10 Worst Things Reed Richards Has Ever Done
The Fantastic Four's leader has a SERIOUS mean streak.
The Marvel universe has many geniuses, but none - except probably Moon Girl - come close to Reed Richards. It is almost absurd how smart this dude is, calculating and solving problems that most people didn't even know existed, let alone that they needed fixing, and has been nothing but a boon to humanity on the whole.
So why then - oh why - does he keep screwing up?
Whether it's because his big brain overthinks everything, or he just doesn't clue his friends and family into what he's doing, there are multiple times throughout Marvel canon where its smartest man constantly finds himself looking like a butt monkey while Sue and the other FF have to deal with the fallout of his screw ups.
Hell, sometimes the horrible stuff he does is 100% intentional - something he sees as the greater good - but to people with more empathetic and small picture viewpoints, just looks like him being a massive knob.
These 10 examples represent some of the many reasons why many Marvel heroes find Reed more difficult than anything else.
10. Injected Franklin With Nanomachines
A wise man once said that it is better to ask for forgiveness than permission. Reed Richards, it would seem, has taken this concept completely to heart. However, even the person behind that phrase, I like to believe, would agree that things like "bodily autonomy" should be listed as one of the few exceptions to that rule.
Shame, then, that Reed Richards disagrees heavily.
Now, when your kid has the power to alter reality to his every whim, to the point where he can magically undo the miscarriage of his little sister, it stands to reason that you would want to keep an eye on him to make sure he isn't going Bright Burn on your ass. But in the short lived series Fantastic Four/Power Pack, we learn that Reed's method of doing this is less "convincing your kid to download Life 360 or something", and more "nanomachines, son!"
This is bad enough on its own, but then it turns out that the nanomachines are potentially radioactive, so even more egg on your face, Dr. Richards.
9. He Hid The Fact That The FF Were Dying
Reed Richards' main flaw, bar none, is the fact that he thinks he can fix everything all by himself. It is that flaw that gives birth to pretty much every decision on this list, and it's why his and Sue's marriage can get more than a little rocky at times.
One of the most egregious examples in recent years came in the form of Matt Fraction's excellent run on Fantastic Four back in 2013. In it, Reed makes the horrifying discovery that - shock of all shocks - getting hit by cosmic rays might have some longer term negative side effects.
While the four DID get amazing powers from the cosmic rays, those same powers are basically a form of super cancer that is slowly killing them all.
But, does Reed TELL his family this? Of course he doesn't - did you forget who we're talking about here? Reed felt that he could fix this on his own, and not even need to tell them. So he hides this fact from his family until it blows up in his face.
8. Forming The Council Of Reeds
Ever wonder where Rick And Morty got the idea for the Council of Ricks? Well, naturally, they got it from one of the biggest satirical inspirations for Rick Sanchez: Reed Richards.
While technically not the action of OUR Reed, enough versions of him make this decision that it definitely counts here. Jonathan Hickman opened his legendary run on Fantastic Four with Reed being approached by three different versions of himself, who take him to see the Council of Reeds. A meeting of the same mind throughout the multiverse, who all gather to swap notes and workshop ideas on how to solve EVERYTHING.
Sounds harmless enough, right? Yeah, no - no it isn't.
See, as we'll learn later in this list, Reed as a character is very VERY close, pretty much all the time, to crossing the line into megalomaniacal evil if he doesn't have his family to yank back on his choke chain. And while the intentions of the Council members are genuine and good, they go about it in a cold, surgical way that our Reed just can't abide by for long.
They openly admit that while giving up their families isn't a requirement for being on the council, it's something that WILL happen. Sue will stop understanding, Ben and Johnny will stop vouching, and Franklin and Valeria flat out deserve better.
While Reed does turn his back on the Council upon learning this - on top of things like learning that every member of the council has either killed or lobotomized and enslaved Victor Von Doom - the fact that this makes our Reed an exception to a disturbing rule says a lot.
7. Made Ben Wear A Thing Suit
Ben's transformation into The Thing represents many things, but in terms of Reed's character, it is a near constant reminder of the consequences of listening to his own ego instead of the facts. Deciding that he HAD to be right and everyone else was wrong cost the best friend he ever had his normal life and all of his aspirations.
Fortunately, many moments have come in the past where Ben has gotten to have his normal body again. But one time when he did, Reed really didn't think through how his friend felt about his former body. So when Luke Cage left the team, leaving them with only three members again, Reed decided to put Ben back on the team by making him a suit that he can use to keep up.
Sounds harmless enough, downright thoughtful of Reed in fact. Shame that he messed it up by making it look like The Thing.
You cannot convince me that Reed motherloving Richards couldn't come up with a less bulky version of The Thing's body that still has all the strength of that former body. And even if he couldn't, Ben HATES how he looks as The Thing, so why subject him to having to look like that at all when he gets his original body back?
6. Backed The Registration Act
Now, in fairness to Reed, nobody comes out of Civil War looking good. Everyone crosses various moral lines that inform the next decade of stories surrounding them due to those lines being so morally egregious that you have to wonder what they were all thinking when they did what they did.
In Reed's case, we at least know WHY he backed the registration act when it was introduced by the US government. Reed was looking at things from the perspective of Asimovian Psychohistory, which predicts the future behaviors of crowds through the lenses of history, sociology, and mathematical statistics. The way Reed saw it, way more people would have died in various ensuing conflicts if the registration act had not passed.
Which is definitely a very good reason for the backing of the act itself. Less so for the actions he takes after that inciting incident. I'll get to the two biggest ones soon, but even barring those, backing the registration act helps set into motion all the other horrible stuff done by people besides him, so he definitely shares the blame somewhat there.
5. Founded The Illuminati
An act so devastating that the next three writers to work on the FF afterwards (Straczynski, McDuffie, and Hickman specifically) spent all their time trying to find out just what the ever-loving heck he was thinking.
The Illuminati was the product of a bunch of super smart, super paranoid heroes coming together to try and solve potential problems for the Marvel universe before they actually have time to BECOME problems. Everything that they specifically do varies depending on the universe you consult, but it says a lot that in a couple of the universes Reed finds, that version of himself decided that the Illuminati members needed to be murdered before they even formed the infamous alliance.
All of the Illuminati members are plenty paranoid on their own, but putting them all in one room together with zero reins to yank them back down to Earth is a recipe for trouble. It was the Illuminati who decided that the best course of action for dealing with The Hulk was to shoot him into space. Only reason that act isn't on the list is because one of the Illuminati members is Doctor Strange, who could have just TELEPORTED Bruce to the planet they wanted to send him to, but for some reason didn't, so Reed can't bear all the blame there.
Unlike the next entry...
4. Built A Prison In The Negative Zone
Reed's biggest screw up in Civil War, by far, is his decision on what should be done with the superheroes who defy the registration act when they get caught by the government: lock them up in the Negative Zone.
Now, for obvious legal reasons, they couldn't use this plot point in the movie, but that was to the movie's benefit since - while The Raft looked like hell on Earth, at least those trapped within it weren't extradited to another plane of reality to be made prisoner by their own friends.
This downright fascist move by Reed has almost zero justification for it, since as Civil War so handily displayed, the Marvel universe ain't exactly hurting for places to put superpowered folks when they get too uppity, so why resort to trapping them in an extra-dimensional gulag at all, even barring the moral and ethical line crossing doing so entails?
But as genuinely horrible an act as this is, it pales in comparison to Reed's other big d*ck-move in Civil War.
3. Made A Killer Thor Clone
Cloning as a concept is one of the most controversial in modern science. There's a reason that real life cloning has limited itself to ONLY cloning animals like Dolly the sheep. It can easily cross the line into being an incredibly invasive breach of privacy and trust of a person's body, especially if they don't give their express consent.
Clearly, to Reed Richards, consent is more of a suggestion than a rule. Or at least that's the logic I ascribe to why Reed thought that cloning his friend Thor during Civil War would at all be a good idea.
Now, one could argue that Thor was dead at the time, so whether or not he consented to being cloned doesn't really play into this situation. I would in turn argue that that is so much worse. Especially since the first thing this Thor clone does is brutally murder the superhero Goliath during the first major conflict of Civil War. In turn escalating everything that happens in that story and beyond.
Reed does a lot of shifty stuff in Civil War, and this is by far the worst of it.
2. His Misogyny Toward Sue
The original idea for the Fantastic Four was as a deliberate subversion of the typical superhero archetype, especially that of team up books where all the heroes get along. The FF were a family, and like any family, they bickered and sniped at each other at the drop of a hat.
For the most part, that original run and how Stan and Jack played that original running gag holds up marvelously. Unfortunately, there's one part where the old books show their age: Reed's misogynistic behavior toward Sue.
Pretty much all modern writers who work on the FF nowadays like to just pretend this was never a thing, and there's nothing wrong with that, but when you want to talk about the worst things Reed has ever done, talking down to one of the most magnificent women in the Marvel universe like she's some useless helpless thing and having that be played for laughs definitely needs to be mentioned.
But hey, at least this era of Reed is well and truly behind us, right? More than our top entry can say.
1. Becoming The Maker
Ultimate Reed Richards seemed like a normal alternate version of our Reed at first, granted with a few things changed to set the two apart. But over time, the layers began to be peeled off to reveal that this version of Reed was a true blue sociopath with a fundamentally contemptuous view of human life, and his universe in particular.
So he became The Maker, with the aim of leaving his universe behind to find one that's a tad more fascinating, after blowing up his original one, of course. He wouldn't be that good a villain if his motivation stopped at needing a vacation.
The Maker is everything that 616 Reed struggles with keeping himself from becoming every single day, as this list so handily demonstrates. He is all of Reed's vices, with none of his virtues, and becoming The Maker - with everything The Maker then does afterwards - is by far the worst thing a version of Reed Richards has ever done.