10 Most Evil Versions Of Superman

Bizarro and Ultraman aren't the only evil versions of the Man of Steel.

By James Egan /

Superman is often considered not just the most powerful superhero, but the most pure.

Advertisement

Even though the Boy Scout can crush a diamond with his bare hands or lift a planet, Superman's greatest strength comes from his compassion towards all living things.

Watching the Man of Steel saving a cat from a tree, reading stories to children in a cancer ward or comforting a teenager battling depression is just as important (if not more so) than watching him capturing the Toyman or bashing an alien in the face repeatedly until the world is safe.

That's why it's so jarring to see Superman depicted any other way besides noble and altruistic. Through cloning, experimentation, or brainwashing, the Metropolis Marvel has been forced on many occasions to face an evil incarnation of himself. Some of these doppelgängers are from parallel worlds where the word" Superman" is associated with mass-murder, genocide, or Nazism.

When you witness a supervillain bearing Kal-El's face take over the world, obliterate cities with a single punch, or gleefully slaughter his friends and fellow superheroes, it makes you realise just how terrifying an evil Superman can be, and why it's a trope writers have repeatedly fallen back on in recent years.

10. Bizarro - Superboy #68 (1958) + Action Comics #254 (1959)

Not only was Bizarro the first evil version of Superman, he popularised the trope of a hero having a wicked doppelgänger.

Advertisement

In Superboy #68, a teenage Clark Kent got shot with a duplicatory ray, which created a double of him called Bizarro. This creature perished at the end of the issue but fans were won over by the character, which encouraged DC's creators to bring Bizarro back one year later.

His backstory has been retconned many times over the years but Bizarro is usually referred to as a clone of Superman created by Lex Luthor. Because the cloning process was flawed, the disfigured ersatz has impaired intelligence and the inverted powers of Superman. He also speaks in opposites, so he'll yell "Goodbye" as a greeting and "I love you" when pummelling his enemies.

Bizarro is as much a victim as he is a villain, but there's no getting away from the fact he's done some pretty evil things over the years.

Because of his impaired intelligence you'd probably think it'd be easy for the Last Son of Krypton to wipe the floor with him, but since he is Superman's opposite, Bizarro has one major advantage over his counterpart; a complete immunity to Green Krytponite. In fact, kryptonite has been shown to boost Bizarro's intelligence, giving the Thing of Steel an edge over his better half.

9. Evil Superman - Superman III (1983)

Superman III is not remembered in the best light. (Even Christopher Reeve admitted it was terrible.)

Advertisement

But to the movie's credit, it is the live-action debut of Superman turning evil. In the story, Richard Pryor's character, Gus Gorman, is hired by a corrupt CEO to eliminate the world's greatest hero with synthetic kryptonite. Although the kryptonite isn't an exact copy, Gus hopes it's close enough to kill Superman.

When Gus presents the green rock to him, it seemingly has no effect. Eventually, Gus realises the kryptonite has corrupted Superman's mind. Soon after, the spit-curled sporting superhero refuses to save civilians in danger, gets drunk, and flicks peanuts in a bar. (Real sick stuff, I know.)

Losing his grip on reality, he flies to a junkyard where he splits into two personas - the evil Superman and the pure Clark Kent. Even though the malevolent doppelgänger has Clark beaten, incinerated, and squished (on three separate occasions), the true Superman withstands all his attacks and emerges victorious.

Superman III may be absurd (the title hero literally fights a bubble at one point), but the Superman vs Superman brawl is definitely a highlight.

8. Brutaal - Earth 2 #14-26

On an alternate world called Earth 2, Darkseid created a duplicate of his Kryptonian rival and conditioned him into a soldier called Brutaal. Tasked with slaying Earth 2's mightiest warriors, Brutaal and Darkseid's general, Steppenwolf, laid waste to humanity, preparing to terraform it into New Apokolips.

Advertisement

After Steppenwolf claimed the world in his own name instead of his master's, Brutaal executed him, reaffirming his devotion to Darkseid. Coming to the realisation that staying on Earth was a lost cause, many people attempted to flee in a vessel called the Space Ark. Sadly, Brutaal destroyed the ship in mid-flight, killing all its passengers.

To stop the world from being burned to ashes, the Superman of Earth 2, Val-Zod, faced Brutaal in an epic showdown. Since Brutaal was brainwashed to believe he was the one true Superman, he saw Val as a pretender and assured him that his victory was inevitable.

But as the fight progressed, Brutaal became noticeably weaker and his skin began to deteriorate, proving he was an inferior clone. Refusing to believe that he is nothing more than Darkseid's pawn, Lois Lane shattered Brutaal's withering body, crumbling it to dust.

7. Overman - The Multiversity: Mastermen (2015)

The Multiversity: Mastermen takes place in a world where Kal-El's Kryptonian ship crash-landed in Germany in 1938, where it was retrieved by the Nazi Party. When Adolf Hitler learned this (while on the toilet might I add), the Fuhrer ordered his men to raise Kal-El as an Aryan super-soldier called Overman.

Advertisement

With his godlike power, the Super-Nazi conquered the world by the age of 17. Although Overman adamantly believed in his cause, he became utterly disillusioned when he learned Hitler's men had exterminated millions of people in concentrated camps.

To make amends, a guilt-ridden Overman spent the next 60 years transforming the world into a paradise. However, a superhero powered by the patriotism of Americans called Uncle Sam refused to bend the knee to Overman since his global utopia was built on lies and bloodshed.

In the end, one of Uncle Sam's teammates managed to work his way onto the Justice League's lunar base and blew it up, causing it to crash to Earth and destroy Metropolis. However, it's theorised in the final pages that Overman voluntarily allowed the satellite to destroy the city to punish himself for playing a part in the Nazi regime.

6. Superman Of Apokolips - Superman: Dark Side #1-3 (1998)

As we all know, Jor-El placed Kal-El in a pod before Krypton exploded and sent it in the direction of Earth.

Advertisement

But in the Elseworld three-parter, Superman: Dark Side, the ship was intercepted by Darkseid before it reached Earth and Superman was raised on the hellish world of Apokolips. Darkseid believed the Kryptonian's power could be used to eliminate his nemesis, Highfather, and so, raised Superman to obey him unequivocally.

When Darkseid believed Superman's power had peaked, he supplied him with a bomb and had him detonate it on Highfather's world, New Genesis.

Before the explosive detonated, Highfather pointed out to Superman that he had been brainwashed by the forces of Apokolips since birth. He then teleported Supes to Earth to show him the life he would've had if Darkseid didn't seize his ship when he was an infant.

After seeing how compassionate humans are, Superman develops a conscience and realises he had been deceived by his master his whole life. Teaming up with the New Gods that survived New Genesis's destruction, Superman battles Darkseid and defeats him. He then becomes the new ruler of Apokolips and begins reseeding New Genesis, hoping to return the world to its former glory.

5. Parallax Superman - Superman #29-30 (2017)

When Superman learns that several children in Metropolis have gone missing, he investigates the locations they were last seen. Using his supersight, the spandex-wearing superhero notices a yellow glow concentrated around an abandoned school. When he explores the building, Superman discovers the children have been kidnapped by Parallax, the creator of fear.

Advertisement

Parallax attempts to possess Superman's body but is unable to since the superhero's willpower is too great. After Parallax tortures the kidnapped children, Superman agrees to let the cosmic parasite take over his body if he frees the children. Parallax agrees and, sure enough, Superman allows the embodiment of fear to possess him.

Before Parallax has a chance to use Superman's body to commit atrocities, Green Lantern's nemesis and ex-servant of Parallax, Sinestro, appears and attacks him. Since Sinestro has mastered fear better than anyone in the universe, he is able to hold his own against his former master.

After Sinestro has Parallax subdued, Superman grabs Sinestro's power ring, which feeds on fear, and entices the godlike entity to possess him again. When Parallax attempts to take over Supes body, the Man of Steel traps him in the power ring, defeating him, at least for the time being.

4. Cyborg Superman - Reign Of The Supermen Storyline (1993)

After Superman was beaten to death by Doomsday, a cyborg called The Man of Tomorrow appeared in Metropolis, insisting he was Superman reborn. The public were dubious of his identity since he was part-machine but he claimed his cybernetics were necessary to repair the damage he sustained from Doomsday.

Advertisement

At first, this Superman seemed like the real deal since he stopped criminals and teamed up with other superheroes. Eventually, he showed his true colours when he orchestrated the destruction of Green Lantern's home, Coast City.

It turns out this "Superman" was a former astronaut for LexCorp, Hank Henshaw. Several months ago, his spaceship was exposed to a solar flare, causing his crew to sustain a lethal dose of radiation.

When Hank learned Superman hurled the Eradicator into the Sun moments before the flare hit, he became convinced the superhero was responsible for his crew's demise. Although this wasn't true, Hank was too consumed by rage to believe otherwise.

Before he succumbed to death, Hank transferred his consciousness into the LexCorp mainframe, giving him the ability to reconstitute his body in robotic form. When Superman was killed by Doomsday, Hank pretended to be the beloved superhero to tarnish his reputation beyond repair.

3. Dark Multiverse Superman - Batman: The Devastator (2018)

The Dark Multiverse is the inverted side of the multiverse, populated by twisted versions of DC's most beloved superheroes. In one of these realities, there exists a Superman who, at first, seems relatively the same as the superhero of Prime Earth.

Advertisement

One day, this incarnation of Superman snapped, killing millions, including his family, friends, superheroes, and teammates. Bizarrely, no one knows the root cause of Kal-El turning against humanity. The Batman of this world originally theorised that Superman turned evil due to being exposed to a new form of Kryptonite or by being brainwashed by Darkseid or Mister Mind.

Naturally, Batman believed he could revert his ally and friend to normal if he reminded him of who he once was. But when the deranged Kryptonian killed his wife and cut Batman's arm off, that's when the Dark Knight realised he had to take his former friend down.

Left with no choice, the Caped Crusader injected himself with Doomsday cells, transforming himself into a beast called The Devastator. After pummelling Superman to a pulp, Devastator poisoned him with Kryptonite and impaled him with his spikes, finally putting an end to Superman's tyranny.

2. Ultraman - Forever Evil Storyline (2013)

Earth 3 is a universe where the concept of good and evil doesn't exist. Instead, everything is perceived as either strong or weak. In this reality, the world is run by a malevolent version of the Justice League called the Crime Syndicate.

Advertisement

The team has an evil version of Superman called Ultraman. The Maniac of Steel's powers are the same as Superman but his strengths and weaknesses are reversed. Not only is he immune to magic, Kryptonite makes Ultraman stronger. After eating or snorting the green metal, the Last Tyrant of Krypton will be borderline invincible for several hours.

Although Superman's power is derived from being exposed to a Yellow Sun, Ultraman can only sustain his strength in darkness. As a result, he keeps shifting the moon to form an eclipse to ensure he is always at full strength.

When the Crime Syndicate imprisoned the Justice League in the storyline, Forever Evil, the supervillains of Earth, led by Lex Luthor, took it upon themselves to defeat Ultraman's team.

After Sinestro and Black Adam exposed Ultraman to sunlight, he was left vulnerable enough for Luthor to batter him into submission.

1. High Councillor Superman - Injustice: Gods Among Us (2013)

Considering there have been dozens of evil Supermen over the last 60+ years, it's ironic the most infamous version originated, not in a comic, but in a video game.

Advertisement

In Injustice: Gods Among Us, Superman loses his mind after the Joker manipulates him to destroy Metropolis and kills his pregnant wife, Lois Lane.

Believing this tragedy could've been avoided if he was less lenient on crime, Superman vows to use lethal force on criminals from now on. When his teammates tell him he has become the very evil he swore to fight against, Superman turned against friends.

Rebranding himself as the High Councillor, the former superhero begins ruling the world with an iron fist. Some of the Leaguers embraced Superman's new vision while others allied with him because they knew they couldn't stop him.

An insurgency, led by Batman, openly opposes Superman's regime and do everything they can to stop his tyranny, so they can return the world to normal. In many ways, this is the most terrifying incarnation of Superman since it proves that the world's most beloved superhero can turn on humanity in an instant if he reaches his breaking point.

Advertisement