10 Things Everyone Always Gets Wrong About Daredevil

Marvel's Man Without Fear isn't as simple as you think...

By Ewan Paterson /

Marvel Comics/Alex Maleev

You'd struggle to find a character in Marvel's library as revered as Matthew Murdock. Lawyer by day, vigilante by night, the Man Without Fear has watched over Hell's Kitchen since the 1960s and has since become one of Marvel's most storied characters, boasting a memorable selection of stories few other superheroes could match.

Advertisement

He's the best, but Stan Lee and Bill Everett's creation hasn't always enjoyed the position he currently has. Today, Daredevil is one of the most recognisable figures of the superhero genre, with appearances across a wide variety of mediums having cemented him as a true A-lister, able to hold his own against the likes of Captain America, Spider-Man and Earth's other Mightiest Heroes both on the page and off it.

But with the advent of new adaptations - as well as the character's resurgent popularity - misconceptions are bound to occur. Unfortunately there are quite a few things about Matt Murdock that people seem to misapprehend, either as a result of an adaptation altering the source material, or just because an element from the comics hasn't been telegraphed as loud as it possibly could've been.

Advertisement

So what in particular do people keep seem to be getting wrong? Let's find out...

10. Daredevil Has Never Killed

Marvel Comics/Billy Tan

As far as Marvel's street-level heroes go, Matt Murdock is actually relatively tame. The Punisher kills every villain he encounters, and Moon Knight - despite originally starting out as a Batman analogue of sorts - is almost just as bad. This leaves the burden of moral responsibility to Matt Murdock, a paragon of Catholic guilt who never, ever kills.

Advertisement

Except, he has - and he does.

Although it's certainly true that Daredevil exercises a no-killing rule, several have perished via his influence. Back in 2010's Shadowland event, a story that saw Murdock possessed by a ghostly spirit known as 'The Beast', Matt stabbed and killed Bullseye in the exact same way the villain had killed Elektra. Yes, this wasn't technically Daredevil per se, but that's at least one blob of red in the character's ledger.

Advertisement

But what about those times where Matt has been in control of his own faculties? Well, back in Kevin Smith and Joe Quesada's Guardian Devil, a storyline that saw a dying Mysterio attempt to ruin Matt's life (a recurring theme in DD's comics), Matt pretty much just turns around and humiliates Mysterio into killing himself. Again, the villain was already dying, but the ethics are questionable at best.

Apart from those two instances, Murdock once threw Bullseye out of a window and broke the villain's neck, murdered Wilson Fisk in the climactic End of Days, and was even responsible for the creation of Typhoid Mary after accidentally throwing her through a window back in Miller's The Man Without Fear. Not a great record, it must be said.

Advertisement

9. Frank Miller's Run Is Definitively The Character's Best

Marvel Comics

Misconceptions may abound when it comes to Daredevil, but one thing that there's no contesting is that the character has been the subject of more legendary story-arcs than any other Marvel character. The likes of Dennis O'Neil, Frank Miller, Ann Nocenti, Brian Bendis, Ed Brubaker and several others have all presided over some truly legendary tales featuring the Man Without Fear, so much so that it would be impossible to proclaim any single one as being definitive.

Advertisement

And yet many still attempt to do so, with Miller's undoubtedly the most revered of the bunch. Everyone is entitled to their favourite of course, and though it is unquestionable that Miller contributed the bulk of what we've come to associate with the Man Without Fear, it is debatable as to whether or not the character peaked with his stint on the book.

Bendis had an utterly superb time on Daredevil with Alex Maleev, followed up by an equally formidable (if not slightly overlooked) run from Ed Brubaker and Michael Lark, and that's without even mentioning the more recent contributions of Mark Waid, Chris Samnee, Charles Soule, and countless others who have worked with Murdock in the years following the conclusion of Miller's run. Then there's Ann Nocenti's run, which arguably exerts just as big an influence on the character as Miller's has over the last few decades.

Advertisement

Point being, Daredevil isn't short of quality. Heralding any single run as the definitive best, however, isn't an easy a task as some would imply.

8. The Black Suit Is Better Than The Red One

Netflix

Daredevil Season 3 was arguably the best of Marvel's Netflix shows, but one thing that was slightly bizarre was the way many fans reacted to the return of the character's black costume. It made sense thematically, with Murdock disillusioned with his faith and the reason why he took up crimefighting in the first place, but was it actually better than the character's iconic red suit? Not by a long shot.

Advertisement

The black costume first appeared in Frank Miller and John Romita Jr.'s The Man Without Fear, a storyline that rebooted Daredevil's origins and one that inspired elements of the show's first season. By the end, however, Matt suits up in the red costume (the character's second in the comics, after the yellow suit), and becomes Daredevil proper.

Designed by Melvin Potter in the show, Matt used it for all of Season 2 and in the second half of The Defenders. It was a great look, modernising the look of the comics with the introduction of armour plating and other materials, but for some reason people just seem to prefer the black outfit, which would pretty much be the same as proclaiming that Bruce Wayne's balaclava look before he designed the Bat-Suit was the superior costume - it just doesn't make sense.

Advertisement

The red suit is iconic for a reason, and it's why it's here to stay.

7. Spider-Man Still Has It Worse

Marvel Comics

In terms of Marvel characters getting the short end of the stick and just having a thoroughly hard time of things, Daredevil and Spider-Man probably take the cake. Tony Stark is up there too, with Iron Man leaving behind a trail of dead love interests and internal demons throughout his escapades as Iron Man, but Peter Parker and Matthew Murdock are perennial misery merchants - they just never seem to be able to catch a break.

Advertisement

So, who has it worse? Well the only way to find out is to list off the worst things that have happened to either character, so here goes.

Since being created in 1962, Spider-Man has seen numerous relationships crumble, with the most notable being the death of Gwen Stacy; battled a condition where he sprouted several new appendages; been the victim of a cloning plot that terrorised readers in the mid-nineties; had his identity revealed in Civil War, leading to numerous assassination attempts against his loved-ones; had his marriage destroyed by making a deal with Mephisto; and lastly, having his mind swapped with Doc Ock and dying in his disease-ridden body.

Advertisement

Touch act to follow, right? Well not if you're Matt Murdock. Since 1964, Daredevil has had his entire life ripped from underneath his feet by Wilson Fisk, leaving him homeless after his former partner, Karen Page, sold his identity for a shot of heroin; was targeted by Mysterio, who tried to mentally destabilise Murdock by faking the rise of the Anti-Christ; witnessed the death of two of his biggest loves, Elektra and Karen Page; had his identity exposed to the public by Fisk, which led to him being incarcerated alongside all the villains he put away; had his wife, Milla Donovan, driven mad by Mr. Fear's drugs; and was eventually even made a fugitive when Fisk became mayor.

Still though, one of the best things about Daredevil has been seeing him overcome all these trials and tribulations, particularly in Mark Waid and Chris Samnee's run, where Matt vows to find happiness even when the whole world feels as though it's against him.

Advertisement

6. He Only Uses A Billy Club

Marvel Comics

Matt Murdock's billy club may be one of Marvel's more iconic weapons, but it isn't the only tool the character has in his arsenal.

Advertisement

Over the years, the Man Without Fear has utilised guns, swords, bows, and even the environment itself against would-be aggressors. There's also the fact he's pretty handy without any weapon at hand too, making him one of the most formidable combatants in the Marvel Universe.

In exciting developments, Murdock is even set to become the guardian of the Bifrost Bridge, a title previously held by Heimdall. We're still waiting to figure out just how exactly he assumes this responsibility, but seeing Matt wield the Bifrost Sword is an unusual, albeit welcome sight to see.

Advertisement

5. The Significance Of Ben Urich

Marvel Comics

Ben Urich is to Daredevil what Commissioner Gordon is to Batman: an integral component of the character's mythos. Given his fate in the first season of Marvel's Daredevil, however, fans could probably be forgiven for thinking that isn't actually the case.

Advertisement

Even though he was portrayed to perfection by Vondie Curtis-Hall, the showrunners deemed that Season 1 needed a death to cap things off, and so Urich was killed by Fisk in the penultimate episode. Say what you will about the subsequent seasons, but one thing there's no denying is that Urich's presence was sorely missing.

In the comics, Ben is an investigative reporter for the Daily Bugle, and a good one at that. He sticks his nose where it doesn't belong, has a keen eye for a good story and is determined to tell the truth, even when it places his own life in jeopardy. He plays a pivotal role in the Born Again saga, and an even greater one in End of Days, where he sets out to tell the story of what really happened to Daredevil, in a media landscape that couldn't really care less.

Advertisement

He's an honourable man, and a figure who has often proved to be the unsung hero of the Man Without Fear's stories, which is why it's such a shame he succumbed to such an unfortunate fate in the TV show.

4. Kingpin Was Daredevil's First Villain

Marvel Comics

Kingpin may be Daredevil's most famous adversary, but he wasn't always as synonymous with the character as you may think.

Advertisement

Yes, while figures like Bullseye, Elektra and Typhoid Mary are all Daredevil bad-guys through and through, Wilson Fisk actually started out life as one of Spider-Man's. There, he took on the role of a stereotypical mob mastermind, a schemer whose plans were constantly foiled by the plucky young wall-crawler. It wasn't until Frank Miller took the reigns on Daredevil where that relationship would change forever.

Miller took the bold decision to make Fisk a paragon of corruption and violence, and changed his concerns from Spider-Slayers to drug trafficking, racketeering, and assassinations. When Daredevil began upsetting his plans, Fisk would turn his attention to Hell's Kitchen, and thus one of the most iconic rivalries in comics was born.

Advertisement

3. It Was Matt Murdock Who Scolded Tony Stark In Civil War

Marvel Comics

It's a testament to Civil War's impact that we're still talking about it almost 13 years after it was originally published, but for better or for worse, it persists.

Advertisement

Despite featuring big climactic battles between the likes of Iron Man and Captain America, a clone Thor ripping apart Goliath and even the Fantastic Four splitting into two, one of the biggest fan-favourite sequences actually revolves around Daredevil, as the Man Without Fear is apprehended by Tony Stark's Pro-Registration forces.

Stark confronts Daredevil, who then proceeds to gift a silver coin to his now enemy before referring to him as "Judas." Given the religious reference it would be fair to assume that Matt Murdock was responsible for chastising Stark, but it isn't, even if it was originally intended to be him.

Advertisement
Marvel Comics

In the wake of the Murdock Papers, where the lawyer's double identity as Daredevil is exposed to the public, Matt is sent to prison. Before sentence is carried, he asks that Danny Rand - the Immortal Iron Fist - assume the identity of Daredevil to keep Hell's Kitchen safe, and to potentially even cast doubt on the court's verdict. This event actually coincided with Civil War, and even though the character featured above looks and talks like Daredevil, it's actually Rand.

2. He's Only Ever Lived In Hell's Kitchen

Marvel Comics

Hell's Kitchen may be where Daredevil was born and bred, but it isn't the only locale the character has called home.

Advertisement

Beginning with Daredevil #87 (Vol. 1), Gerry Conway and Gene Colan decided to send Matt to San Francisco with then girlfriend Natasha Romanoff. The pair shared a place together, and transplanted their crimefighting operation from the East Coast to the West along the way, with Matt and Nat staying in the city for a dozen-or-so issues before their relationship fell apart and Matt came back to New York.

There he remained for a good few decades, until Mark Waid and Chris Samnee uprooted the character all over again and sent him back to San Fran in Daredevil #1 (Vol. 4), with Matt's position in New York having been made untenable thanks to a combination of his identity being made public, and just the city in general bearing too many bad memories for the Man Without Fear to cope with.

Advertisement

Murdock returned to Hell's Kitchen once again at the beginning of Charles Soule and Rob Garney's Daredevil, but there's an argument to be made that San Francisco should be just as synonymous with the character.

1. He's Always Been A Defender

Marvel Comics

For those less versed in the Marvel Universe - no, the Defenders weren't originally a street-level group. The character has only recently been associated with the team thanks to 2017's Defenders TV show, while the comics themselves only recently depicted that group that same year.

Advertisement

So, what's the story with the actual Defenders? Well the original group actually have a lot more in common with the Avengers, with the founding members being Doctor Strange, Hulk and Namor. They take on mystical and cosmic threats, something that Murdock only usually tackles on a smaller, ninja-laden scale.

Turns out that Daredevil isn't really that much of a team player. He only briefly joined the New Avengers, and tends to favour brief partnerships over long-running organisations.

Advertisement

Though, given how it's worked out for the character over the years, it's probably safe to say that's a good thing.

Watch Next...

Advertisement