10 Worst Things Robin Has Ever Done To Batman
Boy Wonder? Well, that's one way of putting it...
Whether on the pages of our favourite DC comics, on TV, in the movies or in video games, Bruce Wayne's relationships with the many and varied incarnations of Robin have been as complex and dynamic as the legendary duo title would imply.
Mentor, drill sergeant, surrogate father, literal father; Batman is many things to many people.
As for Robin, this mantle has been passed from sidekick to sidekick since Bruce first made the fateful decision to take the newly-orphaned Dick Grayson under his wing.
But what happens when things go wrong?
As with any relationship, and especially one as intense and emotionally charged as that of Batman and his Robins, things are not always great and often descend into chaos and trauma.
Whilst ultimately grounded in respect, admiration, trust and - ultimately - love, things have often gone very wrong for Batman and Robin, with the latter often being the aggressor in these tense and often violent situations.
It is more than fair to say that Batman has himself doled out some highly questionable treatment to his crime fighting charges, but all of the Robins are equally guilty of meeting out punishment of every kind to Bruce (except Carrie Kelley; she's pretty much infallible). Here are some of the worst examples...
10. Dick Knocks Out Bruce - Nightwing #30
His identity exposed, and his apparent death broadcast to worldwide audiences, Dick Grayson's time as Nightwing was over, to put it mildly.
Seeking to profit from the alleged demise of his former student, Batman asked the very much alive Dick to go undercover and infiltrate the organisation know as Spyral.
In order to fulfil this mission and discover vital intel on an organisation who had been gathering information on the secret identities of Superheroes, Dick would need to remain dead, so to speak, informing no one - not even Alfred - of his continued existence.
The former Boy Wonder did not take too kindly to this request at all, and a brutal, visceral, unintentionally sexy battle ensued between the Bat and the Bird.
With each consecutive blow backed not just by physical strength, but by frustration, pathos, anger, and pure, raw emotion, the battle was all martial and no art.
After cathartically dispelling who knows how many underlying tensions and declaring to Bruce in no uncertain terms that he is not his "Boy", Dick doubles his efforts and proceeds to absolutely beat the guano out of Bruce, finally putting the Bat on the mat.
9. Damian Leaves - Batman And Robin #2 (2011)
Bruce and Damian Wayne's relationship is one of constant strain and attrition, with even the best, most amicable periods likely to collapse into chaos.
Beginning in the pages of 2011's Batman and Robin Volume #2, when Morgan Ducard, son of Bruce's former mentor Henri Ducard (the name taken by Liam Neeson's character in Batman Begins, in case you were wondering why it rang a bell), arrives on the scene in the guise of vigilante Nobody, he attempts to lure Damian to his side with promises of vengeance and a better, more ruthless approach to defeating Gotham's criminal element.
Damian accepts, abandoning his father and joining Nobody's murderous crusade.
Handing Damian a gun and challenging him to shoot dead a corrupt ambassador, Ducard wanted to see if Damian held the same unshakeable values and subscribed as strictly to the "no killing" rule as his father does.
Damian pulls the trigger, but the gun was never loaded.
Just a test.
Not only does Damian abandon his father to set up shop with a murderer, but by pulling the trigger - regardless of the outcome - he shows once again that the blood of Ra's al Ghul is very much alive in him, and callously disregards the single most profound tenet Batman has tried to enforce from day one.
8. Dick Sleeps With Catwoman - Nightwing #52
To say that Bruce and Selina Kyle have a complicated relationship is putting it mildly indeed.
Enemies, allies, friends, lovers, it's hard to unravel the complex strands of their unique bond, and even harder to keep up with which page they are on at any given point.
Bruce's allies, from his Robins to Alfred, know this and often tease him about his tumultuous courtship of Miss Kyle.
When Nightwing tries to stop Catwoman stealing the legendary Klopmann Diamond, they find themselves pinned down by the gunfire of criminals who have also turned up to get their grubby hands on the valuable prize.
Forced into this precarious situation, their banter turns into flirting, and the flirting turns into, well, something else.
Selina, it turns out, is trying to make Bruce jealous and trusts that Dick will confess all and fulfil her plan (which he doesn't, by the way).
In falling for Selina's wiles and sleeping with the woman he knows Bruce cares for, he commits a huge betrayal of the trust his friend, mentor, and former partner has placed in him.
Now let the Dick jokes commence...
7. Jason Sleeps With Talia Al Ghul - Batman: Red Hood - The Lost Days
The Lost Days tells the story of Jason Todd's resurrection and convalescence under the guiding hand of Talia al Ghul.
Learning new skills, subscribing to tenets and philosphies which Batman would never teach him, Jason is forged into a weapon, hell-bent on returning to Gotham to meet out his own brand of vengeance.
During these "lost days", Jason and Talia become close, and the net result was a famous yet extremely awkward scene of the two of them sleeping together.
Leaving to one side the fact that Talia is effectively Jason's carer at this point, the physical, emotional and mental trauma all too real to Jason following his horrific ordeal at the hands of the Joker, and not even mentioning the age gap, this whole sub-plot is just... wrong, somehow.
Much like the previous example of Dick and Selina's little tryst, Jason knows all too well Bruce's history with Talia, but this does not stop him.
6. Damian Joins Superman's Regime - Injustice: Gods Among Us
The Injustice: Gods Among Us video game and comic book series presented DC fans with an alternate reality in which Superman, tricked by the Joker into murdering his pregnant wife Lois Lane and their unborn child, places the world on lockdown and enforces his iron will with all the might at his disposal (which is obviously considerable).
This totalitarian regime divides the Super/Meta community straight down the middle, with heroes and villains alike choosing either to ally themselves with the ruling Kryptonian, or to go underground to form a resistance movement headed up by Batman.
Old rivalries are buried on both sides in order to achieve their respective goals.
Damian Wayne, now adopting the mantle and accoutrements of Nightwing, turns his back on his father and chooses to join Superman's oppressive regime.
Embarking on a campaign of violence and intimidation, Damian takes to his new role like a Grayson to a trapeze, revelling in his new-found status.
Having already disowned his unstable, murderous heir following Dick Grayson's death at Damian's hand, this further betrayal was further evidence that Bruce and Talia al Ghul's son was too far gone, too enamoured of power and violence to save.
5. Dick Becomes The Joker - The Dark Knight Strikes Again
While Frank Miller's seminal The Dark Knight Returns is widely considered one of the best and most beloved Batman graphic novels of all time, its sequels are not so well thought of, with many not even aware that they even exist.
The Dark Knight Strikes Again is the second entry in Miller's series, and in this strange story, Batman and Catgirl (former Robin Carrie Kelley) are off the grid, in a totalitarian police state headed by (who other than) Lex Luthor.
Left embittered and contemptuous of Batman after being unceremoniously fired years earlier for cowardice and incompetence, Dick Grayson commits the ultimate act of betrayal by submitting himself to a series of genetic tests and procedures at the hands of Lex Luthor.
When a truly nightmarish imitation of the long-dead Joker announces himself on the scene by stalking and killing older heroes, and attempting to murder Batman and Catgirl in the process, Batman recognizes this wraith as none other than his original Boy Wonder, Dick Grayson.
Not only has Grayson thrown his lot in with Luthor, not only has he killed many of his and Bruce's erstwhile friends and colleagues, but he has taken on the guise and mantle of Batman's most diabolical enemy.
4. Tim Dishonours Batman's Legacy - Titans Tomorrow
In the Titans Tomorrow storyline, the Teen Titans were given a rare glimpse of the future and an insight into their future selves via time travel machinations which will be all too familiar to DC comics fans by now.
The Batman of this timeline is not Bruce Wayne, but Tim Drake.
Tim Drake is often considered the most, well, considered of all the Robins, displaying intellect and sound judgement where his counterparts have showed arrogance and impetuousness.
His Batman, on the other hand, is an entirely different beast.
Not only does this Dark Knight use a gun, but the very same gun which killed Thomas and Martha Wayne in Crime Alley all those years ago.
Drake's focus is unwavering, his retribution fatal.
Shooting dead Gotham's criminals without remorse, Tim has abandoned the very rationale and level-headedness which marked him out as the most conscientious and studious of the Robins.
That one of his surrogate sons is executing criminals at all goes against everything Bruce stood for, but doing so in the cape and cowl as the Dark Knight of that time period is the ultimate betrayal of Batman's legacy.
3. Jason Dies - Batman: A Death In The Family
A Death In The Family took us from Gotham to the Middle East, as Batman and Robin set off in search of Jason Todd’s real mother, confronting Lady Shiva along the way.
Betrayed and separated from Batman, Robin finds himself face to face with the Joker, and is no match for the Clown Prince of Crime and his trusty crowbar.
Undoubtedly the most barbaric sequence committed to print in a Batman book, Jason is beaten within an inch of his life by a laughing, gleeful Joker, and is left at the mercy of a ticking time bomb which ultimately claims the life of the second Boy Wonder.
As horrific as Jason’s death was, and as far reaching its consequences for the DC universe, its effect on Batman was arguably worse.
The Dark Knight did not reach Jason in time, so he could not stop the bomb, nor prevent the Joker from brutally beating Jason with a metal bar over and over, revelling in every last stroke as the last of Todd's strength faded.
To Bruce Wayne, a man already haunted and traumatised by the death of his parents whom he was equally powerless to save, it was not only Jason who died that day.
2. Jason The Red Hood - Batman: Under The Hood
In the aftermath of Jason Todd's death at the hands of the Joker, Ra's and Talia Al Ghul submerged the broken Boy Wonder in the Lazarus pit, resurrecting Batman's former sidekick, but not without consequences.
Emerging from the pit traumatised and psychologically damaged, Jason takes on the mantle of the Red Hood and returns to Gotham to seek revenge on the Batman.
Now sporting a red helmet, tactical armour and a leather jacket, this gun toting vigilante embarks on a campaign of crime and violence to get the attention of his former mentor.
Kidnapping the Joker, Jason reveals his identity to Batman, confirming Bruce's suspicions.
Jason forgives Bruce for not saving him, but cannot understand why Batman still allows the Joker - the man who tore them apart - to live.
Tossing one of his guns to Batman and training the other on the Joker, Jason challenges Batman to either kill the Joker or kill Jason himself.
Forcing Batman into this impossible situation, reopening old wounds, and challenging him to break his rule and not only kill but kill with a gun, is undoubtedly one of the worst things a Robin has ever done to Batman.
1. Dick Kills Batman - Titans - "Dick Grayson"
For DC fans with decent broadband, the season one finale of Netflix's Titans is some of the best TV of all time.
Learning from a wheelchair-bound Jason Todd that Jim Gordon and Alfred are dead, Barbara Gordon is missing and that Bruce, under the strain of these events, has finally snapped and is planning to kill the Joker, Dick decides to return to Gotham to confront Bruce.
Far from being able to convince his former mentor to turn from this dark path, Dick's intervention seems only to spur the Dark Knight into further acts of depravity.
Sneaking into the Joker's hospital room to finish the job he started with a Batarang to the heart, Batman proceeds to Arkham Asylum to massacre anyone who gets in his way - inmate and guard alike.
Recognising the futility of appealing to Bruce's better angels, Dick leads a strike team to Wayne Manor to bring Bruce in, resulting in Dick coming across a stricken Batman, buried under rubble and reaching out for help which the former Robin does not give.
Dick Grayson gives in to his own dark impulses and kills Bruce Wayne.
(Thankfully, this all happens in Dick's head courtesy of the Demon Trigon, so no harm, no foul.)