After 16 months and 31 issues, the Superior Spider-Man-era came to a close in April. As one of the most controversial and divisive status quo changes in Marvels history, the Superior Spider-Man will long be remembered for the ways it passionately engaged, and in some cases, enraged readers. Many Spider-Man fans either loved the idea of long-time Spidey villain Doctor Octopus occupying the mind and body of Peter Parker, or hated the way it besmirched the name of one of Marvels most ethically grounded heroes. Now that the Superior-era is officially over (for now. You never can tell what Spidey-writer Dan Slott will unveil next), it's time to look back and determine whether or not Marvel's outrageous concept was successful. While some fans remain angered by the Superior status quo, many others have grown to love and appreciate what will likely be regarded as one of the better Spidey tales of the past 20 years. The Superior Spider-Man incorporated a stable of great comic book artists, introduced wonderful new characters, revived some long-forgotten or ignored heroes and villains, and found new and exciting ways to keep readers invested. Plus, Peter, aka, the Amazing Spider-Man will be back in his own title at the end of April as everyone predicted when Marvel first announced the character would die in 2012. So unless youre still holding grudges for the way a fictitious character in a superhero comic was treated, now is the time to fondly remember a totally unique time in Spider-Man history. Here are 10 reasons (with spoilers) we should celebrate the Superior Spider-Man.
10. It Established Giuseppe Camuncoli As A Top Artist
When the series launched in January, 2013, Superior Spider-Man featured a rotating art team of three artists with various pedigrees and degrees of popularity: Humberto Ramos, the established vet who had been penciling the Web Slinger since the early 2000s; Ryan Stegman, the rising star who had been compared by some to industry phenom Todd McFarlane; and Giuseppe Camuncoli, a steady, but unspectacular penciler who did not have a true note worthy comic book run to his name. Superior provided Camuncoli with an opportunity to flex his artistic muscles. Some of his early work on the series produced some very impressive splash pages and spreads, and his pencils throughout the five-part Goblin Nation arc to close out the book have been nothing short of revelatory. Many of Goblin Nations flashback sequences allowed Camuncoli to reference classic moments of Spidey history, with some modern touches and embellishments. One has to think that Camuncolis stock has risen considerably after the past 16 months.
9. Anna Maria Marconi
While the Superior Spider-Man has struggled with its female supporting cast a bit Mary Jane and Carlie Cooper specifically have suffered from being inconsistently characterized by writer Dan Slott the series did introduce the fantastic Anna Maria Marconi to the mix. Anna Marias most defining physical characteristic has been her height. As a bonafide little person, Slott has had to tread carefully in an effort to not make light of her disability. Fortunately, outside of some occasional references (mostly by villains, and curiously enough, one from Aunt May), Anna Marias diminutive stature has rarely entered into the storyline. Instead, readers were treated to a smart, funny and likeable character in a book that desperately needed a strong female presence.
8. It Mined Gold From The Dark Ages Of Spider-Man
The mid-1990s was not a golden era for the world of Spider-Man comics. With Peter Parkers clone running around and a plethora of poor editorial decisions diluting the quality of the series, most fans and current creators believe this period is best left forgotten. That did not stop Dan Slott and some of the other creators who tackled the Superior Spider-Man the past 16 months from using some storylines to call back to the 90s in ways that produced some worthwhile reads. In Superior Spider-Man #20, Slott reintroduced Doc Ocks 90s flame, Stunner, a woman of Amazonian proportions with super strength to match. The issue ended up being one of the better self-contained stories in the Superior-run, and fans who remember the original Stunner/Doc Ock stories from 20 years earlier were even treated to some vintage visuals of Otto in his white suit attire. Last summer, a two-part crossover in Superior Spider-Man Team-Up and Scarlet Spider focused on the mid-90s storyline when Peter Parkers demented clone Kaine snapped Doc Ocks neck, murdering him (he was later resurrected). As the Superior Spider-Man, Otto did not forget what Kaine did to him years earlier, leading to a wonderfully tense storyline courtesy of Chris Yost who penned both Team-Up and Scarlet Spider.
7. Spider-Man 2099
What initially started out as a bit of a prank eventually evolved into Marvels reintroduction of a vastly underrated and under-appreciated character in Miguel OHara, aka, Spider-Man 2099. In late 2012 before the identity of the superior Spider-Man had been officially revealed, Dan Slott toyed with Twitter followers by asking one of his artists on Twitter about OHaras physical characteristics. The tweet was treated as a private message that was accidentally posted on the main site before being quickly deleted. When Otto Octavius was revealed as the Superior Spider-Man shortly thereafter, it became clear that the OHara tweet was just some friendly game-playing courtesy of Slott. Still, fans responded positively to the idea that OHara might be returning to the mainstream Spider-Man universe. At a comic book convention last year, fans raucously cheered when Slott confirmed that Spider-Man 2099 would return for a special arc in Superior Spider-Man #17-19. Outside of that one arc, Miguel was a mostly tertiary character in Superior. But it was announced last month that original 2099 writer Peter David was coming back to pen a brand new series about the character living in the modern world. Now a whole new generation of fans will discover OHara.
6. It Kept Readers Guessing
When the Amazing Spider-Man first debuted in the early 1960s, one of the most significant storylines involved the secret identity of the green and purple -clad villain, the Green Goblin. Stan Lee and Steve Ditko would often show the character in shadow or his face obscured, teasing readers who were dying to figure out the identity of this mystery man. Fast forward nearly 50 years later: Dan Slott and the rest of the Superior Spider-Mans creative team managed to recapture the magic of the Green Goblin mystery, but this time for an audience that had more instantaneous outlets to communicate and speculate with each other. Whenever the goblin mystery was teased by Slott, fans would immediately take to Twitter and message boards speculating about who was running around the Marvel Universe calling himself the Goblin King? Was it the original Goblin, Norman Osborn? His son Harry? His daughter-in-law Liz Allan? His grandson Normie? A clone? A robot? Slott himself? And like any good yard-spinner, any time it looked like the case was cracked, Slott introduced new information just to throw readers off the scent.
5. The Cliffhangers
Fans who cringe at the exorbitant price of comic books these days unquestionably got their moneys worth when it came to the amount of content and action in Superior Spider-Man. Dan Slott managed to pack a ton of plot development into this series, as a standard issue would often have at least three or four subplots running concurrently (sometimes even more) involving Spidey, Mary Jane, Carlie Cooper, the Green Goblin, J. Jonah Jameson, Alchemax/Horizon Labs, etc. Additionally, Slott had a penchant for ending almost all of his Superior issues on a cliffhanger, whether it be some foreboding comment from the Goblin, the appearance of Ghost Peter, or something else that threatened to throw the Superior status quo into upheaval. Even if you were not totally in favor of a certain plot point or characterization, Slott found ways to make readers invested in his story and eager to read the next issue.
4. It Played Into Dan Slotts Strength As A Writer
While other series have incorporated the Superior Spider-Man since his introduction in 2013 (i.e. the Avengers, Deadpool, Journey Into Mystery and others), Dan Slott, the self-proclaimed "worlds biggest Spider-Man fan," is unquestionably the character's mastermind and chief architect. And those who are familiar with Slotts other Spider-Man writing the past decade (as well as his work on other series), will note that only a mind as wonderfully twisted as Slotts could pull off an idea as grand as Superior. The Superior Spider-Man storyline accentuated all of Slotts gifts as a writer: it was quirky, bold, fast-paced, jaw-dropping, infuriating, head-smacking and funny. People who rolled their eyes at Slotts sometimes corny dialogue during the Amazing Spider-Man era were suddenly enamored with how expertly this verbiage read coming from the lips of the obliviously egomanical Otto Octavius. Readers who thought Slotts constant references to obscure Spider-Man storylines from the past were just show-boaty, were suddenly enchanted when characters like Spider-man 2099 and Stunner appeared in Superior. The series was not without its flaws, but it was also so much fun, and Slott was so clearly comfortable writing it. Even when things went slightly off the rails, most readers realized the end result was something worth smiling about because Slott was in command.
3. It Created New Levels Of Sympathy/Understanding For Doctor Octopus
Once Marvel announced that the new hero of the Superior Spider-Man series would be lifelong villain Doctor Octopus, Spidey fans started to question how they could accept a story that celebrated a murderer and an egomaniac as its central figure. Marvel could not just make Doc Ock an unqualified good guy and ignore his 50 years of treachery and deceit, nor could the publisher have him walk around acting like a villain and expect this wild premise to suspend readers disbelief for more than a few issues. The Superior Spider-Man worked primarily because it had it both ways Doc Ock was a jerk with a gigantic ego that, but he was OUR jerk. He was not necessarily sympathetic in how he went about conducting himself, but the character also made some valid points about the inferior way Peter Parker interpreted "with great power must also come great responsibility." For example, Otto was on to something when he questioned why Spider-Man let a remorseless killer like Massacre go free rather than do the world a favor by putting a bullet in his head. Or how about the way Otto eliminated almost all street-level crime in New York City by installing his spying Spider-Bots in key areas? Amazingly, now with Superior coming to a close, theres a contingent of fans who are bemoaning the return of boring Peter. Otto was not the most likeable character, but he no doubt kept things interesting for the past 16 months.
2. It Proved Peter Parker Was The Superior Spider-Man
When the Superior Spider-Man-era began in January 2013, a small, but vocal portion of the fanbase were outraged by the fact that Peter Parker had been so ingloriously killed off and that readers were now expected to accept long-time villain Doctor Octopus as a hero. Some fans even went as far as to claim that Marvels front office had some kind of personal vendetta against Peter a character that has made the publisher a bucket-load of money over the years. But from the get-go, Superior Spider-Man was a clever analysis of what it meant to be a hero. Yes, for the past 16 months, Otto Octavius masqueraded as a hero, even proving to be Peters superior in some ways. But Parkers tenure as Spidey was always the measuring stick for this series. Even during the issues where Peters astral presence was totally non-existant, Dan Slotts scripts subtly massaged in the question to readers: What would Peter do? Now that Doc Ock has seemingly relinquished his control of Peters body back to the original hero, theres no longer a question as to who is the superior Spider-Man. It is the amazing Spider-Man, Peter Parker.
1. Its Good For Comic Books To Take Risks
There is nothing worse for a long-form storytelling medium like comic books to be viewed as predictable. Certainly many readers are creatures of habit and comfort, but the goal of every publisher should be to engage new readers and generate buzz about a series. Sometimes that leads to editorial mishaps, like the Spider-Man Clone Saga from the 90s, but if you combine the right idea with the right writer, sometimes risk-taking is rewarded. Critics of the Superior Spider-Mans status quo and of Dan Slotts writing, dismissed the premise as a gimmick that would kill the franchise. But the opposite has happened. Spider-Man comics havent been this financially and critically successful in years. Every month, Superior Spider-Man often makes Diamond Distributers top 10 sales chart, and the series was a high-ranking choice in numerous best comics of 2013 lists. Slott has said repetitively that this new status quo has allowed him to tell new stories with new perspectives. Now that the Superior Spider-Man is over, is there anyone out there who is still begrudging Slott for wanting to take this risk and do something different?