10 Most Inappropriate X-Men Storylines
You ever seen a superhero lay an egg?
With the X-Men comics having been going longer than most of its fans, there's bound to be some moments in their history that leave you wondering what on Earth the creative team behind them were thinking.
Between accidentally hilarious storylines, entirely cringey love stories and just a sprinkling of absolutely mad new characters, some X-Men moments manage to take what could have been a fairly normal comic, and instead give you one of the weirdest experiences of your life. They often come out of nowhere, too, in the middle of an otherwise totally conventional series, providing you a surprise shot of confusion where you'd least expect it.
As much as these storylines often leave you feeling they shouldn't have been made, you also can't help but enjoy them, as seeing Quicksilver fall in love with his sister - or watching Nightcrawler become the Pope - is so strange that you just can't look away.
They may not be literary classics, sure, but they are entertaining - even if it's only because some stories try and suggest that things like incest are totally okay.
10. Ugly John - New X-Men #114
Ugly John appears in precisely two comics - New X-Men #114 and #115 respectively - and is, without a shadow of a doubt, one of the saddest comic characters in existence, birthed into a world truly set against him.
In an upsetting twist, Ugly John is actually the character's superhero alias, as his real name is Steve. Why would his superhero name be an insult? Well, Steve's power is that he has three faces, and apparently, each one is equally and uniquely ugly.
That's his entire superpower.
While it is kind of funny to have such a useless ability in a universe where people get to control half the world with their powers, it is also kind of sad, as luck essentially set the world against Ugly John from the start.
He doesn't even get a cool death, as in his final issue he is injured by Wild Sentinels and then put down by Cyclops when his injuries are too bad - meaning his coolest moment is just the mutant equivalent of Old Yeller.
9. Emma Frost And Cyclops Make Out On Jean Grey's Grave - New X-Men #154
Another moment for the ages, there are few fans up to date with the love triangle between Jean Grey, Cyclops and Emma Frost who don't remember the moment Frost and Scott kissed at Jean's grave without equal amounts of confusion and vague revulsion.
There are at least some excuses for this one. After all, Jean Grey did briefly appear to Scott after her death, pretty much asking that he pursue Emma now that she wasn't around.
However, there still is a big old line between pursuing a relationship with someone, and making out with them at the final resting place of your recently deceased other half.
With Emma still being openly rude about the very dead Jean around Scott, you'd at least think you'd discuss the concept of personal boundaries around his dead wife before smoothing her long-term rival.
8. Nightcrawler Becoming The Pope - Uncanny X-Men #423
It's hard to remember the cartoonish 'Holy War' story that ran between issue #423-424 of the Uncanny X-Men without internally flinching just a little.
The story details Kurt Wagner, known better as the Nightcrawler, being recruited to shapeshift into the Pope by an evil sect of the Catholic Church that sought to wipe out all mutants.
While this isn't a huge deal, the way the comic is set out - with the Pope having evil powers, and them hanging mutants on crosses - is so over the top that any genuine critique of the institution is thrown directly out of the window in lieu of wacky evil antics.
Having the Catholic Church as cartoonishly evil supervillains isn't an effective way of pointing out their flaws, and it also doesn't appear to be done for laughs, leaving the comic feeling heavily uncertain in intention as a result.
7. The Metal World-Ending Villain That Was In Love With Jean Grey - X-Men #53
Many people who have read the first few existing issues of the X-Men will have reacted with profound confusion at Professor X initially being in love with Jean Grey - who he had both trained from childhood, and become a surrogate father figure to.
Naturally, it was presumed that this had ceased to be part of the X-Men canon, as years passed without the plot point ever being raised again, and we all forgot about its general weirdness.
Until thirty years later, when - in the event that saw Magneto and Xavier fuse together into the villain known as Onslaught - we saw the cringe-inducing moment raise its head once more.
Quite literally, in fact, as when Jean goes to confront Onslaught, he shows her the exact panels we winced at from years prior, much to her total horror.
With it being safely forgotten and assumed no longer relevant, it's profoundly unclear why it was decided to bring back Xavier's secret longings, aside from to force drama between Jean and her beloved mentor.
6. Nightcrawler Dating His Stepsister - X-Men Annual #4
The moral implications of finding your long-lost brother, not telling him who you are, and then dating him for a considerable amount of time before finally revealing this dark secret are pretty damn strong. Yet, this is exactly the storyline for Jimaine Szardos, Nightcrawler's step-sister, who hides her identity and becomes Amanda Sefton, the hero's long-term girlfriend.
The most concerning part of all of this, however, isn't even how nightmarish this build-up is. As bad as that is, it pales in comparison to the reveal that Kurt isn't horrified that someone who he'd consider a family member has been lying to him in order to date him.
No, instead he's pleased as punch to have been unknowingly dating his sister the whole time, and expresses this both to her and his fellow superheroes repeatedly.
Had they played into the 'adopted' aspect of Kurt's familial ties with Jimaine, maybe this could have been made less creepy. What actually happens, however, is that the two flit between referring to themselves as both brother and sister and boyfriend and girlfriend, reminding us yet again that comics can just be straight up wild sometimes.
5. Mystique Chats Up A High Schooler - X-Men: Worst X-Man Ever
Although all of the World's Worst X-Man comic is made of weird and wild moments from starts to finish, Mystique's seduction of the comic's star Bailey is definitely at the top of the list.
Mystique launches into one of the creepiest villain rants of history at the boy, and also turns into his mother while trying to seduce him at one point, which manages to send an already weird scene into some straight-up oedipal territory.
While we're never told Bailey's exact age, we are explicitly told he's a minor, which means Mystique was dancing into some pretty gross behaviour. More importantly, Mystique does all of this in order to get a picture of her and Bailey kissing to blackmail him with, which takes the fun tone the comic had until then into a really, really dark place.
It's by no means the weirdest moment that Mystique has ever been associated with, but for an otherwise funny and lighthearted comic, this weird blackmail subplot could have been carried off in a million ways that didn't channel some super creepy Freudian themes with it.
4. Anything With Skin - Various Comics
Angelo Espinosa possesses one of the most unfortunate superpowers in the entire colourful cast of the X-Men, being the proud holder of the nightmarish ability that is an extra four to six feet of skin on his body, that he is able to control at will.
This becomes exactly as unnerving as you'd imagine, as watching Skin make the human body into shapes it shouldn't be able to form triggers some primal instinct in the back of your head to start screaming and never stop until he is out of sight.
As such, Skin's ability to appear entirely uncanny to the human eye does make his appearances in comics more than a little disturbing, which is a dying shame, because he does seem to be a genuinely good guy.
Also, giving him the superhero name of 'Skin' does seem excessively cruel, given it is the one thing stopping Angelo from having anything near a life accepted by the rest of society.
3. Beak And Tempest's Egg Babies - New X-Men #141
In the midst of all the other various odd plots occurring during the New X-Men Murder at The Mansion storyline, we get perhaps the biggest and most unusual plot twist of all, in the form of some weird fleshy eggs.
It's unabashedly gross, so much so that it almost endears you to the whole situation, especially as the storyline essentially covers the story of a young teenage pregnancy, albeit a young teenage pregnancy between a couple where one looks like a bird and one that can spit acid, which does sort of change things.
While it has a pleasant resolution when the babies are finally released from the egg sacs, the initial discovery of them is something straight out of the pages of a horror novel, with a terrifying shot to the mysterious (and not especially picturesque) eggs clustered on the roof of the building where they were being kept.
2. Quicksilver Sleeping With His Sister - Ultimates 3
The almost purposeful grossness surrounding Quicksilver's romantic, and inordinately suggestive, relationship in the Ultimates series is one of the most well-known spots of weirdness in the Marvel universe - although it being common knowledge in no way stops it being profoundly weird.
Bonding over their shared frustrations with their father, Magneto, the pair begin a relationship that initially can be read as platonic if you squint at it, before being revealed to be explicitly romantic in Ultimates 3.
The weirdest part of the whole thing is that this incest is sort of approved of within the comic itself, with Wasp telling Captain America that his horrified reaction is due to his '1944 brain', and not basic common sense.
The Ultimates series is weird enough without this story in it, but it all gets amped up to eleven with this unimaginably sketchy side plot.
1. The Sky Sex Love Story - Uncanny X-Men #440
The stuff of sheer, genuine disbelief, few comic moments in the past, present, or future will ever replicate the genuine weirdness that was watching X-Men member Angel lifting his girlfriend Paige into the sky, and then make love to her right there, incredibly explicitly, and with their friends and family gathered below.
It's the kind of surreal, unintentionally funny moment that you couldn't create if you were actually trying to go for that kind of kind of vibe - let alone accidentally creating one in a moment that was intended to be emotional.
If there is ever a dark moment in your life, you can at least rest safe in the knowledge that imagining two people having intercourse while gently rising into the sky is hilarious enough to cure the vast majority of things that ail you. Which is lucky, because once you've seen it, you can't unsee it - forever.