10 Things Everyone Always Gets Wrong About Comic Books

Why is one of the most influential mediums so misunderstood?

By Ewan Paterson /

DC Comics

The comic book medium is one of the brightest and most inventive entertainment mediums currently going, and in a zeitgeist permanently preoccupied with superheroes, it's little wonder that the comics industry is still going strong to this day.

Advertisement

Universally adored, read and critiqued, whether it's the Big Two of Marvel and DC or the other publishers that round out the industry, you can guarantee that something interesting is always happening when it comes to comics. Whether it's the discourse surrounding their publication or the actual stories themselves, readers and non-fans alike always have something to say. Unsurprisingly, not all of it tends to be correct.

Misconceptions may abound in various other mediums, but with comics arguably at their most popular, it's little wonder that critics have taken aim at the industry. Even longtime fans - ostensibly - manage to contribute to the general spread of misinformation, and whether that be through the toxic culture of gatekeeping, or even sometimes through their own ignorance regarding a particular topic, the simple truth of the matter is that comics are just generally rather misunderstood.

Advertisement

Irrespective of the genre or medium, there are just some things that need to be addressed head on. Here are the mistakes everyone seems to make...

10. That The Industry Is 'Dying'

DC Comics

Almost every single year, fans tend to prophesies the death of the comics industry. So the old argument goes, sales are declining every year and, sooner or later, Marvel and DC will just stop publishing books altogether. The actual reality, however, couldn't be further from these claims, with the industry arguably in one of its healthiest positions in years.

Advertisement

There are genuine issues, and it's doubtful that the industry will ever approach the numbers generated by the speculator boom of the nineties, but it's by no means apocalyptic. 2019 has already gotten off to a great start, and although the direct market is prone to the occasional stutter, sales in trade paperbacks and collections rose as much as 5% this February, a healthy increase on the same time last year, and with the increasing profile of the MCU, it's likely that more and more viewers will turn into readers as the years go on.

Again, there are genuine issues: the direct market is archaic, while local comic book shops are struggling as chain stores and the likes of Amazon move in; Marvel and DC have also struggled to promote their books effectively over the years, leaving it to creatives to pick up the slack when books can often live or die on just a couple of issues. There's also an issue with the overall affordability of comics themselves, with prices seemingly rising every year, and this all contributes to the sense that comics are fairly inaccessible.

Advertisement

Of course, there are also those who seem to claim that the industry is on its knees as a result of the big two's burgeoning commitment to diversify their stories, but that literally could not be any further from the truth. Comics are for everyone, and those who perpetuate that myth are incapable of understanding the value of representation, especially when it's proven that comic book readers span various genders, sexualities, races and ages.

9. They're Not "True Literature"

DC

One would've thought that the industry's biggest critics would've moved on from their old line of attack - that comics aren't as sophisticated as classic novels - a long time ago, but the perception still persists to this day.

Advertisement

Whether it's because people think superheroes are childish, or even just that the presence of images makes them 'easier' to read than a traditional black and white novella, the medium's biggest critics tend to decry superhero comics in particular as cartoonish, irreverent and unintelligent. Over thirty years on from the release of Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons' Watchmen - a book counted among Time Magazine's 100 Greatest Novels of all Time - creators and fans alike face an uphill climb trying to convince certain groups that comics are a proper art-form, read by a diverse range of people.

Advertisement

Children get dissuaded from reading funny books by teachers who don't think they're intellectually stimulating, while various artists in school are taught to shy away from the medium altogether, with superheroes deemed a childish distraction. It's so disheartening, especially because some of the best stories ever told can be found in the pages of a comic book.

Marvel, DC and countless other publishers have been busy creating modern mythologies for the past century, and while not every book ends up being a nuanced masterpiece, you'd struggle to find a medium as creative or as boundless in its scope.

Advertisement

8. It's All Just Superheroes

Image Comics

Marvel and DC might specialise in the superhero genre, but that's not the only card hidden up their respective sleeves. Both publishers have specialised in horror, western, war and even romance comics in the past, and while superheroes have featured in those genres too, comics are not their unique preserve.

Advertisement

In actual fact, some of the most lauded works in the medium have absolutely nothing to do with superheroes. Maus, Art Spiegelman's written account of his father's experience during the Holocaust, was the first graphic novel to win a Pulitzer Prize.

Later works, such as The Walking Dead, Saga, Scott Pilgrim, Tank Girl and Fables would all experience immense success across various mediums, while the likes of Archie and Tales from the Crypt would do the same decades earlier.

Advertisement

Although it's easy to criticise superhero comics, given their immense popularity and the fact they're pretty much omnipresent, it's important to remember that they don't represent the be-all and end-all of the medium.

7. Superhero Comics Are All A Power Trip

DC Comics

Whether they're a superhero through and through or just a morally complex anti-hero, you can guarantee that if they're a protagonist in a Marvel or DC comic, that they're likely to use violence.

Advertisement

Superheroes tend to protect the innocent and fight against evil, and more often than not that means they get rough. If that book just so happens to be about the Punisher, then they're likely to get really rough, although to call him a superhero would be extremely generous.

Without going off on too much of a tangent, violence is synonymous with superhero comics - there's just no arguing otherwise. However, to claim that fans enjoy these tails specifically because of that aspect would be to grossly misunderstand the appeal of these characters.

Advertisement

Yes, there absolutely are readers who completely miss the point of what they're consuming - and even creators who help encourage those perceptions - but the heroes of Marvel and DC are all trying to do right by humanity, whether they're the sole survivor of an alien planet gifted with extraordinary abilities, or felt compelled to stop the same tragedy that befell them at a young age from happening to someone else, with no powers at all.

They're inspiring, affecting, and most tend to impart a valuable message. Not all manage to get it right, and there'll always be those who cherish the genre's most superficial elements over its more nuanced ones, but to label all superheroes an outrageous power fantasy would be to miss the point spectacularly.

Advertisement

6. They're Either Just For Adults OR Just For Kids

Fox

Ironically, these two mistakes get levied by people who are and aren't comic book fans. Some critics tend to the medium as childish, and something that adults shouldn't be reading. At the same time, adults who do read comics like to claim that they aren't for kids. Naturally, the truth lies somewhere in the middle.

Advertisement

Since the beginning of the Bronze Age, superhero books in particular have strayed into adult territory, and have largely remained there for the last four decades. They're often violent, dark and mature, dealing with themes that would've otherwise been censored during the height of the Silver Age and the Comics Code Authority.

Those who grew up on the Bronze and Modern Ages of comics have known a medium that's catered almost exclusively to a more adult market, and while that continues to be the case even to this day - with Marvel, DC and other publishers all pushing the envelope when it comes to mature storytelling - to say that comics are just for adults would just be ignorant.

Advertisement

The problem isn't so much that comics are just for kids or for adults - they aren't - it's more the fact that recent trends have neglected younger demographics. Both Marvel and DC have undertaken corrective measures to restore that balance, but the actual reality is that the medium - like any other - has content for specific age-ranges.

Ultimately, people who take issue with video games wouldn't label that medium as being 'just for kids' with the release of a new Pokémon title, and neither would those who criticise cinema deem it a purely adult hobby with every 'R'-rated release. Why is that so difficult to grasp with comics?

Advertisement

5. That Continuity Is A Bad Thing

DC Comics

As the old adage goes, if you want to get into comics, prepare to navigate decades of convoluted continuity. The Marvel and DC universe have been going for so long, and have spawned so many stories and characters that, to approach them today, would be a grave mistake.

Advertisement

Except... it wouldn't be.

Nevermind the fact that both Marvel and DC have engaged with their own share of reboots, re-jigs and retcons, the fact that both companies possess expansive mythologies is actually a great thing. It's part of what makes them so unique, and though yes certain comics are more impenetrable than others (a writer once famously claimed like getting into the X-Men was like tuning into the latest episode of a long-running soap opera), discovering that history is partly what makes Marvel and DC so special.

Advertisement

Take DC Rebirth for instance. Although another reboot, it came in the wake of the New 52, a line-wide reset of DC's post-Crisis continuity. It proved to be a successful experiment, galvanising interest in the DC brand, but even the publisher acknowledged that it had lost something special. Rebirth thus strived to find the perfect balance in between, and the DCU hasn't looked this healthy in years.

4. That DC is Dark, And Marvel Is Light

DC/Marvel Comics

Since the DCEU came along with the release of 2013's Man of Steel, a consensus has slowly but surely been building. According to quite a lot of moviegoers, Marvel - today represented by the monolithic Marvel Cinematic Universe - specialises in the lighter aspects of superhero stories, while DC - until recently dominated by Zack Snyder's dark and gaudy features - is just grim.

Advertisement

Fans of both companies know better. The actual reality is that both the Marvel and DC universes publish about the same in terms of lighter and darker content, with both boasting a diverse selection of books.

It's never been the case that one publisher is darker than the other, and while there are certainly distinguishing features between each world, such as Marvel's tendency to reflect 'the world outside your window', or DC's slightly more epic gods and monsters-esque set-up, tonally, they're just as varied.

Advertisement

So, who's to blame for this misconception? Well there's a lot that must be said about Warner Bros., and how they've managed to present only one version of the DC Universe outside of the comics medium since the start of the decade. Everything is genuinely grim, and though it might frustrate Marvel fans wanting to see what DC's all about, it's doubly frustrating for those familiar with the publisher's comics.

3. The Importance Of Artists

Marvel Comics/Chris Samnee

Back in 2017, the then Editor-in-Chief of Marvel Comics, Axel Alonso, stated that comic book artists don't really "move the needle." By that he meant that readers tend to follow writers more than they do pencillers, inkers and colourists, and though writers do tend take centre stage when it comes to promotional materials, Alonso's conclusion was poorly judged.

Advertisement

While a writer's contributions to a given comic are invaluable (that itself has never been in dispute), artists shoulder most of the work. There's no underestimating just how talented comic book artists are either, and that goes double in regards to the following they command. Good art is intrinsic to a comic's success, and when a fan-favourite artist signs on for a book, readers pay attention.

In truth, it's not so much writers themselves that "move the needle", but entire creative teams themselves. Dozens of creators have managed to cement formidable partnerships over the years, and yet many artists still find themselves undervalued by publishers and even the general public.

Advertisement

Without Steve Ditko and Jack Kirby, there'd be no Spider-Man, no Fantastic Four, and maybe even no Marvel Universe as we see it today. Add to that the fact there literally wouldn't be comics if there weren't any artists, and Alonso's comments are made even more bizarre.

2. That They're Not Political

DC Comics

Pretty much since the advent of superhero books, comics have been political. Captain America was created by Joe Simon and Jack Kirby - two Jewish comic book creators - as a blatant anti-Nazi symbol at a time when a virulent isolationism gripped the United States. His first appearance literally has Steve socking Hitler square on the jaw, while other figures over at DC would join the war effort too.

Advertisement

World War II had a transformative influence on the comics medium, and though the Comics Code Authority would attempt to suppress and censor Marvel, DC and countless other publishers during the ensuing decades, the Big Two in particular wouldn't shy away from real-world events. Stan Lee, Kirby and the rest of Marvel's bullpen made a deliberate choice to set the stories in the real United States, with New York the epicentre of their new universe. From that era came books like the X-Men, an allegory for the Civil Rights Movement; Iron Man, which rooted itself firmly in the Cold War milieu, and the Fantastic Four, which span directly out of the Space Race.

Marvel Comics

Marvel's aforementioned commitment to 'reflect the world outside our window' is fundamentally woven into the company's DNA, right down to Lee's monthly soapbox column in which he attacked racism, prejudice, and decried calls for his books to stop "moralising".

Advertisement

DC, meanwhile, would go on to adopt a similar approach. The hard-travelling era of Denny O'Neil and Neal Adams Green Lantern/Green Arrow took an introspective look towards the reform of the sixties and criticised Nixon's America, while later books would go onto pose similar questions with regards to a myriad of different topics. And yet, today, there isn't a shortage of fans who criticise Marvel and DC's works for being political.

Politics have always been in your comics, folks. Pretending otherwise just intimates a wider misunderstanding of the medium as a whole.

Advertisement

1. How Readers Should Consume Material

Marvel Comics

One of the biggest barriers in place for new readers looking to get into comics is, unfortunately, the fandom itself. There isn't a shortage of gatekeeping or toxic behaviour, but while it's commonly accepted that both those things are pervade circles both online and off, there's another issue that tends to get overlooked - people telling others how they should read comics.

Advertisement

First off, it must be made clear that, if you can support your local comic book shop, then do so. Small, local business depends on your custom in order to survive and thrive, but not everyone is within reach of one. To many, the only way to read comics comes in the form of big, online retailers, and while they don't need your custom, they're a valuable resource for certain fans.

Likewise, the rise of digital comics has also been met with skepticism from older circles. There's no substitute for feeling print and ink between your fingers, but again, some fans might prefer to read digitally, and that's fine. There are loads of great subscription-based services for people who want to read comics, and they should never be made to feel guilty because of the way they invest in their hobby.

Advertisement