Because DC is one of the oldest comics company in the market, they are constantly plagued with the problem of continuity: how do you tell new stories that are both satisfying for long time fans but are accessible for new readers? And what do you do if things get to complicated and convoluted for readers to follow? Answer: you bust out a retcon. Notorious for rebooting their universe every few years or so, DC loves retconning their continuity problems away. However, unlike Marvel, who usually does soft reboots within their rolling continuity, DC favors a hard reboot retconning the slate clean and starting over is the DC way. Though DC doesnt always use a reboot for every retcon, more often than not DC hits the reset button to fix any continuity problems. In fact, if the DC Universe were NES cartridge, DCs editorial team mash the reset button all the time. Often feeling the pressure to modernize their iconic properties, DC has a tendency to use these retcons and reboot to experiment with characters. Sometimes it works often it doesnt. Heres a list of the 15 most controversial solutions DC has proposed for dealing with the complications and convolutions of certain characters and events within their universe.
15. The Hawk-Peoples Ever Changing Origin
The original Hawkman, Carter Hall, dates back to the Golden Age of comic, making his first appearance in Flash Comics #1 (1940). This interaction of Hawkman was the reincarnation of the ancient Egyptian prince, Khufu. He was in a relationship with Shiera Sanders, Hawkgirl, who too was a reincarnated from ancient Egypt. During the Silver Age of the 1960s, DC revived the Hawk characters with a completely new, more science fiction origin, as a space cop from the planet Thanagar. It was later revealed that the reincarnated versions of Hawkman and Hawkgirl were actually from Earth 2, which only complicated matters more by the 1980s when DC released Crisis On Infinite Earths. During this line wide reboot, DC collapsed its Multiverse, and the histories of Earth One and Earth Two were merged, which caused all kinds of continuity problems for Hawkmans origin. DC decided to reboot Hawkman, retconning his origin to where one version of the character was on the JSA in the 1930s and another on the contemporary JLA. Only a few years later when the Zero Hour retcon occurred, their origin changed again, merging the two incarnations into Hawkgod. Eventually, the 1990s JSA untangled the origin, established once again Carter Hall as the reincarnated Hawkman; however, in the '00s Thanagar was again reintroduced into the DCU, changing Hawkmans origin again. In short, DC just needs to make up their minds!
14. Proto-Plasmic Supergirl
Originally, Supergirl had a very simple origin: she was Supermans cousin from the planet Krypton. It was iconic, and it made sense. However, when Supergirl died in Crisis On Infinite Earths, DC decided that it was a good idea to remove her from canon completely, establishing Post-Crisis Superman as the only survivor of Krypton. Fine. Whatever. When DC eventually realised their mistake (i.e. erasing one of their most popular female characters from cannon), they tried to fix it by creating a new Supergirl: Supergirl Matrix. During the late '80s DC published a story where Lex Luthor from an alternate reality created a Supergirl from protoplasmic matrix goo in order to fight three evil Kryptonian criminals who had escaped from the phantom zone. Thats right - she was created from protoplasmic man goo. This version of Supergirl is similar to Pre-Crisis Supergirl in physical features and power set; however, this version has the ability to shape shift. Eventually, this Supergirl Matrix made her way to main earth where she took on the role as the first post-crisis Supergirl. Eventually, Infinite Crisis occurred and Pre-Crisis Supergirl was reintroduced into the DCU, and Supergirl Matrix slowly began to fade away.
13. The Atlantean Power Girl
DC has a really bad track record when dealing with the Super-Women, especially after Crisis On Infinite Earths. Originally, Power Girl was the Supermans Kryptonian cousin from Earth 2. When Crisis On Infinite Earths merged Earth One and Earth Two, Power Girl survived; however, her back-story was not unscathed. A mentioned previously, the Post-Crisis Superman was the only Kryptonian survivor, so Power Girl had to find a new origin. It is obvious DC didnt know what to do with the character, so they decided that Power Girl would be a descendant of the Atlantean sorcerer Arion. Yep over night Power Girl went from hanging out in space as as super-powered alien to chillin under the sea as mystical Atlantean. This jarring retcon remained canon until the first issue of Infinite Crisis released in 2005. Infinite Crisis re-established Power Girls original origin, as she is reunited with her cousin, Superman of Earth Two, who disappeared into a pocket dimension at the end of Crisis on Infinite Earths. Alls well that ends well.
12. Barry Alans Rebirth
For the longest time Barry Alan was hard proof that some comic book character did in fact stay dead. Having met his demise during Crisis On Infinite Earths, Barry Alan was canonised as the patron saint of speedsters. He was remembered as an upbeat moral pillar that defined what it meant to be a hero. Then Final Crisis happened. Athough Grant Morrisons Final Crisis resurrected Barry Alan, it was Geoff Johns The Flash: Rebirth that completely reworked Barrys origin. Originally, Barry received his powers a decided to become the Flash because he felt that it was the right thing to do. However, Geoff Johns retconned Barrys origin, which now includes the Reverse Flash travelling back in time to kill Barrys mother. Barrys father ended up going to prison for her murder where he eventually died. When Johns rewrote Barrys origin, he completely changed the characters motivation. Barry no longer was the guy who did the right thing simply because it was the right thing; he became the Flash in order to solve his mothers murder and get justice for his father. So much for the happy-go-lucky Flash of the silver age. This version of Barry might as well be called Bat-Flash.
11. Four Robins In Five Years
When DC decided to reboot their universe in 2011 with their New 52 initiative, they wanted to de-age many of their main characters in order to keep them young and spry. Thus at the opening of Justice League #1, the superheroes had only been around for a total of five years. This wouldnt have been a problem if DC actually did a proper reboot and started from square one; however, they wanted to keep some of the more popular elements of their previous universe specifically the Batman and Green Lantern franchises. The five-year timeline was particularly problematic for Batman due to the number of Robins hes trained over the years. This meant that DC had to scramble to find a way to explain this, as the time line didnt make sense. Apparently, while Dick and Jason where actual Robins, Tim Drake was never called Robin but rather Red Robin. Fine. Whatever. (The timeline still doesnt make sense). Things got a bit more creative when it came to Damian, the 10-year-old son of Batman and Talia al Ghul who became Robin only a few years before The New 52 began. Grant Morrison addressed this issue in the second volume of Batman Incorporated, where it was retconed that Damian was bio-engineered from Bruce and Talias DNA. All of these retcons were un-necessary had DC not rushed their reboot and took the time to plan things out.
10. Wonder Woman: Daughter Of Zeus
Wonder Woman was created by Psychologist, William Mouton Marston a strident feminist who had a taste for bondage and powerful women. It should come as no surprise that Marstons superhero came from an island comprised completely of women. During the Silver Age Wonder Woman was given a back-story that aligned with her creators ideology. Wonder Woman was not the by-product of hetero-sexual relations; rather, Princess Diana of Themyscira was hand crafted from the clay by the Amazonian Queen, Hippolyta. As one of the earliest feminist icons within comics, Wonder Womans origin reinforced that she was not to be defined by the world of man. Well, along came The New 52, which completely turned Wonder Womans origin on her head. No longer was Wonder Woman creation immaculate; rather, writer Brian Azzarello retconed it to where Hippolyta gave birth to Wonder Woman after getting it on with Zues. Although this a perfectly logical and sensible origin for a character that derives from Greek mythology, this change is not in line with the characters original intent as a strong feminist superhero. No longer is Diana begotten of a woman, without the influence a male progenitor. Rather, rather Wonder Woman's new demigod status is now defined by her father being Zeus.
9. Alan Scott Likes Dudes
When DC began The New 52, all of their Golden Age Justice Society characters disappeared from their main universe. Eventually, they were shipped back over to Earth 2, which got a major face-lift, as all of these Golden Age characters were severely de-aged. No longer were these the legacy characters that fought during WWII against the Nazi armies; rather they were fresh faces with new origins. In reality, they might as well have been new characters all together. Out of all of these golden age characters, Alan Scott was the one whose revision was the most jarring; the first issue of Earth 2 showed Alan proposing to his long time boyfriend, Sam. Over the past few years, DC has tried really hard to diversify their line; however, many fans where upset at how heavy-handed the changes have been. Needless to say that there was some mixed reactions from fans concerning Alan Scotts new orientation. Many felt that this change felt forced, while others praised DC for their attempts at inclusivity and promotion of diversity.
8. Doctor Hurt As Thomas Wayne
Grant Morrisons run on Batman will go down as one of the greatest runs in the characters history; however, it is not without controversy. At the end of Batman: RIP, the main villain Dr Hurt states that hes Thomas Wayne, claiming that he somehow survived his murder by Joe Chill. Doctor Hurt shows up through much of Morrisons run on Batman, and his identity is never truly revealed. Sometimes hes Thomas Wayne, other times hes a distant relative of Bruce Wayne. Hell there are even implications that hes the devil incarnate. Morrison has stated that he intentionally left the characters true identity a mystery, allowing the readers to decide for themselves. Needless to say, if Doctor Hurt is Thomas Wayne, then this would be a major change in the Batman mythos, as it strikes to the very heart of why Bruce Wayne became Batman. Batman has always been driven by the tragic murder of his parent. If this were to be rewritten, Batman thereby suffers an existential identity crisis.
7. Hal Jordan Gets A Space Bug
Back in the 90s DC decided that the resident Green Lantern, Hal Jordan, was out of touch with the youth of the day. So they decided to get rid of him, by making him go crazy with grief. After the villain Mongul destroyed Coast City, Hal went nuts and rampaged through the universe killing the entire Green Lantern Corps as well as the Guardians of the Universe. Convinced that he could resurrect the population of Coast City, he absorbed the energy of everyone he killed and became the evil Parallax. Eventually Parallax was redeemed during the Final Night story arc, where Hal Jordan gave his life in order to save Earth from a sun eater (don't ask). Fast-forward ten years later to Geoff Johns Green Lantern reboot, and he retcons the whole thing: it turns out that Hal never went crazy. Rather, Hal was processed by giant yellow space bug called Parallax that just so happens to be the personification of fear thereby re-redeeming the character once again. So yeah, be careful about those space bugs kids theyll drive ya nuts.
6. Barbara Gordon Walks Again
Barbara Gordon was by far the most beloved and iconic Batgirl thanks to the Adam West TV show. Unfortunately, Barbara has not always been the most well treated character in the Bat-Family, as Alan Moores 1988 Batman: The Killing Joke left the character wheelchair bound at the hands of the Joker. Many critics have complained over the years that Moores story is incredibly sexist: Barbras character was literally cannon fodder for that story. She had no agency within the tale; she was there as a prop to be used, maimed and discarded. However, thanks to the work of Gail Simone and a handful of other talented writers, Barbara took on a new super identity as Oracle. While remaining in the wheelchair, she served as the information hub for the heroes of the DCU. She became one of only disabled heroes in DCs line, and then The New 52 came along and put her back in the suit. Although its wonderful to see Babs running around in the cape and cowl again, DC has lost a character that has meant a lot to many. Oracle proved that physical limitations dont have to limit a persons capacity for heroism.
5. Supermans Marriage Dissolved
Seriously, comic book companies must be full of people who hate marriage. Youd think that the lot of them are single bachelors angry with anyone and everyone who ties the knot. Within the past decade and a half, there have been more marriage controversies in comics than ever before. The prime DC example of this is the marriage between Clark Kent and Lois Lane. The Clark/Lois/Superman love triangle has been a major part of the Superman mythos since Action Comics #1 (1938), and in 1990 Clark finally revealed that he was Superman to Lois and simultaneously proposed: a natural progression for both characters. After a long complicated engagement, Clark and Lois finally got married in 1996. Then The New 52 happened (have you noticed a trend yet?), and DC erased the 15 years of marital bliss between Clark and Lois. In all fairness, DC put a ban on any of their heroes being married, fearing that marriage matures characters to the point of their conclusion; nevertheless, some relationships are too iconic to retcon.
4. Sue Dibnys Rape
Once upon a time Ralph and Sue Dibny were the hallmark of wholesomeness within the DC Universe. They were a couple madly in love and forever devoted to one another. Nothing could shake their rock solid relationship, and then Brad Meltzer had to take a huge dump all over it. In 2004, DC released a major crossover called Identity Crisis where it was retconed that back in the day Doctor Light raped the Elongated Mans wife, Sue Dibny. When the Justice League found out, the lobotomized Doctor Light and mind wiped Batman, who objected to Doctor Lights punishment. This whole story pretty much ruined the DC Silver Age, casting a long shadow across DCs greatest heroes. First and foremost, having a character raped in a story is often a sign of bad writing. Sue Dibny, who was also murdered in Identity Crisis, had no agency and was simply a plot device to usher in a darker, grittier DC Universe, where heroes dont always act like heroes.
3. Crisis On Infinite Earths
Written and illustrated by comic legends Marv Wolfmen and George Pérez, Crisis On Infinite Earths was pretty much the grandfather of all DC reboots. It was here the DC began its quasi-futile attempts to clean up its continuity by destroying the infinite multiverse. The story was essentially a tour de force of DCs multiverse, as it paid homage to 50 years of storytelling. The Anti-Monitor, eventually destroyed the multiverse, barring Earth One, Earth Two, Earth Four, Earth Five and Earth X. All of these Earths were retconned and compounded into a single continuity for a single universe, which as you can imagine, became problematic. Certain character origins, like Power Girl and Hawkman, were rewritten creating confusion amongst fans, creators and editors. Some characters just didnt work in this new Earth, like Captain Marvel (Shazam) who now seemed like cheap rip off of Superman instead of Earths Mightiest Mortal. Though many fans loved the event during its time, others mourned the loss of their beloved heroes, fearing that they would never reappear in comics again.
2. The New 52
After Crisis On Infinite Earths, DC managed to build an incredibly elaborate universe that seemed to grow and change over the years. DC became known for their legacy characters such as Wally West, Connor Hawke and Stephanie Brown. With the JSA standing as the old guard, the JLA as the current guard, and the Teen Titans as the new guard, DCs universe had characters spanning generations. Its history was rich and growing, and then The New 52 wiped all of it away. When Barry Alan ushered in to The New 52 during the events of Flashpoint, he did so with the help of Pandora. Between the two of them, they managed to restructure the multiverse merging DC, Vertigo, and Wildstorm worlds into one Earth. This retconned all of the DC history, removing most legacy characters and shipping the JSA characters back to Earth 2*. Although DC managed to create much needed excitement with this reboot, many fans were angry about the loss of DCs rich history, especially legacy characters that had been around for years. *NOTE: There was a shift over the years in the way DC referred to their various Earths within the multiverse. Originally, each Earths number was spelled out; currently, DC uses numerals when cataloguing their different Earths.
1. Convergence
Convergence is the newest of the what-seems-like countless DC reboots. Finishing up only in May 2015, the end of Convergence caused quite the stir among DC fans, as it was essentially a retcon of the Crisis On Infinite Earths retcon. Penned by comics newcomer, Jeff King, Convergence told the story of how a cosmic version of Brainiac abducted various cities from different doomed timelines throughout the history of the DC universe and kept them on a sentient planet called Telos (don't ask). At the end of the story, Brainiac send Pre-Crisis Barry Allan, Pre-Crisis Supergirl, Hal Jordan Parallax and Pre-Flashpoint Superman back in time to undo the collapse of the multiverse during Crisis On Infinite Earths. The problem is that no one is quite sure how this relates to the previous retcons and reboots that happened in-between Crisis On Infinite Earths and Convergence, leaving many fans scratching their heads about the current history of the DC multiverse. It seems that DCs editorial team used this half-baked story to retcon the original retcon in order that they can officially say that everything counts as continuity, including each of the aforementioned retcons. Although this event was a flop from the beginning, Convergence ushered in the current state of the DC universe, where diversity is representation and genre are emphasized and where story trumps continuity.