10 DC Characters Who Discovered Batman's Secret Identity

The World’s Greatest Detective has the world’s worst kept secret.

By Zoë Miskelly /

Having a secret identity is maybe the most important part of being a superhero. While there are those who go without, the general rule is that in order to keep you and your loved ones safe, a secret identity is key.

Advertisement

For Batman, the importance of concealing his true identity is even greater than most. As Bruce Wayne is such a well-known celebrity in the DC universe, the potential for him to be blackmailed - or killed - by those who know about his night-time heroics is insanely high.

Perhaps more importantly, the fact that Bruce Wayne has adopted practically every sidekick he’s ever taken on means they are also put at risk should anyone uncover his secret.

This said, ironically one of the most popular reasons for someone to find out Batman’s secret identity is actually through his various wards, narrowly seconded by the fact that Bruce Wayne’s chin is apparently not that difficult to identify him by.

Regardless of the cause, seeing how different characters react to discovering the iconic superhero’s true identity makes for endlessly interesting comic material - as well as an endless crisis for the Caped Crusader.

10. Every Robin

As should come a surprise to precisely no-one, every individual Robin has deciphered the secret identity of their mentor at some point or another in their point as his sidekick.

Advertisement

What is interesting, however, is how different the ways in which each Robin ends up discovering about Bruce Wayne. For some like Damian, the process is pretty much hand fed to them - as Batman’s son is told by Talia Al Ghul of who exactly his father is, and his subsequent ‘birthright’ as his heir.

On the other end of the spectrum, however, we have Tim Drake - the third Robin - who works out the identities of both Bruce Wayne and the first Robin, Dick Grayson, by recognising an acrobatics move that Tim remembered Grayson doing in his time as a professional acrobat.

While the various Robins learning about their Batdad is never exactly shocking, the different ways they manage to are genuinely effective in showing the different skills, backgrounds and personalities each member possesses.

9. Lex Luthor

Pretty much any superhero who has a vaguely famous status in their civilian life has an astronomical chance of being found out by Lex Luthor.

Advertisement

For a man with such considerable ego, intellect, and almost unquenchable curiosity, collecting secret identities is likely to Luthor what collecting Pokemon cards is to us – only, you get the brooding face of Bruce Wayne instead of Pikachu.

After the Crime Syndicate kidnapped Nightwing and revealed him to be Dick Grayson in the Forever Evil series, the road was paved for Luthor to make the link that Nightwing’s incredibly concerned mentor was likely also his adopted father, Bruce Wayne.

Luthor eventually uses this knowledge to try and blackmail his way into the Justice League, which goes a pretty decent way to explain why Batman is so profoundly displeased when Luthor eventually joins the team.

8. Bane

As a muscle-bound human tank, it’s easy to presume that Bane wouldn’t be able to figure out Batman’s secret identity - as the criminal is often subject to being mischaracterised as not the smartest guy in the villain’s gallery. But Bane not only possesses an intellect that matches his considerable strength, but one key trait that so many supervillains lack: common sense.

Advertisement

In Knightfall, Bane learns Batman’s identity by doing something almost every comic fan with common sense has brought up in the past - looking at Wayne’s seemingly quite distinctive chiseled jawline, and realising it is exactly the same as that of the superhero.

With people going to semi-ridiculous lengths to decipher the identity of the Caped Crusader, it’s pleasingly simplistic to have someone just say ‘hey, doesn’t that guy look familiar?’ and then connect the dots from there.

7. All The Founding Teen Titans

When you keep in mind how closely the original Teen Titans team worked - and more importantly lived - together, the idea of any one of them being able to keep their real identity secret from the squad grows more and more unlikely.

Advertisement

This is exactly the case for the team’s Robin, Dick Grayson, who would naturally also out his mentor’s true identity to the team.

Short of outright exiling himself from social interaction with the Titans, there was no real way for Robin to hide his and by extension, Batman’s - true identity. Perhaps more importantly, it serves to show Grayson's commitment to the team, as he shows he doesn't just trust them to save his life, but to also keep his civilian life a secret.

However, having your secret identity ruined because your kid wanted his own superhero team has to be a pretty bitter pill for the Dark Knight to swallow - which may also explain his less than cheery encounters with the team itself.

6. Riddler

The matter of the Riddler knowing Batman’s secret identity is an often changing topic in the comics.

Advertisement

While Riddler is not consistently characterised as knowing Batman’s secret identity, he is perhaps the one supervillain most likely to learn exactly who the hero is. That said, it’s equally interesting to see someone so smart completely unable to work out the Dark Knight’s true identity, so it’s not the end of the world in the timelines where the Riddler is totally unaware.

Arguably the comic that created these fascinating concepts is Hush, wherein the hyper-intelligent supervillain puts his brain towards discovering Batman’s true identity – and hits upon the truth, taunting the detective with his discovery.

The comic was iconic enough that many more have taken after it, creating a truly interesting dynamic between the World’s Greatest Detective, and the man committed to outdoing him.

5. Deathstroke

Deathstroke is one of few villains who historically - and consistently - knows the identity of the Dark Knight.

Advertisement

This theme began as far back as 1992, wherein Slade shows up in the Batman comics at Wayne manor to ask the man for help. While the exact way Deathstroke uncovered the true face of the Bat, it’s a popular fan theory that he actually found out as a result of the earlier Teen Titans title The Judas Contract, where he learns the identity of Robin, and presumably uses this knowledge to uncover his mentor’s identity.

While the DCU has been retconned several times since this comic was published, Slade is still shown know Wayne’s secret identity as recently as after Rebirth, so it’s clear the assassin still knows exactly who is under the bat-shaped mask - although this time around, it’s entirely down to him noticing all the small details that don’t quite add up surrounding Bruce Wayne.

Of all the various people who know Batman’s secret identity, it’s almost definite that Deathstroke is the one who places the hero at the most risk.

4. Zatanna

In one of the more unconventional discoveries of Batman’s true identity, Zatanna’s initial reason for knowing about Bruce Wayne’s secret night life manages to be one of the best reasons to ever be retconned, as she is revealed to have been childhood friends with the hero.

Advertisement

Not only is it a reasonable way for the magician to have an inkling into his secret identity, it also serves to show us a more casual Batman – as Zatanna is one of presumably very, very few friends who know both of Wayne’s identities.

While this backstory was retconned for a more generalised ‘Batman told the superheroes closest to him’ explanation, this doesn’t overshadow the fascinating dynamic that comes from Batman having a childhood friend who knows his secret identity without also wanting to murder him for it.

3. Plastic Man

Of the entire DC superhero cast, the single last person you’d expect to be aware of Batman’s secret identity has to be Plastic Man - as the laidback jokester appears to be pretty dang far down on Batman’s ‘most trusted’ list.

Advertisement

However, in the 2001 Justice League America #50, this is exactly what Eel O’Brian is added onto. After the Justice League is left divided over the discovery that Batman had detailed plans on how to kill them all, the hero seeks to regain his team’s trust by revealing his secret identity to them.

While this did involve the whole ‘main team’ of the Justice League, the most surprising member for this reveal to happen to is without a doubt Plastic Man, who was arguably the member of the League that the Detective trusted least.

Although O’Brian’s relationship with Batman is never precisely smooth, this serves as proof that a level of respect passes between the two.

2. Silver St. Cloud

Batman’s love interests learning his secret identity is certainly nothing new. Between Talia Al Ghul, Catwoman, and even Wonder Woman in some continuities, it’s been proven time and time again that the best way of getting under the mask is by getting with the World’s Greatest Detective.

Advertisement

But, the redeeming factors in all these cases lies in the fact all these romances have been with either superheroes or supervillains - meaning that often, the case is that these women are trained in tracking people down and espionage, which means it’s inevitable they eventually uncover down Batman’s true identity.

In the case of Silver St. Cloud, however, this could not be further from the case. St. Cloud’s only superpower is that she is also a billionaire, and yet in pretty much every comic series where she meets Batman, she manages to uncover his true identity with an almost worrying speed.

Is Batman’s secret true nemesis the only woman in the known universe who can always spot him from a mile away? Only time will tell.

1. The Joker

Given that the whole point of a superhero having a secret identity is supposed to be so their enemies can’t track them down, it’s more than a little unusual that there are multiple comics wherein the Joker is canonically entirely aware that his archenemy is actually Bruce Wayne.

Advertisement

While these universes are definitely surprising, they’re also pretty logical. After all, aside from leaving a sneaky bomb in the Batcave, why would he care about the comparatively boring and pompous Wayne, when he finds his Batman alter ego all the more interesting?

For Joker, the real ‘fake’ identity is Bruce Wayne, and thus way less interesting to the Crown Prince of Crime.

As much as it’s exciting to watch a hero have to conceal their identity, it’s twice as interesting to see the ramifications of their main enemies being completely aware of who they are - especially with a character as unstable and unpredictable as the Joker.

Advertisement