be tied into real world history, and Death and the Maidens does this with aplomb, tying Nyssa's backstory into the Nazis and World War Two is fascinating ways. It becomes apparent that while Nyssa disagrees with her father in some ways, in other's she is very much her father's daughter, and her ultimate plan is just as extreme as anything Ra's would dream up.

2. The Black Mirror (2011)

Scott Snyder is already being hailed as one of the best Batman writers of all time, with his New 52 stories seemingly barrelling from one instant classic to the next. He is soon to start on a new arc named 'Endgame', the contents of which are so secret that DC have only revealed the title in their solicitations. We think that's pretty cool and, like most fans, are on-board for whatever Snyder comes up with. Some readers may think that the New 52 launch was Snyder's first Batman work, but that would be incorrect. He actually had his first crack at the Bat with this run on Detective Comics #871 to 881, which took the title right up to the start of the New 52 relaunch and it was the strength of these stories that convinced DC that he was the right man to then steer the main Batman title. The Black Mirror met with much critical acclaim upon it's release, so in a sense it could be said that it isn't really underrated, but we reckon that so much focus and praise has gone to The Court Of Owls and Death Of The Family etc that it is worth discussing this masterwork again. The series is notable for featuring Dick Grayson as Batman, thereby giving the story a grippingly different feel than if it had been a Bruce Wayne tale. The series tells two main stories, with the first being Dick going up against a new villain named The Dealer, who is selling stolen pieces of supervillain equipment at macabre auctions where all attendee's have to wear gas masks to protect their identities. The story running parallel to this involved Jim Gordon's son James, a character who hadn't appeared in DC continuity since he was a boy in Year One, returning to Gotham. James Jr is presented as a cold, emotionless man who many, including his sister Barbara, suspected of being a remorseless serial killer. Snyder weaves an intoxicating mystery, subtly laying down clues but holding off on a definitive explanation of James Jr's true nature until the very end of the story.

1. Strange Apparitions (1977)

The 1970's is seen as a decade of paramount importance for the Caped Crusader, with writer Denny O'Neill and artist Neal Adams' interpretation of the character generally being credited with rescuing Batman from 1960's camp and restoring him to the status as the dark creature of the night we know today. Their run included the creation of Ra's al Ghul and the classic Joker story 'The Joker's Five Way Revenge' in 1973. These stories are rightfully held up as definitive but could lead many to believe that the '70's was entirely O'Neill and Adams territory, which isn't true. In 1977, writer Steve Englehart began a run on Detective Comics that is also seen as the 'definitive' Batman. Teamed with artist Marshall Rogers for #471 - 476, Englehart delivered superior Batman stories featuring villains such as the Penguin, Deadshot, Hugo Strange and a new creation, crime boss Rupert Thorne and also one of Batman's most famous love interests, Silver St. Cloud. #475 also gave us the classic Joker story 'The Laughing Fish' and even though Englehart and Rogers were only teamed for six issues in total, their influence on Batman creators since far outweighs the small output of their run. Englehart actually wrote two other issues before Rogers joined him, and Rogers pencilled three more after Englehart left, but all of these stories have been collected as 'Strange Apparitions'. These stories are severely underrated, an indication of which is that the trade paperback has been out of print for a number of years, meaning that it now costs a pretty penny to buy a copy (let alone trying to track down the single issues). DC would never let Year One go out of print for example, and yet many observers credit Strange Apparitions with similar importance. It's influence is clear to see in the Batman animated series, which directly adapted The Laughing Fish for one episode, and featured Rupert Thorne as it's recurring crime boss, not Carmine Falcone from Year One. Englehart also asserts that Tim Burton's 1989 Batman movie owes a debt to his stories and says that he was brought in to write a treatment for the script whenever two other writers were floundering. Regardless of this, Strange Apparitions is clearly one of the most important, yet underrated, Batman stories ever. What other classic, yet forgotten, Batman stories have we left out? Sound off in the comments below!