10 Subtle Changes That SAVED Iconic Comic Book Characters

Wally Wood's Daredevil redesign changed EVERYTHING.

By John Tibbetts /

When it comes to superheroes, the devil is in the details.

Advertisement

There are about a bajillion things that can go wrong when designing a superhero, whether because there are just so many of them out there that not enough stand out features on a new character will make them fade into the crowd, or because you overlook a bunch of tiny little details that don't work, which end up making the entire house of cards crumble.

Or sometimes you get the design right but there's something about their powers, or their origin, or their supporting cast, that just flat out does not work, and needs to be changed. And it seems like something small, but when a writer comes along and DOES change it, the whole thing starts working like a switch watch.

Sometimes changing just one or two details, no matter how subtle, is all it takes to take a character to the next level. This list is a tribute to those decisions, the parts of our favorite iconic heroes and villains that we all take for granted now, but back when they first debuted, didn't really exist..

10. Discovering Philosophy - The Question

Steve Ditko, as revolutionary as he was throughout the silver age, was one of those writers who was best kept on a leash. You take him off that leash, and you get stuff like his original run on The Question, which debuted in Charlton Comics alongside his other creation, his reboot of Blue Beetle.

Advertisement

The main problem with his original Question series was the same problem that cropped up in certain issues of Spider-Man and even Blue Beetle - that being that Ditko was a sucker for Randian Objectivist philosophy. And if you've ever read a single sentence written by Rand, you'll know why it's almost impossible to get through an issue of that original run without your eyes rolling out of your skull.

The solution to this was as simple as just changing writers. So when The Question came to DC Comics post-crisis, the reins were handed to writer Dennis O'Neil.

Overnight, O'Neil metaphysically killed off the original Vic Sage and started anew. And thus, the Question became more of a philosophical figure instead of just a paragon of objectivist philosophy.

9. Superman's Declining Powers Post-Crisis - Superman

There were many reasons given for rebooting the entire DC universe the first time in Crisis on Infinite Earths, from more general goals like streamlining the DC universe as a whole (by doing away with the DC multiverse altogether), to much more character specific decisions, such as the many alterations made to Superman's comics.

Advertisement

Superman being akin to Santa Claus for a lot of kids - a mythic figure who can just do ANYTHING that you want him to - the Man of Steel had spent years with that mindset being applied to his power-set, with him often just making up new powers on the spot because he's Superman - no sh*t he can do that.

Overtime, this approach (as well as the seemingly unending array of 'Super' characters at the publisher's beck and call), undermined Superman's importance and relatability, and was in part why Crisis came about in the first place.

With the reboot, DC just cut everything but his base power set - heat vision, super strength, indestructible, ice breath, and flight - and reset his mythology to zero to start again. Although certain elements have returned, there's no denying it was an essential change to make to a hero then rapidly losing appeal.

8. Introducing The Parallax Fear Anomaly - Green Lantern

When Green Lantern was rebooted in the silver age DC changed the power ring from having a mystical source to a sci-fi one, being a cosmic embodiment of willpower... that just also happened to be weak to the color yellow. What?

Advertisement

Yeah, for decades Green Lantern was infamous among comics nerds for having one of the all time dumbest weaknesses in the history of the medium. Now in most cases like this, the solution if you want your character to be taken seriously as time goes on would be to just pretend it was never a thing to begin with, because they're comic books, and it is totally okay to just do that.

Instead, they went with a different solution.

See, when they introduced the color spectrum of power rings, they also introduced various deities that represented these types of rings, most notably Parallax. And with him came the minor lore detail known as the Parallax Fear Anomaly.

This is the Green Lantern mythos' small but effective way of explaining why their power rings don't work on things that are yellow. They CAN, under normal circumstances, unless the ring-bearer is incredibly afraid. When that happens, the rings have no effect.

7. The Round Shield - Captain America

The original Captain America shield, as the movie so helpfully showed, was originally - well - a shield. It was angular, sort of diamond shaped, good for blocking bullets but not a lot else.

Advertisement

While Captain America wasn't necessarily in danger of being cancelled, especially after that first issue sold so well, Joe Simon and Jack Kirby quickly realized that the captain needed something a bit more creative, for the sake of excitement if nothing else.

So they redesigned the shield to be a perfectly circular disk shape, as well as simplified the color scheme to instead be two red stripes, two white, and a blue center with a big white star in the middle. This not only made it more easily recognizable, but its disk shape meant that Cap could now throw his shield to take down enemies, making for more creative and dynamic fight scenes.

6. Leaning More Into The Crazy - Deadpool

The best thing that ever happened to Deadpool was Rob Liefeld being kicked off of writing him. Once that happened, the Deadpool we all know and love began to surface.

Advertisement

It's difficult to pin-point a precise moment where this change happened - if anything it was more of a slow dawning realization on the part of the people writing him throughout the late nineties and early 2000s, that a character who can come back from literally anything can be a great vehicle for comedy. (It is worth noting, however, that the first occasion where Deadpool broke the fourth wall came in Joe Kelly's run on the character, in Deadpool #28.)

Thus, Deadpool went from yet another Rob Liefeld creation obviously ripping off Deathstroke, to the dark biting satire of superhero comics that everyone loves.

What makes watching the change in real time throughout Deadpool's early appearances really is how subtle it surprisingly is. After all, basically nothing about his backstory and personality change. he was already pretty casual about his inability to die and the harm he causes others. It's just that the universe around him started treating what was going on as funny instead of with the typical edginess that defined comics in the nineties.

5. Joined The X-Men - Wolverine

Wolverine originally debuted in an issue of The Hulk, as a one-off opponent for the jade giant. After the issue ended, we didn't hear much out of Wolverine, and why would we? He was a bad guy of the month, and once The Hulk was done with him, he'd served his purpose.

Advertisement

But then came along Len Wein and Dave Cockrum.

With the X-Men having laid dormant for several years, Wein and Cockrum decided to reboot the entire team with new and old characters - one of which was Wolverine, who was co-created by Wein in that aforementioned Hulk comic.

Wolverine's base personality went unchanged, but when he was put on a team with characters like Cyclops, Storm, Kitty Pryde, and Jean Grey, Logan's personality and backstory began to flourish.

The results of this speak for themselves, as Wolverine is now one of the most famous characters in the entire Marvel canon. Where would he be today without the X-Men?

4. Forming The Heroes For Hire - Iron Fist And Luke Cage

These days the Marvel Netflix shows have done more than enough to make people love Luke Cage (the less said about what they did to Iron Fist the better), and Iron Fist has been kicking around since the seventies. But there was a time when these two heroes were about to be scrapped for good.

Advertisement

Iron Fist and Luke Cage were both products of the martial arts and blaxploitation film movements of the 1970s, so when martial arts movies and blaxploitation cinema started to die out, Marvel frankly had no idea what to do with either character. The solution was devious in its simplicity: team the two up.

Very little about the two as characters changed, but putting them together in one book - Heroes For Hire - turned their luck around practically overnight. The two characters are alright on their own, but together their chemistry is electrifying.

This one simple change made these two almost forgotten minor heroes into legends of the Marvel universe.

3. Ditched The Batman Comparisons - Green Arrow

People joke about Green Arrow being a knock off of Batman all the time, both in and out of the DC universe, and for good reason: that's exactly what he was when he started out.

Advertisement

Big money, lives in a mansion, young ward, superhero cave, even an arrow themed car to drive around in. It's enough to make one wonder, when they go back to read those original comics, what possessed DC comics to keep such a redundant character around at all?

Well, when Green Arrow was folded into the larger DC universe, they found the perfect spin on the character to separate him from Bruce: have him lose his fortune, and become a hard-travelling lefty in the late 1960s. (Oh, and he also grew a Van Dyke beard, which is pretty important too.)

The change came courtesy of Dennis O'Neil and Neal Adams' Green Lantern/Green Arrow comic, which cast Queen opposite Hal Jordan, a space cop who embodied establishment, conservative politics.

It gave Olly an identity that was all his own, to the point where the biggest gripe people had with the Arrow TV show when it first started out was how it seemed obsessed with being everything that had been holding Green Arrow back to begin with: a ripoff of Batman.

2. Admitted That She Had A Point - Poison Ivy

Ever since her inception, Poison Ivy was intended to be a superpowered commentary on eco-terrorism - someone who took her love for the environment "too far" by escalating it to violence against innocent people or - gasp and horror - the poor guiltless oil barons and forest destroying corporations!

Advertisement

Yeah, if they didn't make some kind of pivot with her FAST, Ivy would not have lasted long in the 2000s. Now that we are mere decades from irreversible ecological disaster, more and more comic writers have made waves to reform Ivy. She's now more of an anti-hero than a straight up bad guy.

Her motivations are still the same, but the universe doesn't immediately vilify her as much as it used to, like the infamous Batman The Animated Series episode where she's somehow the bad guy for turning a woman who ordered the deforestation of a millennia old rainforest for cardboard into a tree.

While she does still occasionally walk in circles with the villains, Poison Ivy's first and foremost priority has been shifted to the protection of the planet, something that's come as a relief to readers, and fans of Ivy especially.

1. Introducing The Red Costume - Daredevil

More than any other entry on this list, this little change was something that Daredevil DESPERATELY needed if he was going to survive in the modern day.

Advertisement

The yellow costume that he debuted in definitely has its charms, but it was an odd choice for a character who lifted his namesake from Satan himself. Leave it to artist Wally Wood to respond, who gave the Man Without Fear his now iconic crimson costume in 1965's Daredevil #7.

The new suit is his now famous solid red skintight body suit with two D's emblazoned on the chest, and two little red horns on the head. It gave Matt a more imposing image while still being bright and colorful, and while the occasional change has been made here or there, Wood's template isn't going away anytime soon.

Daredevil would not have survived with the costume he debuted in, and changing it was most likely what saved the character from disappearing into obscurity forever.

Advertisement