10 Supervillain Replacements That Outshone The Originals

The second Green Goblin is secretly better than the original...

By Paolo Carlos /

In the world of superhero comic books, legacy characters have the honor and burden of continuing the mantle of an individual. The character has to strike a balance between distinguishing himself from his predecessors while keeping true to the title he or she is representing.

Advertisement

For the heroes side, we've seen great examples of this trope such as Miles Morales as Spider-Man, Jaime Reyes as the Blue Beetle, or Damian Wayne as Robin.

But on the other side of the coin, there have been many legacy villains who have done the same as the heroes mentioned and have been successful in their own right. These are the baddies who managed to stand on their own feet with the mantle, while some even managed to surpass their predecessors and become the definitive version of the character.

With that in mind, here are the greatest villain replacements DC and Marvel have showcased throughout the years. As always, there will be spoilers ahead.

10. Crime Master's Jack O' Lantern - Jack O'Lantern

Jason Macendale was a former CIA operative who became a costumed terrorist named Jack O'Lantern - one of the lesser-known Spider-Man villains. Despite this, Macendale would quickly abandon the title and be the second incarnation of the Hobgoblin though would later be killed.

Advertisement

The Jack O' Lantern identity would then be passed down from person to person, from Steven Mark Levins in the 90s, former Mysterio Daniel Berkhart, Maguire Beck, and an unnamed man who claimed to be Steven Levin's brother.

And so this takes us to Crime Master's Jack O'Lantern, who debuted in 2011. As a boy, this unnamed figure killed his parents and became a dangerous assassin. He would then serve as a nemesis towards Flash Thompson's Agent Venom - deducing his identity and targeting those closest to him. He is the most notable among all incarnations due to being the most violent person to wield the title, even killing the previous men who have used the Jack O'Lantern name.

After death, Jack would even become a bigger threat as he'd turn into a supernatural demon who would hollow out the skulls of his victims.

9. Caitlin Snow - Killer Frost

Killer Frost is a recurring DC villain with three women who have taken up the title.

Advertisement

The first is Crystal Frost who first appeared as a Firestorm villain. A freak accident grants her the power to absorb heat and project cold and ice, becoming Killer Frost. She would eventually die from absorbing too much energy, her memory being preserved in the Hall of Justice.

Then we'd get Louise Lincoln as the second incarnation. A friend of Crystal, she recreated the events that turned the deceased woman into a supervillain as she vowed to avenge her and face off against Firestorm.

But the most recognizable version of Killer Frost has got to be Caitlin Snow who first appeared in the New 52. The young doctor merges her body with ice and becomes the supervillain, Killer Frost - joining famous DC teams such as the Suicide Squad and even the Justice League of America.

Adding to this incarnation's popularity is The Flash TV series where she was featured heavily. Played by Danielle Panabaker, Caitlin Snow would be a mainstay throughout the series' nine-year run.

8. Max Dillon - Electro

Nowadays, the name Electro is associated with Spider-Man but this wasn't always the case. In the Golden Age of Comics, he first appeared in 1939 as a robotic superhero. Created by the brilliant and reclusive Professor Philo Zog, Electro was used to fight crime and corruption.

Advertisement

Then in 1954, Ivan Kronov would be the next incarnation of the character - a Soviet soldier who was experimented on to combat Captain America and Bucky Barnes. The procedure would be a success, turning him into an electricity-powered supervillain who would square off against the iconic duo occasionally.

But of course, the title of Electro would then be passed in the 60s into the man known as Max Dillon. He was a lineman struck by lightning while working on a power line which turns him into a living electric capacitor. Dillon then used these newfound abilities to a life of crime and would battle against Spider-Man for decades and become one of the most iconic foes for the Web-Head.

Ultimately, it is interesting to see how the title Electro was passed down to three different characters.

7. Carol Ferris - Star Sapphire

Though now known as a character from the Green Lantern mythos, Star Sapphire initially debuted in The Flash during the Golden Age of Comics. She claimed to be a queen from the 7th Dimension and attempted to conquer the Earth by destroying all plant life.

Advertisement

She'd later be retconned into the Queen of the Zamarons who was banished due to her unworthiness.

The Star Sapphire character would then return in the Silver Age of Comics, this time as a new character, Carol Ferris. As Hal Jordan AKA Green Lantern's love interest, their romance becomes complicated when the Zamarons crown her as the new Star Sapphire. This added a new layer of drama with the character as the two lovers would often cross paths and duel one another. Sadly, Jordan and Ferris would separate with the latter being engaged to another.

Carol would be the definitive version of the character and would return in every major continuity reboot from DC. She has been a mainstay in the Green Lantern storyline and her relationship with Hal Jordan remains the best among DC's love stories.

6. Helmut Zemo - Baron Zemo

Baron Zemo is a Marvel supervillain who first appeared in The Avengers during the 60s. A Nazi and the founder of the Masters of Evil, Heinrich Zemo is considered one of the greatest Captain America villains and is responsible for the death of Bucky Barnes.

Advertisement

His legacy would then continue with his son, Helmut, who would be a more morally gray version of the character.

While Heinrich was killed early during his tenure as Baron Zemo, Helmut would become a recurring character in the Marvel 616 Universe. He initially set out to avenge his father by taking on Captain America but circumstances would lead him to renounce his father's ways and carve his own path as the supervillain.

This is best seen in the original Thunderbolts storyline where Zemo, along with a handful of others, masquerade as superheroes who manage to actually do some genuine good. Unlike his father, Helmut is a well-intentioned extremist - vowing to take over the world for its own betterment and believing that humanity has to be made to improve.

5. Barbara Minerva - Cheetah

The Cheetah is Wonder Woman's most iconic foe and has appeared in the comics since 1943.

Advertisement

In the Golden Age, the character was Priscilla Rich - an aristocratic young woman who dons a Cheetah costume and battles our heroine time and time again. Despite having no superpowers, Rich would be a throne on the Amazon Princess' side yet eventually dies from illness.

Years later, Priscilla's niece, Deborah Domaine would take over the mantle, having the same attributes as her predecessor.

But after Crisis on Infinite Earths changed the DC Universe forever, we would then be introduced to Dr. Barbara Minerva who would become arguably the definitive version of the supervillain.

A wealthy archeologist, she forces an African tribe to perform a ritual on her, one that will grant her powers beyond human capacity. This turns her into the new Cheetah - now sporting orange skin, black spots, a tail, and supernatural strength and reflexes. And though the ritual partially backfires as it leaves her weakened in her human form, this version of the Cheetah would be the first to match Wonder Woman physically.

4. Aaron Davis - The Prowler

The Prowler was initially a title held by inventor Hobie Brown who used his gifts for crime and become an adversary for Spider-Man. Though the two would square off from time to time, Brown would eventually mend fences with the wall-crawler and become a valuable ally to the hero. He'd even star in his own limited solo series in 1994.

Advertisement

Enter the Ultimate Marvel Universe, a revamped version of the comics that allowed writers to tell new stories. This time around, Miles Morales served as the new Spider-Man after the death of Ultimate Peter Parker. The new Prowler, on the other hand, would be Aaron Davis - Miles' uncle who was a career criminal.

This twist was an ingenious one, playing on the importance of the Uncle Ben figure in Spider-Man's life. If Ben taught Peter great power and responsibility, Davis would be the dark inverse of the archetype and be Miles' signature villain. The character's life then came to an end when his gauntlets accidentally killed him.

Since then, Aaron Davis would be used for subsequent adaptations of the Prowler, first as Donald Glover in Spider-Man: Homecoming then by Mahershala Ali in Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse.

3. Shapeshifting Clayface - Clayface

In Detective Comics #40, Basil Karlo was a has-been actor who turned to a life of crime and be the Clayface persona, a character from one of his films. The villain initially was also a grounded Batman villain - without any abilities and only wearing a mask.

Advertisement

It would then take the Silver Age of Comics for the character to truly shine and be the supervillain we all know and fear.

This time around, a man named Matt Hagen fell into a radioactive pool that made him look like mud and granted him shapeshifting powers that enabled him to appear as anyone. And though the character wouldn't be the definitive version of the villain, this rendition would set the standard for the Clayface character onwards.

Since then, Karlo has reclaimed the role of Clayface and would be retconned to have Hagen's shapeshifting and mud-like appearance. Although there would be more people to hold the title, Clayface wouldn't be the villain he is today without Matt Hagen's original turn as the character.

2. Harry Osborn - Green Goblin

Most Spider-Man fans agree that Norman Osborn is the iconic rendition of the Green Goblin. The first to carry the title, he has been a throne to the Web-Head's side and is responsible for causing so much pain such as the death of Gwen Stacey. But after Osborn's demise, it would be his son, Harry that would take the mantle.

Advertisement

Now Harry's already had a rough life, becoming a drug addict during his breakup with Mary Jane Watson but his fate would take a turn for the worse upon transforming into the iconic supervillain.

His turn as the Goblin would be emotional taxing due to his friendship with Peter Parker. In one occasion, Harry even kidnaps MJ, Aunt May, and Flash Thompson with bombs strapped to their heads. The character would then have an on-and-off relationship under the mantle - forgetting he was Goblin and then remembering it all over again.

In the end, however, Harry Osborn would choose to do the right thing during his final confrontation with Spider-Man, when he decides to rescue Mary Jane and his son, Normie. Harry then succumbed to the Goblin Formula but would make peace with Peter before he died.

1. Eobard Thawne - Reverse Flash

Believe it or not, there was an early version of the Reverse Flash character in the form of Edward Clariss in the 1940s. Known as The Rival or Rival Flash, he served as the evil counterpart of Jay Garrick's Flash and had recreated the formula that gave Garrick his trademark superspeed.

Advertisement

Years later, when this Flash character was revamped into the Silver Age with the introduction of Barry Allen, a new version of the Rival would be introduced. This time around, Eobard Thawne is a scientist from the 25th century who becomes obsessed with ruining the Scarlet Speedster's life upon finding out that he is destined to be the hero's greatest arch-nemesis.

He would then adopt the name Reverse Flash and becomes motivated to travel through time to destroy Allen's life.

The villain has proven to be a formidable foe for The Flash for years - from killing Iris West and even being responsible for the death of Barry's mother, Nora Allen. He has been featured in different DC adaptations and is considered one of the fastest speedsters in the DC Universe.

Advertisement