10 Times Captain America Got Very Political

Fox thinks Cap only got political with the new title. They couldn't be more wrong.

By Percival Constantine /

The release of Nick Spencer and Daniel Acuña's Captain America: Sam Wilson #1 has angered people in conservative media. Fox & Friends in particular railed against the fact that in the issue, Wilson (formerly the Falcon, now the new Cap) fought the Sons of the Serpent, who were kidnapping illegal immigrants. The co-hosts lamented the fact that Cap apparently now fights conservatives instead of traditional Captain America villains like Hydra and wish they could go back to the days when Cap punched Hitler. One of the hosts even said, "keep politics out of comics." These hosts (including the proclaimed comics "expert" Clayton Morris) have obviously never actually read any of those comics; Captain America has long reflected contemporary politics. Even dating back to that first issue, the iconic image of Cap punching Hitler was considered very controversial at the time, released before America entered World War II. So controversial, in fact, that New York Nazi sympathisers sent death threats to Joe Simon and Jack Kirby. But these two instances weren't the only times Cap got very political. Here are ten other times when controversial issues were portrayed in the comics.

10. Cap Readers Were Very Political

If you look at the letters pages in most comic books, you'll find most fans commenting on the stories and the characters, making requests for things they'd like to see, or criticising things they didn't like. And Captain America's "Let's Rap With Cap" letters page was largely the same - except a lot of letters also talked about important issues of the day, including discussions on what it meant to be an American and a patriot. When the Cap comics really hit their stride in the late 60s, there was a lot of political turmoil. The Vietnam War, the Civil Rights Movement, Watergate, the counterculture, and countless other things. And the comics, particularly under writer Steve Englehart, reflected this. The readers responded in kind. Marvel received letters from all across the ideological spectrum, discussing important issues of the day and even responding to each other. In regards to Steve Rogers' political stance, Roger Stern wrote a lengthy response in Captain America #247 to a fan who felt Cap was a Reagan conservative: "Cap is not quite the rock-ribbed conservative you imagine him to be. As a matter of fact, he€™s probably about as dead center in the political spectrum as one can get... If anything, Steve Rogers probably grew up as a New Deal liberal." Hardly seems like the kind of discussion that would appear in a comic book free of politics.

9. Support For Conscientious Objectors

Captain America #163 features Steve Rogers and his former love interest, Peggy Carter, walking in the woods near her family's Virginia estate. Along the walk, they meet a Vietnam vet named Dave Cox, a former POW who lost his arm in the war, who said he's become a conscientious objector after what he's seen. When the Serpent Squad attacks, Cap and Peggy take refuge in Dave's home. Peggy tells Dave to use his rifle to help, but Dave says he won't resort to violence again and that the gun isn't even loaded. He just keeps it as a reminder of what he was. The Squad breaks through and demands Dave tell them where Cap is hiding. But Dave refuses, even when being tormented by them, which allows Cap to get the drop on them. After the Squad has been defeated, Peggy says she can't understand why Dave wouldn't break. Cap explains to her that just because he's a conscientious objector, that doesn't make him a coward.

8. Reagan Transformed Into A Snake

Captain America #344 took place at a time when Steve Rogers gave up the Captain America identity and became the Captain (we'll get to that a little later). Viper of the Serpent Society poisoned Washington DC's water supply and the result was that President Reagan was transformed into a snake that Cap had to battle. Although never mentioned by name, the President in the issue is clearly drawn to be Reagan. The cover text reads, "The Captain vs. the Deadliest Snake of All!" and the title of the issue, "Don't Tread On Me", is found on the Gadsen flag (along with a snake), a popular image among conservative movements. The issue also features Viper attacking the First Lady and saying that she's not worth the bullets and the final image, which shows "Reagan" giving a speech after he's returned to normal, depicts the president still having fangs in his mouth. Usually when Presidents appear in comics, they're mostly depicted in shadow and appear extremely benign. But depicting a Reagan lookalike as "the deadliest snake of all" in a 1988 comic is pretty partisan, even if he's transformed against his will.

7. Cap Resigns During The Reagan Administration

Captain America #332 saw Steve standing up to the Commission on Superhuman Activities. They claimed that because the Captain America identity, costume, and shield were created by the government that they were their property. They told Steve he could only continue using them if he was willing to acquiesce to their terms or compensate the government. Steve spent the issue contemplating what he should do and in the end, he made the decision to resign from being Captain America. What makes this political is Steve's reasoning for abandoning the shield; he felt that, in addition to forcing him to leave the Avengers, that the Reagan administration would force him to work for their terms. One of the things Cap wondered the government would have him do is going to fight alongside the Contras in Nicaragua, leading to an image of Cap with a gun shooting villagers. It's not as overtly partisan as some of the others on this list, but the message is clear - although he began his career as a soldier under FDR, Cap didn't feel comfortable filling that same role under Reagan.

6. Commie Smasher Captain America

For years, there was a really big continuity error in the Captain America comics. When Cap returned in Avengers #4, it was stated that he went into the ice before the end of World War II. But the comics of the 1950s contradicted this, as there was an attempt to revive Cap and Bucky in that period and the title of the book became Captain America: Commie Smasher. The comics were a product of the Red Scare hysteria of the 1950s and were mercifully short-lived (Stan Lee even claims he doesn't remember writing them). But fans remembered them and numerous letters asked why Marvel hadn't addressed this oversight. In Captain America #153-156, Steve Englehart answered the question. He revealed that the Cap and Bucky of the 1950s were actually different people than Steve Rogers and Bucky Barnes turned into heroes, but the Super Soldier Serum they used was unstable and drove them crazy. They were revived in the 70s by a government official who was upset with Nixon's China visit and felt the country needed "real" heroes. The 50s Cap and Bucky were racists and misogynists, with the Falcon calling 50s Cap a "penny-ante Hitler." It was a clear statement against the Red Scare antics that fueled the Commie Smasher issues and Steve said that the 50s Cap's ideas were out of step with reality.

5. The New Cap Takes On A Right-Wing Militia

After Steve Rogers gave up the Captain America identity, the Commission hired John Walker to replace him. Walker had been the Super-Patriot, a right-wing superhero who led the Bold Urban Commandos (BUCKIES) in attacks on foreign exchange students. Captain America #335 features Walker's first mission as Captain America, with the soldier tasked with infiltrating the Watchdogs, a right-wing militia group. They were opposed to anything "indecent" or "immoral," like pornography, evolution, sex education, abortion, etc. Shockingly, however, Walker himself noted that he believes in those things as well. In the story itself, Walker and his partner, Lemar Hoskins (the new Bucky), go down to the new Cap's hometown in Georgia to find the Watchdogs, with Lemar posing as a pornographer that Walker fights to attract the Watchdogs. The Watchdogs try to lynch Lemar and when they go to burn down a library that refused to ban books, Walker finally takes them out. The issue was so controversial that it caused a member of the Moral Majority to write a letter in anger at the portrayal of his ideology.

4. Commie Smasher Cap Becomes Full-On Nazi

The 70s wasn't the last we'd hear of the Commie Smasher Cap. He resurfaced again in Captain America #231-236 as the Grand Director. And in case the penny-ante Hitler remark didn't make it clear, this time around the Grand Director went full-on white supremacist. Dressed in what could only be described as a supervillain version of the KKK hood and robes, he also wore an armband with the swastika on it and led an organization called the National Force. The Grand Director was under the control of a Cap villain called Doctor Faustus, and the National Force's goal was to make America strong by purging undesirables, claiming that "a white America is a strong America." And Steve wasted no time in condemning them, saying that, "they're Nazis by a different name." No two ways about it, the National Force and the Grand Director were far-right American nationalists, no different from the KKK or other organisations appearing lately to throw around the claim of "white genocide."

3. Two Americas

Ed Brubaker is considered by many to be among the greatest Captain America writers, and with good reason. In Captain America #602-605, he wrote a story called "Two Americas" that featured Bucky as the new Cap going up against the Commie Smasher Cap (his name now revealed as William Burnside). The beginning of the "Two Americas" story actually did generate some controversy in conservative circles because of the above image. The comic was published when the Tea Party was just starting up and due to backlash, Marvel eventually altered the protest signs in reprints. But the content of the story is still very reflective of the climate. Burnside returned, back in his Captain America costume, claiming that the America he loved was gone and talking of a "real" America and a "fake" America (much like former Republican Vice-Presidential candidate Sarah Palin and current Republican Presidential candidate Mike Huckabee). The Watchdogs also returned in this story as well, with Burnside leading their organisation. The notion of a right-wing militia was really driven home in these issues and it was up to Cap and the Falcon to stop them before they could blow up the Hoover Dam.

2. The War On Terror

As I've probably demonstrated up to this point, the Cap comics have always reflected what was going on in contemporary American politics. And no event changed America as much as 9/11. John Ney Rieber and John Cassaday launched a new Captain America volume and their first six-issue story-arc dealt with Cap's reaction to 9/11 and subsequent involvement in the War on Terror. When the Towers fell, Steve Rogers worked in his civilian identity to help survivors. Later in a New York neighborhood, he intervened when he saw a group of people try and attack a Muslim American. He told the attackers that what they're doing wasn't justice. The Muslim character intervened, trying to talk with the man who tried to kill him. Cap also went on a mission for SHIELD to take out a terrorist named al-Tariq operating in an American town called Centerville where there's a bomb factory. The trail from al-Tariq leads Cap to face a ringleader who gives a speech telling Cap that his family was killed and he was disfigured in one of many areas America supported guerillas during the Cold War. He asks Cap, "Tell your monster where he's from" and Cap can't. It was a powerful series of issues that refused to paint the War on Terror in the simple black and white that politicians and the media kept pushing.

1. The President Led The Secret Empire

Captain America #169-176, the story of the Secret Empire, is one Marvel's seminal stories. But, more than that, it was also one of the most political stories they ever published. The Secret Empire was an organization within the US government that managed to infiltrate Roxxon's Brand Corporation subsidiary. They tried to discredit Cap's reputation through the Committee to Regain America's Principles. The leader of the Secret Empire, the mysterious Number One, was attempting a coup d'etat of America by threatening to detonate nukes unless power was turned over to him. Cap confronted Number One in the White House and when he (but not the audience) discovered Number One's identity, he committed suicide. The comic only ever said that Number One was someone in a position of high power in the government, but it was heavily implied that he was the President of the United States. The government covered all this up, however, and Steve was so disillusioned with America that he gave up the Captain America identity and took on the identity of Nomad for a time. The story was published in 1973 and writer Steve Englehart specifically intended the story to be a metaphor for Nixon's administration and the Watergate scandal. And the parallels are obvious, not only in Nixon/Number One but also the similarity between the Committee to Regain America's Principles and the real-life Committee to Re-Elect the President (CRAP/CREEP). What other political issues from Captain America comics do you remember? Sound off in the comments!