10 Criminally Underrated Comic Book Runs EVERYONE Missed

Featuring the Batman comic every fan HAS to read...

By Ewan Paterson /

DC Comics

Despite annual prophesies that claim the comic book industry is teetering on a cliff-edge, it's still big business. Marvel and DC publish hundreds of titles ever year, and with the likes of Dark Horse, Image, IDW and countless other independent publishers releasing their own work too, comics fans really are spoiled for choice when it comes to choosing what to read.

Advertisement

The sheer selection on offer can bring both positives and negatives though. The sheer selection on offer is great, but sometimes the volume of high-quality, brilliant books can lead to other comics falling underneath the radar. They may still get all the plaudits, but often these books just get drowned out underneath all the other releases on a given Wednesday, while others debut to immense acclaim, only to be ignored in the years following.

But let's take a positive approach to the topic. For many readers, highlighting those runs that didn't necessarily get the attention they deserved the first time around presents an opportunity to check out something new, and with most of these stories collected in trade paperbacks or online, they're easily accessible too.

Advertisement

It might not be the case for every comic, but whatever the publisher, there's bound to be at least one book here you missed.

10. Uncanny X-Force - Rick Remender & Jerome Opeña

Marvel Comics

Prior to Marvel's efforts to expunge the X-Men from Marvel continuity and replace them with the... Inhumans (cheers for that, Ike Perlmutter), everywhere you looked, Marvel's Mutants were there. Come 2010, there were dozens of X-books on shelves, most of which featured Wolverine.

Advertisement

At the time, there was a general fatigue surrounding the character, and it was easy to see why. Logan was in multiple X-Men books, the Avengers, and even his own solo series. The Canadian Canucklehead was everywhere, which made the prospect of him leading the latest iteration of X-Force a somewhat frustrating one for readers.

However, come the release of Rick Remender and Jerome Opeña's Uncanny X-Force #1, it became clear fans were missing out on something special. The series was met with instant acclaim, with particular praise given to Opeña's work, but also to Remender's compelling script. The book itself revolved around the group (the X-Men's off-the-books counterpart), setting out to assassinate Apocalypse, who had recently been reborn in the body of a child.

Advertisement

This led to something of an ethical quandary, and one no one on the team really knew how to negotiate. Speaking of the group, the lineup of Wolverine, Psylocke, Fantomex, Archangel and Deadpool was perfect, with Remender able to provide a distinct voice for each member.

9. The Question (Various Titles) - Greg Rucka

DC Comics

Although an argument can be made that Dennis O'Neil, Denys Cowan and Rick Magyar's Question run from the eighties is a forgotten classic in its own right, it is fondly remembered despite its collections having gone out of print. Greg Rucka's Question, on the other hand, is still awaiting a similar appraisal.

Advertisement

Greg Rucka has been at the forefront of DC on and off again since the late nineties, and took a particular interest in the street-level heroes of Gotham City. He first wrote the Question (Vic Sage) in the equally underrated Batman/Huntress: Cry for Blood, before returning to the character all over again in 52, where he then killed him off. At this stage, though, Rucka had been busy developing the character of Renee Montoya, a GCPD detective first introduced in Batman: The Animated Series.

Montoya became a lead in Rucka and Brubaker's seminal Gotham Central, and from there, the writer pretty much became synonymous with the character. So, when Sage passed way in 52, the mantle then fell to Renee, but Rucka was only given a select couple of arcs to make the mantle hers.

Advertisement

Like the earlier Question series, Rucka's arcs (Five Books of Blood, Pipeline), are now out of print, but they're well worth tracking down, especially if you loved his work on Gotham Central.

8. Patsy Walker, A.K.A. Hellcat! - Kate Leth & Britney Williams

Marvel Comics

Most Marvel fans will probably recognise Hellcat from the now cancelled Jessica Jones series on Netflix, and though the character doesn't suit up in that show, Patsy Walker is a fully-fledged superhero in the comics.

Advertisement

She's long been a part of the street-level circuit in Marvel's version of the Big Apple, but few books have ever devoted time to fully explore the character. That changed in 2015, when Kate Leth, Britney Williams and Megan Williams penned a whole new series based on the hero, called Patsy Walker, A.K.A. Hellcat!

The book was cancelled after its seventeenth issue, and never quite generated the momentum some of Marvel's other books did at the time, but it was still fantastic, showcasing Walker reconciling with her childhood whilst living life in a city that is constantly on the move.

Advertisement

It boasted a gorgeous art style, a sharp script, and a cult following, but it wasn't enough to stop the series from concluding in its 17th issue two years on from its debut.

7. Ghostbusters - Erik Burnham & Dan Schoening

IDW Publishing

While fanboys despair at the state of Ghostbusters and the wider, maybe unsalvageable discourse surrounding it, they've only gone and missed the group's best period.

Advertisement

Atari developed what was effectively Ghostbusters 3 in 2009 with Ghostbusters: The Video Game, and though that game too is actually pretty underrated, it did spark a brief resurgence of the Ghostbusters IP. In 2011, IDW Publishing released a Ghostbusters comic of their own, written by Erik Burnham, and with art by Dan Schoening and Luis Antonio Delgado.

Burnham et al. have been involved with Ghostbusters for almost the entire decade now, and it's from that consistency that they've been able to fashion such a wonderful selection of stories.

Advertisement

All embody the films in their own way, but there's also a clear love for all aspects of the franchise. Burnham's writing bears the echo of The Real Ghostbusters cartoon series, and with later works having also incorporated elements from the 2016 reboot, it's plain and obvious to see that Ghostbusters can still be fun, if only people gave IDW's work a read.

6. Deathstroke - Christopher Priest & Carlo Pagulayan

DC Comics

There's no other way of putting this: Christopher Priest is a legend of the comics medium, and his work during DC Rebirth deserves twice the amount of attention it's actually received so far.

Advertisement

The writer is perhaps most famous for galvanising Black Panther in the late nineties and early 2000s, and though his work over at the House of Ideas has been formidable, it might be possible that he's been putting out his best work while at their competitors.

So far, throughout Rebirth, Priest has lent his talents to several books - Justice League, which he concluded in 2018 - Deathstroke (the topic of this entry), and the mini-series Deathstroke vs Batman. All have been met with acclaim, but maybe not the same attention some of DC's other titles have, which is a huge shame.

Advertisement

Deathstroke has always been one of DC's most iconic adversaries, but few stories have really delved into the character's backstory. Priest's work can then be considered something of a corrective measure, as it devotes the time to not only flesh out Slade Wilson, but to push the character into new and exciting territory.

As of the time of writing Deathstroke is still ongoing. Be sure to support while you still can!

Advertisement

5. Daredevil - Ed Brubaker & Michael Lark

Marvel Comics

Daredevil has more legendary runs than pretty much any Marvel character in existence, because, for some reason or another, the best in the biz just keep on coming back to him. Dennis O'Neil, Frank Miller, Ann Nocenti, Brian Bendis - these are just some of the names who have graced the book over the years, with the likes of Mark Waid and Charles Soule the most recent to contribute.

Advertisement

However, there's another run that tends to get overlooked by True Believers - Ed Brubaker and Michael Lark's - and it may be because of two factors. First off, Brian Bendis and Alex Maleev had only just wrapped up their stint on the book, and it was phenomenal; second, Brubaker was actually working his magic on Captain America at the same time, marshalling Steve Rogers in a run with Steve Epting that would later be considered as one of the character's best.

In this instance, there was an abundance of amazing works emerging from the House of Ideas, and because Bendis' run laid the groundwork for Brubaker's, many seem to forget that some of the best Daredevil stories of the 2000s came from the latter's hand, with The Devil in Cell-Block D kicking things off spectacularly in 2006.

Advertisement

Brubaker and Lark's run was still highly regarded, but it tends to get omitted from conversations surrounding the all-time great Daredevil runs, perhaps because it was sandwiched in between the aforementioned series and later Mark Waid's.

4. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles - Eastman, Waltz Et Al.

IDW Publishing

Given that it still surprises people to hear that the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles are actually comic book characters, it probably shouldn't be all that surprising that some of their best books are also somewhat overlooked.

Advertisement

Created by Kevin Eastman and Peter Laird, the Heroes in a Half Shell have been going strong since the mid-eighties, but their most enjoyable comic didn't arrive until 2011, courtesy of IDW.

The new book rebooted the Turtles and elected to tell a brand new story, one that revolved around the Turtles, their Master Splinter and Shredder being locked in an eternal reincarnated struggle throughout the ages. It was the perfect reimagining, masterminded by Eastman itself, and the book has remained IDW's most consistent, having released its 90th issue this January.

Advertisement

It's a great run, spearheaded by Eastman and other writers Tom Waltz and Bobby Curnow, and with a smorgasbord of artists by their side, including Dan Duncan. There are literally dozens of collections now based on this comic, but despite garnering praise and publicity upon its initial publication, Turtles hasn't been lauded in the same way since.

3. Jonah Hex - Jimmy Palmiotti & Justin Gray

DC Comics

Given Jimmy Palmiotti and Justin Gray were working on Jonah Hex for six years, it's actually bonkers to think that the run isn't held in the same regard as some of DC's best. Yes, western comics haven't been an exemplar of popularity for quite a while now, but the duo's stint on Hex was typified by quality, carving out a new role in DC's lineup for their infamous bounty hunter with the help of some legendary artists, including the late, wonderfully talented and adored Darwyn Cooke.

Advertisement

If there's any word that would describe Palmiotti and Gray's Hex, it would be cinematic. Their run speaks not just to the spaghetti westerns of the 1960s, but also to the revisionist westerns of the next decade, and it remains absorbing throughout. Add to that the introduction of Tallulah Black, a fellow bounty hunter who falls in love with Hex on their journeys together, and you have a western comic that is, in every sense, DC's most definitive.

Unfortunately, Palmiotti and Gray's series is difficult to come by physically. Trade paperbacks went out of print a while ago, and though it is online too, those after a physical collection may have to be patient.

Advertisement

In the meantime, readers curious to read Palmiotti and Gray's run can check out All-Star Western, where Hex ventured to 19th century Gotham City. Several pivotal Hex stories are also collected in the must-read Graphic Ink: The Comics Art of Darwyn Cooke, so venture there if your interest has been piqued.

2. Batman: Streets Of Gotham - Paul Dini, Dustin Nguyen & Derek Fridolfs

DC Comics/Dustin Nguyen

Every Batman fan has their own favourite Bat-era, whether it be Denny O'Neil and Neal Adams' run from the 1970s, the Legends of the Dark Knight era during the nineties, or even Snyder and Capullo's stint from the New 52 in some cases. However, one era that simply does not get enough praise is Grant Morrison's stint on the Dark Knight, which resulted in Batman: Reborn in 2011.

Advertisement

The Animal Man scribe's stint on the Dark Knight was somewhat divisive at the time, but its high-concept, innovative approach only worked to the character's benefit. Batman was killed in 2011's Final Crisis, leaving the rest of the Bat-Family to pick up the pieces, and for DC's writers to experiment with a whole new level of freedom.

Multiple books from the Reborn era could be considered underrated, with the likes of Bryan Q. Miller's Batgirl, Fabian Nicieza's Red Robin and even Snyder, Jock and Francavilla's Detective Comics all falling short of long-term praise, but perhaps the biggest victim is Streets of Gotham.

Advertisement

Paul Dini, Dustin Nguyen and Derek Fridolfs had already presided over a brilliant (if not brief) stint on Detective Comics with Private Casebook and Heart of Hush, and Streets of Gotham only continued that trend. Together, Dini et al. fashioned the best Hush story ever punt to print, but with Morrison busy at work doing amazing things on Batman & Robin - not to mention bringing Bruce Wayne back from the dead in the aptly titled Return of Bruce Wayne mini - it was almost inevitable that Streets would fall short of the attention it deserved.

Dini had already worked his magic on the Caped Crusader with BTAS, but his long-running series was phenomenal. Add to that a great backup strip in Manhunter written by Marc Andreyko, and Streets of Gotham lays a solid claim to being the most underrated Bat-series of all.

Advertisement

1. S.H.I.E.L.D. - Jonathan Hickman

Marvel Comics

Jonathan Hickman has been working his magic over at Marvel for years now, presiding over a barnstorming stint on Fantastic Four before applying his same talents to the Avengers, which culminated in 2013's Infinity, the storyline that inspired many of the elements seen in Avengers: Infinity War.

Advertisement

However, there's another of Hickman's books that many fans seem to have overlooked, and that is S.H.I.E.L.D. Published in 2010, and featuring art from Dustin Weaver and Christina Strain, S.H.I.E.L.D. was effectively a prequel that revolved around the adventures of Howard Stark and Nathaniel Richards, the fathers of Iron Man and Mister Fantastic respectively.

It's a truly beautiful book, one that blends history, science and magic together to create one of the best espionage stories in the Marvel library. It also provides valuable insight into the Earthly history of the Marvel Universe, and though it was a relatively brief run, clocking in at around 12 issues and a tie-in comic, it was one of the most unique series Marvel published that year.

Advertisement

Hickman is never short of praise when it comes to his work on Marvel, but one does get the sense that S.H.I.E.L.D's status as one of the writer's few overlooked works is a slight injustice. Definitely check it out if you get the chance.