10 Marvel Heroes With Surprisingly Tragic Origins

Man, the Pet Avengers are dark.

By Zoë Miskelly /

By rule of thumb, comics usually are quite transparent with which characters are going to get a dark backstory. Brooding, all-black wearing anti-hero? Probably going to have a rough time. The cheerful comic relief character? A wholesome, spotless upbringing.

Advertisement

But this isn't always the case. Often, some of the darkest backstories come from characters you wouldn't expect to have them, either for shock value, or as a handy reminder that not everyone with a sad origin story has to don a black leather trenchcoat.

And although it might seem jarring to have Frog Thor or Goldballs have heartbreaking moments in their storylines, it's also absolutely crucial, as it removes the predictability of comics that can make them seem so formulaic. Allowing characters to not be permanently soured by their history allows them to feel more like real people, who are nine times out of ten capable of overcoming bad experiences without it giving them a goth phase.

Although you wouldn't expect that maggots, children, and small kind aliens would all have backstories that could make Batman shudder, it's also darkly delightful to know that Gotham's protector doesn't have a complete monopoly on tragic origin stories.

10. Goldballs

Continuing a concerning trend of joke characters being given inordinately tragic backstories, Goldballs discovered his powers in the middle of someone trying to rob him. The whole thing looks exceedingly traumatic, not helped by the fact that after Fabio stops shooting balls, the police come to arrest him, having presumed that the young mutant is attempting to assault everyone he's hit with the golden orbs.

Advertisement

If you can't feel sorry for a screaming teen uncontrollably shooting magical eggs from himself, then there's likely few people you can feel sorry for, as Fabio's discovery of his powers literally couldn't get any worse if he tried.

The event showcases how even seemingly innocuous powers can be used in distressing ways, which is a solid reminder of why the X-Men are so important - because if Goldballs can cause a scene, so can literally anyone with powers.

9. Demolition Man

Given he's a knockoff Wolverine with the nickname 'D-Man', you'd be forgiven for thinking that Demolition Man would, backstory-wise, have minimal depth.

Advertisement

However, his origins are surprisingly bittersweet, with the young Dennis Dunphy wanting nothing more than to be a superhero. As he grew up, however, Dennis' dreams changed, and he decided instead to become a professional athlete - dreams which would be dashed when every sports team he applied to rejected him.

Devastated, Dunphy sought out enhanced strength and speed from the villain known as the Power Broker in order to improve his abilities. In an ironic twist, gaining these enhancements meant that the would-be sportsman was too powerful to play any spot without harming those around him, and so the Demolition Man was born.

While Dunphy never seems put out about becoming a superhero, there's something incredibly sad about the fact that, by the time he became a hero, Dennis didn't actually want to be one - even if he doesn't seem too upset about it.

8. Skin

Mixing the world's creepiest superpower and the world's saddest backstory into one huge mess, Skin started out life as Angel Espinosa, a young man dating a gang member named Tores. After Tores turned a night drive into a drive-by shooting, the stress of this event would kickstart Angel's dormant powers; turning him grey, giving him the ability to stretch his skin out several feet, and knocking him out cold.

Advertisement

This was surprising enough to Tores that she crashed the car, leaving Angel to regain consciousness in a car wreck, with his girlfriend nowhere to be found having presumably fled the scene - and her friend dead in the burning remains.

Fearing how his family would react to his unnerving mutation - and knowing that Tores would likely face murder charges for the car accident were a witness to be alive - Espinosa left town, joining the X-Men in hopes of learning how to control his powers.

7. U.S Agent

Initially just a cheap rip-off of Captain America, the U.S Agent - known perhaps better as John Walker - would develop over time into his own character, with the only remaining similarity between the two being their tragic backstories.

Advertisement

John's combat training comes from his time in the forces, which he joined in honour of his brother, Michael, who had died in the Vietnam war. Disillusioned with the life of a soldier, Walker would attempt to become a superhero, which would see his parents killed by villains and him beat up by Captain America, in a beautifully awful chain of dominoes.

While the U.S Agent's life would never become easier - down the road he would end up losing an arm and leg in a fight against the Thunderbolt's leader, Nuke - Walker would steadily become kinder and less quick to anger over time, providing a surprisingly unique character arc for a hero who started off as a total copy of another.

6. Broo

Being hated by your entire species for caring about people sounds like the worst time possible. This being your life for your entire upbringing sounds even worse, which means it's safe to say that Broo - a Broodling who was hated by his kind for wanting things like friendship and compassion - has one of the sadder backstories of the Marvel universe.

Advertisement

Worse yet, the only reason Broo wasn't immediately killed in the first place is because the Broodling population was at an unusual low, meaning that the Brood Queen decided to leave the tiny alien alive until their species was once more abundant, which is maybe the saddest reason to not be killed ever,

Mercifully, Broo is rescued by the X-Men and brought home to the Jean Grey School for Higher Learning, where he could live out his life amongst people who valued him for his kind and caring nature, instead of hating him.

5. Maggott

Perhaps the most underrated X-Men ever, Maggott's backstory almost justifies his power being two gross matter-eating maggots taking up the space where his stomach should be. Born with these maggots, Japheth suffered from terrible stomach pains, which were initially diagnosed as stomach cancer.

Advertisement

Terrified of bankrupting his family with expensive medical treatments, a twelve-year-old Maggot decided that the only solution to his problem was to leave his home and kill himself. Mercifully, Magneto was able to track down the boy before this happened, explaining to him the true nature of his stomach problems. Even this wouldn't quite lead to a happy ending, as when Japheth returned home to tell his father the good news, he would find the man had been murdered in the time he was away.

After all this suffering, Maggott would be able to join the X-Men, where he was at least among others who had similarly tragic histories.

4. Mr. Immortal

Although being immortal sounds like maybe the coolest power ever, it's worth remembering that it's a power that can generally only be discovered in tragic ways - such as the case of Craig Hollis, who discovered he was unable to die after several suicide attempts.

Advertisement

And this isn't even the most tragic part of Hollis' backstory, as his life before discovering his powers was even sadder. When his mother passed away in childbirth, the spirit who took her - named Deathurge - became a sort of guardian angel for the young Hollis, spending time with him and making sure his childhood wasn't spent mourning the loss of one of his parents. But, as the name suggests, Deathurge also convinced Craig to get into many, many dangerous situations, culminating in him convincing the boy to burn down his childhood home - which would lead to the death of his father.

With all this in mind, it's all the more impressive that Mr. Immortal is so cheery after all that's happened to him - although that might have something to do with the oxygen cutting from his brain every time he dies.

3. Zeitgeist

The charismatic leader of the X-Force, Zeitgeist's gross superpowers - which allow him to projectile vomit acid - have been seemingly responsible for a series of traumatic events throughout his childhood and into his adult years, which may explain why he is as insufferable as he is in the series.

Advertisement

The most disturbing of these events comes in the very first time Axel Cluny's powers manifested, as they first emerged when Zeitgeist was in the middle of kissing his highschool sweetheart, leading to Axel instead burning her face right off of her.

Ever since then, Zeitgeist would suffer from nightmares that revolved around this night, although he would be unable to recall the girl's name every time it happened. With it being implied that this was not the sole time that Cluny's powers would result in him hurting loved ones, his cold and hostile demeanor becomes much more self-explanatory - although also considerably more tragic.

2. Throg

Of all the heroes you'd expect to have a tragic backstory, a member of the Pet Avengers has to be pretty low down on that list. But despite his bright, cheery amphibian exterior, Throg actually has a heartbreaking backstory - and a very, very surprising one.

Advertisement

Because Throg wasn't born as Throg. He wasn't even born as Puddlegulp - his frog name before he picked up a fragment of Mjolnir. No, Throg was first known as Simon Walterson, as we learn in the Pet Avengers series that Throg started out life as a college football star who was, in fact, human.

After the death of his wife and unborn child in an unexplained accident, Simon fell into a deep depression, turning to witchcraft to try and speak to his loved ones just once more. While a witch successfully did just that, she was also out of Simon's price range, and when he was unable to pay she turned him into a frog.

Which means that, yes, your favourite child-friendly Pet Avenger has one of the most messed up stories in the entire of the Marvel universe. Enjoy the nightmares.

1. Rage

In the most cliche origin story of all time, Elvin Haliday found himself exposed to toxic waste after hiding from his school's bullies, the fumes of which would transform him from his weedy 13-year-old self into a super-strong invulnerable thirty-year-old - which makes perfect sense, if you squint real hard.

Advertisement

It's seemingly totally ignored that, while Elvin is a buff badass now, he is also still internally a teen, meaning that all the life-threatening adventures he goes on are less cool, and more morally dubious, as the Avengers send him on several missions before they discover his true nature.

This lack of concern for the technical thirteen-year-old would stay consistent throughout Rage's time in comics, all the way up until his death in Venomised #2 - proving that Marvel will kill as many kids as they want, so long as they don't actively look like children.

Advertisement