10 INSANE Times Superman Beat Batman

Sometimes all the planning and preparation that Batman does isn't enough to win against Superman.

By John Wilson /

It is a well-known comic trope that, with enough planning and preparation, Batman can beat Superman in a physical confrontation. But conventional wisdom and common sense explain that Superman is just a step below an actual god and Batman is only a human being with a belt full of gadgets, and any fight between them ends in one way - with Bruce in a hospital bed!

Advertisement

The fights between the two heroes rarely begin organically. They usually happen when Superman has been compromised in some way. He is either taken over by magic, some form of Kryptonite, or is under the thrall of a villain, and it is up to Batman to bring the Man of Steel back to his senses. This often involves Bruce hitting Clark in the head repeatedly until he snaps out of it. Less often, it is the Dark Knight doing something illegal or something potentially deadly that causes the Metropolis Marvel to go after his dark Gotham counterpart.

Because Batman often winning in a fight against Superman was such an old and overused troupe, there are those writers who will go against the grain and write a story where it is Bruce that is on the losing end of the battle instead of Clark.

The reasons for these vary and they may only be part one of a longer engagement, but instead of giving readers what they have come to expect from these fights, the writers give them the outcome that logically makes sense.

10. Superman: Red Son

Superman: Red Son imagined a world where the baby Kal-El landed on a Ukrainian farming collective instead of Kansas and became a hero of Mother Russia and its eventual leader. His influence spread until only Chile and the fractured United States remained free from his control. The brilliant American scientist Lex Luthor opposed him.

Advertisement

In the “Ascendant” part of the three-issue miniseries, Batman was the head of an anarchist terrorist network in Russia who saw all the prosperity and abundance that Superman had forced on his country as oppression. He joined forces with Luthor and the head of the KGB to stage a coup. Capturing Wonder Woman as bait and tying her with her own Lasso, the Soviet Bat lured Comrade Superman to an abandoned base outside Siberia and engaged a battery of red sun lights that robbed Kal of his powers. Batman began beating him mercilessly, with Superman only getting a hit with a 2 x 4 in when he caught Comrade Dark Knight monologuing. Batman knocked Superman down and threw him into a bunker.

Knowing she could hear him, Superman told Diana that she was his only hope even though he knew it would hurt. Wonder Woman broke the magic Lasso and destroyed the red sun generator. Superman burst out of the bunker and confronted Batman.

The Caped Crusader flipped a switch that exploded the bomb in his chest, preferring to die a martyr than to live as yet another Superman “robot”. Sadly, something also “broke” in Wonder Woman as a result of destroying the Magic Lasso, as it turned her hair white and altered her mind.

9. Batman #612

In part five of the “Hush” storyline called “The Battle”, Poison Ivy had once again gotten control of Superman, and this time, she had laced the potion with Kryptonite and she had no intention of letting go. Batman and Catwoman escaped to the sewers and separated as Bruce put on the Kryptonite ring. Clark smashed through the wall and Bruce immediately started delivering a series of blows with the ring, slowly weakening Kal.

Advertisement

Batman made Superman follow him outside and directed his attention to a nearby skyscraper where Catwoman was holding Lois Lane. Selina pushed the reporter off and the shock of seeing Lois in danger broke Ivy’s control, just as Bruce had planned. He knew that Cat could have saved Lane if necessary but thankfully it wasn’t. A grateful Man of Steel was unable to tell the Dark Knight Detective where Ivy was but a leaf and the keen nose of Krypto revealed the villain's location.

On this surface, this may seem like a Batman “win” until you realize that Superman was somehow still in some control because he was not hitting Bruce with anywhere close to his full power when they were fighting, And also, Superman broke Ivy’s control on his own. The Bat and the Cat may have set up the circumstances but it was Clark’s willpower and his love for Lois that allowed him to break free.

8. Injustice: Gods Among Us #35

The Joker had tricked Superman into believing that he was being attacked by Doomsday, and when Kal-El flew the monster into space, he found that it was actually his wife, Lois Lane, and that he had killed her. Worse yet, she was pregnant with their first child and Joker had attached a “deadman’s switch” to her heart that caused a bomb to go off beneath the Daily Planet that devastated Metropolis, killing thousands. Superman put his fist through the Clown’s heart and then decided to end evil throughout the world by taking over the planet. Sides were chosen, friends were killed and Superman made good on his word.

Advertisement

Batman got one of the “Super Pills” that gave normal people powers and took it back to the Batcave to analyse and hopefully synthesize more of them after telling the remaining Insurgents to hide. As the computer started an analysis, Superman arrived. To distract the Man of Steel, the Dark Knight tried to play on his guilt about killing Green Arrow earlier that day. He then played a video of Clark and Lois’ wedding.

Bruce asked Clark if he believed that he was truly honoring Lois and Metropolis’ deaths by taking over the world. Superman angrily said that he was done being lectured. So, Batman fired a sonic cannon at Supes, sending him reeling. Bruce grabbed the pill but Clark recovered and told Bruce that he would not kill him but he couldn’t have him meddling in his plans and broke the Dark Knight’s back over his invulnerable knee.

7. Adventures Of Superman #642

In part three of the “Superman: Sacrifice” storyline, Superman was standing over the bloody, battered, and bruised body of a Batman who was currently undergoing his third session of Purple Healing Ray treatment from Wonder Woman. And despite not remembering beating his friend nearly to death, his fingerprints on Bruce’s skin and bruises made it impossible to deny.

Advertisement

Martian Manhunter sifted through the damaged computers and found footage, and Superman - along with a tense Hawkman, Black Canary, Flash, John Stewart, and Wonder Woman - watched as a seemingly disoriented but determined Man of Steel launched an unprovoked attack on the Dark Knight. Only engaging the satellite's internal defenses saved Bruce’s life. A deep mental scan by J’onn found that Maxwell Lord was the culprit behind Superman’s mental possession, and there was no immediate way to undo it.

Batman requested that Diana “get him the hell out of here” and she teleported with him to the Batcave, then she returned. A plan was made to lock Kal-El in a teleport loop until a solution could be found, but Supes believed it was they who were possessed by Lord and quickly incapacitated them and burst out of the satellite, heading for Switzerland.

Diana was the only one in any shape to follow, and she revealed to The Flash that Bruce gave her the Kryptonite that he keeps in the Cave. She teleported to Switzerland to find Superman and confront Lord. Unfortunately, she found both. Lord commanded Superman to make Diana bow before the King.

6. Justice League: Origins #2

In the second issue of the “Origins” story arc, Batman and Green Lantern traveled to Metropolis having just met each other moments ago in Gotham. The Dark Knight continued his initial complaint that Hal was too bright and attracted too much attention. Lantern encased Bruce in a construct cage as Superman arrived, saying to let him handle this. Supes smacked Jordan through the cage and a couple of parked cars. As Batman rose up, Clark asked, “What can you do?”

Advertisement

When we returned to the fight, Superman remarked that Barman has emptied his entire utility belt against him to no avail, as the Boy Scout slammed Bruce into a wall and began asking him what he knew about the mysterious boxes. Green Lantern regained consciousness and rejoined the fight, first trying to capture Superman in chains, which he thought was ludicrous, and a shield to protect himself and Batman.

The Flash had also reluctantly joined the fight, at the request of Green Lantern. Batman finally stopped the battle, explaining that they knew nothing about the Parademons and that they only came to Superman because Bruce believed that, as an alien, he might have some insight in the boxes. The quartet had to hide in the sewers when government agents descend on their location before they could finish their conversation. Elsewhere, the boxes began acting strangely.

5. Lex Luthor: Man Of Steel

In this villain-centric miniseries, Lex Luthor needed something to increase the cognitive functions of Hope, a young woman in stasis under the care of his scientists. Bruce Wayne had it and Lex believed he could use their mutual distrust of Superman to get what he needed.

Advertisement

One of Wayne’s companies had come up with an Alzheimer’s cure that Luthor needed, and Lex gave Bruce a piece of Kryptonite while explaining that the public had only Superman’s word that he won’t harm them. That evening, in his Batman identity, Wayne was looking at the Kryptonite when Supes arrived and blew it out of his hand before the pair had a brief fight that Batman lost badly. Superman was about to knock Bats out when he noticed a lead-lined compartment on the Dark Knight’s utility belt with his x-ray vision. Clark crushed it and Bruce gave Lex the research.

Lex used the research to turn Hope into his own private superhero that he controlled. When his henchmen, the Toyman, double-crossed him and killed children and his lead scientist, Luthor sent Hope after him. Using an actual control unit, he forced her to drop Schott, who Superman saved seconds before he hit the ground.

It turned out that Hope was an android and Lex caused her, and the facility where she was created to explode, attempting to make it appear that Superman had killed her.

4. Superman/Batman #23

In Part Four of the “With a Vengeance” storyline, Bizarro and Batzarro have made a complete mess of things. By misusing the teleporters on the Watchtower, they have ended up in alternate realities. Batzarro found himself on Earth-30 where he failed to make himself understood by the Red Son Superman. Bizarro was having similar bad luck with Terry McGinnis on Earth-12.

Advertisement

On the Earth of the Maximums, the Kryptonite Man possessed the New Earth Batman and attacked the New Earth Superman, our main protagonists, and the pair fought briefly while the Maximums argued what to do with them. The possessed Batman seemed to have the upper hand but Clark had a plan. Using a specific strike at a pressure point just below his ribcage, half of Krypto-Bats body went useless on him.

During the fight, Superman was talking to the Maximum’s mechanical member, Robot, who realized that Clark wasn’t the villain here. They used his exoskeleton to encase Bruce’s body and drove the Kryptonite Man from his body. The Maximums arrived to apprehend Superman, but so do Bizarro and Batzarro. The mixed-up pair tried to rescue their idols and boom tube back to New Earth but it went awry almost immediately - with only three getting away as Viking cut Batzarro’s chain and he fell to the floor in front of the Maximums.

3. Batman: The Dark Knight Vol. 2 #5

Batman was in Scarecrow’s clutches, who had his fear toxin coursing through the Dark Knight’s brain. Crane tried to chip away at Bruce’s heroism and told him that he was hollow inside and would never be able to save everyone, no matter how hard he tried. The Bat’s private fears and feelings were also working against him, especially the unresolved feelings of guilt that he should have done something to save his parents.

Advertisement

Through sheer force of will, Batman continued to fight the effects of the toxin and Scarecrow took another tact. He injected a drug that removed fear into the Bat’s bloodstream and then hid. Superman arrived to find Bruce kneeling on the ground, mumbling. As Clark reached down to help him up, the Dark Knight punched him through a wall.

Ranting about Kal-El’s alien nature, the crazed Caped Crusader continued to pummel the Man of Steel, who was screaming to his friend to fight the toxin's effects. Superman was forced to stop holding back and deliver a devastating blow to Batman. The unconscious Dark Knight collapsed to the ground.

Thankfully, adrenaline burned the toxins out and saved Bruce’s life.

2. Superman/Batman #33

At the conclusion of the “Enemies Among Us” storyline, most of the Justice League and a large number of the population had fallen under the influence of the alien Black Rock, including Batman. And the rock gave him the power to take the fight against Superman as his physical equal.

Advertisement

The pair traded blow after devastating blow as Batman talked about how the aliens saw humanity as greedy, petty, and weak, and Superman countered with that may be true of some but not all - and definitely not Batman. Clark remembered something Bruce told him earlier and he used his heat vision to ignite a gas tank, engulfing them both in an explosion. Kal-El said that he remembered that it may be able to scare the alien influence from the Bat’s body.

The still possessed Batman said the aliens knew of his morality and that he would never kill again. Superman grabbed the Dark Knight by the neck and began punching him, saying that he knows his friend and he knows that he would rather die than live like this, so he will free him or give him peace. With a bloody face and a cracked cowl, Bruce finally indicated that he was himself and the aliens have left him.

1. Batman Vol 3 #42

Through her connection to the Green and the plants that everyone ingests, Poison Ivy controlled every person on the planet, except Batman and Catwoman. Thanks to some incredibly fast thinking, Bruce created an antidote for himself and Selina. But Ivy claimed that she doesn’t care, because she has the rest of the world and they aren’t a threat to her anymore. Despite this fact, Superman constantly hovered over Wayne Manor.

Advertisement

Bat and Cat left the mansion, went out for a burger, and then went to a house where both Flashes and Kid Flash arrived. They are quickly dispatched by Selina, and Bruce disabled Clark with a loud whistle. The person Batman was looking for wasn’t there, and we next see the couple hanging upside down from a skyscraper with Superman, Wonder Woman, and Green Lantern Jessica Cruz hovering nearby.

Batman mocked Ivy’s utopia as she talked through Superman, and he inquired about a boy who was deathly allergic to greens and thus couldn’t be controlled by her. He asked where he was hanging. Ivy got more and more agitated and she screamed for Batman to shut up. He said “No” and Superman hit him in the head so hard that he killed Batman. Ivy brought him back, claiming there is a person worth everything to Catwoman. Bruce deduced the only person who could tend to a person with massive brain trauma was Dr. Harleen Quinzel, aka Harley Quinn, who was also mind-controlled by Ivy.

Advertisement