10 Greatest Superhero Replacements That Outshone The Originals
Sometimes, the original isn't always the best.
Mainstream comics books thrive on one thing: consistency. There's a reason why it takes superheroes so long to age. That is to preserve the status quo. Whether its Captain America hailing from World War II or Clark Kent wearing glasses, there are some things that are left unchanged. Companies do this in order for new readers to catch up easily. By always retaining the status quo, anyone can grab a comic and not feel lost.
But sometimes, change is good. Change can mean a breath of fresh air or can give new life to a comic series. This may be due to the comic being unpopular or the series hasn't made an impact as much as it was supposed to. Because of this, existing superheroes are revamped for new readers. This can also mean switching up a superhero team's roster.
These replacements can make a dent in the collective consciousness to the point that they can become more well known that the originals. There are characters who made their comic series their own and became the definitive versions of the title or the team.
10. The New Teen Titans - Teen Titans
The Teen Titans started out in the 1960s. Consisting of Robin, Aqualad, Kid Flash and Wonder Girl, they were a team of sidekicks. Despite attempts to reach out to youth culture, the series was cancelled by its 43rd issue.
Despite attempts at a revival during the 70s, the Teen Titans would find their stride through the duo of Marv Wolfman and George Perez. Called the New Teen Titans, the series added new members to the roster while keeping Robin, Kid Flash and Wonder Girl. New additions included Beast Boy from Doom Patrol as well as original characters, Cyborg, Starfire and Raven.
The series dealt with the teens and their conflict with their parents. These included Cyborg's estranged relationship with Silas Stone. Vic blamed his father for his accident and for turning him into the superhero. While they would reconcile, Victor Stone's arc ended with the death of his father. There was also Raven's conflict with her demonic father, Trigon the Terrible. By exploring these, the comic showed a more mature side than ever before. The series was also known for introducing Deathstroke to the DC Universe.
The additions of Cyborg, Raven, Starfire and Beast Boy served Teen Titans well. They would become permanent members of the team, appearing in animated shows as well as live action TV.
9. 2008 Guardians Of The Galaxy - Guardians Of The Galaxy
The original Guardians of the Galaxy was a far cry from the one modern-day readers may know. The team was created in the 60s and consisted of members Vance Astro, Charlie-27, Martinex and Yondu Udonta. They were active in the 31st century in an alternate version of the Marvel Universe. While attempts were made to revive the team throughout the years, these Guardians of the Galaxy did not reach the popularity levels of their fellow Marvel peers.
Enter, 2008. Dan Abnett and Andy Lanning formed a new version of the Guardians, one that would prove to be more popular than the original incarnation. This new team consisted of Star-Lord, Rocket Raccoon, Groot, Phylla-Vell, Gamora, Adam Warlock and Drax the Destroyer. Despite existing individually before, it was the first time these people banded together.
When it was time for the MCU to unleash the Guardians, director James Gunn used the 2008 team as the basis. 2014's Guardians of the Galaxy was a risk and yet became one of the MCU's biggest hits. What resulted from the film was a box office success and turned Star Lord and company into Marvel A-Listers.
8. Barbara Gordon - Batgirl
The inclusion of Batwoman and Batgirl in the Silver Age of Comics was due to Fredric Wertham. The psychologist's claims regarding Batman and Robin's relationship forced DC to add their female counterparts to ensure their image as heterosexual superheroes. But during the 60s, Batgirl and most of the Dark Knight's extended cast were phased out to simplify things.
The 60s also saw the success of the Batman TV show. Because it was a hit, the show's writers teamed up with Julius Schwartz to create a new character that would entice female audiences. The result was Barbara Gordon, daughter of Commissioner Gordon, who became the new Batgirl. With an iconic costume and an array of gadgets, Barbara proved to be a popular addition to the cast.
Gordon's impact on the industry would also extend after her tragic injury. Shot by the Joker in Alan Moore's The Killing Joke, Barbara was left paraplegic. Despite this, she became Oracle and remained one of Batman's trusted allies. While the original Batwoman and Batgirl fell into obscurity, Barbara Gordon has remained a series staple in the Batman mythology.
7. Green Hulk - The Incredible Hulk
The Incredible Hulk was created by Stan Lee and Jack Kirby in the 1960s. It was the story of Doctor Bruce Banner who underwent a metamorphosis. After saving young Rick Jones, the good doctor was blasted with gamma radiation. As the sun fell and the night began, Banner turned into the Hulk.
But things would change for the Hulk. For one, his skin was changed. Because of the printing problems with grey, he was then given a green complexion. The other was the cause of his transformation. The Avengers #3 would make it so that Banner transformed due to surges of fear and anger. Despite these changes, The Incredible Hulk would only last for six issues before the series' cancellation. But the character would remain a part of the Marvel Universe, guest starring in other titles such as The Avengers and The Fantastic Four.
Banner turning into the Hulk because of rage and stress would then become the norm for future issues with the character. At the same time, while his gray skin would return as well as other new personas, Banner's green color would become the iconic image of the character.
6. Tim Drake - Robin
Robin had always been a Batman staple. The original was Dick Grayson. A circus acrobat who lost his parents, he was taken in by Batman to be the first superhero sidekick. Years later, Grayson quit as Robin, feeling he outgrew the role. The next Robin was Jason Todd. He was a street kid caught stealing one of the Batmobile's wheels. His angry and brashness led to his death at the hands of the Joker.
But for Tim Drake, things were different. After noticing a change in Batman's behavior, he figured out that the Dark Knight was Bruce Wayne. He then sought the billionaire, claiming that Batman must have a Robin to keep him in line. While it took a lot of convincing, Batman agreed and Drake became the third Robin.
His time as Robin would prove to be a popular one which led to a solo series in the 1990s. His new costume was also well received, with a more practical feel and the first Robin to wear pants. While his predecessors were fine as Robin, they grew as characters outside the title. Dick became Nightwing and Jason became Red Hood. But with Tim, he was great already as Robin.
5. Carol Danvers - Captain Marvel
The first Captain Marvel was created in the Silver Age of Comics and was a man named Mar-Vell. He was a member of the Kree Empire and was sent to Earth. Sent to spy on the human race, he became a superhero to protect the earthlings. He then encountered a woman named Carol Danvers. Working for the US Air Force, she was caught in an explosion and sustained numerous injuries. Little did she know however, that the accident would change her life forever.
The explosion gave her powers and led to her becoming the superhero, Ms. Marvel. The transformation turned her into a Kree-Human hybrid. Her solo series was deemed socially progressive at the time and Danvers became a feminist icon. It was also noteworthy that she was one of the few female heroes in the Marvel Universe to have solo title.
In 2012, after the death of Mar-Vell, Carol assumed the title and became the new Captain Marvel. As one of the most powerful beings in the Marvel Universe, Carol Danvers overshadowed Mar-Vell's time as the superhero and launched the character into mainstream popularity.
4. Hal Jordan - Green Lantern
Green Lantern was created by Bill Finger during the Golden Age of Comics. Alan Scott was a railroad engineer who discovered a magic lantern. This object gave him abilities and turned him into the first Green Lantern. Because comic books were waning in popularity after World War II, the title was cancelled shortly thereafter.
Julius Schwartz, the man responsible for revamping numerous titles, then decided to revive Green Lantern. But the character would undergo a new identity, origin, costume and a new set of villains. This time around, the hero was pilot Hal Jordan. After discovering Abin Sur, the dying alien entrusted his ring to Jordan. This enabled Hal to become the Green Lantern. The series also introduced the Green Lantern Corps: a space police force that patrolled the galaxy.
The pilot's legacy as the Green Lantern would inspire and define future stories to come. While Alan Scott was the first, Hal Jordan is the best. While there would be more Lanterns - such as Guy Gardner, John Stewart, Kyle Rayner, Simon Baz and Jessica Cruz - they all wouldn't exist without the creation of Hal Jordan.
3. Johnny Storm - Human Torch
Appearing in Marvel Comics # 1, the original Human Torch was moulded in the vein of science fiction tales. An invention by Dr. Phineas Horton, the Torch was an android who had the ability to control flames. While initially a menace to the public, he soon became a hero and protected human beings. This Human Torch would also go up against Namor, the Sub-Mariner while encountering heroes such as Captain America and Bucky Barnes. Despite this, the character fell into obscurity in the 1950s.
In 1961, Stan Lee and Jack Kirby breathed new life into the character. Repurposing the character into their new team, The Fantastic Four, he was given a new identity. This new version was now teenager Johnny Storm. When he and his compatriots, Reed Richards, Ben Grimm and sister Sue Storm were exposed to cosmic rays, they all received powers. In Johnny's case, he had the ability to set himself on fire and throw flame projectiles. While he'd occasionally butt heads with Grimm, aka The Thing, Johnny became an invaluable member of the team.
While the original Human Torch was Marvel's first superhero, Johnny Storm and The Fantastic Four officially launched the Marvel Age of Superheroes. As Marvel's first family, their success led to other titles such as Spider-Man, The Avengers, The Mighty Thor and many more.
2. Barry Allen - The Flash
The Golden Age Flash was a man named Jay Garrick. After inhaling smoke vapours inside a laboratory, he gained to ability to run at superhuman speed. Sporting a metal helmet and a red shirt with a lightning symbol, Garrick became the titular superhero. But like many heroes mentioned here - such as Batgirl and Green Lantern - the Silver Age of Comics revamped The Flash.
Barry Allen was a forensic scientist. After being struck by lightning and bathed in chemicals, he received superhuman speed much like his predecessor. Inspired by a comic that detailed Jay Garrick's exploits, Barry became The Flash. Coming in with a new look, the Scarlet Speedster's popularity led to the numerous revivals of Golden Age characters. Without The Flash's success, characters such as Hal Jordan and the Justice League of America would not exist.
Allen's stint as The Flash also introduced a concept that changed comics forever: the multiverse. This meant that Jay Garrick existed in a parallel universe to Barry's. The story entitled 'Flash of Two Worlds' allowed two versions of the characters to co-exist and would spawn titles such as Crisis On Infinite Earths.
1. All New, All Different X-Men - X-Men
The original X-Men were five teenagers. Cyclops, Marvel Girl, Angel, Beast and Iceman, they were handpicked by Professor Xavier to represent Mutantkind's best. With their matching outfits and the school setting, these teens fought against villains such as Magento, the Vanisher, Juggernaut and more. Despite later introducing new members such as Havok and Polaris, the series would publish reprints during the first half of the 70s.
But in 1975, Len Wein and Dave Cockrum would bring a new and fresh take on the X-Men. Rather than teens, this team consisting of adults hailing from different countries. There was African Storm, Russian Colossus, German Nightcrawler and Native American Thunderbird. There were also previous X-Men villains Banshee and Sunfire who hailed from Ireland and Japan, respectively. Last but not the least, there was one-time Hulk villain, Wolverine, who would become the most recognizable member of the team.
While members would come and go, this iteration proved to be a success. The 2nd generation X-Men's success made them as popular as the likes of Spider-Man and The Fantastic Four. With more mature themes and a diverse cast, they saved the series from extinction. Their introduction also became the key to the X-Men's success: their ability to change. While other titles could get stagnant, the series' rotating cast members ensured the team would always feel fresh.