10 Terrifying Joker Stories You Never Read

It's not all about the Killing Joke, you know...

By Chris Joyce /

The Joker.

Advertisement

Everyone interprets that name differently, feels a slightly different shudder, evokes contrasting connotations of dread... but the net result is the same: fear.

We all recoiled in horror when he paralysed Barbara Gordon in The Killing Joke, and held our collective breath when, after murdering an entire talk show crowd, he proceeded to snap his own neck in The Dark Knight Returns.

But what of his lesser-known exploits, those horrifying stories you may not have read?

The Joker is undoubtedly Batman’s greatest, most detested foe - one with no super, meta, nor supernatural powers to speak of, but whose notoriety and legend are born of his complete lack of human emotion. However, there is still a sense of the familiar with the character, owing to the fact that he's by far the most prolific villain in DC's comics.

This is what makes those lesser-known tales featuring the Clown Prince of Crime so special, as it rekindles those terrifying first memories every fan had the first time they encountered the character. Hidden gems by any other name.

Here, then, are ten of the most deplorable, most terrifying Joker stories you've never read...

10. Joker (2008)

Taking its lead from Heath Ledgers' portrayal of the Joker from Christopher Nolan’s The Dark Knight movie, opting for a Chelsea smile and make up over a chemical-induced rictus grin, this heightened sense of realism only served to magnify the palpable sense of fear within this graphic novel’s pages.

Advertisement

Inexplicably released from Arkham Asylum and keen to rebuild his criminal empire, the Joker, with help from his loyal driver Johnny Frost, sets out in search of - who else - Harlye Quinn, this now moonlighting as a dancer in a seedy club.

Encountering real life versions of Waylon Jones/Killer Croc, Harvey Dent, the Riddler and more in this dark and disturbing graphic novel, the Joker’s acts of murder and butchery are terrible, heightened by the ultra realism of Lee Bermejo’s incredible art work.

In perhaps the most iconic sequence in the book, Joker takes one of his former lieutenants, Monty, backstage at the club Harley dances at, skins him alive, shoves the flayed yet still breathing man onto the stage, then slaps a dollar onto his skinned ass as he falls on his face dead under the stage lights.

This occurs early as the Joker looks to send a message to all would-be usurpers, and sets a brutal tone for the rest of this classic book.

9. The Man Who Laughs

An severely under-appreciated and oft overlooked story, The Man Who Laughs is truly the stuff of nightmares.

Advertisement

Set in a time period when the Joker is still an unknown quantity to both Batman and Gotham in general, the discovery of his first crime scene is enough to reduce battle-hardened GCPD veterans to vomiting, traumatised wrecks.

Mutilated, twisted, barely recognisable as human corpses are wheeled out of an abandoned factory unit, their unseeing, dead eyes are the very antithesis of their maniacal laughing faces.

As the Joker begins to emerge into the public consciousness, threatening to kill prominent members of Gotham City’s ruling class - including a certain Mr Wayne - by inflicting upon them the same chemically-induced death as the unfortunate transients from the factory, the city is in a perpetual state of panic.

Nothing is ever as it seems with the Joker, so expect twists, turns, and misdirects throughout this tale of terror, which all lead inexorably to a final showdown with the Dark Knight which is as brutal and visceral as the rest of the book.

A true horror masquerading as a superhero title, The Man Who Laughs will etch itself into your psyche as truly as a knife through the heart.

8. No Man's Land

Sometimes, one act of true horror is all it takes to elevate (or relegate, depending on how you look at it) an otherwise by the numbers story to true horror status.

Advertisement

A supporting, ensemble role often allows ample room for the Joker to horrify us with his uniquely chaotic brand of violence.

In the No Man’s Land story arc, Gotham has been cut off from the mainland after the destruction of its bridges, and soon descends into anarchy and chaos.

Whilst appearances from Huntress, Poison Ivy, Bane and even Superman keep the storyline broad and not as Joker-centric as others on this list, it is our man who leaves the most lasting, most sickening impression.

Kidnapping all of Gotham’s babies - an act of abject depravity in and of itself - Joker forces Sarah Essen-Gordon (what is it about Joker and the Gordon family?) to chose between stopping him, or saving the life of one of the infant hostages who is unceremoniously thrown in Sarah’s direction.

Not a conscious decision but a primal human reaction, Sarah saves the child.

Her reward for doing so?

Joker shoots her in the head.

7. The Clown At Midnight

The Clown at Midnight demonstrates once again the black depths of the Joker’s heart, and shows in technicolour his absolute lack of human emotion.

Advertisement

Recovering from a gunshot wound to the face, the Clown Prince of Crime announces his plan to unveil the latest iteration of himself to Gotham at midnight, and the Batman is invited to this macabre shin-dig.

His most loyal ally and on-off lover Harley Quinn is tasked with killing all of the Joker’s former lackeys and lieutenants, taking pieces off the board and wiping the slate clean for organised crime in Gotham.

Delivering poisoned roses to henchmen city-wide, Harley carries out her task with the deference and zeal you would expect.

That is, of course, until she learns of the Joker’s true plan.

Planning to rid himself of all of his former captains, Harley finds herself in the Joker’s cross-hairs as the penny drops that she is to be the central attraction in Joker’s midnight special.

Saved only by the inevitable intervention of a certain Dark Knight, Harley comes to understand her true worth in the eyes of her ‘Puddin: absolutely nothing.

Joker’s willingness to elaborately murder those he supposedly cares about (in as much as he can truly care about anyone), purely to gain the attention of the Batman once again paints a harrowing picture of an unpredictable and remorseless killer.

6. Gotham Central: Soft Targets

As a general rule, it is perhaps fair to say that art which imitates real life, or at least skirts uncomfortably close to reality, is more effective and more visceral than more fantastical examples of creative expression.

Advertisement

In this regard, Soft Targets is perhaps the most terrifying Joker story of all.

Gotham at Christmas time is an understandably busy city. Families walking hand in hand past husbands out buying presents for their wives, while snow falls and colourful lights blink.

Gunshots ring out.

Using a high-powered sniper rifle and seemingly choosing his targets at random, Joker indiscriminately murders regular citizens who pose him no threat and have committed no wrong.

Gotham is on high alert, as nobody knows who the shooter is and haven’t yet entertained the notion that it could be the Joker.

The level of violence in evidence here, the juxtaposition of the Christmas setting with the bodies on the streets, their blood turning the snow red, and the uncomfortable yet inevitable parallels with real life atrocities make for a genuinely horrifying ride.

A shocking, nightmarish vision, Gotham Central: Soft Targets remains one of the most terrifying Joker stories ever committed to print.

5. Brave And The Bold #31

Diagnosed with a rare disease curable only by extreme microscopic intervention, The Atom accepts the mission to enter the Joker’s brain via his ear canal and administer the treatment.

Advertisement

Once inside, however, things take a terrible turn.

Having already been informed by the medical team that he may witness some of the Joker’s memories whilst inside his brain, The Atom was not prepared for the level of depravity to which he bore witness.

Immersed in Joker’s childhood memories, The Atom witnessed playground violence culminating in the child who would be Joker splitting open another kid’s head with zero remorse.

He saw the killing of animals by the troubled youngster, and watched in horror as, whilst arguing about the monster their son was becoming, Joker’s parents were burned alive inside their locked home by none other than… well, you can probably guess.

Later memories saw the Joker as a young man turn a simple robbery into a murder scene and, when his horrified partner in crime showed his shock and disgust at this escalation, he unflinchingly kills him too.

Perhaps worst of all for The Atom, having administered the life-saving treatment to the pale-faced psychopath, he throws his hands over his mouth in horror as he unwittingly utters the same words said by the young Joker in a violent memory.

4. Batman #23.1: Joker

Another book, another version of the Joker’s history.

Advertisement

Batman 23.1 deals with Joker’s childhood as a malnourished, abused, frightened child raised by his deplorable Aunt Eunice.

With only his stuffed toy Jackanapes for company, this poor, tormented soul is beaten, bullied, insulted and tormented by his guardian.

Seeing his unkempt appearance and filthy countenance, Aunt Eunice scrubs the child clean with a wire brush and a bottle of bleach “right down to your clogged pores”, turning his skin a pallid white.

Recreating these childhood traumas using live animals from a Gotham City Zoo, the adult Joker once again sets out to terrorise the fair city and sow destruction and carnage in his wake.

It is not the Joker’s modern day criminal exploits which send chills down the readers’ spines, though, but the virtually colourless flashback scenes.

His Aunt, who openly brags about the brutal way in which she killed her Husband - Joker’s Uncle - is a rare breed of villain.

Starving, beating, humiliating and belittling a child to the point at which he himself becomes a monster like the Joker, the pain and trauma of his childhood is visible in the adult Joker’s eyes, is truly a harrowing thread to pull at.

Of course, there's a very good chance he just made the whole thing up.

3. Batman: Nosferatu

Long time DC Comics readers are all too aware that tales of the Joker’s origin and early history can be contradictory and unreliable at best, and that truly unique, unambiguous, fresh takes on the formula are rare specimens indeed.

Advertisement

Enter Batman: Nosferatu.

This Elseworlds tale eschews the traditional Joker and instead presents the reader with the nightmarish creature known as the Laughing Man.

A pale skinned chimera, built by the villainous Doctor Arkham from the body parts of countless deceased Asylum patients, this cyborg killing machine has more than a little of The Terminator in its DNA.

On the orders of his master, Dr Arkham, the Laughing Man is sent to kill anybody who threatens his Asylum and the nefarious work he performs within, and to subsequently put a violent end to any who do learn of his malevolent ways.

The Joker has arguably been devoid of any semblance of humanity and the capacity to experience true human emotions in every iteration of the character to date, but never before has it been so literal, so visceral, and so downright terrifying.

The Laughing Man is not a man at all, but a ghoul spliced together by a madman from the very flesh of the criminally insane.

2. Whatever Happened To The Caped Crusader?

A very weird book narrated by the deceased Batman, the version of the Joker presented here flips everything we thought we knew on its head.

Advertisement

Seeing Bruce struggle in his early years as the Bat of Gotham, failing to apprehend criminals and prevent their crimes, loyal Butler Alfred devises a plan to focus Bruce, encourage him, and keep him motivated and confident in his crime-fighting endeavours.

Alfred becomes The Joker.

Via the use of elaborate make up and costumes, Alfred presents Bruce with an arch-nemesis, a villain with whom to lock horns and channel his rage.

What questions does this raise about Alfred’s mental state? Does rationalising that he is only doing it for Bruce lesson his disturbing behaviour?

Seeing the merit in this crazy idea, Alfred goes so far as to hire his old actor friends to take up similar outlandish mantles: The Scarecrow, Catwoman, The Penguin.

Against this thespian-shaped whetstone, Batman’s skills are sharpened, his methods honed to he point he actually does become the hero Gotham needs.

Cue Alfred’s most intense actor friend, Eddie Nash.

A method actor to the last, Nash becomes so embroiled in his character - The Riddler - that he kills Batman during a hostage situation.

Alfred - The Joker - in trying to save Bruce, is inadvertently responsible for his death.

1. Batman Elseworlds: Two Faces

Perhaps the most bizarre, unnerving, and undoubtedly terrifying Joker stories of all time, Batman: Two Faces begins in ordinary enough circumstances.

Advertisement

A gala exhibiting a rare flower - the Twilight Orchid - descends into chaos when Two Face attempts to steal the rare and powerful specimen, killing Pamela Isley in the process.

Bruce, who was unable to prevent this tragedy, creates a serum derived from the orchid to rid Two Face of his dual personality affliction.

Testing it on himself, Bruce discovers he has imbued himself with superhuman strength and abilities, unaware of a devastating side effect.

Using his new-found power to fight crime and rid the city of those who would do it harm, a spate of grizzly murders of women comes to Bruce’s attention. Mutilated, smiling corpses point to a pale, hysterically laughing maniac who has begun to stalk the streets of Gotham.

A dark game of cat (bat?) and mouse ensues, as the fledgling crime fighter fails to locate this giggling horror, until an horrific realisation dawns on Bruce; in attempting to cure Harvey Dent of his dual personality, he has instead created one of his own: The Joker.

Bruce Wayne, Batman, the Joker... One and the same.

Like Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde come to Gotham, Bruce is the one committing these abhorrent, violent crimes against the women of the city, including one Selina Kyle, as his hitherto unacknowledged alter-ego the Joker.

Unable to live with the guilt, the shame, and the horror he has unleashed, Bruce ultimately takes his own life, destroying both Batman and the Joker in one last act of courage.

Advertisement