10 Insane Alternate Versions Of Superman You Won't Believe Exist

Elseworlds tales and crossovers with the multiverse full of weird, wonderful, and totally insane alternate versions of the Man of Steel.

By Tom Baker /

Ah, Superman. Boring old whitebread, big blue boy scout Superman. He's so uncool, right? Just...helping people. Being nice. It gets so tedious. Plus he has pretty much every superpower going, so you can never tell any interesting stories with him, cos you know he's never gonna get hurt or die (except for that one time where he did). We've grown a little complacent with the Man of Steel over the nearly eighty years of his existence. We want a bit of a change. The character and his origins have become such an ingrained part of modern culture that he's practically a modern myth. We know all about the doomed planet Krypton, his being sent to Earth, his double life as reporter Clark Kent, his being faster than a speeding bullet/more powerful than a locomotive/able to leap tall buildings in a single bound/having laser eyes. What if we could offer you something different, though? A Superman who wasn't raised to be an American good old boy, a Superman who decided to use his powers for evil, even a Superman who never became a superhero? Guess what, nerd: we totally can do that, because DC Comics have a treasure trove of imaginary stories, Elseworlds tales and crossovers with the multiverse full of weird, wonderful, and totally insane alternate versions of the Man of Steel which will blow your mind. Or at least question the decision making of the editorial teams.

10. Real-Life Superman

Superboy-Prime, who orchestrated the continuity-shredding Infinite Crisis, was supposed to be Clark Kent of our reality. As in, actual reality, where you're sitting and reading this right now. He was a big fan of the Superman comic books, and eventually broke through the multiverse to face him, going a bit wrong in the process. This wasn't the first time that a fanboy became Superman, though; Kurt Busiek and Stuart Immonen's Secret Identity from 2004 features a kid who gets named Clark Kent after the popular Superman comic book character, and hates his parents for it. Having to deal with endless teasing isn't easy for the real world Clark, retreating to a broken-down farm tractor he calls his Fortress of Solitude to escape from his tormentors. One night, after falling asleep beneath the tractor, he awakens to find himself floating in the air, and discovers he has all of Superman's powers. He gets a job at a big city paper and starts dating a woman called Lois whilst fighting crime as Superman. So it starts off weird and then...goes exactly the same as Superman. So remarkably sane in the end, but pretty weird before that, right?

9. Barack Obama Superman

Just so you know, that isn't us being totally racist by thinking that a black Superman must resembled the US President. Creator Grant Morrison has stated that Calvin Ellis, the Superman of Earth 23, is explicitly based on Barack Obama, though, so I think we're okay. That's still pretty weird, though, sticking the current president in a cameo role as a superhero in the epic Final Crisis crossover that saw the main Superman seeking the help of his analogues across the multiverse. Kalel's origins are almost identical to Kal-El of the main reality, except he is the Commander in Chief. There had been a black Superman before, but Calvin Ellis was the first one to get properly fleshed out, with his White House furnished with a Brainiac supercomputer that covers for the president when he's off doing superheroic shenanigans. It would actually make a lot of sense for America's greatest hero to be the president; it makes less sense having Barack Obama be Superman. Regardless, he'll soon be starring in Morrison's upcoming miniseries Multiversity, so expect to see more of this particular insanity.

8. High Councillor Superman

A surprise hit, the Injustice: Gods Among Us fighting game took place in a future dystopia with a dark backstory that was filled in by the tie-in comics. By the time of the videogame the world is a war-torn battleground, with Batman leading an insurgency against the insane and murderous Superman, who has decided to take over the planet whilst wearing a fun new costume and calling himself High Councillor Superman, like he's part of a British governmental cabinet or something. Now the idea of an evil Man of Steel isn't particularly novel - they're a dime a dozen in the DC Universe, which is why you won't see any of them on this list - but the way that he cracks in the Injustice comic books is remarkably insane. Deciding he's bored of toying with the Dark Knight, the Joker instead sets his sights on Superman, tricking him into killing Lois Lane (and the baby of Clark Kent's she was carrying) and dropping a nuclear bomb on Metropolis. He reacts in kind by snapping the Joker's neck when he's being put on trial. Pretty crazy for Superman to straight-up murder a supervillain by snapping his neck, huh. That would be out of character.

7. Bruce Wayne: Superman

If you're yelling at your scream that that picture is clearly Batman, not Superman, then firstly: use your indoor voice, and secondly: you're very perceptive, maybe you should be writing this article? In Superman: Speeding Bullets, the orphaned Kal-El is adopted by Thomas and Martha Wayne, who give him the name Bruce instead of Clark. Despite this fork in the road of classic DC continuity, the Wayne parents still fall foul to a mugger whose guns them down, only this time he then gets incinerated by young Bruce's heat vision. He feels vindicated that he wiped out his parents' murderer, but ashamed that his powers waited until they were beyond help to manifest, so he keeps them under wraps. That is until he grows up and finds it impossible to ignore the crime-ridden streets of Gotham City any longer, taking up the cowl and calling himself Batman! Except he's technically Superman. Just in a Batman costume. Speeding Bullets is pretty much just Clark Kent playing dress up, with some other weird twists like Lex Luthor falling into a vat of acid and getting some Joker-style facial scarring and insanity for his troubles. At the end of the story Lois Lane convinces Bruce that the Batman costume is a little dark, and it's only by adopting a friendlier, more colourful alter ego that he might drag Gotham out of its perennial darkness. So he becomes Superman after all, but that doesn't stop what came before from being totes insane.

6. Centaur Superman

In terms of insanity the Superman from Elseworlds miniseries Whom Gods Destroy should probably be at the top of this list, but he's almost too ridiculous to celebrate in anyway. You don't wanna give DC ideas when it comes to a follow-up. The bright idea of celebrated X-Men writer Chris Claremont, the story indulges in both Greek mythology and alternate history as the classical pantheon of gods meddle in human affairs to the degree that the Nazis win World War II and rule the world. Thanks a lot, Zeus. You big beardy jerk. That means you get the Third Reich version of Wonder Woman, which is insane enough as it is, but it's the version of Superman in this dystopian alternate reality which really takes the biscuit. Or oats. Because he is a centaur. Well, at the end he's a blonde woman, after crossing a bunch of literal trolls and harpies, but then he gets cursed by a witch and becomes half-Superman, half-horse, and lives amongst a harem of centaur ladies. And he's evil. It's only after Lana Lang whips out a bridle and rides him like a pony that he returns to normal, just in time for the Nazis to be defeated and for him, Lana and Wonder Woman to live happily ever after on the moon.

5. Harvey Dent, Superman

Tangent Comics was a whole line of alternate reality stories told in the DC Universe, with strange new takes on everyone from The Flash to the Secret Six. Inspired by Franz Kafka's The Metamorphosis, a nightmarish short story about a normal man who wakes up one morning to find himself slowly transforming into a beetle, the Tangent Universe's Superman was a regular guy who gets touched by a "god force" and finds his brain rapidly evolving so that he reaches a higher plane of existence. Or something. Also the guy is called Harvey Dent, but he isn't Two Face. Having introduced the character and his powerful telekinetic abilities in the original one-shot, the Superman of Earth-9 reappeared in the miniseries Tangent: Superman's Reign, where he ruled his alternate reality using his crazy powers whilst wearing what looks like a bathrobe. He eventually ended up fighting heroes from the main DC Universe and gets knocked out by the regular Superman, which was disappointing for everyone, because then he got arrested and wasn't allowed to wear his dressing gown any more.

4. Communist Superman

Mark Millar's Red Son did the unthinkable, turning the epitome of truth, justice and the American way into an icon for Soviet Russia who is "the Champion of the common worker who fights a never-ending battle for Stalin, socialism, and the international expansion of the Warsaw Pact", owing to his coming to Earth and touching down in a Ukrainian collective farm instead of simple, rural Kansas. Of course, instead of his classic S-shield he has a hammer and sickle, because Mark Millar is nothing if not subtle. Inspired by a silver age "imaginary story" where Supes lands in international waters between the USA and the USSR, both of whom rush to take control of the child, Red Son depicts a Superman who is both a propaganda tool and powerful weapon for Stalin, eventually taking control of the Communist Party himself and going to war with America's greatest champion, Lex Luthor. Along with featuring an insane Commie version of Superman, there's also a Russian Batman who wears one of those big furry hats, which is fun.

3. British Superman

A large number of the Superman Elseworlds tales are predicated on baby Clark Kent, having escaped the exploding Planet Krypton, crash-landing somewhere other than the Smallville field where Ma and Pa Kent find him and raise him to be good, virtuous and polite. And a superhero. That's true too of True Brit, where Kal-El finds himself in Weston-super-Mare, and co-writer John Cleese revels in making an absolute mockery of his home country through the lens of the Man of Steel. Named Colin Clark - his adoptive parents' corruption of Kal-El - the young superhero is raised with the stiff upper lip and "what would the neighbours think?" mindset of a stereotypical young Englishman, which means that he keeps his amazing powers under wraps so as not to draw attention to himself or cause any trouble. It's only after becoming a writer for an awful tabloid newspaper and saving The Rutles (a Beatles parody whose films and albums featured various Monty Python members) whilst pursuing a muck-racking story that he adopts the Superman identity, which of course includes a bombastic Union Jack over his costume. Pretty goofy.

2. Tarzan Superman

Superman and Tarzan teamed up for a straight adventure in the 30s set Claws Of The Cat-Woman, which was fun, but Sons Of The Jungle provided a really weird twist on both characters' origins. Instead of landing in Kansas, baby Supes ends up in the jungle where he is raised by gorillas, whileas Tarzan is never lost by his clumsy parents and grows up to be a bit of a posh English ponce called Lord Greystoke. Greystoke has an adventurous streak, though, and on an expedition to the rainforest he stumbles across a super-powered chap in a loincloth who has painted a big S on his chest for some reason. It all goes a bit Jungle 2 Jungle at the end when Greystoke decides he actually quite likes the simple life of hanging out with gorillas and eating ants, whilst the primitive Superman abdicates his throne as Lord of the Jungle and makes a move to the big city, where he'll start wearing slightly less revealing clothes than he did in West Africa. There's some adventure involving a lost city full of treasure and monsters where the characters have to team up to prevail, but it's the sight of Superman as an idiotic muscle man raised by monkeys that's just...weird.

1. Amish Superman

The whole premise of Elseworlds tale JLA: The Nail spawns from one small change in DC history that has a huge effect on the universe, as Ma and Pa Kent's truck suffers a burst tire from the titular nail, meaning they never discover and raise the baby they were supposed to stumble across in a crashed spaceship. Instead of becoming Clark Kent and, later, Superman, the baby is found by an Amish couple and grows up...well, Amish, completely cut off from modern society. So instead of becoming humanity's greatest champion, nobody knows that the Man of Steel even exists. As a result of this the Justice League is a rag-tag band of heroes who bicker all the time without their courageous leader, and face being ostracised by a populace who have been whipped into an anti-superhero frenzy by Daily Planet editor Perry White. Everything gets worse from there, as mayor Lex Luthor teams up with bitter, crippled ex-hero Green Arrow to take down a team they assume are alien invaders, Luthor grafting Kryptonian DNA he found in Kal-El's empty spaceship to Jimmy Olsen, creating a Bizarro Superman clone with all of his powers. Eventually evil Olsen's battle with the Justice League stumbles into an Amish community near Metropolis, where he is stopped from killing Batman by...Kal-El, who sadly doesn't have one of those cool chin-strap beards that his male elders sport, but is wearing a straw hat and old-timey clothing in place of his blue-and-red tights. It turns out he still has all his Superman powers, he's just lived a life shunning modern society and tending fields instead of saving lives. Which is hilarious and also a bit selfish. We would've loved to see Superman's Rumspringa.