10 Stupid Arguments About Batman That Don't Make Sense
Not a superhero, huh? Wanna say that to his face?
If there's one thing you learn from spending any sort of time on the internet, it's that people have a lot of opinions about Batman.
When Ben Affleck was cast as the Dark Knight in Batman V Superman, people were instantly deriding his performance. It didn't matter that the film still had another year until it released, and the same premature takes have proven endemic for the character, dating all the way back to 1989, where fans voiced their displeasure at Michael Keaton being cast in the role.
The character just really gets people's backs up. But then, when a character is around for 80 years and has seeped into almost all parts of pop culture, people do tend to get attached.
But because Batman is a character that's been so widely disseminated throughout the world - even if somebody's never read a comic, they've probably seen a film, or watched an episode of a TV show or something - there are plenty of people who are ready to have opinions about him, without really understanding the character.
You'll have no doubt come across people who will tell you that Bruce Wayne is just as insane as the bad guys he locks up (if not more so), that those supervillains only exist thanks to the Caped Crusader inspiring them, and that Bruce should just use his money instead of "beating up poor people".
Boohockey. Here are ten such stupid arguments about Batman that don't make sense.
10. He's Insane
It's an easy joke, but a good one.
"Batman? Oh, you mean that guy who had a psychotic break when he saw his parents shot in front of him, so he decided to dedicate his life to a totally unhealthy exercise regime in order to wage a one-man war on crime? And he does it whilst dressed as a six-foot tall giant rodent? That guy must be nuts, right?"
That's a common argument trotted out against the Dark Knight, and it should be noted that it's one that Batman villains use it all the time. "We're not so different, you and I", and so on.
There are some similarities between the hero and his rogues gallery - that's what makes their confrontations more interesting than him just, y'know, fighting evil dudes. But they key difference between them is what makes Batman the hero, and the rogues the bad guys: Batman isn't insane.
It's sort of patronising and problematic to assume that somebody who goes through massive childhood trauma is going to go nuts, and more than a little cynical to deem somebody who wants to change the world for the good as bad as the criminals they're fighting.
9. The Supervillains Exist Because Of Him
Another of the most common arguments against Batman is that he's to blame for the sudden uptake of supervillainy in Gotham City. If it wasn't for the Dark Knight swanning about in his flamboyant dress, the criminal underworld would never have got the idea to take on similarly colourful personas and expand their misdemeanours to an appropriate scale.
Again, this is a position often taken by members of his rogues gallery. The Joker especially is fond of telling Bats that they need each other, that they're yin and yang, that one cannot exist without the other - the latter meant literally, since an accident at a chemical lab involving the pair is what gave the Joker his appearance in some origins.
Obviously, the real-world explanation for why supervillains showed up at the same time as Batman was to give the character somebody appropriate to punch. In-universe, meanwhile? The world of DC is such that it can give birth to multiple different superheroes. Hundreds. Obviously, it would also have the ability to create baddies in silly get-ups too.
8. He's Not A Real Superhero
How do you define a superhero? Superman is the first real such character to appear in comic books, setting the template of a guy with heightened abilities in a cape and tights. Batman followed soon after, and was in a similar mould.
However, unlike the Krypton-born Man of Steel, Bruce Wayne was very much a son of Earth, a regular human being. Whilst Clark Kent had otherworldly abilities owing to his origin, Batman is just a person. So he's not really a superhero, right?
Is a superhero just somebody with powers who doesn't use them for ill? That doesn't seem quite right. And yet that's the justification people always give for not characterising the Caped Crusader as a "real" superhero, in the same way they would Superman, Wonder Woman, or even Martian Manhunter.
Is he really more of a superhero than Batman? It's all the more ridiculous when you consider that Batman kind of does have superpowers, if you quantify them as being abilities beyond most human beings. Nobody on Earth - fictional or otherwise - has the martial arts training, resources, or deductive reasoning that Batman does. (Nor his eerily supernatural ability to always be two steps ahead of everyone, whether friend or foe.)
7. All His Enemies Are The Same
Batman has one of the most celebrated rogues galleries in superhero comics. It helps that he also has one of the largest rogues galleries in superhero comics, giving a greater chance to improve his batting average than, say, the relatively light list of antagonists The Demon has to face up to.
It does mean that creators ran light on ideas at times, though. Setting aside the likes of Mr Freeze and such, it's sometimes suggested there's not a whole lot of difference between The Joker, The Riddler, and The Penguin. Besides the definite articles which precede all their titles, they really haven't that much in common besides being, again, eccentric doers of evil.
It makes sense that they'd be sorta similar, all coming out of the same city. And whilst The Riddler is pretty close to The Joker's schtick on paper, and The Penguin has an even more deformed appearance than the Clown Prince of Crime, seeing them in action just goes to show how different they are.
They're all a little nutty to varying degrees, but The Penguin is a much more level-headed (if angry) gangster type; The Riddler is smug, insecure and self-destructive with his intelligent ploys; and The Joker is a pure force of chaos. They couldn't be more different.
6. He's The Best Member Of The JLA
Grant Morrison's defining run on JLA in the early nineties suggested that, whilst the rest of the team could be defeated using sheer strength by most comers, Batman's brain would always put him on top.
Mark Waid did a similar thing with his iconic Tower of Babel storyline, which came not long after Morrison's time on the book. In it, a supervillain takes advantage of a set of fail-safes Batman had set up, each of which are designed to perfectly incapacitate any and all of his supposed friends.
The ever-paranoid Caped Crusader set up all of these methods of essentially beating up his team mates just in case any of them ever went rogue. Which is where you realise that Batman is far from the best member of the JLA.
The rest of them have a mutual respect and trust for each other, knowing that they can take on any threat together, and always have each other's backs. That's not a respect or trust that the Dark Knight feels for any of them. He's not a team player - at least historically - so how can he be the best?
5. He's Nothing Without His Gadgets
That's the one and only reason he kind of sucks as a Justice League member, by the way. But, again, there are those that will say his lack of a traditional, mutation-or-magic-born set of superhero abilities are what should render his membership null and void.
If pushed though, those naysayers can be forced to admit that his gadgets are pretty cool, and probably help him out. But ah, isn't it those gadgets that make him so formidable in the first place? Nary a battle goes down in a Batman comic, movie, TV show or video game without him whipping out any number of wonderful toys, from the shuriken-like Batarangs to Adam West's infamous Shark Repellent Bat-Spray (from a range of Oceanic Repellent Bat Sprays).
Here's the thing: not everyone can throw a Batarang successfully. The Marvel Vs DC event proved that even master assassin Bullseye, who can turn anything into a weapon, isn't much cop with them. At least compared to the master. Batman's gadgets only work when Batman's using them, but Batman works without his gadgets. All that training in ninja skills and martial arts wasn't for nothing.
4. He Can Only Be Dark And Brooding
In most of his adaptations to other media, Batman is a singularly dour and dark figure. In Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight trilogy of films, the principal outlook is right there in the title. Getting King Goth Tim Burton to helm the earlier films probably didn't help that case much, either.
It's an attitude that persists to this day, in minds of both fans and creators. Why is Batman so serious? Well... he's not. Not all the time. In fact Batman has proven himself to be one of the most malleable, experimental characters in comics. Creators can do just about anything with him. That's why the Christian Bale angst-ridden Caped Crusader is as legitimate as the dancing, campy Adam West Batman from the sixties.
Even everybody's favourite Batman - the one in the nineties Animated Series - isn't as po-faced as all that. There's plenty of angst and pathos in that show (especially when it was supposedly for kids), but Batman smiled a lot. He cracked wise. Batman does that sometimes. And he should!
3. His Parents' Deaths Are All That Fuel Him
The idea that Batman is a perpetually angsty figure who doesn't have the time for frivolity is often tied into the argument that his whole crime-fighting career is based on unresolved grief over his murdered parents.
To act like the murder of his parents when he was a kid is the only thing that inspires Bruce Wayne to do what he does night in, night out, however, is absurd.
Suggesting somebody only does the right thing - even to an extreme degree - because they're mentally scarred, or working through some issues, or something, is silly. Bruce Wayne was probably always going have that sense of justice, which was instilled in him from an early age anyway. His parents' death was just the catalyst.
2. Batman Is His True Self, Bruce Wayne Is The Mask
Now here's the really strong stuff, the sort of cod-intellectual points coined by armchair psychologists who have read a lot of comic books, have a foggy memory of one Psychology class they took at university, and an inflated sense of self-worth (i.e. they like hearing the sound of their own voice).
Get ready to have your minds blown by this ground-breaking theory, folks. Bruce Wayne died the same day as his parents. That billionaire playboy thing is simply a front. In fact, it is Batman that is his truest self, because that is when he does what he really wants to. As in, fight bad guys, clean up Gotham, that sort of thing.
In that sense Batman is his real face, and Bruce Wayne is the mask. Eh? Eh? Except totally not.
Again, Grant Morrison provided a great example of Batman devoid of Bruce Wayne's humanity in his run on the book, when the character had to reset his brain and for a while was a purely crime fighting being: a violent thug hopped up on crystal meth. Bruce Wayne is integral. He's what keeps Batman grounded, and one day retiring gives him a reason to go on.
1. He's The World's Greatest Detective
Batman's origin story has been told time and again, in dozens of different formats and slightly tweaked takes. In every single one, though, a key part of Bruce Wayne's journey from orphan to superhero involves a round-the-world field trip. That's where he learns to hone both body and mind, training with everyone from master criminals, to boxers, to pick pockets, to martial arts legends, to private detectives.
The physical side of his Batman persona has been well covered, and hasn't been found lacking. The detective part, though, leaves a little to be desired. But there's nobody who will argue otherwise: he's the world's greatest detective. It appears as the byline on comic covers a lot of the time. Heck, he's the star of a series called Detective Comics. A series that's run for nearly a century, no less. And yet it's a misnomer.
Batman really isn't much of a detective a lot of the time. Sure, when he's being written well he is, and if he's appearing in a certain type of story. But really, how much detective work does he do in the Nolan films? Or the Burton ones, for that matter? There's barely any detecting going on at all.
Say Batman isn't a superhero, call him a fun-loving joker, call him the worst member of the Justice League of America. Just don't ever try and argue he's ever a detective, let alone the world's greatest. (That's Sherlock Holmes. Duh.)