10 Moments When Superman Was A Real Jerk

Considering he's supposed to be a bastion of all that's right and good, Superman sure can be a horrendous dick sometimes.

By Chris McKittrick /

DC Comics

Wouldn't it be great if there was a guy like Superman in real life - the sort of guy who makes it his life's mission to protect the weak in society? Well, maybe not. Because Superman is the strongest and smartest superhero there is, that means in addition to saving the world from time-to-time he can pick on anyone he wants without fear of them doing much of anything to him.

Advertisement

Just think: if you thought the bully who mistreated you at school was bad enough, imagine if he had superpowers. Though it's not as common as it was in earlier eras, Superman has a long history of being depicted as mean, cruel, and a flat-out jerk to even his closest friends in his comics. Most of these instances happened on the covers of his comic books and these covers were meant to be shocking in order to entice people to buy the issue.

Usually there was a logical explanation why Superman was being such a jerk within the story, or the cover was just exaggerating the situation in the comic. However, this wasn't always the case. Even when you read the context, Superman is sometimes just being a jerk because he thinks it's hilarious to mistreat his closest friends. Most of the time he's the only one laughing. Here are ten examples of when Superman was being a huge jerk despite being one of the world's most popular superheroes.

Advertisement

10. When He Mistreats His "Pal" Jimmy Olsen

DC

If you pick a random cover from Jimmy Olsen's 163 issue comics series, which ran from 1954-1974, chances are your pick will feature Superman doing something awful to Jimmy on the cover, and it goes beyond mates pranking each other for a few laughs. Superman has seemingly done everything he could in order to hurt Jimmy both emotionally and physically.

Advertisement

If he's not trying to kill him, he's forcing Jimmy to marry a gorilla, burning his gifts with his heat vision, making him gain a massive amount of weight so he can make fun of him for being fat, or just telling him he's annoying twerp. Superman might be a cruel jerk, but based on all this evidence Jimmy has to be a sadist as well. There's no other explanation why Jimmy would go through such awful treatment in order to stay "pals" with Superman.

Jimmy has to have an ocean of psychological problems from dealing with Superman, especially since he€™s willing to suffer indignity after indignity just to stay friends with Superman. We know Superman€™s a jerk, so the real question is: why do these people stay friends with him?

Advertisement

9. When He Decides To Take Over Earth

DC

Though in his earliest stories Superman's powers were limited -- the whole "faster than a speeding bullet, more powerful than a locomotive, able to leap tall buildings in a single bound" deal - by the time the Silver Age rolled around he was usually portrayed with limitless powers. In addition, as DC Comics' most popular character, the company regularly portrayed him as far more powerful than any of the other superheroes.

Advertisement

By that measure, if Superman wanted to take over the Earth there would be little standing in his way. So there are a few stories of this era featuring Superman getting annoyed at humanity for one reason and another and deciding, whatever, I'm just going to run things from now on. Though he always changes his mind, the fact that he's done it multiple times is worrisome enough.

What's interesting about this is that modern versions of Lex Luthor have used this exact argument to explain why he hates Superman so much. Luthor sees himself as humanity's best defence against Superman if he ever decided to use his powers to enslave the Earth. He might be a supervillain, but considering comics like the ones above, Luthor might be on to something.

Advertisement

8. When He Was Willing To Let Jimmy And Aquaman Die Of Dehydration

DC

Though there are plenty of examples of Superman mistreating Jimmy, the October 1968 issue of Superman's Pal, Jimmy Olsen might be Superman at his jerkiest. The cover depicts a smiling Superman standing holding a pitcher of water above Daily Planet office worker (and, as the comic's title indicates, Superman's friend) Jimmy Olsen and Superman's long-time Justice League ally, Aquaman.

Advertisement

Witness Jimmy and Aquaman crawling on their hands and knees in the middle of the desert under a blazing sun as they beg Superman for water, but Superman insists that they're in some kind of contest and only one of them can live. Who would do such a thing to two of his best friends, especially someone like Aquaman who can't be out of water for more than an hour?

Superman could easily pick them both up and bring them to the closest oasis in a matter of milliseconds. More importantly, why would DC expect any of their young readers who bought this comic to think Superman was the good guy? If this was the first Superman comic you ever read you wouldn€™t think he was the world€™s greatest superhero, would you?

Advertisement

7. When He Belittles His Friends...

DC Comics

Though there are countless examples of Superman belittling his friends and allies (he is a jerk, after all), the above panel is perhaps the most hilarious example of it. In the midst of several personal problems, Green Lantern gets reamed out by the Man of Tomorrow for having a messy personal life.

Advertisement

This is instead of perhaps helping Hal Jordan get through these problems or at least providing emotional support. The most ridiculous aspect is that Superman seems to feel that the worst offence is that Hal doesn't have an apartment. Come on, Kal-El, it's not like all of us have a giant citadel in the Arctic that we call the Fortress of Solitude to live in.

Sure, it would make it less solitude-y, but why not offer Hal a room there to crash in for a bit? Or, at the very least, there's got to be a spare room on the Justice League satellite that you guys haven't filled with trophies yet.

Advertisement

6. ...Or Reveals Their Secret Identities...

DC

One would think that Superman would understand the importance of secret identities considering back in the day Lois would try to figure his out every issue. However, it sometimes seemed like Superman only pretended to be Clark Kent so he could make friends at the Daily Planet that he could be mean to as Superman.

Advertisement

But for heroes like Batman, their identities are integral to their heroism. If there's no super-rich Bruce Wayne, Batman can't afford all those wonderful toys. But by now you know how Superman treats his friends. Superman will not only gleefully bring the press to your secret hideout, but he will smash through the wall and probably stick you with the repair bill. It doesn€™t even matter if you€™re busy.

This could be happening while Batman and Robin are creating an antidote to a fear toxin that Scarecrow just unleashed on every elementary school in Gotham, as evidenced by the chemistry experiments they're conducting on the cover. Or maybe the Dynamic Duo is trying to create synthetic kryptonite to shut Superman's identity-revealing mouth once and for all. Would you blame them?

Advertisement

5. ...Or Just Beats Them Up

DC

If belittling them or revealing their identities wasn't enough, Superman often goes the brutish route and just beats up his friends.

Advertisement

While in most cases these actions are blamed on things like mind control or some kind of wacky kryptonite that makes him go crazy, it happens often enough that the other heroes should probably question if "mind control" is just an easy excuse for Big Blue to pummel his so-called friends to a pulp just to remind them that he€™s stronger than them.

For such a powerful guy, Superman definitely has some sort of superiority complex if he enjoys beating up his less powerful allies this much. Apparently going around calling yourself "Man of Steel" doesn't feed the ego enough.

Advertisement

4. When He Is Being Jingoistic

DC Comics

Yes, times have changed and Superman was created in an era marked by the prelude to World War II. It's not surprising that during the war he became an icon for America and the creators of the comic used his comics as propaganda. In the context of the early 1940s, it makes sense.

Advertisement

Still, it's probably off-putting to modern readers to see Superman happily punching out awful caricatures of Japanese soldiers on covers of comic books that were primarily sold to children. Now that Superman is a global icon and appears in media released all over the globe, DC Comics has sometimes tried to step away from the whole "American way" aspect that the character had in his early years.

It's not surprising that even during the height of America's War on Terror that DC didn't release any "Trounce a Terrorist!" covers.

Advertisement

3. When He Makes Out With Other People's Wives

DC

Apparently Krypton was a planet that was all about free love because Superman seems to have no problem with making out with other people's wives, even right in front of them. But let's be honest, what can you do about it?

Advertisement

This is Superman. Your wife probably already has a crush on him, and if you try to tell him to back off he can kill you just by looking at you. He might even just kill your wife afterward to destroy all evidence that he convinced your wife to commit super-infidelity.

2. When He is Unable To Make Easy Decisions

DC Comics

It's hard to envy Superman when he's faced with dilemmas. Does he rescue a fishing boat that's sinking off the coast of Nova Scotia, or catch a toddler who fell out a high-rise window in Singapore? He can't be everywhere at once, which means that the Last Son of Krypton sometimes has to make some difficult choices. Of course, not all those choices are difficult.

Advertisement

The above example is a perfect one: "If you save the Joker, Perry White dies!" Should Superman rescue a homicidal mass-murdering clown who has bedeviled his friend Batman for years, or should he let the Joker fall in order to preserve the life of Daily Planet editor Perry White, who probably hasn't done anything wrong in his life except be dumb enough to be friends with Superman? Even the Joker would think it's an easy decision.

However, knowing how Superman treats his "friends" he'd probably rescue the Joker just so the supervillain could keep killing citizens of Gotham to torment Batman. As for Perry White, he had a good run as the butt of Superman's jokes.

Advertisement

1. When He Tries to Kill Lois Lane

DC, Superdickery.com

Superman's relationship with Lois Lane is so ingrained in our culture that it made headlines when DC Comics decided to reboot it's continuity and no longer feature Clark Kent and Lois Lane as a married couple in 2011. However, for most of Superman's history Lois was unaware of Superman's secret identity.

Advertisement

She often suspected there was something more behind Clark's glasses, which led to dozens of stories about Lois putting herself into danger in order to get Superman's attention as she desperately hoped he would fall in love with her. Of course, Superman being the jerk that he often was in those days regularly used Lois' sadly pathetic attempts to gain his affection as opportunities to belittle, embarrass, or just flat-out attempt murder on Lois.

Most of the time he tried to kill her he'd save her at the last moment and say, "Ha, ha! That's what you get for snooping!" These days one can look back at these issues and read them as a woman's sad attempts to win the heart of a man who would rather abuse her emotions and threaten her life. Or you can just laugh hysterically at the idea of Lois professing her love for the Man of Steel only for Superman to respond by trying to kill her. It depends on your sense of humour.

Advertisement

What€™s your favourite €œSuperman is a jerk€ moment? Let us know in the comments.