10 Times Superheroes Did The Wrong Thing For The Right Reason

Superheroes make mistakes and sometimes do the wrong thing for the most noble of reasons.

By John Wilson /

Jonathan Lockwood Huie once said that “Heroes act in spite of their fear, while the rest of us act because of our fear.” They make the hard choices, the split-second calls, and face the consequences that most of us hope we never have to face in our entire lives. And many times, they do it silently and without any recognition or accolades.

Advertisement

In the world of superheroes, that is intensified a thousandfold. The very least that they do could have major ramifications and their mistakes could have major consequences. Some have powers that could quite literally crack the world in half and every action they take has to be measured by what is necessary and who needs to be saved.

Many actions happen in a matter of seconds. And every hero has aspirations to do the right thing, all the time, for the best reasons. But sometimes, like all people, they fall short. Their intentions are good but they do the wrong thing. They make a mistake. They zig when they should have zagged and because of that something bad happens. It’s not the outcome that they intended but their hearts were in the right place.

10. Salvation Run

The President authorized a program to capture the world’s super-villains and send them off-world. The order was carried out by the “Suicide Squad”. The villains had been diverted to a hostile planet. Alliances formed almost immediately. Luthor created one with the promise of getting everyone home and the Joker gathered the crazier villains together to start some trouble. It was revealed that Darkseid’s torturer DeSaad had diverted the villains there as targets for his new Parademons. Luthor created his teleporter and got many of the villains home, killing some to power it.

Advertisement

Besides the legal ramifications, this plan was doomed to fail. Putting this many volatile personalities together in one place, even a place where they had to depend on each other for their survival, was just a powder keg in search of a match. And introducing the Joker into that wasn’t just providing a match, it’s providing a flame thrower.

Something needed to be done about the supervillain problem. Even a wedding in one of the heroes' own former headquarters wasn’t safe from supervillain attack and there were so many villains with so much power that the heroes barely had time to run from one fire to the next.

9. The Justice League Lobotomizes Villains.

After the heinous sexual assault of Sue Dibny, wife of the Elongated Man, on the Justice League Satellite, Zatanna wiped the mind of Dr. Light. She also made an “adjustment” to his personality. Batman arrived on the Satellite when she was in the middle of this and she was forced to take a few minutes of his memories as well. On an earlier occasion, five members of the Secret Society of Super-Villains swapped bodies with five members of the Justice League. Zatanna wiped their memories as well and perhaps, others.

Advertisement

There is no greater violation than having your mind violated. Removing information is one thing but to alter a person’s personality is terrible. And to alter the mind of a friend and colleague like Batman is even worse. Batman prides himself on his mind and doing anything to it is cutting him more deeply than any knife.

However, the civilians in the heroes' lives have to be protected. There is no hero you can name that doesn’t have some kind of tragedy in their backstory and a near-constant battle to protect the people they love in their current exploits. Nothing is scarier than knowing that your loved one is in danger, especially because you put them there.

8. Wonder Woman Snaps Max Lord’s Neck

Maxwell Lord used the mental powers bestowed by the Gene Bomb to obtain the position of Checkmate’s Black King. Lord convinced Brother Eye that the Metahumans were a danger to the human population. Lord also gained mental control of Superman. Wonder Woman tried to convince Lord to let Superman go, even binding him in her Lasso. But Lord refused. Seeing no other way out, Diana snapped Lord’s neck, killing him. Lord arranged for his death to be broadcast worldwide.

Advertisement

Wonder Woman should have found another way. She should have tried to knock him out, call the Martian Manhunter, Zatanna, or others that could have broken the mind control. Just because Lord said that the only way of ending his control was by killing him didn’t mean it was so. Diana didn’t have to do it alone and killing Lord practically destroyed her mission of peace in Man’s World.

Max Lord needed to be stopped. He killed Blue Beetle. He manipulated his way into one of the government’s lead clandestine agencies and the scope of his power made him a threat to anyone he encountered. If he could control Superman, there were very few people who would be immune to his power.

7. Kingdom Come’s Kansas Gulag

On Earth-22, The “Gulag” was the nickname given to the Superhuman Rehabilitation Facility that Superman created to house and re-educate those violent young superhumans who refused to comply when Superman and the earlier generation of heroes returned. The facility was created with the intention of housing people for months. However, within two weeks, it was beyond capacity. The prisoners revolted and a brainwashed Captain Marvel breached the escape-proof walls. The American government sent a nuclear bomb which Marvel detonated in the air. It still killed most of the people there.

Advertisement

Superman created a ticking time bomb. He put the worst, most violent beings on the planet into one place. He forgot that not everyone was impressed by or could be intimidated by him. Some of the members of this new generation just didn’t care about anything. Even life or death.

Superman had to come back and teach the new generation what it means to be a hero. So many of them were indistinguishable from the villains they fought. They would fight for fighting's sake and not care about the collateral damage. Superman at his best is both inspirational and aspirational and he needed to step away from the farm to remind them of that.

6. The Illuminati Removing The Hulk From Earth

SHIELD Director Maria Hill contacted Iron Man about the Hulk, who had recently destroyed parts of Las Vegas. Tony brought a plan to his fellow members of the Illuminati. The plan was to send the Hulk to an uninhabited planet where he could be alone. Namor declined and said when the Hulk would return, he would seek vengeance against them. The other four in attendance said yes and they tricked Banner onto a SHIELD satellite in need of repair and shot him into deep space. However, a malfunction sent Hulk to a war-torn world where he had to battle daily.

Advertisement

Bruce obviously wanted to stay away from people, as he was hiding in Alaska. If Tony had come to Bruce and offered him a ship equipped with the means to work on a cure and the means to live a comfortable solitary life, Bruce would have gone without a fight.

Something had to be done about the Hulk. When Hulk was under Banner’s control, his capacity for good was almost incalculable but when the Hulk was a mindless force of nature, he was a deadly storm of destructive rage. Only the Hulk’s friends stopped his rampages occasionally. Which Hulk would arrive was the question and the constant fear of everyone.

5. Hal Jordan And Zero Hour

Hal Jordan, possessed by the fear creature Parallax, planned to restart the universe to reflect his own views. Hal wanted to eliminate all evil and resurrect his destroyed hometown, Coast City. Parallax fought the heroes, was weakened by the Spectre, and killed by the Green Arrow. A new Big Bang happened and repaired time through natural means instead of a guided hand.

Advertisement

Hal tried to recreate Coast City with his ring. This was a violation of Corps rules and it got him called to OA to be reprimanded. But the devastated Jordan left many of his fellow Lanterns for dead as he took their rings. Hal murdered the Guardians and took the power from the Central Power Battery. This made him an easy target for the Parallax entity that had been trapped within.

The DC Universe needed to be fixed. The Crisis on Infinite Earths took more than 50 years of stories and tried to distill everything down into a single cohesive history on one planet Earth. But things fell through the cracks. The histories of a few characters refused to be retconned. So writers and artists tried on their own to fix it with varying degrees of success.

4. No More Mutants

As the “House of M’ reality was falling apart, Wanda Maximoff whispered three words: “No More Mutants.” When normal reality returned, it was estimated that nine out of every ten mutants had lost their powers on “M-Day” or the Decimation. Former mutants were targeted and some began to seek safe-havens. The estimated “198” known mutants assembled at Xavier’s school and received governmental protection. X-Factor Investigations declared their area as a “Mutant Town” and made it a safe place for mutants as well.

Advertisement

Even though Wanda had been manipulated from all sides during the House of M, she had no right to destroy the mutant population. Some mutants died immediately because their mutation was so extreme that it was the only thing keeping them alive. Some did not want to live in a world without powers and some were murdered because of what they had done when they had those powers.

And while the decimation of a species was terrible, it did force the mutant community to start paying closer attention to its members. It forced them to begin self-policing, self-controlling, and not letting people with world-ending powers run around unchallenged. It made the mutants more responsible for the actions of them all.

3. Batman’s Contingency Plans

Realizing that they were among the most powerful beings on the planet, Batman had created constituency plans for all of the members of the Justice League, past and present. He did this in case they are corrupted, became mind-controlled, or turned evil. All of his plans were to detain and incapacitate. Ra’s Al Ghul once stole his plans and altered them to be deadly for members of the League.

Advertisement

It was Batman’s distrust, need to be in control, and need to keep everything secret that was his undoing in the Tower of Babel incident. If he had simply revealed to the League that because of the semi-regular frequency of the team being mind-controlled, Batman had come up with plans to neutralize them until the threat is past. That simple statement could have saved a world of headaches.

But contingency plans had to be made. Too many of their villains had taken complete control of the League in recent history and it was only luck and the villain’s arrogance that allowed the League to win. And Batman was only human. When he worked and fought among gods every day, he had to be prepared.

2. The Superhero Civil War

The New Warriors’ mistake cost 600 people their lives and triggered a movement to make every person with powers register with the government. Captain America had seen the corruption and misuse of government power far too often and knew that registered heroes would be limited in who they could help. Iron Man believed that heroes needed to be held responsible and policed. Sides were picked, battle lines were drawn and people were hurt and killed. It took Cap seeing that the public was on Iron Man’s side to get him to stand down.

Advertisement

It didn’t need to come to blows. Iron Man, Reed Richards, and Hank Pym didn’t need to create a clone of Thor and it certainly didn’t need to kill Bill Foster. If Steve and Tony had remembered that they were friends and that Tony had been against registration for years and that Cap was against children putting themselves in harm’s way, they could have found common ground.

Too many young heroes with too much power were using their powers irresponsibly. Of course, they rebelled when they were met with the idea of forced registration but if they were offered help and an opportunity to learn, chances are that many would have signed up willingly.

1. Flashpoint

Barry Allen awoke in a world where he didn’t have his speed, Superman and the Justice League didn’t exist, The Amazons and the armies of Atlantis were at each other's throats and Batman was Thomas Wayne, avenging the murder of his slain son, Bruce. But Barry's mother was alive! He found that he saved his mother but doomed the world by traveling back in time.

Advertisement

As one of the heroes that understand the complexities of time dynamics, Flash knows better than most how changing the timeline can lead to disaster. Even though Barry changed everything back, the timeline was still altered for a time by outside manipulation and the heroes had to endure the New 52 timeline. This change might not have been possible without Barry’s initial trip.

Flash had to do everything he could to thwart the schemes of Eobard Thawne. Zoom’s manipulations of Barry’s life, the lives of other speedsters and the time steam as a whole are too dangerous to be left unchallenged. And The Flash is one of the few heroes equipped to deal with Thawne. The mistakes Flash himself made are prime examples of the mess Thawne can unleash if left unchecked.

Advertisement