10 Unbelievable Times Batman Beat Superman

The many times the Caped Crusader knocked the Man of Steel on his butt.

By John Tibbetts /

You would think a brawl between Batman and Superman would be over relatively quickly. I mean, for all the Dark Knight's gadgets and know-how, a guy who's bulletproof is still a guy who is bulletproof.

Advertisement

But then, is the company called AC Comics? No sir, it's DC comics, which stands for Detective Comics, which means that Batman - famously referred to over the decades by the moniker of the World's Greatest Detective - is the star of the show here.

Now, Bats and Supes are supposedly best friends, unless you ask certain writers who shall remain unnamed. Except not really; I'm talking about Frank Miller. But there have been many times where the two have been forced to come to blows. And some of those times, Batman - through sheer ingenuity or will - came out on top against the mightiest superhero around.

With that in mind, then, here are ten such examples of those times where the Caped Crusader managed to get the better of the Man of Steel, the Last Son of Krypton, the Big Blue Boy Scout: Superman.

10. Batman/Superman Annual #1

Bottom of the list, since neither party were fighting all that seriously, but it still counts.

Advertisement

In this annual issue of Batman/Superman, the duo find themselves at the mercy of a gladiatorial arena where they are ordered to fight to the death. Now, obviously the two aren't actually going to do this, but in order to buy time until one of them can think of something, they at least try to make it convincing.

Thus we see that, in terms of raw fighting ability, all else being equal, Batman will come out on top. Granted, the conclusion is nothing decisive, ultimately keeping it from being further up the list, but the way the fight was going at the time showed Batman distinctly at an advantage, so I'm willing to call it for the Caped Crusader in this scenario.

Also keeping it from getting any higher is the simple fact that Superman wasn't fighting seriously, so it's hard to truly gauge how well this would've gone for Bruce otherwise.

9. Batman: The Dark Knight #5

This may come as a shock, but the majority of the time, Batman and Superman DON'T want to fight each other. Like, not even a little. Not even when one is being mean. They're friends, and friends don't typically resolve any issues they have with each other by beating the living daylights out of the other.

Advertisement

So in order to GET them to fight each other, writers have to come up with convoluted misunderstandings or, failing that, the tried and true mind control plotline!

In Batman: The Dark Knight #5, Batman gets hit with a new strain of Scarecrow's fear toxin, turning him into a raving lunatic with super strength. It comes down to Superman to get him to snap out of it, only for Bats to take advantage of the fact that Clark doesn't want to hurt him by beating him to a bloody pulp.

Superman technically wins, downing Batman with a solid right hook, which is what keeps this entry from getting any higher, but the Caped Crusader was close to - for the first time - downing the Man of Steel with no tricks, gadgets, or edgelord robot suits.

8. Superman: Red Son

A common theme you've probably noticed through this list is that Batman knows full well that trying to take on Superman head-on is, uh, unwise, to say the least. Even when backed against the wall and needing to fight his way through the Man of Steel, Bats usually has to stack the deck in his favor in some way to even survive a man who can reduce him to red paste by briskly walking through him.

Advertisement

One of the most notable examples of this took place in the beloved Elseworlds classic, Superman: Red Son.

In this alternate universe, where Superman's craft instead landed in Soviet Russia instead of Kansas, Batman is reimagined as a violent terrorist who hates Superman's guts to the point of gleefully bombing buildings full of people just to draw him out. Their final confrontation takes place in an underground mine shaft that the Dark Knight has filled with lamps that have the rays of a red sun, thus weakening Superman immediately.

If it wasn't for Wonder Woman making the save here, Superman would have been done for.

7. Batman: Hush

Batman: Hush holds the distinction of being one of the most terrifying examples of a Batman/Superman fight, purely because Batman genuinely comes off as outmatched and in over his head.

Advertisement

For context, in this part of the story, Poison Ivy has used her powers to seize control of Superman's mind. When the Dark Knight and Catwoman get to close to unraveling this scheme, Ivy sends her new boy toy to make a nice pair of grease stains out of them both.

What results is less a fight and more a desperate struggle to avoid the out-of-control Kryptonian by any means necessary. It doesn't last long, of course, as Superman demonstrates that if he got serious, Batman wouldn't even have time to react before he was murdered. Fortunately, Catwoman makes the save by appealing to Kal-El's primal need to protect others... by throwing Lois off the side of a building, thus snapping Supes out of the mind control when he instinctively goes to save his beau.

6. The Dark Knight Strikes Again

It should be a rule that comic book listicle writers MUST receive a bonus in their next paycheck whenever they have to talk about The Dark Knight Strikes Again, because otherwise, it's just not worth it most of the time.

Advertisement

However, in terms of fights between Batman and Superman, this one did have some big shoes to fill, so it should be covered. It goes without saying that its predecessor is quite a ways further up on the list.

Anyway, Strikes Again follows up the legendary fight of its predecessor by having Superman invade the Batcave at the behest of the government, only to find Batman there waiting for him with a pair of Kryptonite gauntlets. No armor this time, which you would think would make this fight more one-sided, but with Bruce having wrapped his arms completely in Kryptonite for this fight, Superman can't do a lot but get knocked around.

The fight is the highlight of this infamous series, but if that isn't faint praise, I don't know what is.

5. The Man Of Steel #3

When John Byrne was given the task of rebooting Superman for the first time in the company's history after Crisis on Infinite Earths, there were of course a lot of aspects of Superman's mythos that suddenly needed to be explained that the original 1930s' comics just never bothered with. One of which being how exactly Superman and Batman met.

Advertisement

With Frank Miller having similarly rebooted Batman in the pages of Batman: Year One as a dark, mysterious vigilante, naturally the two don't start off on the right foot. Batman claims to be trying to be a little better in his approach to super-heroing, but considering he starts off their relationship by forcing Superman to help him stop the villain Magpie or else he'll set off a bomb on an innocent civilian, the Last Son of Krypton isn't exactly convinced.

It turns out to be a complete lie, of course. After Magpie is put away, Superman confronts Batman about the bomb, and Bats just puts it in Superman's hand. The only life in danger was the Dark Knight himself; a ruse he pulled to get Superman to help him stop Magpie. Batman doesn't defeat Superman in the classical sense, but he does start off their relationship by establishing a key difference between them.

"I am smarter than you."

4. World's Finest #240

The Silver Age of Comics was the wild west for DC, and I don't just mean that in that there were entirely too many cowboy comics during that time. Literally, anything could, and probably did happen. For example, one of the first instances of Batman becoming a rebel against a tyrannical Superman was actually from this time, and in true Silver Age fashion it was...weird.

Advertisement

In this story, Kal-El is pressured into assuming the leadership role of the shrunken city of Kandor. And, in a twist that I'm sure will never be copied by cynical edgelords decades later, almost immediately becomes an emotionally erratic tyrant over the poor Kandorians. Sensing that they perhaps made a mistake, the Kandorians call in Batman to deal with the problem. Bruce agrees, and soon discovers the true root of the Man of Steel's turn to evil; the monstrous creature responsible for corrupting Superman into a vicious fascist tyrant: a cat from outer space!

If you caught that reference, congratulations, you have officially watched way too many Disney movies.

So anyway, through a hilariously convoluted series of misdirections, Batman manages to get the cat off of Supes and get him back to his senses. Basically the same conclusion as the previous entry, but nicer: "I am smarter than you, and thank god because who else could have deduced an alien cat?"

3. Superman/Batman: The Trust

This beautifully rendered mini-story by Chipp Kidd and Alex Ross is one of the best encapsulations of Superman and Batman's friendship and how deep it runs.

Advertisement

Brainiac has seized control of the Last Son of Krypton and is using him to wreak havoc. Now, Superman and Batman aren't idiots, and have discussed what measures need to be taken should something like this happen. So, Batman pulls out a gun and gets to work.

As you can probably guess, the gun is loaded with Kryptonite, so as Batman grapples onto Superman's leg and takes aim, it appears the story is headed for tragedy. But Clark is Bruce's best friend, so of course Bats would never break his one oath when it came to the Boy Scout. Instead of a bullet, the gun is loaded with a Kryptonite dart, that accomplishes the same thing without killing Superman, allowing Bats to remove Brainiac's control device.

A glorious win for the Caped Crusader and a touching reaffirmation of their friendship to boot.

2. Batman: Endgame

The biggest problem with Batman: Endgame as a storyline, besides it being one of the worst offenders of Scott Snyder's need to insert a chapter's worth of text into a single freaking panel, is that it played its trump card WAY too early. This storyline STARTS on Batman having a knock-down, drag-out fight with the entire Justice League, and it's so glorious that anything after can only disappoint.

Advertisement

Case in point, the star attraction of the first half of the story, a Jokerfied Superman going toe to toe with an already run-ragged Batman. The World's Greatest Detective has used the Fenrir armor and all the countermeasures it has to neutralize half the Justice League, but not without taking some licks himself. And while the suit is tough, this is still Superman we're talking about here.

At the end of it all, Batman just barely manages to eke out a win by spitting Kryptonite gum in Superman's eye, sending them both to the bottom of Gotham Bay. Thus demonstrating Batman's ultimate point during these first two issues: who wins between Batman and Superman? Neither.

1. The Dark Knight Returns

Despite your writer's dig at Frank Miller in the opening of this list, it could only be this fight at the top. This fight is the biggest reason why anyone remembers The Dark Knight Returns. Batman and Superman had fought in the comics before, but Miller really did sit down and ask "okay, no holds barred, both sides giving it their all, who would win and how?"

Advertisement

Superman, now a stooge of the openly fascistic American government - and you know we're in a bad way when America is closer to TDKR's America than Batman Beyond's corporate dystopia nightmare, and the corporate dystopia nightmare starts looking pretty good - rolls up on a blacked-out Gotham to bring the Caped Crusader in. Batman, knowing that this was always how it was going to end when he took back up the cowl, has prepared for the fight with the now iconic armored suit.

The resulting fight is one of the best in comic book history, a genuine back and forth with both sides employing a mix of strategy and brute force to try and get the other to stay down. But Batman has something Supes doesn't: Green Arrow, who hits him with a Kryptonite arrow the second he isn't looking.

The Kryptonite doesn't kill Clark, and Bruce seemingly dies immediately after this due to a heart attack, but killing Clark wasn't the point. The point was to show the world that the US government's superweapon wasn't invincible, that they CAN be defied and even defeated. That real change can come.

And boy howdy, does that sound good these days...

Advertisement