10 DC Heroes With Surprisingly Tragic Origins

Soooo... about Mister Miracle...

By Ewan Paterson /

DC Comics/Mitch Gerads

Frustratingly, thanks in part to the mixed fortunes of the DC Extended Universe, most tend to consider the DC universe a decidedly darker place than Marvel's. While it's true there's an aesthetic and even tonal delineation between both publishers, both practice their fair share of dark storylines. It's never really been the case that one company strove to be 'edgier' than the other, and if there was, the closest example would probably be late-nineties-early-noughties Marvel.

Advertisement

Still, for all there's a general sense of parity when it comes to the mix of tones on display across either side of the Big Two's divide, DC's darker elements are certainly telegraphed more prominently. Their biggest mascot is Batman, and as far as origins go, they don't really get much darker than his - unless your name happens to be Frank Castle.

But while that may be the case, like Marvel, the DC universe is also home to some characters you wouldn't really expect to have emerged from tragic beginnings. Some were hidden beneath the surface, while other stories were there all along, and simply took a moment of reflection for readers to realise that yes, maybe a child raised by a torturous grannie-general would maybe have some issues as they grew older.

Advertisement

Either way, all of the following characters share common ground in that their personalities all belie a darker past, one DC are only just beginning to grapple with in some instances.

10. Cyborg

DC Comics

To those who were raised on the beloved Glen Murakami Teen Titans cartoon from 2003, the first image of Cyborg that'll come to mind will be him as an outspoken, tofu-loving genius who had a constant back-and-forth with fellow Titan Beast Boy. The years since have painted a much darker portrait of the character however, with Cyborg having made the leap from the Titans to the Justice League, and with it, a slight adjustment in personality.

Advertisement

Even before all of that though, Victor Stone had a tragic origin. Readers would probably be able to discern as much given Vic is half man, half machine, but it wasn't immediately telegraphed by his place on the Titans or by his friendly demeanour; no one could've possibly figured out from appearances alone that Vic fell into a bad crowd when he was young, or that in the same night his mother was killed by an inter-dimensional monster, that he himself would be brutally attacked by the same creature and that he would become half machine in order to survive the encounter.

Yeah... that's a lot to take in.

Advertisement

It's not as if Stone has had it easy since either. He's died multiple times, and creators have even saw fit to introduce the occasional bit of body horror into his comics too. Far from the tofu chowing funny guy from the show, right?

9. Plastic Man

DC Comics

DC have two stretchy guys in Elongated Man and Plastic Man, and while both have seen their fair share of trauma, it's the latter, Eel O'Brian, who's had the rougher deal.

Advertisement

Given the character's goofy costume and personality, that probably seems a little odd. After all, Plastic Man is the Justice League's premier jokester, and it's hard to picture anyone carrying a lot of weight on their shoulders willingly donning that jumpsuit-sunglasses combo to fight crime.

Only, in O'Brian's case, his tragic beginnings may actually be responsible for his lighthearted demeanour. You see, O'Brian was originally a criminal, and it was him getting double crossed by his associates that led to him encountering the chemicals that turned him all stretchy. Granted those are some pretty cool powers to have, but it's also worth bearing in mind that Eel nearly died during the whole affair, and that even before, he was made an orphan at ten-years-old.

Advertisement

It's a tough start no matter how you look at it, and we can only be thankful O'Brian turned into such a good hero after the cards he was dealt.

8. Vixen

DC Comics

Vixen is one of those DC characters that could make the company millions given the right attention - a fact her fans will no doubt reiterate - but it's that specific lack of attention that probably makes her tragic beginnings so elusive.

Advertisement

On the surface, Mari McCabe has the dream life. She's a model by day and a superhero by night, and she's even climbed DC's ranks to join the Justice League on occasion. However, her glamorous lifestyle wasn't just handed to her, and even then, that didn't mean Mari escaped tragedy for long.

McCabe was raised in the fictional African nation of Zambesi, which is where her powerful totem - the artefact that allows Mari to emulate the abilities of Earth's animals - originates. Her mother was tragically killed by poachers, and her subsequent adoptive father, a reverend by the name of Jiwe, was murdered by her uncle.

Advertisement

Not exactly the rosiest of childhoods, it must be said. But that wasn't even the end. By the time Mari had taken up her mantle as Vixen, her early crimefighting career saw her modelling job get caught in the crossfire of a drug smuggling ring, and led to Mari even joining the Suicide Squad to seek guidance for her powers.

7. Zatanna

DC Comics

Although the tragedy of Zatanna's origin isn't immediately apparent, it's something that rears its head the more you begin to contemplate the transformative effects of DC's many retcons - for better or for worse.

Advertisement

Originally, Zatanna became a superhero after following in her father's footsteps, the legendary magician known as Giovani Zatara. When her father goes missing, Zatanna combines her love for the mystic arts on the stage with her admiration for the Justice League, and goes on to become a key member in the years following.

Sadly, Zatanna's early years on the team were made more tragic thanks to subsequent retcons, seen in Identity Crisis and then the New 52. The former retconned her time on the League by revealing Zatanna willingly altered the personalities and memories of villains and heroes alike, and it proved to be doubly controversial.

Advertisement

Less controversial, but still maudlin, was the character's origin in the New 52. In this new continuity, it was revealed that her father Giovani was actually one of the founding members of the Cult of the Cold Flame, a sinister magical organisation devoted to raising an army of mystics. Giovani is then killed by Constantine, so again, it wasn't the brightest of starts for Zatanna in DC's new universe.

6. Captain Atom

DC Comics

As the inspiration for Watchmen's Doctor Manhattan it would probably be fair to suspect that Captain Atom has an equally tragic backstory. That said, it might even be fair to say that the Captain had it worse, with his military career actually being the thing that led him down the path of being a literal radioactive man.

Advertisement

Post-Crisis, and hot on the heels of DC's acquisition of Charlton Comics, the publisher reimagined Captain Atom as a Vietnam veteran who was framed for a crime he didn't commit. He's sentenced to death by a military tribune, but Nathaniel Adam is given an alternative. If he lets the military use him for an experiment with little to no chance of survival, he'll receive a full pardon. A no brainer, really, given a small chance of survival is better than none, but still - there's no getting away from the fact that the military have effectively abused Adam by this point.

The experiment that gives the Captain his powers basically involves the military detonating a nuclear warhead beneath a crashed alien ship with Adam inside. He dematerialises, only to emerge a near two-decades later as the glowing superhero fans now know.

Advertisement

Things got a lot worse before they could get better though. His old commanding officer, General Wade Eiling, decides to ignore the previous pardon and coerce the Captain into being a government sanctioned superhero. He's remained that way pretty much ever since, and with the knowledge of his origin in hand, you realise how tough the Captain really has it.

5. Mister Terrific

DC Comics

Mister Terrific, aka the third-smartest man on Earth, is one of DC's coolest characters. Yes his gadgets might seem goofy and the 'T' motif may have its detractors, but there's no denying Michael Holt is a fascinating character, and one with a fascinating mystery to match. He's been a part of the Justice Society of America, the spy organisation Checkmate and even on his own team in the Terrifics, which should all go some way in intimating just how important he is.

Advertisement

However, for all the success Holt's achieved throughout his superhero career, he didn't get off to the best of starts. His brother died at the age of twelve, and while Michael was able to bounce back and go onto share his intellect with the world whilst also starting a family, his wife and unborn child die from an accident. Holt, caught in a pit of despair, contemplates suicide.

Fortunately, Michael is paid a visit by the Spectre, who regales him in the tale of the original Mister Terrific. Holt then vows to honour the original Terrific's memory by becoming a superhero, and while he's been able to chart a new course after the deaths of his family, it's something he still carries with him every day.

Advertisement

4. Booster Gold

DC Comics

Booster Gold is a glory hunting time-traveller from the future desperate to win affection (and money) from those in the 21st Century. Gradually, over time, Booster comes to realise that there's more to being a hero than fame and riches, and it's one of the most gratifying characters arcs readers have had the pleasure of seeing develop over the last couple of decades.

Advertisement

Still, Booster's initial motivations for travelling back through time and getting rich come actually stem from his tough upbringing. Michael John Carter was raised in poverty in the future, courtesy of his father, who ran out on both him and his sister after losing all their money gambling. Still, Carter was able to turn things around, and became a star athlete with a scholarship. Things were going well... until his father returned.

Michael's dad managed to convince him to throw games on purpose so they could cash in on the winnings, and it cost him his career. This is what led him to travel back through time; to regain his reputation, and potentially enjoy some financial gain after years spent living in poverty.

Advertisement

So yes, while Carter eventually learned there was more to super-heroics than fame and glory, he can be forgiven for thinking as much given how hard his lot was to begin with.

3. Alan Scott

DC Comics/Gary Frank

Alan Scott was one of the original DC Comics heroes. A true legend of the Golden Age, Scott became the first Green Lantern and went on to play a key role in the precursor to the Justice League - the Justice Society of America.

Advertisement

Sadly, with time, Alan's spark began to fade. As the Silver Age came in the old fascination with mystical heroes started to wane, and so he was replaced by a newer, space-age Green Lantern called Hal Jordan. Scott's story was erased from DC continuity for years, until subsequent retcons brought the character back into the fold, and there alongside his fellow Lanterns.

Because Scott was so inextricably linked to DC's multiverse, however, the character's origin took on a tragedy of its own - one only placed into an in-universe context with the release of Doomsday Clock.

Advertisement

Geoff Johns and Gary Frank's series reveals how Doctor Manhattan was responsible for the New 52, and how it came from him killing Alan Scott and stopping the advent of the JSA.

2. Wonder Woman

DC Comics/Ray Dillon

Given no one does tragedy better than the Ancient Greeks, it might seem a little odd to place Wonder Woman on this list. After all, the character's darker elements are more prominently telegraphed these days, and there's an obvious tragic undercurrent to the idea of Diana being caught between two worlds - the Amazons', and Man's.

Advertisement

But again, not unlike Alan Scott, Diana's origin took on a decidedly more darker tinge during the New 52. In an incredibly controversial retcon, Brian Azzarello and Cliff Chiang made it so that, in order so that the Amazons could continue, they reproduced by raping sailors off the high seas, only to kill them and put any men born into slavery.

The series also retconned it so that Diana wasn't moulded out of clay, but was instead conceived by Zeus when he had an affair with her mother Hippolyta.

Advertisement

Needless to say, fans really didn't take to this origin, and it was thankfully retconned as a fabricated origin during the DC Rebirth.

1. Mister Miracle

DC Comics

Mister Miracle is potentially the most fascinating example on this list, because unlike all the other characters here, the tragedy of his origin was staring us in the face all along. Everyone just chose to ignore it - at least until 2016, when Tom King and Mitch Gerads came together to tell a new story about the character - one that tackled Scott Free's trauma head on.

Advertisement

Jack Kirby's Fourth World stands today as one of the most unique and exciting worlds ever created, and Mister Miracle embodies that from head to toe. The basic premise is that the leaders of two warring planets - New Genesis (a place that stands for all that's good), and Apokolips (a place that doesn't) - decide to trade their children to broker peace. Highfather sends his son to live with his counterpart on Apokolips, while Darkseid sends his child, Orion, to live with Highfather. So far, so good - but things take a tragic turn pretty quickly.

Once he finds his way to Apokolips, Scott is raised within the torturous confines of Granny Goodness' orphanage. He's tortured repeatedly, all day, all night, and only escapes after another victim of Granny's abuse, Big Barda, falls in love with him and both escape to Earth.

Advertisement

Scott would adopt a colourful costume as Mister Miracle, but it's almost a mask to hide just how horrible his upbringing was. His biological father didn't care what became of him on Apokolips, and, in a tragic example of what real life abuse can do to people, he still harbours some love for Granny.

Exploring that trauma is what made King and Gerads' comic such a hit over the year or so it spent on the shelves, and it goes to show how even the most exciting premises can bring dark consequences to the fore.

Advertisement