10 Reasons Why Donny Cates’ Venom Was So Great

Cates’ run is considered by many to be THE definitive Venom saga.

By Daniel Carville /

Whether you prefer him as a gigantic, slobbering fiend that haunts Peter Parker’s nightmares, or as an antiheroic ‘Lethal Protector’ of the innocent, there have been few Venom comics that have struck as big a chord with fans as Donny Cates’ 2018-21 ongoing series. Favouring the latter approach to the character, the book flew off the shelves and was constantly brought up in discussions of the best comics out there at the time.

Advertisement

This run, along with the Tom Hardy-led Venom movies, is often credited as propelling Venom into stardom, a superhero worth bringing up in the same discussions as characters like Iron Man and Captain America.

What was it that Cates and co did to so drastically shift readers’ perceptions of the human/alien symbiotic goo-duo?

10. Separating Venom From Spider-Man

While both the Peter Parker and Miles Morales incarnations of Spider-Man do appear as supporting characters during certain arcs, Donny Cates made a point from the early issues to distance this relationship that had defined the character for so many years. Before the release of the first Venom movie, a major concern from fans was that the character would not be able to function without the Web-head’s input.

Advertisement

Cates, however, rewrote elements of the canon to make Venom stand on his own two feet, specifically through the introduction of Knull, God of the Symbiotes. The warped rendition of the spider-symbol across Venom’s chest was revealed to be a depiction of the symbiote dragon known as Grendel, with Knull himself sporting a similar image in red. Our symbiote’s reconnection to the hive resulted in the discovery of a long-dormant power, a huge pair of red-and-black wings, allowing the antihero an alternative mode of transport from the decidedly spiderish web-slinging.

The evolved depiction of Eddie Brock’s relationship with Peter Parker was also interesting to see, Eddie having seen the error of his ways and wishing to build some form of friendship with the man he had been vindictively targeting for the past 30 years of publication history. Even during Venom’s good guy revamp in the ‘90s, no writer ever allowed him to truly make peace with Spider-man, presumably because the rivalry was so popular.

9. Not One, But Two Venom-Centric Event Books

Much of the buzz surrounding this run can be attributed to the release of two event miniseries, Absolute Carnage, which saw a resurrected Cletus Kasady on a bloody quest to free the dark god Knull, and King in Black, which depicted the entity’s arrival on Earth, a result of Eddie Brock’s decision in #5 of the former series. These two stories serve as major arcs in the Venom run, even if they don’t technically appear in issues of that comic.

Advertisement

Serving as the protagonist of a successful event book is likely to take any character to new heights of popularity (fingers crossed for Howard the Duck vs Thanos in 2039), but the prior efforts of Cullen Bunn’s Venomverse and Venomized didn’t seem to do the trick. Luckily, 2019’s Absolute Carnage garnered rave reviews across its five issues, as did 2021’s King in Black, which is widely considered to have been a perfect finale after Knull’s debut in Venom #1.

The use of Eddie Brock as a leading man in these two universe-shaking stories drew the kind of attention the character had rarely seen before. For his actions to have such dramatic consequences for the Marvel Universe had not been seen before; the character was typically relegated to smaller stories that affected only his and Peter Parker’s world. Giving him the chance to save the universe alongside Earth’s mightiest heroes allowed Eddie to be respected as one of them, even if he didn’t see himself as one.

8. The Use Of New And Old Venom Villins

Any hero, or antihero, worth their salt better have a decent rogues gallery of baddies up their sleeve, yet this is a department in which Venom has historically been lacking. Of course, he’s fought many villains over the years, his clash with Juggernaut in Venom: The Madness being particularly memorable, but the only personal villain he’s battled enough times to be considered an archnemesis is Carnage, and he first appeared in a Spider-Man comic (Amazing Spider-man #359).

Advertisement

Not only is Carnage used extremely well as an antagonist in Absolute Carnage and Venom Island, which emphasised the personal connection between the slimy red sadist and his ‘father,’ Donny Cates also conceived original villains for his hero to face up to, namely Knull, Virus and Codex. While Venom clashed with plenty of original villains during his string of 1990s miniseries - Dr. Paine, anyone? - few were as memorable as these misfits.

Fans are hoping to see an onscreen rendition of Knull face off with Tom Hardy’s Venom one day, which is an indication of the huge popularity the character quickly found after his introduction. This oddly mirrors Venom’s own rise to fame; he was considered a ‘breakout villain,’ quickly joining the ranks of Green Goblin and Doc Ock, despite debuting years after them.

7. Incorporating Canon From The Classic Comics

A lot of people might not know this, but Eddie Brock is actually from San Francisco. He is most frequently depicted onscreen with a working-class New York accent, which originated from Hank Azaria’s take on the character in Spider-Man: The Animated Series and endured all the way to the live action Venom movies. But the butch, blond bad boy was born on the opposite side of the country, in sunny California, as revealed in Venom: Lethal Protector #1.

Advertisement

Bringing Eddie back to San Fran for a troubled reunion with his estranged father was just one of the things Cates did to make sense of the admittedly messy Venom canon. This run made frequent use of locations, characters and concepts introduced by previous writers, in ways that were rewarding for long-time fans without alienating new ones.

From setting an arc on the Island of Bones, where Venom brought Spidey for their supposed final battle in Amazing Spider-Man #347, to the reintroduction of Eddie’s sister Mary, to the exploration of Eddie’s relationship with his ex-wife Anne, these moments were always used in service of the story rather than as blatant, distracting fanservice.

6. Expanding The Mythology

Since its introduction in Amazing Spider-Man #252, the history of the symbiote and its entire race has been about as nebulous as the black goo itself. Some writers would have you believe that the symbiotes, or Klyntar as they later came to be known, are a peaceful species and that Venom is a rare example of a crazy, violent one. Others would tell you that the symbiotes are inherently malicious creatures and that the Venom symbiote was cast out for being too empathetic and wanting to bond with its hosts rather than drain them.

Advertisement

The foundation that Cates lays for the symbiote mythos in this run is rock-solid enough that future writers can build on it, rather than ignoring or retconning it. While some readers may miss a more sci-fi oriented approach, giving the symbiotes a creator in the form of Knull grounded the entire fictional species, and allowed for unique storytelling developments, such as the reveal of the symbiote planet’s true nature.

Cates’ success in putting meat on the bones of the Venom mythology is one of the most emphasised elements in discussions of his run, and it’s easy to understand why. Any time questions had been answered about the mystery of the symbiotes’ past beforehand, they were never particularly groundbreaking or hard-hitting, whereas Cates’ worldbuilding has injected new life into the concepts of symbiotes in general, rather than just the one we all know and love, Venom.

5. A Strong Emotional Core

Donny Cates has stated in interviews and podcast appearances that his decision to introduce the character Dylan Brock, Eddie’s son, was in large part to give Brock ‘something to fight for’. In most of his appearances, Venom’s raison d’être has been either to kill Spider-Man, or to protect the innocent by generally violent means.

Advertisement

While writers have given antiheroes children before, as a way of grounding them emotionally and revealing a softer side, Dylan was still a great character to bring into the series. This father-son relationship is sweet as well as believable, and the reader really feels Eddie’s desire to protect his son from the consequences of his dark past, as well as Dylan’s, perhaps misguided, idolisation of his father that drives him to be more than just a normal kid.

Cates of course leans heavily into the dynamic between Eddie Brock and his symbiote, something that has proved popular with Tom Hardy’s take. Favouring a less comedic approach, Cates digs into the fundamentals of their relationship, what they need from each other why they stay together, and whether they even should. It’s a complex depiction of a turbulent relationship in which harm is done to both parties, yet the desire to try and do better prevails. Just try not to take it as couple goals.

4. He Fixed Eddie Brock’s Characterisation

Since his early appearances as a villain, Eddie Brock has been presented as a man of contradictions. He claims to be a protector of innocents, yet he was completely happy to do away with them if they stood between him and his Spidey vendetta. In 1993 he officially became an antihero, yet he still saw Spider-Man as a villain. And what was the reason again? Oh yeah, he revealed the true identity of a killer after Brock exposed the wrong guy. That’s a punishable crime, apparently.

Advertisement

Eddie has always claimed to be a guy that cares about justice, yet felt little remorse for his villainous actions. Donny Cates finally made sense of this in Venom #11, which revealed that this pattern of behaviour stemmed from a traumatic incident in Eddie’s youth. He was responsible for a horrendous injustice and felt that he needed to do good in order to make up for it, but the incident completely shattered his sense of what was right and what was wrong, who was innocent and who was guilty.

It suddenly made complete sense that Eddie would deflect blame onto Spider-Man instead of owning up to his mistakes, and that he would vilify him while seeing himself as the hero. It also makes complete sense that Eddie would want to genuinely try to better himself and make up for his mistakes after all these years.

3. Ryan Stegman's Art

It shouldn’t have taken this long to mention, but the brilliant artwork by Ryan Stegman on Venom is a huge part of what makes the book so great. While he isn’t present for the entire run, showing up mostly for the major climactic storylines, his contribution to the book cannot be understated.

Advertisement

He carves out a corner of the Marvel universe that is entirely Venom’s own. The rainy, gothic cityscapes are the perfect playground for these stories, from New York to San Francisco, as well as more abstract locations such as those seen during Knull’s backstory.

His character design is also brilliant, his Venom harkens back to the original Todd MacFarlane drawings with the big, bulbous forehead and hugely expressive face, with the seamless addition of the dragon wings only enhancing the timeless design. Similarly, his design of Eddie in his various incarnations, whether it be long haired, bearded or both, is based on MacFarlane’s original rugged depiction, rather than the generic handsome comic hero he is often portrayed as. He gives Knull all the spindly gravitas you’d expect, and it’s a delight to see his version of all the marvel heroes that show up in King in Black.

2. A Satisfying Redemption Arc

Transitioning a character from villain to superhero is not an easy task, and something that Venom has never quite achieved before. His antihero turn was primarily a demand from marvel due to his popularity, and some writers, including Venom co-creator David Michelinie, were sceptical of the move.

Advertisement

During his string of miniseries in the ‘90s, Venom may have been a protector of innocents, but he never seemed to reconcile with his past, or even want to. In Venom: Lethal Protector, he is confronted by a team of soldiers with advanced technology known as the Jury, led by a man named General Orwell Taylor. They are bent on killing Venom as vengeance for his killing of Taylor’s son, Hugh, during a prison break.

This could have been an opportunity to explore the painful reality of facing a dark past when one is trying to better themselves, but it doesn’t really go anywhere. Cates depicts Eddie as a man who is so haunted by his past that he doesn’t even know how to see himself. His struggle towards redemption is made all the more believable and satisfying by the fact that Eddie is doing it for others, not because he wants the satisfaction of having done good.

1. It Sets Up A Whole New Era

By the final issue of Donny Cates’ Venom, the reader truly gets the sense that a meaningful story has been told that has changed the characters and their world. It doesn’t circle back round to the beginning to leave a clean slate for the next creative team. In an industry that thrives on ‘the illusion of change,’ this kind of ending is satisfying to see.

Advertisement

The status quo of Eddie and Dylan Brock is completely different from the beginning of the run, a result of their completed character arcs. The final issue is ideal in that it sets up a future for the characters, while also being such an effective finale that it would serve as a fitting ending if Venom never appeared in a comic again.

The new creative team of Al Ewing, Ram V and Bryan Hitch are building on this in their new run, as opposed to undoing it so they can start from scratch, which is a testament to just how impactful Donny Cates’ run is. Many comics make the claim that ‘nothing will be the same again,’ but this run is already demonstrating it. Venom will truly never be the same again.

Advertisement