10 Problems With Marvel's Secret Wars Nobody Wants To Admit

Who's that? What's going on? How long does it go on? Who cares?

By Tom Baker /

They say never to look a gift horse in the mouth, but what choice do you have when the horse in question won't stop telling you how great all the spin-offs of his gift are, how it's going to change the universe as you know it, and that it's a perfect jumping-on point for new readers? Marvel's Secret Wars is, in a lot of way, crazy good fun. Jonathan Hickman and Esad Ribic's main book is a blast, with all sorts of wacky antics and Game Of Thrones-style political intrigue on top of the weird sci-fi stuff. The crossever event of the summer has also set the stage for Marvel to do some really interesting books, like giving Captain Marvel's Carol Corps a headline slot and bring back Garth Ennis. But it's not perfect. Really, is anything? The bar is set especially high for comic book events, since so many of them are absolutely dire wallet-sucks that essentially try and sucker regular comic-buyers into spending even more money so they can find out why all their monthly titles have a funny banner on them. And this current crossover is no exception, although it also comes laden with a load more drawbacks that are all its own. Like the length, breadth, and the amount Ribic struggles to draw people looking surprised without making them appear like sexual aids. Here are ten problems with Secret Wars nobody wants to admit.

10. It Goes On For Ages

As it stands, Marvel's latest crossover event is set to wrap up in September. That means that, when all eight issues have come out, it will have been running since May. That's a full five months of Secret Wars, almost half the year given over for a one storyline. That is unprecedented not just in Marvel, but in comics as a whole. Not because their aren't long-running arcs, but because the length of Secret Wars dictates how long until Marvel actually start publishing their regular titles again. Right now almost all their books are on hold until Secret Wars is over, so €“ unless you pick up Hawkeye, Howard The Duck or Squirrel Girl €“ any book you read has to be a Secret Wars one. That's sort of a crummy publishing strategy, effectively forcing readers to engage with the crossover even if they have no interest. If they want to read new Spider-Man, X-Men or Avengers books, they're going to be tied into Secret Wars in some way. For five months. Way to scare off casual readers, Marvel, good job.

9. Oh, The Delays

Of course, that five months thing has always been an estimate, with the core Secret Wars limited series having always been a little vague in its scheduling. At this point it isn't so much undecided as it is completely off the rails, with reports that issues are being delayed up to a whole month €“ after the first few issue were fortnightly. Whether it's artist Esad Ribic struggling to keep up, editorial problems or printing issues is unknown. But because all the tie-ins are so close to the main narrative, every time an issue of Secret Wars gets delayed, all of them get delayed too. Otherwise, they might give away revelations that were supposed to appear first in the core book. Which makes sense, but it means that those delays could push back the entire line of comics Marvel is publishing right now. The worst case scenario is there are weeks where Marvel just don't publish anything. That's a pretty dire state of affairs. And it means fans have to wait even longer for the whole thing to be over.

8. Most Of The Spin-Offs Are Pants

In most cases, crossover events are worth putting up with because the tie-ins will be interesting. Civil War is pretty naff, but the Frontline spin-off book was genuinely strong, and the one-shot of Iron Man mourning over Captain America was great too. The Superman issues which connected to Final Crisis were better than the event itself. That's not really the case with Secret Wars. The main series is a grand, sweeping feudal epic, played on a cosmic level with superheroes. There's some interesting stuff in the tie-ins €“ Captain Marvel And The Carol Corps, Siege, 1602: Witch Hunter Angela, A-Force, Infinity Gauntlet €“ but then there's...everything else. Inhumans: Attilan Rising continues to make the evolved humans happen (with about as much a chance as €œfetch€), Secret Wars Journal is a mess, Inferno is the follow-up to an X-Men storyline nobody liked in the first place...Marvel has effectively cancelled its entire publishing line, and replaced it with what are mostly duds.

7. It Undoes Some Genuinely Interesting Changes

According to the All-New, All-Different Marvel teasers the publisher have been using to slowly reveal the state of affairs post-Secret Wars, at least some of the major changes made recently are going to stick. Thor is still a woman, Sam Wilson remains in the Captain America costume, and Steve Rogers remains old as balls. Already, though, they're undoing the Death Of Wolverine they spent months building up to, several issues actually depicting, and then about a billion spin-offs and follow ups in the months after. Shaking the multiversal snow globe in Secret Wars is an opportunity to undo that without raising many questions. Worse than that, meanwhile, is the Superior Iron Man being kicked to the kerb after just six issues. Tony Stark with a flipped moral compass, which leads to him moving to San Francisco and enslaving the populace with Extremis 2.0, was a lot of fun €“ and it never got to go anywhere, since he's back to being nice under a new creative team soon.

6. Esad Ribic's O-Faces

Jonathan Hickman's previous Marvel work has placed the writer with some artists of varying quality. Amidst the Kuberts and the Leinil Francis Yus, though, there was the far more inspiring sight of Esad Ribic every so often. The Croatian comic book artist knows the ins and outs of widescreen superhero stories, but brings something fresh too. For the most part his work on the core Secret Wars book has been good as well, managing to zoom in on the characters whilst also panning out to illustrate huge, crazy, impossible science fiction scenes without missing a beat. The use of non-traditional superhero comics colouring in concert with that is a joy to behold. In fact, there's only really one place that Ribic's work falls down, and sadly it appears a lot through Secret Wars: his o-faces. There's at least one every issue, and it's supposed to be a group of characters being shocked by something. In Ribic's hands, however, it looks more like a load of superhero fetish blow-up dolls have been arranged in a tableau.

5. You Need To Do A Lot Of Back-Reading

€œEverything ends€ is the tag line of Secret Wars, implying the ultimate bookend to the Marvel Universe that's been in existence since the early sixties. While technically true, the more immediate meta-story that it's drawing to a close is the one writer Jonathan Hickman has been telling in absolutely all of his work for the publisher so far. For somebody who has devoured Hickman's Fantastic Four (which featured Doctor Doom and his universe-saving powers heavily) or Avengers (which is where the whole collapsing-multiverse thing began) is hugely gratifying. For somebody who is less familiar with literally hundreds of issues...it's a lot less so. In fact, Secret Wars #1 was so tied to Hickman's Avengers and New Avengers books that it continued immediately from scenes featured in them. To make any sense of the alliances and rivalries in play, of the themes and plot twists, in the roads that lead to Secret Wars, you're expected to do thousands of pages of back-reading.

4. Even Then, It's Totally Impenetrable

And even if you do all that, there's no indication that you'll have a clue what's going on. Partly that's down to the book not giving much away all at once; partly it's because Secret Wars is utterly impenetrable. Not every title needs to adhere to Stan Lee's famous €œevery comic could be somebody's first€ edict, but c'mon. Give people a chance. Say you really enjoyed Age Of Ultron, but you've never thought to pick up an Avengers comic before. Braving the local shop for the first time, having perhaps heard a little about this cool Secret Wars book, you buy the first issue only to find that absolutely nothing makes sense, and you have no idea what's going on, and nobody's helping you. Secret Wars has been produced as a completely inside baseball work that appeals solely to existing comic book fans, and ones with deep pockets at that. It's not necessarily a bad thing, but when comics sales are constantly shrinking and relying on the current audience is clearly not working, at least give newbies a chance will you.

3. The Cast Is Too Big

To be fair to Secret Wars, this is more a problem with Marvel editorial and its approach to all crossover events. See, Secret Wars is actually unique in that it's mostly self-guided; Hickman is definitely getting to tell the story he wanted to, wrapping up a huge story arc he's been telling for the past five years or so. That's usually not the case. No, Marvel's events are most often cooked up at a writer's retreat, with multiple hands in putting together the basic plot, before it's handed off to somebody to actually script. Even then, the editor will poke their noses in and demand that the book feature all the characters they want to push that year (mainly ones appearing in films). What that means is the story becomes bloated and saggy and almost every Marvel character currently in print demands a cameo, so that you wind up invested in none of the stars since they're never on screen for long enough. Secret Wars has the same problem, and it's one of simply too many cooks spoiling the broth.

2. None Of It Really Means Anything

Of course, meaning is a malleable, subjective thing in a cruel, uncaring universe. Does anything we do really mean anything? And if not, then what does it matter what a load of fictional perverts in their underoos do in a comic book? Not a lot, but on a less nihilistic tip, the events of Secret Wars don't really have any meaning even in their own story. Everybody knows that most comics storylines don't stick, that writers will forget the forgettable and retcon the truly memorable so it's like they never happened. But still, there is some deference to continuity and telling a serialised story. Gwen Stacy is still dead (in the main universe anyway), Cap feels bad about Bucky, and so on. The whole point of Secret Wars and its setting is that it's outside the main continuity. When it ends, everything will go back to normal. Most of the characters featured in Secret Wars and its tie-ins, and the stories in them, won't be returning. It's all even more inconsequential than your average dream, hoax, or imaginary tale. So who cares?

1. It's Like Every Jonathan Hickman Story

Jonathan Hickman is a writer with a few recurring themes, quirks and plot structures. That's fine, every writer has them: Chris Claremont introduces plot elements months before using them, Brian Michael Bendis likes to make everybody Jewish, and Frank Miller produces hate-filled garbage about how great fascism is. In Hickman's case, almost everything he's ever written involves a bunch of smart people making a big plan, and then the plan going wrong. At which case they execute a series of sub-plans, because they had planned for failure, and then it's just plans and failures all the way down to the very bottom. That's the case with his creator-owned projects like Manhattan Projects and East Of West, it was the case with Fantastic Four, New Avengers and Avengers, and it's totally what's happening in Secret Wars right now. It's something he does well, especially with all his deference to game theory, military strategy, following your head not your heart and the like. It's just that, when Secret Wars is such a huge thing and so much bigger than anything he's ever done, it might be nice if he took the chance to do something new. Maybe it's too big a risk. Maybe that's the whole problem.