10 Times Spider-Man Has Been Outwitted
From diabolical to downright genius, here are 10 ways Spider-Man's villains have outwitted him.
Springing onto the page in 1963, written by Stan Lee and pencilled by Steve Ditko and Sol Brodsky, Spider-Man has become one of Marvel's most popular heroes - and from then to now, he's grown from a hot-headed teenager into a legend among the superhero community.
These days, his character is renowned for three of his best qualities: his web-slinging, his quick wits, and his big heart.
While Spider-Man's heart and webs are never in question, there have been times when his wits have been put to the test - and even times when they've been found wanting.
A surprising number of the web-slinger's enemies have proven that they're not just able to out-punch him, but that they're able to out-think him, too - which almost always leads to disaster for our young hero.
Spider-Man's rogues gallery of evil scientists, criminal masterminds, and giggling madmen have come up with some shockingly complex schemes to get the upper hand on our favourite wall-crawler over his long career as New York's defender - and the entries on this list are some of the most dramatic and the most devious.
From anti-Spider gadgetry, to psychological warfare, to using his own powers against him, here are ten times Spider-Man's villains thoroughly outwitted him.
10. Tombstone Fights In A Phone Booth - The Amazing Spider-Man (2022) #3
Lonnie Lincoln, AKA Tombstone, is better known for brute force and intimidation tactics than his quick wits. However, over his many brawls with Spider-Man, Tombstone has slowly but surely figured out how to counter the web-slinger's fighting style.
Written in 2022 by Zeb Wells and pencilled by John Romita Jr., this comic sees Tombstone playing to his strengths with a calculated choice of terrain.
Spider-Man has gotten the better of Tombstone dozens of times despite the latter's impressive combat prowess - and this is due mostly to his pitched agility.
Though Tombstone is no slouch in a fistfight, with superhuman strength and unmatched durability, Spider-Man's massive speed advantage meant he spent most of their fights hitting air. Recently, however, he pulled a surprisingly cunning strategy. By luring Spider-Man into a cramped space between hydraulic walls - taking some of Spidey's best punches like a champ while he got into position - he robbed Spider-Man of any room to maneuver.
Catching the wall-crawler with a vicious body blow, he proceeded to crush his ribs in a bear hug, ending the fight. In just a few panels, Tombstone proved that as well as being strong, he's also more cunning than we realised.
9. Hobgoblin Commits The Perfect Crime - Amazing Spider-Man Vol.1 #245
While a lot of later entries on this list involve villains defeating Spider-Man in a fight, there's more than one way to outwit your opponent - it could even be as simple as making sure you have an escape plan.
In Amazing Spider-Man #245, written in 1983 by Roger Stern and pencilled by John Romita Jr., we see Roderick Kingsley - also known as the original Hobgoblin - put his criminal cunning on display to give Spider-Man the slip.
After an exhaustive search for the Hobgoblin's identity as both Spider-Man and Peter Parker, it seems as if our hero has finally unearthed a lead - a small-time criminal named Lefty Donovan. However, Spider-Man's instincts tell him there's more to this case. When Spider-Man unmasks the Hobgoblin, he discovers it is in fact Lefty Donovan - but Donovan lets slip that he wasn't acting alone - he had a criminal employer.
Just as he's about to name the mastermind behind the Hobgoblin, Kingsley remote-controls Donovan's glider into a building, killing him and tying up any loose ends.
8. Kingpin Hits Spider-Man Where It Hurts - Peter Parker, The Spectacular Spider-Man Vol.1 #89
Unlike many of the other villains on this list, Kingpin doesn't often involve himself with superheroes, preferring instead to own crime at a street level. When he does, however, he uses the same tactics that served him well in organised crime - cunning, manipulation, and a willingness to play the long game.
While this plan was ultimately unsuccessful, Spectacular Spider-Man #89 - written in 1984 by Bill Mantlo and pencilled by Al Milgrom - sees Kingpin use Spider-Man's own allies to lay a trap for him.
In this comic, Black Cat, former cat burglar and Spider-Man's new partner, is searching for super-powers that will allow her to protect him. In desperation, she goes to the Kingpin - who, in exchange for a few robberies, hires New York's top scientists to make her superhuman.
Her powers are fitting for a Black Cat - she can bring her enemies bad luck! - and she couldn't be happier. However, Kingpin hid some secret fine print in her abilities - everyone close to her, including Spider-Man, suffers from the same terrible luck, to the point that their lives are at risk.
7. Doctor Octopus Proposes An Alliance - Amazing Spider-Man Vol.1 #55
Doctor Octopus is one of Spider-Man's oldest and most persistent enemies - and describing his many attempts to beat Spider-Man over the years would require a whole separate article.
This one, however, really showcases Doc Ock's ability to think on his feet. Written in 1967 by Stan Lee and pencilled by John Romita Sr., Amazing Spider-Man #55 sees Spider-Man tricked into teaming up with Otto Octavius.
After stealing a tech-nullifying device from a military convoy, Octavius plans to use the device to hold Stark Industries hostage. Spider-Man, however, has predicted Doc Ock's plan, and appears soon after to fight him.
In desperation, Octavius uses the nullifier on Spider-Man, hoping to disable his web shooters. However, the nullifier's electromagnetic frequency plays haywire with the young hero's Spider-Sense, causing him to collapse instead. When Spider-Man recovers, Otto is amazed to discover that Spider-Man is suffering from temporary amnesia - and, in a flash of genius, quickly convinces him that they're partners in crime.
Not only does this finish the fight, but Spidey also helps his new "partner" escape! Otto definitely had the upper hand in this exchange.
6. Kraven Beats Spider-Man At His Own Game - Amazing Spider-Man Vol.1 #294
Released in 1987, written by J.M. DeMatteis and pencilled by Mike Zeck, many consider this comic to be Kraven the Hunter's finest hour. Kraven, born Sergei Kravinoff, is a Russian supervillain with superhuman powers who hunts his victims for sport - and sees Spider-Man as the ultimate big game.
After years of trying and failing to catch his elusive quarry, Kraven retreats into the shadows - until finally, near the end of his life, he decides to dedicate himself to one last hunt to prove himself stronger than Spider-Man.
While fighting Spider-Man head-on never went well for Kraven, this plan was very different - after stunning Spider-Man with a poisoned dart, instead of going in for the kill, he dressed in a Spider-Suit of his own and took to the streets. By the time Spider-Man awoke and found Kraven, the Hunter had already caught a terrifying rat-man named Vermin - a beast Spider-Man had never managed to capture without help in the past.
By defeating Vermin when Spider-Man never could, he has finally proven himself as the superior hunter, and ends his own life soon after, satisfied that he fulfilled his ultimate goal. A hollow victory? Maybe. But a victory nonetheless.
5. Green Goblin Hacks Spider-Man's City - Superior Spider-Man Vol.1 #27
This story, written in 2014 by Dan Slott and pencilled by Giuseppe Camuncoli, only sort of counts as Spider-Man getting outwitted - because, while Superior Spider-Man is indeed a Spider-Man story, Superior Spider-Man is not Peter Parker.
During Otto's body swap with Peter Parker - a story that nearly made it onto this list - Otto took up the mantle of Spider-Man, determined to prove he was the superior vigilante.
Looking to streamline the whole "swing around the city looking for crime" process, Otto invented hundreds of Spider-Bots to trawl the city scanning for criminal activity, which he could act on only if he was needed. For a while, the new system worked like a charm, but Otto's celebration was short-lived - for soon after, the Green Goblin made his move.
In his arrogance, Otto had never installed a failsafe for if his Spider-Bots were hacked - and that's exactly what happened. Overnight, the Green Goblin rendered Otto's early warning system useless, and when he and his Goblin Army stormed New York, the Superior Spider-Man was completely caught off-guard. Otto Octavius has always prided himself on his intelligence, but against the Green Goblin, that very pride was his undoing.
4. "Spider-Man" Breaks Bad? - Amazing Spider-Man #1
Spider-Man's secret identity - and how his villains have tried to deduce said identity - have been key aspects of several Spider-Man storylines over the years.
But in Spider-Man's debut, written in 1963 by Stan Lee and pencilled by Steve Ditko and Sol Brodsky, a villain outwitted Spider-Man in a truly unique way - by using his anonymity against him. Testing our your hero's commitment to masked heroism, Amazing Spider-Man #1 marked the appearance of his first villain - The Chameleon.
Dmitri Smerdyakov, half-brother of Sergei Kravinoff (AKA Kraven the hunter!), emigrated to the US from Russia around the time Spider-Man was first starting out. By this point, Dmitri had already invented his Chameleon persona, and uses it for the first time to steal missile defense plans from the Lark Building.
Seizing his chance to incriminate the young hero, Chameleon returns to the Lark Building disguised as Spider-Man, then lures the web-slinger to the same spot with the promise of a job offer. Then, when Spider-Man arrives, Chameleon takes off - leaving Spider-Man the only culprit. While Spider-Man does defeat Chameleon, the police then mistake Spider-Man for the imposter, firing on him and forcing him to flee.
3. Mysterio Makes His Entrance - Amazing Spider-Man #13
A list of the times Spider-Man has been outwitted wouldn't be complete without the Master of Illusion himself - Mysterio. Making his debut in Amazing Spider-Man #13, written by Stan Lee and Steve Ditko, Mysterio's first heist in the Midtown Museum set the tone for all of his appearances to come.
At this point in Spider-Man's story, he was nothing more than a masked vigilante making a name for himself - inspiring Mysterio, like Chameleon before him, to try and frame the young wall-crawler for his robberies. When Spider-Man tried to put a stop to this, he was amazed to discover that his Spider-Sense wasn't working - and more amazingly, Mysterio could make his webbing disppear with a wave of his hand.
Later, of course, he discovered that this wasn't the work of magic, but incredibly sophisticated equipment. Using a special Spider-Sense jammer and a web-dissolving mist, Mysterio had nearly fooled Spider-Man completely - until he began to gloat about his victory, not realising Spider-Man was recording their conversation. While Mysterio's arrogance proved his undoing, he certainly gave the young hero a run for his money.
2. Mysterio Comes Back From The Grave - Amazing Spider-Man #141
Ever the persistent nemesis, the Master of Illusion makes this list one more time for his triumphant return to villainy. In a two-issue arc beginning in 1975, written by Gerry Conway and pencilled by Ross Andru, Mysterio is up to his old tricks - taunting Spider-Man with holograms of his old villains, and even tricking the hero into punching brick walls until he injures his hands.
But as Spider-Man was about to find out, the real illusion was only just beginning.
When Peter Parker went to the Bugle to tell everyone Mysterio was back in town, his friend Ned Leeds gave him a nasty shock - apparently, Mysterio had died in prison a year ago. Now haunted by what he believed to be a vengeful ghost, Spider-Man's fear of these illusions was dialled up to eleven.
It was only when he discovered one of the image projectors did he realise the other possibility - just because the original Mysterio was dead, didn't mean someone else hadn't taken up the mantle. After a final showdown with the new Mysterio, it's revealed he was Quentin Beck's old cell-mate out to avenge his buddy, but he really had Spider-Man fooled for a minute there.
1. Spider-Man Fights Himself - Amazing Spider-Man #149
Top of the list for outwitting Spider-Man has to go to one of his most devious villains - Professor Miles Warren, AKA The Jackal. A former mentor of Peter Parker, the Jackal's revenge hit Peter mentally and physically. In the finale of the Delusion Conspiracy arc, written by Gerry Conway and pencilled by Ross Andru in 1975, Jackal uses Spider-Man's abilities against him - before ending their cat-and-mouse game with a lethal coup de grace.
Once the Jackal had succeeded in his plan to clone Gwen Stacy, his plan to get back at her "murderer" - who he thought was Spider-Man - started in a truly genius way - by earning Peter's trust. Since his Spider-Sense doesn't activate for trusted friends, Professor Warren was free to drug him into unconsciousness before growing a clone of him - forcing the two into a battle to the death, where both were perfectly evenly matched.
While one Spider-Man did manage to best the Jackal and free his hostages, the other was unfortunately killed - making the Jackal one of the only villains to murder Spider-Man. Between that and circumventing Peter's Spider-Sense without a single gadget, the Jackal definitely outwitted Spider-Man in this story.