10 Things DC Comics Want You To Forget About Two-Face

The skeletons in the closet of everyone's favourite disfigured villain.

By Tom Baker /

"What's the most you ever lost on a coin toss?" That's not an exact Harvey Dent quote, but he's probably said things close to that, and we just got done re-watching No Country For Old Men. That Anton Chigurh, eh? Chilling. The most memorable villain to ever spring from the Coen Brothers' minds might have been without his most infamous affectation, however, were it not for the influence of Two-Face. A member of Batman's rogues gallery since the Dark Knight's introduction in the forties, the former District Attorney was disfigured with acid by a disgruntled gang member, forcing him to bring his now twisted former on justice down on Gotham City. He also has either a neat tailor or is a dab hand at the sewing machine to produce all of those half-and-half suits that he wears. And they perfectly align with the split between the scarred and normal sides of his face! Quite the skill. Like The Joker, Poison Ivy and the rest of the Batman's best villains, Harvey Dent is a bundle of quirks, gimmicks and idiosyncrasies that add up to make one colourful, memorable bad guy. Or anti-hero. Depends how he's feeling that day. He has those suits, white on one side and dark on the other; there's his tragic past, where once he was aligned with the likes of Commissioner Gordon and Bruce Wayne; but most of all there's Two-Face's method of meting out justice at the flip of a scratched coin, the result of which decides his victims' fate. DC Comics would not leave such momentous decisions to chance. As such a visible part of the Batman mythos - especially given his appearance in the Dark Knight film, played with panache and suitable gravitas by Aaron Eckhart - they've done their best to keep a consistent, singular version of the character on the page. The guy with the coin, the twisted anti-hero, trapped forever in his dual identities. Which means having to put aside a lot of Harvey Dent's sixty year history. Here's ten things DC Comics would rather you forget about Two-Face.

10. The Existence Of Plastic Surgery

Superhero comics operate with a strange sort of logic. The concept of comic book death has it that any major (or even minor) character who kicks the bucket can and probably will eventually be resurrected, through some combination of the sci-fi tech, magic or continuity fixes which are the norm in the fantastical world of cape comics. That is, unless the character's death is an important narrative device, like that of Batman's parents; Bruce Wayne is fuelled by their murders to become the Dark Knight, and in his time he's come across numerous ways he could bring them back to life, but never has. Because it'd ruin the story. The same is true, in a smaller way, for Harvey Dent. In a DC Universe which has clones, the Lazarus Pit and people with reality-warping superpowers, "fixing" the scars that transformed him into Two-Face would be a doddle. In fact you could do it with stuff we have in the real world - skin grafts and plastic surgery have advanced to the point that people with such disfigurements can have their faces put back almost exactly how they were before. There have been a couple of times where DC admits to this glaringly obvious option to rehabilitate Harvey Dent, but it's not really worked out either time. In both contemporary stories and Frank Miller's future-flung Dark Knight Returns, Two-Face has been temporarily "cured" of both his facial scarring and his insanity only for the latter to return and convince him to bring back the former, often in gruesome fashion. As bringing back Thomas and Martha Wayne would, reuniting the two faces of Harvey Dent would ruin the character. Poor guy, his happiness squandered by the demands of telling a good story.

9. Lando Calrissian Was Meant To Play Him In A Film

It seemed that, for a time, Tim Burton was going to tell the first complete, long-form Batman story on screen a good twenty years before Christopher Nolan got anywhere near the director's chair. In the 1989 film about the caped crusader - the first of the modern superhero movies, really - Burton introduced scores of important elements of the Batman mythos, including hints at future installments in what was to be an ongoing franchise. One of those elements was Billy Dee Williams' part as Harvey Dent, the District Attorney who liaises with Commissioner Jim Gordon over the costumed freaks plaguing Gotham City. Williams believed he was signed on for multiple films eventually culminating in the actor portraying the villainous Two-Face. Which would have been super cool both because we would have loved to have seen Williams' version of the character, and because they would have made sure the transformation from hero to bad guy was especially tragic, since audiences would have seen him on the side of the good for two films. Except then his character got cut out of the follow up film, Batman Returns, entirely. Wesley Strick's rewrite of the script actually excised a scene where Dent flipped a coin, heavily foreshadowing at his fall from grace in the next film. That next film, of course, was Batman Forever. Burton left the series, as did most of its stars, and in amongst all the recasting hoopla Williams had his chance at playing Two-Face torn straight from his hands by Tommy Lee Jones in one of his hammiest and most forgettable performances. A great shame and, considering his age and Eckhart's time in the part, we'll probably never see what Lando Calrissian could have brought to the role.

8. He Disappeared For Twenty Years

Two-Face wasn't always such a vital part of Batman's shadowy cabal of enemies. In fact, Harvey Dent was almost entirely absent from DC Comics for over a decade. Following his introduction in 1942's Detective Comics #66, the character only appeared a handful of times in the forties and fifties before disappearing entirely. The creative team didn't really know what to do with the character once they'd figured out his gimmick (which was noticeably less nuanced than it is nowadays, as we'll find out later), and so simply didn't use him as much. They were also bound by changing trends in the world of comics publishing, itself inspired by the strict censorship of the Comics Code Authority which controlled the content of all mainstream funnybooks. A violent, chaotic and hideous villain such as Two-Face would probably have failed to pass the CCA's checklist of suitable content for kids, and DC were skewing more towards that younger demographic anyway. He was dropped in favour of more "kid friendly" villains, because we guess The Joker is somehow less terrifying to a toddler than a guy with a weird face flipping a coin. He did make one brief, notable appearance in 1968's World's Finest #173, the Superman-Batman team-up book, where the caped crusader copped to him being his most feared enemy, due to his unpredictability. It wasn't until the early seventies that the character was fully revived, however, as Dennis O'Neil and Neal Adams took control of the Batman titles and returned them to their darker, pulpier origins, installing Two-Face as one of the character's arch enemies. We're glad he made it through the wilderness (he made it through-oo-oo-oo).

7. When He Was Defender Of Gotham

The One Year Later storyline was one of the contemporary occasions where DC deigned to let Harvey Dent have plastic surgery and return to some sort of an ordinary life. Well, perhaps not ordinary, because during Batman's absence following the Infinite Crisis crossover Dent was entrusted with the safety of Gotham City. Which, as you can imagine, went about as well as entrusting the safety of a city to a known psychopath and murderer would do. Especially one you've just trained up in martial arts and detective skills. Satisfied with his abilities following a team-up against Mr Freeze and Firebug, Batman leaves the city in Dent's capable hands, only to return to a right old mess. A string of mysterious killings involving lesser members of his rogues gallery like KGBeast, Magpie, The Ventriloquist had occurred, each of them slain by a double-barrelled shotgun that was the preferred weapon of one Two-Face. Which isn't quite what the Dark Knight had in mind when he assured Dent that taking on a vigilante role would allow him to atone for his own past crimes. So it turns out Dent very much proves the "you can't teach an old supervillain new tricks" adage, as his time as Gotham's protector beneath a cowl was marred by his - ahem - more "extreme" methods of dealing with the scum that plague the city's streets. Batman's return exacerbates the re-emergence of his Two-Face persona and, when confronted over the villains' murders, Dent detonates a bomb and runs away without giving a real answer. An answer we never got and never will, since nobody has spoken of this little episode since.

6. He's Father To Twins

Two-Face Strikes Twice is the Batman comics take on Kramer vs Kramer. Which doesn't sound particularly exciting when you put it like that, but it is still a Batman comic, meaning there's plenty of BIFFs, POWs and WHAMs alongside the custody battles. The conflict central to the 1993 story arc was between Harvey Dent and his ex-wife Gilda, as he becomes convinced the reason their marriage failed was because he was unable to give her children. As if, y'know, the whole scarred supervillain thing wouldn't have been reason enough for the divorce courts to send their case speeding through. In a particularly galling bit of irony Gilda marries Paul Janus, whose surname recalls the Roman god who had two faces. Smooth move, Gilda. Jealous that some new guy is straying onto two pieces of his turf (his ex-wife and his gimmick), Two-Face resolves to frame Paul by kidnapping him, replacing him with a doppelganger and having said double disfigured with acid the same way he was. That way Paul wouldn't look any better than him, and Gilda would start wondering why this seems to keep happening to her. In the course of the story it transpires that the former Mrs Dent, having been reunited with Paul after Batman inevitably foiled Two-Face's terrible plan, is pregnant. When she gives birth to twins - yes, twins - Harvey once again breaks out of Arkham and this time abducts the tykes, believing them to be Janus's. Except, it turns out, they're actually his children, created using sperm he had frozen when he was DA and was constantly receiving death threats. Why Gilda decides to impregnate herself all those years later is never really explained, but Two-Face loses his will to fight and releases his twin babies. He returns to jail, Gilda returns to Paul, and none of this was ever mentioned ever again. We suppose stories of Two-Face chaperoning the kids on the weekends he gets custody wouldn't have been all that exciting...

5. He Hates All The Robins

If you join all the dots, Harvey Dent is more of an arch enemy to Batman's sidekicks than to the Dark Knight himself. Over the years Two-Face has been a constant menace to the various orphans who have take up the role of Robin, perhaps hinting that he doesn't really like kids, so it's probably best he had nothing to do with those twins of his. That is, if the way he's treated Dick Grayson, Jason Todd and Tim Drake is anything to go by. In the Robin: Year One storyline he tricks the young Grayson into a scenario where he has to chose to save the life of either Batman or Gotham Judge Lawrence Watkins. It turns out it's a trick to mess with the kid's head, as he unleashes a Batarang that cuts down both Bats and Watkins from their nooses, only for Watkins to plummet into the open water that was secretly beneath him and drown. Not content with the psychological scars he's just inflicted on the poor kid, Two-Face then orders his henchman to beat the stuffing out of him. Perhaps worse was the effect he had on controversial second Robin Jason Todd's life, since it was Dent who killed his father and orphaned him. To be fair, the elder Todd had been a hired goon for he supervillain, and was dispatched following a botched job, but it still mightily screwed up the kid and lead him to be a terrible sidekick to the Dark Knight and later a crazed villain. The third Robin, Tim Drake, has thankfully never been too battered - emotionally or otherwise - by Two-Face, besides your average ass-whupping during his and Batman's ongoing battles against him. Damian was spared the courtesy, too, so maybe he's broken out of the cycle and returned to being a Batman villain, rather than a Robin one.

4. He's A Total Rip-Off

We know we're starting to sound like a broken record at this point, and there's that whole "there's nothing new under the sun" thing, but seriously now. Not content with biting on The Shadow in their creation of Batman and copy a Conrad Veidt look for The Joker, Dark Knight co-creators Bill Finger and Bob Kane also purloined the pop culture of the recent past in putting together Harvey Dent's look, gimmick and MO too. Robert Louis Stevenson's Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde wasn't particularly recent when Two-Face first appeared in the early forties, but artist Kane says that he pretty much ripped off the 1931 film version from his childhood for the look of his new villain, simply combining the pre-and-post-transformation looks of Fredric March into one ghastly visage. The good/evil dual personality of Jekyll and Hyde also figured into the unpredictability of the early Two-Face, who could do either righteous or nefarious deeds depending on what a coin toss told him. The other major influence in Dent's origin actually came from another pulp hero whom Finger and Kane had strip mined for parts in the creation of their most enduring superhero. The Black Bat was a crime-fighting vigilante with a bat costume, so a lawsuit between his publishers and DC was somewhat inevitable. What the courts failed to notice was that Two-Face's origin was totally ripped off from the Black Bat, too, who was a District Attorney that was disfigured by an acid attack from a criminal in court and so decided to take the law into his own hands. Which should sound familiar, if you've been paying any sort of attention.

3. His Obsession With Twos Was A Little Goofy

As we said up top, the coin toss is one of the most simple and chilling aspects of Javier Bardem's assassin character in No Country For Old Men, and that's ripped off wholesale from Two-Face. More than any other member of Batman's rogues gallery, the morality and duality of Harvey Dent and his criminal enterprises are complex and nuanced, a skilfull balance of genuine insanity and a good man driven to do bad things. That duality is encapsulated in his coin, one side scratched, which he flips to decide almost every action in his life - but usually, and most dramatically, to decide what happens to those who cross him. The coin itself has its own dark backstory, introduced alongside Dent's history of childhood abuse in Batman: Year One. It turns out that Harvey's father used to beat him on a regular basis, but the likelihood of him getting a pasting relied on where that coin ended up; later, imbued with all that significance and violent psychic energy, the coin becomes as complex a totem as the character of Two-Face himself. Which is pretty cool, and absolutely not what the Two-Face character started out as. It wasn't the duality that was his gimmick but the number two. We're not getting all Sesame Street sponsor on you, lots of Two-Face's early appearances were brought to you by the number two, like robbing buildings with "2" in the address, or only committing crimes when the time's 22:22. It was goofy as heck, even for Golden Age superhero comics, and also made it incredibly easy for Batman to solve any and all crimes he was involved in. Because they always involved the number two. If Two-Face had stuck with this number thing, you can bet The Dark Knight would have been a lot less po-faced and dramatic. Maybe more educational.

2. The Four Other Two-Faces (Ten-Face?)

The biggest skeleton in Harvey Dent's closet might be that he isn't the only person to have been Two-Face. In fact he wasn't even the first, since when he debuted in 1942 - with the DA background, acid attack and all - he was named Harvey Kent, who was later retconned to be both Harvey Dent and also a separate character called Harvey Kent...? Yeah, we're not sure about that one either, but it probably doesn't count any more so we can just forget about that. Anyway, this original Two-Face was given a happy ending to his story after just three appearances as he was given surgery to return his face to normal, and testimony given by Batman himself was enough for Gotham City to absolve him of all crimes committed under his supervillain guise. A couple of years later, however, DC realised they kinda liked the character. Instead of subjecting Dent/Kent to another fall from grace, however, they made the new Two-Face an actor also happened to fall prey to an attack whilst in the witness stand. Harvey Apollo was driven to madness by his disfigurement, and so took on a life of crime. That is until the writers behind Batman totally forgot about him and, in 1948, introduced yet another Two-Face. This time he turned out to be Harvey Dent's butler in disguise, trying to convince the world his erstwhile employer had returned to a life of crime. Of course Batman, world's greatest detective, soon figured out his ploy and cleared Dent's name. In 1951 the character turned up yet again. This time it was another actor, Paul Sloane, who was supposed to play Two-Face in a movie fictionalising the villain's activities. Except the acid in the courtroom scene was real, because the prop master was jealous of the actor's good looks. Less than a year later another actor took the part, hoping to frame Dent again, to no avail. By Detective Comics #81, Harvey Dent became Two-Face again, and we all tried to move on from these interlopers for the sake of our own sanity.

1. That He Ever Existed

DC's New 52 initiative saw the reboot and rethinking of many of their titles and characters, for better or for worse. In the Batman line of comics the main characters remained mostly unchanged, save for the healing of long-crippled Barbara Gordon. The caped crusader's villains, meanwhile, were host to a series of radical reinventions, from Harley Quinn taking on her...non-traditional costume from the Arkham videogame series to The Joker cutting his face of for reasons we still don't quite understand. The biggest change was reserved for Harvey Dent. Far from the white knight out to rescue Gotham City from the gutter, the Dent we meet in the New 52 universe is right down there with them, a defense attorney who uses every dirty trick in the book to get his uniformly guilty criminal clients off. It's only after getting tied to the sociopathic twin sisters from the McKillen crime family, Shannon and Erin, that Dent gets forced into being a good guy. Bruce Wayne funds his campaign to District Attorney, hoping to keep him from getting involved with the twins' criminal activities and to apply his knowledge of legal loopholes to keeping bad guys off the streets. Naturally that all goes down the pan as soon as he has the McKillen sisters committed to a maximum security prison, where one of them promptly kills herself. The surviving twin breaks out of the jail, tracks down Dent, and seeks revenge by murdering his wife before his eyes and then pouring acid all over his face. After she flees the country Dent, as Two-Face, takes control of the McKillen crime family in Gotham and runs it until Erin returns to wrestle it back from him. After jailing Erin before Two-Face can enact his own form of justice upon her, Batman tries to stop Dent's own criminal escapades, attempting to talk him down by reminding him of all the good he did as DA. Refusing to listen to reason, the villain nevertheless admits to knowing Bruce Wayne's secret identity but keeping it to himself and not killing him, despite being tempted to do both. Then he goes home and shoots himself in the head. So, er, yeah. In the New 52, Harvey Dent killed himself at the end of Batman and Two-Face #28 from February 2014. He was alive during the Forever Evil crossover event, but we're still unsure about the timing of that, so either DC wants us to forget that he's supposed to be dead or want us to just discount his existence at all. Because he's dead. Quite an ignoble fate for one of Batman's greatest villains. What were the chances of that?