10 Superheroes Screwed Over By Reboots

DC Rebirth and Heroes in Crisis sure did Wally West's Flash dirty, huh?

By John Tibbetts /

If you're a fan of the big two comic publishers then you have long since made peace with the concept of reboots. They've long since become associated with the marketing ploys thinly disguised as narrative shakeups meant to spike up the numbers by completely overhauling every single book in either DC or Marvel's universes. Marvel's done it about once on that scale by now, while DC has done it quite a bit more.

Advertisement

However, a reboot can mean any amount of change to the status quo of a character's universe. The only criteria is that it has to be a reset to zero, whatever form that takes. As such, there have been reboots for characters both big and small. And because there are so many of them, there have been - of course - some MASSIVE stinkers.

Whether because the idea of the reboot was sound but badly executed, a terrible idea from the get go, or the character was doing just fine and didn't NEED a reboot, these superheroes have never been the same ever since editorial decided that the backstory and development their writers had been painstakingly building up was for dumb nerds.

10. Iron Man

Tony Stark is already considered to be obnoxious enough, so it's doubtful turning him into a teenager would have fixed this problem.

Advertisement

This reboot comes to us courtesy of the Avengers storyline The Crossing, in which our original Iron Man was revealed to be a bad guy working for Kang this whole time. If that makes absolutely zero sense to you, good, you still have all your brain cells working, so carry on as normal.

Anyway, to make a long and very dumb story short, defeating Kang requires the aid of Tony Stark...from the past. When he was a teenager. Who they then let stick around because they're already letting the space time continuum die in a pool of its own blood, why not kick in its teeth while it's down?

This reboot of the Iron Man story had teenage Tony Stark take center stage, seemingly to appeal to a younger audience. Which, like a similar later attempt - the cartoon series Iron Man: Armored Adventures - blew up right in their faces and didn't last long at all.

9. Jaime Reyes

While Jaime Reyes has been treated by DC outside of the comics as one of the best character they've ever created (which he is) the comics themselves have not really been kind to him. After the excellent Giffen and Rogers run in the late 2000's, Jaime had to live on through backup stories in the pages of Booster Gold, and while those were all well and good, then came the New 52. And this is where the problems arise.

Advertisement

See, like most of the rebooted series in the New 52, ESPECIALLY the bad ones, the writers behind the new Blue Beetle series couldn't decide whether to continue with business as normal, or make something completely new. Because of this, the New 52 version of Jaime just kinda meanders around, completely lacking the spark and wit that made the original run so fun.

The last time we even saw Jaime before the Rebirth series was in a super obscure DC cosmic book you've definitely never heard of where he was just a one off joke.

8. The Punisher

With the inherently kinda Yikes nature of The Punisher acting as a constant albatross around the character's neck, several writers have tried to find the right spin on him to make it all work better for a modern audience. On the good side of the spectrum we have stuff like the Garth Ennis run, while on the polar opposite end, we have... Punisher Purgatory.

Advertisement

After The Punisher dies yet again, the powers that be decide to bring him back... as an avenging angel of Heaven.

A stretch? Oh definitely, but hey, good writers have made mountains out of less material. Shame then that the writers who kicked off this reboot of the character had basically no idea what to do with him now that they had sprung this new idea on him. Just your typical Punisher shenaniganry, just with an incredibly tacked on supernatural twist.

It could have worked under better writers (as much as anything can), but it's no surprise that The Punisher needed Garth Ennis to come along in order to drag him out of the hellfire.

7. Peter Parker

Spider-Man has had many reboots, many little more than re-establishment of the classic status quo because Spidey is Marvel's biggest cash cow so he'd better look exactly the same all the time.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, those pesky writers kept coming along to give him new adventures where he kept - gasp! - developing as a character. He even got married to Mary Jane, imagine that. But since one of the great traditions of the Spider-Man canon is half honoring/half pissing on the legacy of Gerry Conway, this could not stand any longer.

So, when Joe Quesada became EIC at Marvel and took over Spidey in particular, he decided to undo the whole thing with the reboot story One More Day. Now, was this accomplished via the morally murky waters of a divorce settlement where the dirty laundry of both parties are aired for all to see and deeper, darker layers of these two characters are revealed?

Nope, that might actually be pretty cool. Instead Aunt May gets shot by one of Kingpin's assassins after the events of Civil War revealed Peter's identity, and Pete gives up his marriage to Mary Jane to Mephisto in order to save her.

As a result, both him and Mary Jane have been in character limbo ever since, with Spidey in particular being completely in the muck as a character, a hopeless victim of the status quo for years to come.

6. The Avengers

Hey you know that picture Rob Liefeld drew of Captain America? You know, the side profile one where his chest is twice the width of his head and everything just looks off and horrible? You ever wonder under what idiotic circumstances that would let Liefeld make that accursed abomination?

Advertisement

Well I got the answer, but you ain't gonna like it.

After the event in which Onslaught murdered both The Avengers and the Fantastic Four, Marvel revived and rebooted their entire line with a new creative team, made up exclusively of writers and artists that had left Marvel for Image Comics earlier in the decade.

While some of them worked, like the reboot of the X-Men, others like Avengers: Heroes Reborn were unmitigated disasters, with the Avengers book in particular being one of the worst books in the team's entire decades spanning lifespan to this day.

It isn't hard to see why the book sucked, seeing as how it was the pinnacle of nineties excess for Marvel, and long after said excess began to lose favor with audiences.

5. Starfire

With the final five, we move into the absolute worst of the worst, so let's start with one of the most controversial reboots in comic history: the reboot of Starfire in Red Hood And The Outlaws.

Advertisement

If you grew up with the original Teen Titans show in the early 2000s, then you likely fell in love with the little known DC heroine Starfire. Maybe you even started reading about her in the comics. So when the New 52 rolled around and put Starfire in a mainline book that was getting a ton of press - Red Hood And The Outlaws - DC fans young and old rejoiced.

Then the book came out. And this is where the use of the term "screwed over" becomes uh... ironic. Because not only do they erase Starfire's history with the Titans, but they also make her obsessed with having no strings attached sex with anyone she comes across. Because..."genetics"?

Quite a far cry from the multilayered character fans grew up with in the original comics and the cartoon. And one that later writers have understandably dedicated all of their energies to getting as far away from as they possibly can.

4. Lady Blackhawk

But hey, at least Starfire's still AROUND, right? At least they DID get around to fixing what was wrong with her from the New 52 eventually. That's more than can be said about a ton of heroes out there, most egregious for my money being the lovely Zinda Blake, Lady Blackhawk.

Advertisement

Zinda is a hard partying, hard drinking, hard fighting WWII pilot who was blasted into the future for reasons that are, frankly, unimportant. Because what is important is the fact that Zinda was one of the most fun characters that DC had made in decades (no surprise that she was created by Gail Simone).

So because its whole purpose seemed to be to gut all the fun out of the DC universe, along came the New 52 to wipe her and a ton of other heroes from the Earth.

Maybe one day Lady Blackhawk will come back, who can say. We all thought Wally West was gone for good, but he eventually came back, so anything's possible.

Oh Wally, don't worry, we'll get to you...

3. Stephanie Brown

Oh Steph, the things they've done to you...

Advertisement

Another pre-New 52 character, Stephanie Brown - otherwise known as Spoiler and even Batgirl for a time - Stephanie Brown has the distinction of being heavily disrespected even BEFORE she got rebooted. The most notable case of which being, of course, War Games, where she was brutally murdered and left to die by Leslie Thompkins for DARING to be a superhero and a teenager at the same time.

Fortunately she was brought back shortly thereafter when fans responded to this with unmitigated FURY, and Stephanie was even made into the actual Batgirl. This was by far the best era for the character, and one of the best for the mantle of Batgirl as a whole. Fun, lighthearted, but still with just enough of that dark Gotham edge that makes the bat-family so damn hardcore.

And then the New 52 - the reboot where fun goes to die - undid all of that and restarted the character from scratch. Now, I'm not saying that undoing that idiotic War Games storyline was a BAD thing, but they've kept the character firmly in stasis for fear of losing Barbara Gordon as Batgirl because the status quo rules over all!

2. Wally West

For the longest time, the one and only Flash was Wally West, who took over the mantle when Barry Allen nobly gave his life to saving the world from the Anti-Monitor. There had been talk of bringing Barry back for years, but things like the Justice League cartoon cementing Wally West as the one and only Flash in a lot of fans' head definitely put it off for a few years.

Advertisement

But eventually he DID come back, and of course, when the New 52 rolled around, Wally was erased from the timeline altogether. This was a decision fans hated, but like most decisions fans hated, DC was determined to die on this hill for various stupid reasons.

But one day, to everyone's shock and delight, he finally returned, and got his own snazzy new outfit to go with it! Books like the Flash and Titans at the time really helped get people back in touch with their old pal Wally.

Than Heroes In Crisis happened. By now the events of Heroes In Crisis are notorious, particularly the part where Wally is revealed to have been the murderer of multiple superheroes in a PTSD fueled outburst. He then tried to pin the crime on Harley Quinn and Booster Gold, which he knew wouldn't make any sense, but for various dumb reasons he needed the League running in circles chasing a wild goose.

So DC brought back Wally West... only to make him a mass murderer. What could possibly be worse than that?

1. Most Of The Ultimate Universe

In the early 2000s, Marvel fans were treated to a bold new experiment by Marvel: the Ultimate Universe.

Advertisement

The idea was simple - boil down all of their mainline properties into their most iconic elements and put them in the hands of all star writers and see what they come up with. Giving fans a new version of the Marvel universe that doesn't outright replace the old one, but gives new fans a jumping on point without decades of baggage.

The merits of the Ultimate Universe, especially in its later years, are not what's being discussed here, the fact is that this is a Marvel that a lot of fans grew up with, and thanks to Secret Wars 2015, that universe is gone. Besides Miles and Ultimate Reed Richards - who has rebranded into the supervillain The Maker - the rest of this reimagined Marvel universe has vanished from comics altogether.

Now, granted, the comics have since established that the Ultimate Universe is still out there, but not properly, because we haven't' actually SEEN them come back for real. How could any other hero come close? It's hard to screw over a group of characters more than just wiping them all off the face of the multiverse.

Advertisement