10 Times Superman Was Forced To Kill

Truth, Justice, and the American way...?

By Tom Baker /

Advertisement

Superman doesn't kill. It's a truism almost as old and well known as the Man Of Steel himself, who by last count was something approaching 77 years old and in no danger of losing his popularity, with his last big screen outing netting a cool $872.7m at the box office. It's one of the key aspects of his character, besides the red-and-blue uniform, the spit curl, and the secret identity that nobody really buys but ssshhh, we've all accepted it for this long, just go with it.

He may not be born of this Earth but Superman is supposed to represent the best of humanity, a standard we should all hold ourselves up to. Which means living virtuously, helping people, and firing lasers out of your eyes if you can. It also means not straight up murdering people, or killing at all, because that's not cool. Even on Krypton, a place that was certifiably crazy-go-nuts. It's why people kicked up such a fuss about the end of Zack Snyder's Man Of Steel, why the character's depiction in the Injustice: Gods Among Us video game is so weird, and why people are always wondering why Kal-El doesn't use his superior powers to just enslave the whole human race.

Advertisement

Because he's a good dude, that's why! Jeez! Except, well, it's one of those truisms that isn't actually true. Clark Kent, against his better judgement, has killed before. And he'll probably kill again, albeit reluctantly. Fun as it is to see The Punisher gun down loads of gangsters, there's a lot more drama in a guy who expressly respects human life and holds it sacred having to snuff one out.

Which is why, today, we're going to look at ten times Superman was forced to kill.

Advertisement

10. Zod At The End Of Man Of Steel

Warner Bros.

Let's get the obvious one out of the way first off. Zack Snyder's reboot of the Superman movie franchise came after Bryan Singer's slavish sequel and love letter to the more colourful, innocent fare of Christopher Reeve in the seventies - which dramatically bombed at the box office.

Advertisement

Not wanting a repeat of that disaster, Warner Bros. looked to Christopher Nolan's incredibly successful Dark Knight trilogy of Batman adaptations, and decided they wanted more of that. So Man Of Steel became the "realistic", grimdark Superman movie where death and destruction awaits behind every corner and, more often than not, Kal-El himself plays a big part in it.

Basically the entire last half of the film is Supes grappling with Kryptonian bad guys General Zod and Faora across Smallville and Metropolis, highly populated urban areas that are completely decimated during the superpowered battle.

Advertisement

If that wasn't enough accidental death caused by our supposed paragon of humanity and heroism, the film climaxes with Zod and Superman in a train station, with Zod shooting some eye beams that will evaporate a family if Supes doesn't stop him in time. So the Man Of Steel decides to break the guy's neck, which is direct and indisputable murder. Zod didn't really leave him a choice, but still.

Not cool, grimdark Clark.

Advertisement

9. A Kryptonian Dragon

DC Comics

Most people needn't worry (though tell that to the populations of Metropolis and Smallville), since it appears Superman keeps most of his killings solely to creatures from his home planet. He's probably jealous of people muscling in on his "Last Son Of Krypton" shtick. How can he cry about how alone he is in the universe if he's actually not alone in the universe? Jeez.

Advertisement

Keeping with the grittier style introduced in Man Of Steel, DC Comics recently relaunched their whole shared universe under an initiative called the New 52, which has mainly been about eliminating interesting character development and making everyone angsty murderers.

Superman is no exception. A recent storyline in the Man Of Steel's main title saw a mysterious Kryptonian villain - but not Zod, mind you - trying to resurrect his homeworld, but on Earth. And apparently Krypton had huge dragons, because if it can have Russell Crowe, why not huge dragons? Naturally, it's Superman's mess to clean up, so he hot tails it over there and starts putting the smackdown on this mythical fire breathing monster. He comes to the conclusion that the creature's DNA is decaying, so it's not technically alive, but it is hella destructive.

Advertisement

So he roasts it with his heat vision and it explodes. Sure, there's the "not technically alive" proviso and the dragon did have the potential to harm civilians, but also Superman just killed a sentient being without really thinking too hard about it. And an endangered species, at that! Kal-El, Bill Oddie would have words with thee.

8. Dr Light During Trinity War

DC Comics

Just to make sure you didn't think that was a momentary lapse in morality, or particularly out of character for this all-new all-different big blue boy scout, DC decided to follow up the dragoncide of Superman #13 with even more murder amongst the Trinity War crossover a few months later.

Advertisement

The premise of the eleven-issue event that ran through the Justice League title was that Pandora's Box actually existed and was a crazy powerful, ancient weapon that a lot of bad dudes wanted to get their hands on. Pandora herself approached Superman to look after it, believing him to be "without sin", but just touching it made him go a little loopy, so she scarpered.

A little while later, the Justice League end up in Kahndaq trying to stop Shazam from causing a diplomatic incident, which escalates into a battle between the League and the government-sponsored JLA. One of the members of the JLA is new recruit Dr Light, who was best known in the pre-New 52 continuity for being at the centre of Identity Crisis, a.k.a. the worst comic book ever written that reduced all of the DC superheroes to manipulative, back stabbing jerks.

Advertisement

Hoping for a bit of career rehabilitation in this new universe, Light teams up with this nice team of do-gooders and ends up fighting Superman. And by "fighting Superman", we mean "having his head blasted clean off of his body by Superman's heat vision".

During the heat of the battle the Man Of Steel and Dr Light wind up duking it out mano-a-mano after he inadvertently attacks Wonder Woman (whom Superman is sweet on, because they get fan fiction people to write comics now). Everyone is shocked at the cold-blooded murder, not least of all Supes himself, and it's later revealed he was mind-controlled to do it as an ongoing campaign to discredit him and the Justice League.

Advertisement

Still killed him, though.

7. Mxzyptlk, Then Himself

DC Comics

Alan Moore has made a career out of deconstructing superheroes (and frankly we're getting a little tired of it), but his first - and possibly best - exploration of the modern mythical pantheon was probably Whatever Happened To The Man Of Tomorrow?, billed upon publication as "The Last Superman Story." And for all intents and purposes, it was exactly that.

Advertisement

Remember the New 52 we mentioned a bit ago? That's something DC does a lot, and it started with an eighties crossover designed to slim down the company's forty year history a little called Crisis On Infinite Earths. After the event, everything got switched back to year zero, meaning decades of Superman continuity were wiped from the canon. Which meant Alan Moore had carte blanche to do whatever he wanted with it - it wouldn't count in a month's time anyway.

Or at least that was the idea, but the story ended up becoming one of the most celebrated in the character's history. Drawn by long-term Supes artist Curt Swan and with assistance from editor Julius Schwartz, the story brought in many tropes and characters prevalent during the more innocent Golden and Silver Ages of the character, before giving them a lethal twist. Over the course of the two-part story, Clark Kent's secret identity is revealed and Lex Luthor, Lana Lang, Jimmy Olsen, and Krypto all get killed by Brainiac and the Legion Of Super-Villains.

Advertisement

It transpires that this was all orchestrated by Mr. Mxyzptlk, a being from the fifth dimension who previously turned up as a fairly easy to deal with prankster. Having transcended time and space for a while, though, he got bored and bloodthirsty, deciding to turn his attention on his greatest foe. Transforming into a more formidable, mind-bending form, Superman realises the only way to stop Mxyzptlk is to trap him between two dimensions, effectively killing him. Having broken his oath never to take a life, Superman enters the "GOLD KRYPTONITE ROOM" of his Fortress Of Solitude, committing suicide.

Or did he...?

Advertisement

6. Zod And Pals At The End Of Superman II

Warner Bros.

One of the defences brought up by people who liked Man Of Steel was that its denouement was entirely in keeping with previous depictions of the character. We've already seen the handful of times Superman has killed an enemy to save thousands more lives in the comic books, but he also did it in the Christopher Reeves' movies, too.

Advertisement

What are seen as colourful, innocent old-timey superhero pictures courtesy of Richard Donner (and Richard Lester, we add under duress), actually involved Superman pretty much just murdering the villains of the piece - and again, they're General Zod and his Kryptonian cronies. Negotiations really don't work with those guys, huh. Superman II, specifically, featured this, and the production was such a mess that we don't have a clue if it was Donner, his replacement Lester, or one of the film's four credited screenwriters who came up with the climactic action scene.

The basic plot of the movie is that Kryptonian criminals General Zod (Terence Stamp), Ursa (Sarah Douglas), and Non (Jack O'Halloran) escape from their Phantom Zone prison and start wreaking havoc on Earth, hoping to coax out Superman, the other surviving Kryptonian. Zod takes advantage of Superman's noticeable concern for the innocent bystanders, and starts purposefully placing them in peril during their fight in Metropolis. Realising the only way to defeat the villains lies in his Fortress Of Solitude, Superman lures them there - and out of harm's way - where he exposes them to a magical crystal chamber that saps them of all their powers, rendering them useless and not at all dangerous. Then he crushes Zod's hand to a fine paste and tosses all the baddies into a bottomless pit where, lacking their super strength, they will surely die.

Advertisement

What a hero! It's not got the visceral nastiness of snapping a neck, but condemning people to either be splattered or starve to death is still pretty hardcore.

5. Everyone In The Olden Days

DC Comics

Batman famously has his own variation on the no-killing rule, with his stretching to expressly forbid the use of guns, following his parents getting shot as a kid. Except, in the early days of the character when they hadn't quite nailed down all these absolutes, the Dark Knight used to murder people all the time.

Advertisement

That same respect for human life clearly came late in the game for Superman, since his thirties appearances by creators Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster were full of Golden Age genocide courtesy of the Last Son Of Krypton. Not so virtuous now, huh. Not wishing to waste any time, he got right down to it in the pages of Superman #1, when the character was just starting to enter the "jingoistic propaganda figure" phase of his career, as he tossed an army general off of a cliff and then destroyed an enemy plane without checking to see if the pilot parachuted out in time.

From there, he blew up a munitions factory and appeared as a star witness in his Clark Kent guise at a criminal trial, ensuring the defendants all got the death penalty. Man, old timey Superman was super into people dying. In the next issue he broke into a bad guy's lab and let him be consumed by his own poison gas, boasting that it had no effect on his alien physiology. Then he caught a bomb dropped by an enemy aircraft and chucked it back up, destroying the plane (and, presumably, everyone onboard). He lets a truck full of criminals fall of a cliff in favour of saving one belonging to the Daily Planet, which sort of puts paid to The Prisoners' Dilemma boat scene in The Dark Knight.

Advertisement

Oh, and finally he let a guy who'd figured out his secret identity fall down a flight of steps and break his neck before he could spill the beans. Yes, "fall", that sounded convincing enough...

4. Imperiex And Brainiac, To Save The Universe

DC Comics

We've said it before and we'll say it again, but Our Worlds At War is one of our favourite modern crossovers. There's so much to revel in the sprawling multi-part comic book epics that are mainly designed to make you part from even more of your hard-earned dollars than usual, but in this case we were rewarded with a huge, cosmic event with some real stakes and lasting implications. And it was pretty much just Superman versus Galactus, the planet-eating deity from Marvel Comics, so we enjoyed it on a purely geeky fan service level, too.

Advertisement

In Our World At War, the Galactus analogue is Imperiex, the living embodiment of universal entropy who is slowly making his way to Earth and destroying every planet, star system, and piece of space junk he comes across during his journey. Imperiex intends to use our world as the staging ground for the "hollowing" of the entire universe, which obviously everybody's a little put out by. So much so that heroes and villains alike team up to try and stop him - even the legendary Darkseid pops up to stop this interloper from decimating the cosmos before he can get a chance.

Ultimately Brainiac, a long-term Superman villain who was also part of the resistance against Imperiex, betrayed the Earth and decided to shack up with the world destroyer, absorbing some of his new buddy's energy and vowing to use it to rule everything. Left with no choice after conventional attacks fail to halt their progress, Superman shoves them through a wormhole that takes them back to the exact moment of the Big Bang, which "spreads their consciousness across trillions of light years instantly". Which isn't exactly conventional murder, and most lawyers would have a hard time drawing up a precedent in court, but it sounds like killing to us.

Advertisement

3. The Joker, In An Alternate Dimension

DC Comics

Injustice: Gods Among Us is a very, very weird video game. A fighting title developed by the people who made Mortal Kombat, they had the unenviable task of not only dreaming up a reason for a bunch of DC superheroes and villains to be fighting amongst themselves, but also why the usually anti-death likes of Superman, Batman, and Wonder Woman would be pulling off some brutal FATALITY-style finishing moves.

Advertisement

NetherRealm Studios ended up doing well at hinting at why the former superfriends had all fallen out without going into too much detail, which meant there was plenty of room for the prequel comic book to pick up the slack. By all accounts, the Injustice comics have become pretty entertaining as they've entered their second year, becoming a pretty goofy and fun alternate reality, wish-fulfillment kinda funny-book. The first batch, though, were pretty rough. The art was uniformly ghastly, the writing wasn't up to much snuff either, and in order to reach the status quo of the games we had to see a lot of superheroes acting wildly out of character.

Like Superman shoving his fist through The Joker and murdering him by tearing out his heart, for example. To back it up a little, the first issue of the comic opens with Batman telling Supes that Lois Lane is pregnant with his super baby. Which is all very exciting, if a little unrealistic as Mallrats will tell you, and whilst they're distracted by the celebrations, The Joker walks up to Lois and Jimmy Olsen in the street and shoots them both dead.

Advertisement

Enraged, the Man Of Steel turns up at court on the day of the Clown Prince's trial and kills him. Which puts him a little at odds with Bats, who has managed to resist that urge for years, and from there a superhero civil war breaks out. So maybe he wasn't forced to kill in this situation but, man, wouldn't you?

2. Doomsday

DC Comics

The Death And Return Of Superman are not good comic books. Not by any stretch of the imagination, and boy do we comic geeks manage to stretch. We put Richard Simmons to shame with our stretches.

Advertisement

The killing of DC's biggest character and cultural icon wasn't ever meant to be a good story, however, it was just supposed to be an "event". It was a publicity stunt that was 100% successful, as the story got picked up in mainstream news outlets across the world and consequently the issues in question sold like hot cakes. Like, at least forty cakes. That's as many as four tens. And that's terrible.

For a storyline that was particularly uninspired in its conception, the method of Superman's demise was similarly dull, with new villain Doomsday being introduced explicitly as the Man Of Steel's only physical equal, which meant that long-term fans and children alike were treated to a multi-page action scene of splash pages where Superman was pummelled to death by a big grey dude with protruding bone things. The final image was of Clark Kent beaten, bloody, bruised, and limp in Lois Lane's arms.

Advertisement

It was all rather upsetting. Thankfully Doomsday had also died at Superman's hands during their brawl that took in the whole of Metropolis and caused a level of damage that would make Henry Cavill jealous. This was after the monster - who was Kryptonian in origin, because of course he was - had already laid waste to the rest of the Justice League and clashed with Superman on numerous occasions. On this final one, however, Kal-El decided to break an oath that even super glue couldn't piece back together at this point, punching Doomsday to death just before he expires himself.

1. Zod And Pals In Superman #22

DC Comics

So, Superman doesn't kill, except for when he does. And more often than not, when he decides to get his hands dirty with the blood of his enemies, the enemies in question are General Zod and the Kryptonian crime gang.

Advertisement

We've already seen our hero eliminate the bad guys in Superman II and Man Of Steel, both cited as being totally out of character and not consistent with the comic books at all. Except they absolutely are, and there was a whole storyline about it back in the eighties, courtesy of writer/artist John Byrne.

Byrne, who had previously made a name for himself drawing some of the most famous X-Men and Wolverine stories in Marvel's history, made the jump to DC right around the time of that Crisis On Infinite Earths thing we mentioned earlier. He was entrusted with rejigging and updating Superman's origins and character for a modern audience, which he did in the Man Of Steel miniseries. Apparently updating Clark Kent for the eighties meant giving him a mullet, but besides that, Byrne did a pretty good job of recreating the hero for a modern age: he still had the same costume, the same morals, the same abilities. He was just younger. And used a cell phone from time to time.

Advertisement

In this new universe, we reverted back to Kal-El as the actual Last Son Of Krypton, with none of these other dilly-dalliers counting in the existing continuity. Which meant that when he inevitably faced General Zod in Byrne's version, he had to travel to a pocket universe within his own where many Kryptonians had survived the planet's destruction, including alternate reality versions of Zod, Quex-Ul, and Faora. Who actually weren't different from any other incarnation, and so Superman has to beat them up.

He then realises that the group were sentenced to death before Krypton was destroyed, and they only avoided this punishment because they managed to escape before it was dealt. They had also just wiped out the human population of this alternate Earth, so Superman reluctantly took the role of executioner, exposing them all to Kryptonite that had no effect on him for some reason. He sure did feel bad about it, though, and maybe that's the most important thing: Superman shouldn't kill, true, which means that when he is forced to, it's all the more tragic.

Advertisement

And dramatic. And worthy of being put in a list.