10 Most Overrated Graphic Novels Of All Time‏

Just this once, we 100% expect and understand all your insults in the comments.

By Tom Baker /

In comics there is an established "canon" of the very best works the form has yet produced. Just as with the conventional literary canon, these are the privileged few, the cream of the crop, the limited number of masterpieces against which all future and past comic books are judged. They're not simply good or important due to personal taste and popularity, the criteria instead considering the work's aesthetic and literary value, the cultural and historical impact, and the plain quality in order to decide if they deserve a place in the upper echelons of graphic novels. And in comics, just as in traditional literature, people are always arguing about what deserves to be part of that canon and - if you wanna get really radical with it - whether the stuff that gets promoted to it is even any good. Everything is subjective, this much is true, but there are a handful of comic book storylines and collections out there which have received widespread acclaim and continue to be cited as a benchmark for graphic novels years later. Plus, because everything is subjective, we're well within our rights for calling these stories out for being totally overrated. Bear in mind before you sharpen your deadliest weapons, commenters, that we're not necessarily saying these comics are bad. Many of them aren't - after all, they wouldn't have ended up part of the canon in the first place if they were out-and-out terrible, would they? That doesn't mean they're totally infallible, though, and it's dangerous to think so. If we see certain works as perfect, we build a fence around them, deflecting criticism that they're probably entitled to. So here, True Believers, we are parachuted into a field of comic book sacred cows with...well, not necessarily slaughter on our minds, but certainly some stern words and uncomfortable home truths to share. These are the ten most overrated graphic novels of all time, and just this once, we 100% expect and understand all your insults in the comments.

10. Kick-Ass

To start off, we have a series that is still ongoing and, whilst it wouldn't necessarily be held up as a great literary work in the same way as others on the list, is incredibly popular and indicative of both the writer's work and a particular trend in comic books as a whole. A writer and a trend we are, frankly, sick of, but we'll get there. Gosh, when did you get so impatient? Mark Millar and John Romita Jr's Kick-Ass may be better known for its film adaptations at this point, but each of those draws upon the comic books. The original graphic novels have seen a huge boost in sales and praise as a result of the version seen in multiplexes around the world, so there's your canon placement right there. An inversion of the stereotypical superhero story, in Kick-Ass a plucky teen who is sick of crime decides to take matters into his own hands. The only problem is that he lives in the "real world" rather than the more fanciful comic book universes of DC or Marvel, so when he tries to face down criminals, he gets the crap beaten out of him. Graphically and frequently. Like a lot of Millar's creator-owned work, Kick-Ass gets a lot of approval from fans and critics for deconstructing the superhero genre, looking at how its basic principles would work if applied to reality, and introducing realistic sex and violence (sometimes uncomfortably mixed together) to a genre that's still seen as being inherently immature. All of which isn't anything new, and isn't anything particularly clever, either. Kick-Ass, like the majority of Millar's work, is a thoroughly cynical work in the worst way. It still indulges all of the cliche tropes of and is as far-fetched as superhero comics it supposedly pokes fun at, it's full of ugly homophobia, misogyny and violence against women, and is just kinda childish and stupid. Still, Romita's art is always a treat, and we're glad it keeps Christopher Mintz-Plasse in work.

9. Sin City

Speaking of brilliant artwork and misogyny, Frank Miller's Sin City cycle of noir-infused stories for Dark Horse have broken out of the comic stores and become graphic novel stalwarts, finding their ways into the hands of people who wouldn't normally be caught dead thumbing through a funnybook. The pulpy adventures of broken men and women are full of sex, violence and pessimism but, most importantly, the stark and impressionistic black-and-white artwork of Miller. His use of light and shade is masterful, the look of black-and-white film noir taken as far as it can go, a glorious exaltation and celebration of what comics can do over any other narrative form. At the same time the sex, violence and pessimism are incredibly wearisome, and Miller takes on as many of the bad parts of pulp and noir as the good. Like Kick-Ass, Sin City has been boosted by its movie versions, but it was part of the canon long before then, one of those fateful few comics that appeal to a wider audience. Between that and Frank Miller's elevated status within the comics industry, you don't heard much criticism of Sin City. But you should. Because it's not great. The protagonists in each of the vignettes that add up to make the larger story are paper-thin, each a collection of pulpy cliches with a visual motif, a motivation for whatever violent acts they're going to do, and not a lot else. They're barely developed, and don't have room in their limited pages to grow any further. At least the men get to keep their clothes on, whilst almost every female character is a stripper, a prostitute, or struts around in a state of undress regardless. Sin City is seen as a higher form of comic books, but it actually suffers from many of the issues which keep mainstream comic books dismissed as low culture, oftentimes being even worse than your average issue of Catwoman or Red Hood And The Outlaws. Oh also swastikas. Lots and lots of swastikas. Half-baked, misogynistic and historically insensitive. A classic!

8. Arkham Asylum: A Serious House On A Serious Earth

You can say a lot about Kick-Ass and Sin City, but at least they're legible. Arkham Asylum: A Serious House On A Serious Earth was the first mainstream American comics work by writer Grant Morrison and artist Dave McKean, a match made in heaven in terms of the pair's unconventional and experimental styles. The combination of the two is less heavenly for readers, however, since it lead to a Batman graphic novel that's so difficult to follow that it's nigh-on unreadable. But hey, the title has a quote from a Philip Larkin poem, so it must be clever! Or pretentious. That might be a better word. Arkham Asylum was published as a graphic novel in 1989, was an instant critical and commercial hit and today frequently sits atop lists of the best Batman stories ever told. And yet Batman barely figures into it, and neither do the promise of "graphic novel". The idea of sequential art is that words and pictures tell a story in tandem. In Arkham Asylum, neither really fulfils that promise, instead leaving the reader to navigate a series of impressionistic paintings and scrawled missives that lack any sort of structure of logical sense. We're not total philistines here - we went to an art gallery once and very much enjoyed the gift shop - but we have our limits. Dave McKean's work is undeniably impressive, as he twists and morphs the Dark Knight's rogues gallery into terrifying funhouse mirror versions of their regular selves, and we've definitely enjoyed Grant Morrison's work before and since. Those things do not a cohesive or even fun read make, though. Morrison has copped to consciously penning "something that was more like a piece of music or an experimental film than a typical adventure comic book", which we can dig. We definitely prefer David Lynch to Brett Ratner. However his "dreamlike, emotional and irrational" version of Batman comics is just a headache to read, and leaves you feeling empty upon finishing it, as if you're missing something. Don't worry, you're not the only one.

7. Transmetropolitan

There's perhaps no other writer in comics that has more of a cult around him than Warren Ellis, and no character with more of a following than Spider Jerusalem. Ellis's most celebrated character is the star of Transmetropolitan, a radical work of satirical science fiction with the dystopian Hunter S Thompson analogue as the readers' guide to a ridiculous and over-the-top future world. If that sounds like Transmetropolitan doesn't have any sort of story, plot, or anything besides some neat ideas and colourful characters, well...it's because that's very much the case. Don't get us wrong, Ellis and Jerusalem have earned their cult status to a degree. Each gleefully barrel through wild and occasionally lucid moments, and so long as you've never read Ed Regis's book Great Mambo Chicken and the Transhuman Condition: Science Slightly over the Edge (on which the series draws heavily), you'll get a kick out of all the nutty near-future technology and concepts that Transmetropolitan skips across on its merry way towards nothing. Like Arkham Asylum, Transmetropolitan is heavy on visuals (whatever other quibbles we have, Darick Robertson's jam-packed future City is a treat for the eyes) and ideas (even if they're not particularly original), but cares not for such trivial, unenlightened concepts as "story" or "plot". Which is all well and good, but it's asking a bit for a reader to sit through sixty issues of your comic book that's running solely on the vapours of cynical technological and sociological predictions and Uncle Duke. For a series that positions itself as a revolutionary alternative, none of its ideas are particularly original, and as the series progresses it begins to run out of steam and realise that it hasn't got much in the way of direction and, like Wile E Coyote realising that he's standing in mid-air, the quality plummets until the comic comes to violent end. It was fun while it lasted, but it's by no means the epoch for modern graphic novels many claim it to be.

6. The Sandman

The Vertigo line of DC Comics that produced Transmetropolitan is a serial offender, its "Mature Readers" stamp being the hallmark for comic books that suggest a sort of literary quality that many of them cannot hope to live up to. That's not for want of trying in many of their cases, and especially not in the case of Neil Gaiman's magnum opus Sandman. Perhaps even more than Warren Ellis and Transmetropolitan, Gaiman and this series inspire a fanatical devotion which will see great vengeance and furious anger rained down upon any heretic who suggests they aren't perfect. Which they're not, obviously. Nobody's perfect, least of all Gaiman, who very much suffers from the same affliction of his main comics writing influence. Alan Moore's penchant for florid prose - by which we mean, loving the sound of his own voice - has been kept alive by writers like Gaiman, and nowhere is that more clear than in the 70-issue run of Sandman. The series has its many accolades, and many of them well deserved: it does well to weave a hitherto-unseen mystical element throughout mainstream DC history, ably juggled a rotating series of artists according to storylines that played to their strengths, and is one of the best examples of a single, complete story told through long form comics. Still, 70 issues is a long time to tell any story, and Gaiman frequently ducked into narrative side streets and dead ends that were fun to explore, but a little inconsequential. His writings on the fantastical and the strange are still difficult to process at times, if you've not an intimate knowledge of folklore from around the world, or ever seen a James George Frazer book. The Sandman is hamstrung too by the era in which it was produced, the primitive printing and artwork of the eighties and nineties making what's supposed to be a timeless tale hopelessly dated. In comparison to what came after it, Sandman also pales in comparison. Not only the Vertigo series (and otherwise) which have been inspired by it - Fables, The Unwritten et al - but also the spin-offs from Sandman itself, like Lucifer, which have all taken the groundwork Gaiman and his artists laid and vastly improved upon it. The series was influential, and another which was read widely by people who otherwise had no interest in comics, but that doesn't mean it's necessarily amazing.

5. Kingdom Come

Mark Waid and Alex Ross' Kingdom Come was the pinnacle of the post-Watchmen/Dark Knight Returns trend in superhero comics to make things all grim and gritty, to place their purely fantastical characters into a world as conflicted, violent and morally grey as our own (see Mark Millar, it's not original AT ALL). It was also the point where, thankfully, we realised that was quite enough of that, thank you very much, let's return to our escapist fantasies. Or at least stop thinking that showing Superman kill is at all interesting or challenging or anything more than something done for shock value. Kingdom Come is overrated on two levels. The book is well-remembered both for the story by veteran writer Mark Waid, who has done much better work before or since (his current run on Daredevil is a lot of fun and you should be reading it), and the painted artwork by Alex Ross, who renders the costumed protagonists in a photorealistic style. Neither of these things is actually all that impressive, at least to our eyes. The story, such as it is, is an extrapolation of the dystopian future of the Dark Knight Returns. Villains have become more vicious and violent, meaning that a new breed of superheroes has responded in kind, culminating in the murderous crime fighting of Magog and his friends. Obviously, most of the old guard - lead by Superman - aren't so hot on the whole "killing supervillains in cold blood" thing, culminating in a superhero civil war. Which might also hint at the Biblical end times, according to a ludicrously overblown and pretentious framing device where a priest quotes scripture atop scenes of an elderly Batman scrapping with Power Girl. And if that wasn't enough, there's Alex Ross' art. He certainly succeeds in making it photorealistic, but his paintings have a static and lifeless quality that's the exact opposite of comics, and representative of his working entirely from life models. Plus his approximation of the impossibly bulky physiques of most superheroes is to make them fat. So, sure, if you want a tubby Man of Steel doing Atlas poses whilst you read quotes from Revelations, you might enjoy Kingdom Come. For the rest of us, there are better things to spend our time with than this overrated graphic novel.

4. Civil War

You have to give Kingdom Come some credit, though, as it buried its political and sociological allegory beneath comic book grandstanding and religious jiggery pokery. That rascally Mark Millar has no time for such subtlety, naming his series about a civil war breaking out amongst the heroes of the Marvel Universe, um, Civil War. He also makes no qualms about putting references to post-9/11 America, terrorism and the Patriot Act front and centre with a story where an exploding supervillain who kills a bunch of civilians leads the federal government to demand all metahumans disclose their powers and secret identities. One of the promises the crossover event hype machine for Civil War made was the thrill of seeing not just heroes and villains fighting each other, but heroes fighting heroes! Friend vs friend! You know, the sort of thing that had happened in every team-up issue of a superhero comics since the thirties, where the costumed vigilantes initially tussle due to a misunderstanding, manipulation of brainwashing, before joining forces to fight the real enemy. Still, any notable unoriginality wasn't enough to put off fans, who bought Civil War in their droves. Marvel even managed that most coveted of comic book coups, breaking into the mainstream and enticing in readers with promises of grown-up storytelling and political allegory. We've already been through why the latter is a joke, and the former notion isn't too difficult to disprove either. Mark Millar is a child. He looks like an adult, talks like an adult, and his birth certificate may argue otherwise, but he is a child. Civil War offers a child's view of the geopolitical landscape, a child's idea of a satisfying narrative arc, and a childish joy in taking the best toys from your toybox and smashing them together. Which, admittedly, is fun, but it doesn't make for one of the best graphic novels of all time. Far from it, in fact.

3. The Dark Knight Returns

Sin City may be his artistic peak, but the Dark Knight Returns is what made Frank Miller a household name. In that his name was spoken even in houses that were lacking in longboxes and Six Billion Dollar Man dolls is testament to what he did with the Batman character, taking a pop cultural icon best known for the campy Adam West TV show and breaking him down into a hard, bitter old man who hates the world and everybody in it, who gets a kick out of enacting violence on the scum on the streets, a Bruce Wayne who had more in common with Travis Bickle than the billionaire playboy people were used to. The Dark Knight Returns showed us the caped crusader as we'd never seen him before. But just because you're doing something that nobody has done before means it's good, or worth paying attention to. You could take a dump in the centre of the Ritz dining hall, and it'd certainly be original, but you'd also spoil a lot of people's meals. As an older, sadder Bruce Wayne returns to clean up the streets of Gotham in a much more brutal fashion than before, even breaking the Batman's number one rule of not using guns (not for the first time, but still). Arguably, DKR isn't a Batman story. It's a fascist fantasy dressed up in Batman drag, as the gothic superhero instead becomes a gruff military general, drilling his new sidekick like a rookie soldier and turning the Batmobile into a friggin' tank. Like some of the other most overrated comics on this list, the Dark Knight Returns is also lacking in any tangible plot. It's just a series of vignettes showing off how messed up this future Batman is, leading up to a fight with Superman that seems more like fan service than anything, the predictably and self-consciously "cool" Frank Miller siding with his hero of that totally square Man of Steel, dude. Not that we can necessarily blame Miller for this, either, but the graphic novel did inspire years of terrible comic books where people imitated its grim and gritty style to try when trying to bite on its crossover, "mature" success. It's a striking comic, and done with some visual panache, but boy is it overrated. And if you want to string us up for that, well, that would be a good death. Good enough.

2. The Dark Phoenix Saga

We're going to give you a bit of a long winded metaphor here (and one that's not even that much of a stretch), but bear with us, because it'll all make sense in time. Readers of a certain age will no doubt remember the X-Men cartoons of the early nineties with fondness. They'll look back on it as both a quality show and one that came out just as the form was breaking out of the goofy shadow of Superfriends and into the seriousness (and serious accolades) of Batman: The Animated Series. Try watching it today, though, and your opinion might change. Even through the rose-tinted specs of nostalgia, the X-Men cartoon is hampered by poor production values, some dodgy voice acting and truly heinous writing at times. Still, to suggest such a thing to an avowed fan of the show, and you're not going to win yourself any friends. The same is true of Chris Claremont's run on the X-Men comics in the seventies, with artists Dave Cockrum and John Byrne, which served as the basis for much of the TV series. During his time on the book, Claremont introduced some of the most popular and enduring concepts, characters and storylines in X-Men history. He arguably hit his peak, creatively and commercially, with the epic Dark Phoenix Saga, a cosmic g(r)eek tragedy for the merry band of mutants that saw Jean Grey die tragically. And not even for the first time, believe it or not. The Dark Phoenix Saga's place in the pantheons of the X-Men and comics as a whole is certain. It was one of the most shocking and heartbreaking moments in a superhero comic to that point, and it continues to be drawn upon from comics produced today. That doesn't necessarily mean it's any good, though. Claremont was better perhaps as an ideas man than an actual writer, although his ideas were somewhat questionable at times too (remember when Wolverine met some honest-to-goodness leprechauns during a team trip to Ireland? Yeah). Reading the X-Men comics of the seventies with a modern eye is very, very difficult. There's a whole lot of ignoring the showing-not-telling rule, with dialogue and narration boxes often describing what the reader can plainly see from the artwork, all the more of an affront due to Claremont's histrionic purple prose. It's almost difficult to find Jean's death moving amongst all the exposition and soap opera-worthy speeches given around it, a comparison that robs the final moments of any real gravitas. Rather than an elegant, classical tragedy, it has more the air of an As Time Goes By cliffhanger, only with worse costumes. But don't just take our word for it, comics writing legend Kurt Busiek hated it at the time, too:

1. Watchmen

The Citizen Kane of graphic novels, the only comic to appear on Time magazine's list of 100 all-time greatest books, Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons' Watchmen is undoubtedly a virtuoso work, a true masterpiece of the form. Subverting and eschewing the superhero comic as we knew it, the pair broke down the genre in a way that fans had never seen before, provided political commentary for the Cold War era and was an amazing achievement in terms of form and page structure with its nine-panel grid layouts. It's also totally overrated. The amount of effort that Moore and Gibbons put into it is evident on the page, with the meticulous detail in the artwork and the overlapping storylines (especially the allegorical pirate comics-within-the-comic), but effort doesn't necessarily equal good quality work. The murder mystery that Watchmen supposedly centres around is something of a dud, the death of the Comedian barely important when there's sexual dysfunction and the existential loneliness of superheroes to be getting on with. Moore's barely-contained disdain for superhero comics is also evident throughout. The bearded writer has been more outspoken in his dismissal of the form he made his name in since, but that animosity is clear even with this relatively early work. Watchmen is a hateful piece of work, sucking all of the joy and fun from mainstream comics and daring you to admit you liked such a childish thing in the first place when it's got all this perversion and violence barely beneath the surface. It also ends with a total deus ex machina cop out, as Ozymandias' grand masterplan - which, unlike any other well written mystery plot, the reader could not possibly have figured out for themselves - comes off without a hitch. Like The Dark Knight Returns and Arkham Asylum, Watchmen is much more invested in blowing our minds by deconstructing its genre than in telling a good story. Ultimately, that makes reading Watchmen an entirely shallow experience. Its nihilism and lack of depth means none of the characters are relatable, fans clinging onto the affectations of avowed right-wing psychopath Rorschach in lieu of anyone actually likeable. The female characters, like almost all of Moore's work, are given a pretty bum deal, all paper-thin or sex objects. Gibbons' art is slick, but flat, grimy but not particularly evocative. It has been incredibly influential, popular and part of the zeitgeist. It's also incredibly overrated.